Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/119/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/119/2007 Généré par l'IA

Patent Claim Validity Review: Novelty, Obviousness, and Definiteness

Numéro de cause ATAS/119/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case concerns the review of several patent claims related to various technical devices and processes, where the core issue was whether the claims satisfied the statutory requirements for patentability, particularly regarding novelty, non-obviousness, and definiteness of the claimed subject matter. The court affirmed the rejection of several claims, reasoning that they were either anticipated by prior art, making them not novel, or rendered obvious by combining existing prior art references, thereby failing the non-obviousness test; furthermore, some claims were found insufficiently precise, thus violating the written description and definiteness requirements.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Patent Claim Validity Review: Novelty, Obviousness, and Definiteness: The court affirmed the rejection of several claims, reasoning that they were either anticipated by prior art, making them not novel, or rendered obvious by combining existing prior art references, thereby failing the non-obviousness test; furthermore, some claims were found insufficiently precise, thus violating the written description and definiteness requirements.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
validité du brevet nouveauté matérielle caractère distinctif de la marque condition légale contestation de l'établissement des faits phase préliminaire d'examen

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive to rule on the costs of the proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
A/2345/2006
Patent Validity and Infringement Suit Involving Prior Art and Claim Construction
A/4636/2006
Patent Validity and Prior Art Challenge
A/4100/2006
Patent Validity and Infringement of Apparatus and Method Claims
A/1701/2007
Patent Infringement and Validity Dispute
A/3645/2006
Patent Validity Dispute and Remand

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to rule on the costs of the proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



               #$$$%#%&&' (#$$)#%&&*

(

 (+ +( +  +   

,- .

 /$ !0 %&&* 



 !"#$ !%  "#"

"# !"#$! & '



(

%%   %%%!)#(((*+!, &! "$0"

-    %%  ./#        % !0(*1!  !

-   2                    !"

  .36  

       ! "746!   !

- %   %  ! "#(( #8("98:!3%;0!<$$=>1! , &!

-       , & %%  %!3  %%  % ! (>5! , &



    3444.3.115 ?36  

+ 1(

4@  A:#( " 4 0$B .115!  +/# )#9 " 9 " 8#/ (8$"B""# !$4+5?!(  !$4+*>!<(#$"("6"$#94++4@

.@ %  )00 C " A:#( 8$($!  9 " 8#/ (  "$ (DD=$8D"<78(:(8#($8(("(" ((("8$BE@

?@  A:#( " "B ( "B "$0(0  .4 # .115 (  $($ (# "700.C#.115 9"$8D$("8(:@

>@   " > B .115!  9 " $  B($  "#" F  ##<#"((("8$BE""$$)$( .4B.115@"#"E"$(8G.1B.115@ 5A.115! 9"$A(B0"#"" ##<:#($(0D$80"$ .5 A .115! ((  (((  (((   0( <  8( < 0 " 9"" "78$""#((B8(H("#$F $##(@"#"7(80#$F((A(@

*@ %  :#(  8  9 " $!  "#" "8 "7 8(( " 9 8:  ##( " "B " ?>75?? 0@ ?1 8/" "8:@ =#8"8(("(  ##( " #:! E #8  ($H(  A<7 ##( " "B!".746?0@51!"44B.115"((@

5@ "#"(9$$0"78(("98:"6C+0@1*8/ "-"("98:"./#8"< 8% !(( "5(9.115"=@-"("8$BE"<( "/B"$((8"#"B"B##(""B "?746+0@5*!D(#"".1(9.115"=@-"( (((88$(B0#$ 9"$6"$#9.115< 8(("98:""#"7$B(F..+7.1C0@1*##(" "BI..+7?6>0@5*41#.115#($H(00$(#"7B " 455 0@ 51J@ 7B " B 8/ "  -"( (B ( "  ,)!7((("8$BE(""#""84 AB .115! ( " 47+6? 0@ 61!    " (( 0"( " 4+ A .115@(("B"B""#"7$(9(F.?*74*10@>* ##(""B@

    3444.3.115 >36  

"("#:!"#"B(#$B"B"..7*?. 0@1*!($H(A<7"B!((".+K(.115"  "((("7$8:"8%(@

6@   " 4? "$#9 .115!  9 " $  ##<$ D D= $8D9"88(:"B"B@

C@  79 "79A( " "#" "  "$ #8(!    $($ :"$FA:@

+  (

4@ 7(@.*"0$"$98:"8$BE80! B!BB((B"($"46"$#94++?I-J!($B: 4AB.111!/:8$"""B@<A(( 8"L"8(("(F8(:I(@4..(4.? " B= J! A:"""B#8$(("7(@6?@4"0$"$ 8$BE 80 " .* A 4+C. IJ! ( F /B  9 (""84K(.11?!"(!8/<700  $($(#I(@4>. J!D$("7008(:9" $" $8(("$(#$8A:""B@

.@ %7(@..-IB(B:"84AB.111J! " "B!  8(( " ( < "(  #: ( 8(:$ 0#$#( D(@4..!4.?!4>4(4>. M(@?F* -788<( 8:#((F(0$I@4J@)<A(!8((" (F8(:8"F"00$(8(("(!:#($ " B " 9 8: D(( