Statutory Interest Commencement Date Dispute
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe appellant sought review regarding the calculation of statutory interest on an award, arguing that the lower court erred in applying a specific date for the commencement of the interest period, as mandated by a statutory provision relating to an earlier final judgment in the same matter. The court reasoned that the relevant statute explicitly dictated that interest accrual must begin from the date of the final judgment in the prior proceeding, not from the date of the subsequent court's judgment confirming that prior determination, thereby rejecting the appellant's contention and upholding the application of the statutory commencement date.
Regeste Legislator
Généré par l'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statutory Interest Commencement Date Dispute: The court reasoned that the relevant statute explicitly dictated that interest accrual must begin from the date of the final judgment in the prior proceeding, not from the date of the subsequent court's judgment confirming that prior determination, thereby rejecting the appellant's contention and upholding the application of the statutory commencement date.
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe court ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the federal proceedings.
Texte complet
!"#$%!%&&$ !"%"!%&&'
((
() ) ( )
*+ , " -. %&&'
!!!" #$$% &'& ' ) )* ()* + "*! !! ,"* -*) ) .&
*)
'' ' ' ,// ' !*!" '' ' ' ' 0 ! 1*2*)#3 *450
&$6#:&
/
#; " #7<9 5" +=! * )!" (! #: >+!) #78$ ? !) &; ))!+" '! #787 "?@*)+!)$#>+!)#739;:# A*B""*" 22"()CDE()="*"( @">=,:#"F) #77% * )*)!* *!!("; ,!*)+ #7%: =! *! !*"!;' "( G=*?!*)+!"()H!)*! 2"") .?);
$; #7%%")*)!*!)"?! (*! * 0)!5C!&()H!E)*+!!; 4 )!) )* *" :9 ! #7%% ,!*")" !!=" )F)!= I F)+*! IJ
I "( , ( )* ' + =, *)+! ? ,DIC(!H#);E;
:; ) ))!) #< >!* #77K ! !4 )" )" = "( !2*,L2!=*&!= * F)#77K! +)!*) !*? )* ("*!) !!+*C(!H$);E;
<; ) ))!) $K >!* #77K ,)" )* )" 4 )!) )*?!C(!H:;#*:;$);E;
K; ) ))!) < >! $99: ! ? + )()! ** + )" ( )!)(()= "( !2*,L2 !G*&*) !+!*? * )) !*?)*+!!;
8; !> !*? ))!)4 )!)=!!"*")+ @"A*)(! ()C(!H<*K);E;)F)!=!*!*"I!* ( @)I,!*")"!!="+ !)*)+!"( )*""+!! !) $# >+!) :# ! #739 * ( ) ,D :# A* #739 :# "F) #77%; > *" J I)*)!* *!!(" D H #) >+!) #777& *!*! 'H9#6#777I;
3; )"!! ## +F)$99:! "? !) )* 7K#4); * ? "( )* #,#K<4); C(!H8;#*8;$);E;
%; )"!! #3>+!)$998)"!2"!!4 )",)" =,+!* !))))*,!+!!*" (*F!!* " )* = ,+!* ( "*" )" F!2* !)*; ))) +!* ( ) "= = ,"*!* ,"5 )* :< =! ! +!* "*" ((!="!*(,"5)*3; ()*!4"*""*F!
6#78$6$998 &:6#:& = ! * ) )*! = $<,:%84); +!* "*" +)" *) ( ( ) (")! #) +F)$99::9>+!)$998;"*""?,)")F )) ** "! *)* > ) * ,44* (!4 , "+* (( !*! "*"G()"*)*!)";
7; G*)"!! *"*")#7>+!)$998 )*(")! #) +F)$99:#)>+!)$99KG*)= ** )*,)""*"4!G"?#,9$84);* "( ?$934);() ! C(!H%;#*%;$);E;
#9; $3 >+!) $998 ) ,)" ! ! 4!* ()+!) *)*! "!! #3>+!)4)M!C(!H7*#9);E;
##; ) ))!) #3 4"+)!) $998 ,)" 4 )" (( !*! ? "!! 4!* ** + !) = )*!**! "*!* ())!*; *!*) ()"F")*!**! ,44*(!4;
#$; )"!! $9)$998!)4")*!**! ,44*(!4 *!4=, )!*2)=)")*!**! !*!))" +)F;') ) ) ,)" )!F * ) ! ) >2* * #8 +F) $998 () = ! " "!! $9 )$998*() ")*!**! ,44*(!4;
#:; ,!*)+)4 !*!2!)"!! ) (( !*! *$3+)!$998&)"!2"&G*)=)>*" , (( !*! #34"+)!)$998* 4!)""!! )*!**! #3>+!) $998; *!" = () **! F 4 ! !+ =" () ,)" ( +!*B*))*) N)!2*)) "!+!*"*" !="!!@*>!44!)"=)*"*)+! ()H,D)!*"*")" F!2* !)*; *?,G(*! ())!(*! +" () ,)" ! , ")*" *!4 = ,* =, * $# >+!) $99K = ! ! (*! ! !=" (!H !) * =, !! ( + !) ! ,))) !;' "!! #3>+!)$998!*)+ !, ( *) "*" ) *( *!; 4! "*" ()"!" ? ,)" =,( ))!*()!*"( ))!;
#<; ) ))!)$7!$998,)"!*)>*") ) *)"!! ; )H+ ()!H)* = + ! ) !* *! " ) "!! * )) " ) N"!2 * )!*" ("** )!F* ) !* 0)!5 )= !( !*! "2 *)!F ("***!* !!,)";
) !) 4!* + !) = ! (*! !* B*) !")" * )!*" 4"") * =, )!* A )) "!! )
6#78$6$998 &<6#:& (( !*! 4)M!;H )= !* ) "*)*! "!! *)()!!!=,F !);
)!!(* *?,*! "!! #3>+!)*$3+)! $998 *!4 = )*!**! * *)!+; 'F!!!)* = !) !*)+ @"?!4!="#7%:?#77% !* ()! (* " *!*! ;
4!*))=)=, * N)"!! 4!G*! )* ## +F) $99: ! "*!* ( ! )+" = !!=!* *!*! (@" ( ) 5= " !! = G*)!* (* !!+! C E ()H ! * 2+ ! (*! C E *" :9 (*F) $99: C( #<E; 4!* + !) = ! "*!* !! ()4!** !4 )" !**! () * =, )"+ *! "!! ## +F) $99: *)+!)!* ()!!( () **! F 4 !;)((=,* > )!4 )"!4!*=,*)+!!* ? ,D H * N "( G "( " )* )*#7%%=!4 )*! "*")"("*" ))* ("*!) = () () )* ()!* !* ( @)& F)=,D&*=" *!*! *!)*!!=" F)G * *!!( !* *()!"!! C(8;:#:*#<E;' ()"!! ## +F) $99: ! )"" G(**!+ * ! 4!* ) !) =, )+)!*H**>=,? "H)* '/);#,#K<;&;
4!*))=)"2*== !=,! !*!"#739?#77% (+* )* B*) ()! (* " )!2 *!*! !+*,B*)H#7%: " *!*! () ()(!=,#7%: =! !* @*" ! * )!* H *&? A B*) 44!!" ? , '2)"4!*=,*)+!!*( ),D *() , !4 )";)() 5?!(,+ !))*!+?4!*;
4! *!* = )*!**! * ())!*; * "2) **,44!)*! ! =,*=,>+!)$99K=, ( + !) ! 2; 4!* ))=) =, * $# >+!)$99K !! (*! ,4!*= )(() ? ! 0)!5 = )*! * =!* C( #7E; )!H) "*!* ">? *$#!$99<( ! !),)"(!=,,*)!? !! (*! C(#3*#%E; ,*4!*!! (*! =!*:#!$99K!)",*! !0)!5 )4!*="!! , *) !)* *!*)))C($#E;
#K; +!*" ? () ) ! )"( #< >!* $998 )>* ) ); *!* =,! ,@ ( +! *! ()!!(
6#78$6$998 &K6#:& () **! F 4 ! ) N , >! "*" !!*" () ,)"*!>! ")!2* )*=!*",)" )=,=!!* @*"!;)!)4!*+ !)="! ())!(*! , "? )!)H * N ! 4!*=,+!*) !*))*!**! =,*=:#! $99K=! (*! !,!4 )"=,)"+!**)+!" ?,D*,+!*("*")" F!2* !)*;*!) ! ="!! )*!**! #3>+!)$998*!*)+*(*!; * + !) 4 )! ! ,+)! $99< * ? ! ! (*! !*!=,*)-!*(( ), F!2*! ,G!) (+* !),)"*+")!4!))*)!H);
#8; ) ))!) #< A* $998 ,)" )()! )2* ">? !+ =" ()""* > ** = >)!() * ) !* ,) , !!*)*! =, 4 ()+ 44!* ,*! )=, )!* !) 4! ,@ )5)5) * ( ) ))=) ,"+* )));*!) ! =,+)!$99<(*)!)!*A )) (* )));
#3; ,!*!"() ))!)#$(*F)$998!*( !*! ;
#%; ()H !*! )!H) ")!*) ? ) )* "*" 2)"?>2);
(
#; !2+ !)O )2!*! >!!!)CE"*" !4!"*!*!*"H #) A*$99: )!F* ) ! ( "K>2 * ()"!* * +!&()"!* K (("* * #8 >2 ) C)*; # *;)*K8 E;
'!*?O*! O"*! #8>2)() )!F4"") $3>+!)$99<C /#:9#98E) !2+ ! (*"#:4"+)!) !( !*! *)!* !))2*()* )!F* ) ! !"2) ) ? *) ! >2 *!*!) O* O"*! +G>2);
$; 4 )"* ? ,)*; K8 ; # *; 5; # )!F * ) ! -*!*!= ***! ()"+?O)*;K8 !4""))()*!2"")) !8 * F)$999 C E)*!+? !4"")$9"F)#7<8)O)&+!! *)+!+*C 'E;' ("*)*! *)!( )>2)O(H * "*F!;
6#78$6$998 &86#:& :; *? ("*)*! ! )!F* ) ! H+*"2*+")";44* ,)*;K%;# *)!F ) ("***!* !!,)" ,*) ()*! *"(P*) );,)"=!4!*, F>*,"!! ()! () ! (*! (* 5 !!),2!)+**)!F ! !!=) )*4!*, ));
<; )!)) )!*)>*"$7!$998,"*"4 )*"!()"+ ())*;K8 ;
K; )"F*) )**)*! "!! ) (( !*! * !)4)M!;
!! = )(( ) )* ,)*; :3 ! 4"") () ") !!*)*!+ $9 "F) #78% C Q ' #3$;9$#E ()"+ !* = * )!*" 4"") *!4!*)"!! 2 44!!=()*! * ()! ())!*) ! * )!*"* )!H)!* 2 44!!())!*()) !** ;
,)2* = ! (*! * 0)!5 !* B*) !")" * )!*"4"")(!=,G!*4!* '*=, "*")""4!,G"*)*L5)*!+? !C)*;<7*; 'E* !; @ ! !")) = ,!*!" * * )!*" 4"") ? = * ""2" 4 *! 4"")*! *!H) ,)& +!!; (*()" !() ")()=4!*="!! ) (( !*! !* )"!2" , ( (B5" ) )* 4!) + !) ) !*,B*)**4!()="!! ) (( !*! )() ( ) ,*! )2* "+ ((" "!! #3 >+!) $998 ="*"*)!*$3>+!)$998*)!F" !H)=,!,@ (! )4 )*,!*!"?*)!)"!! ) (( !*! ; * ? *)*! !) ,* ( !( " () !; ()"F) )** ")*";
8; !*!2 ( )* ) ( !* + !) ! )*!**! ()**! " ? ,)" ( ) (")! #) +F) $99: :9 >+!) $998 * >*!4!";
+)* ,)*; $K ; # ()**! !A* * 5" !+* B*) )*!*";)*!**! (*B*)G!2" )=,!*")""*!*F 4 !* =, )!* !**! !44!!; ' !" !( !*! ) !* ) )*!**! ,"*!* ()H * N ,!*!**! ,) !4!*!(*)!=()H +)*()**! ;
6#78$6$998 &36#:& 3; +!* ()!) ! ,G!) =*! + !) ! ()**! +)"?) )*, *"*"!H)!;44*!) )** ="#739?#77%(+*)*B*)()! (* " )!2 *!*! *!* =, !+* ,B*) H #7%: ? *!*) ," *!*! () ()(!=,#7%:=!!* @*"! *)!*H *&?AB*)44!!"?, '2)"4!*=,*)+!!* ( ) ,D * () , !4 )"; 4!* * !(!!**=()**! =!! *"*"+)","*!*=()*!* !; *)2* !*(*B*)")*") N!!=4!* ))=),!*!"!!(()*!*(,!)),*! ,)") F!2*! ,))!*?,=!!*! !* @*"!;
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
,!) B ,(!) !( !*! ,)) ,* ( F!2" ,*)()))5)54!"*)!)!,)" () 5(+* ()"*) ? ()**! ,*) ) !; ) )* )!* )() 5)?!(,+ !))*!+ * N F**! !*"!4!*=,( +!*(@) *!*! '; ! =,! !* =*! (* )) +)* ) N ) ) !* B*)!( ))! " "!& ;
%; +!* ! ,G!) ,G(*! ())!(*! +" () ) )*;
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
,()H >)!() ) ? () ( ,! )*; <3 ; $ ' C* !((!F,(H (**4!*=,)*;$K;$ )()! *)E )=)*!**! *!(*F?4*,!!*)*! C() G( ))) , ()**! E )!* !")) ( !* "()* "! * N 4* "*" ! ! F! ! = ,!!*)*! )!* A G!H *( C() G( ? , ! , *)P (*FE )) (* ))) 4!* ()+,*! )=!;44*!, (M!* * ! 2 ? * +)* ! ))!* +* ! !) ( !F!!*" ( ) !!*)*! )") )F )* ()**! +)"?* )*4*()*C /##9:9<E;
7; ,(H)*!**! 4!*, F>*,"!! !*" #3 >+!) $998; !! = 4!* ))=) ) )* ,* 4!* = ,)"!**)+!"( ),D#739?#77%=! *!+ )*!**! ;)! (*! +!* !*""*H :9!#7%%*?=,"( G,)""( ")* )**! *G()"*4!*; !&!!*"*")(("? !J!) )*!!!)*4 )!))(!(),)" >!*$99:=,*)+!"( ),D:# A*#739:#"F) #77%C4;5;8E;
/ ) * **)=! !H * N )()!H)"!! )* )*) )*## +F)$99: ""*=!)!*A!()))) (*=, !* ))); )*!**! * H ) !(*F ? 4* ,!!*)*! ; (* * >)!() )((" () (* (* !")) ( !*"()* "! * N4* "*" !!!
6#78$6$998 &76#:& =,!!*)*! )!*AG!H*()) (* )))4!*()+,*! )=!;),(H )!F" *,+!=!)!*?* * !A()) ! ))) )=, )F" * = ! )"!* ! ! (*! )* ,)" ,*&?&!) +)! $99<; "= "!())!(*! *+?"5"(*) !*#)!$99K; "!! ! *" #3 >+!) $998 * *)!+ * ,2!* ()**! (")! != ) !* )*!**! ! * (")!" =! ) ()**! "5 (! ( , " +* "!! !* )*!+?(")! *")!)#)>+!)$99KC /#$$$38 !; F6FFE;
#9; * ? G!) ) !* ! )") )*!**! ()**! +)"#)>+!)$99K:9>+!)$998;
) )*!+ =?*"2)()!!(() **! F 4 !;
) !*?() **! F 4 !"!*!)**O)*;<O! *!**! *G()"* )"?O)*;7 **;+*( )OF O*!+!*""**!=*G!2=,!!*)*! *!!*)" ( )** )"!() =* !H) @; ' >)!() ) O! ) !*=!** > )+FC /#$3:8 !;:#$8:%< !:E! ()*G!* @OG!2)=O* )!*")(*() *=O"+!* *)!) C4; "2* !)) ) !* !!*)*!4 + ; $ ) #77#(;<$%E;
()*!!) ,!!*)*! !* ,F*!) * * ( )** () () ? *) (),!!*)"*)!**!))+*2 "=, ! ))*! !44!()*; )*! !*! !* @(*!! G!2) ,* )!*" =, 4 ) G () ) =, ! 4!***) (( 4!=,!"2!*!*("&!; B 4M ) !* ? () **! F 4 ! (* ! B*) !+ =" ()"!(*, ( )**,!!*)*! (*!F,"+!) 5S,!!*)"* (")"2!*!C /#$7:%# !;3;# * F))"4")!*"E;
,((!= )= ,!!*)*! )" (() ) !* ) = ,!!*)"4 ( ) (*) ( )**=,! !H)H ) 4 )) !*; !!,* )!*"=!4!*() !4 )*! ) !* *!4!) G(**!+ )"" B ! () ,G(**!+ *!"2! !*! *!+!+* *)"!J E ! 4* = O* )!*" !* !*)+ !**! )H* ? O"2)() "*)!"
6#78$6$998 `#:& FE =O !* 2! !* " + !) 2! !!* ("* E = O!!*)" O!* ( )) (* !"!** O!G*!*)!2* F* E=O! !*4 ")!&!( )())!( !*! =O! )!* !4!)F!)()">!*= E !O!*(52"(! * N)!2*"*" "C /#$#88 !;$Q!R )"!) !* !!*)*!4 L * /)4 )*&)&&! #77# <H "!*! XK97(;#9%Q)!5Y/ 6 )2Z))! 2! )[*2)5* $H "!*! 0)!5 #77: (;##3(()*!!H)*(;#$85;K8:E; ) !* ? () **! F 4 ! (( ! !*" *) )!2* F**!( !*! ()!()O!!*)";
) )* 4!* + !) = !*! * )"!" =! ) ) N"!! 4 )"*")? *)=!! " G(**!+(!=,( +!*"*) !)>*!4!";
)!F " 4!* (* ))=) =, *!H) )*!**! ()**! ()!!(() **! F 4 !,*(((!F** = * (!= * *G* ! @ 4 )"* "!! )) " ,!!*)*! ; ,* = ,2 =*"+ ="?,)*; $K;# =F 4 !,)"(* )*))!2 (*;
! )(() = ,)*; $K ; # )*!**! ()**! !A* * 5" (* B*) G!2" )= ,!*")" "*!* F 4 ! * =, )!* !**! !44!!; ) N ! ,* ( **"=()**! +)", *"*"!A*!)!* A() " ! () ") !")) , (( !*! ,)" )!*G!)?*() ")">?! !*! F
4 !*!**! !44!!"*!*)"!"*, (( !*?)*!**! ;
##; ',2!*()!H) !*! &F 4 !&>)!()()"! =4!*=F""4!!!)()**! !2 )=,!,@+!*() !*44!* ( ( ) ) =,! "*!* F 4 !; ) 4*&! =,! !* ) (F!,!**! !!!"2!22)+;,!*=F
4 ! ** = !*! )! * G ,F" )= 4!* =! !* ? , F!2*! )*!*) C+! *! + !) , ) )!2)E *!(*F? ( )** !4 ?"2!22)+; ,G,*! G!2!F,@*) !*=!!+ =F 4 !)H+ ) !*; , )) F 4 ! ) )* ,* ( **F * F,!)(! *(),!*!";
6#78$6$998 &##6#:& *?G!) !*! J!@!,G!)!,)")!*! !**! !44!!&*="4!!())*;<*K, ) ) ()*! 2"") ) !* ) ! C Q %:#;##E & () )F )* =! ! * )""; ) ( !* , 4!* , F>* , G () ,!*!" * )!F " !( ,"** ( ""*!()*,G!);
+!* )+ @) ? ,* )!*" !*!" 4! = )!H) G! ! !*! , )! * )(! ) )*;
6#78$6$998 &#$6#:&
( / ) () ) ( )
012-2 ++ 3 422 2 5 6 "$% )7
-2 +
#; ")) ))+F;
-2
$; ,* ()*!* =,! * **" = ) !* ) )*!**! ()**! +)" ? *")!)* #) >!$99K*(")!";
:; + ! ? ,!*!" ? 5)2 ( ) )!H) ,G!) ! !*! ,)! *)"!,(H*)) +"!! ;
<; O!*!" ? +)) ? ) )* /);%99&& ? *!*) "(;
K; 4 ) ()*! =O (+* 4 )) ) ) *) ()"* ))B* "! :9 > ) H *!4!*! () (! ) " )" )!F 4"") ) '5[!S)5 4=! 8 899< *) ! G(!); "! (* B*) () 2"; " !) !*J E !!=) G**="!! ) )*"!) F*!)!*("!! ="Q FE G( ) ( ) = *!4 ! *! ( + !) ) *) "!! Q E ( )*) !2*) )()"**; '! " !) *!* ( *) ! ""* "")" ) E FE * E !& )!F4""))( ))(*))*!H))) )=O! +)"))!))+F;" !)) )*! ) ) @ ()+ =! ) * > !* !! = "!! =" * O+ (( ="*"G("!") )*C)*;#:$#98*#9%E; 2)44!H) ()"!* !// R)!' R
6#78$6$998 &#:6#:& (! 4 )()"*))B** *!4!"G()*!!!=O?O44!4"") ) !()2)44
6#78$6$998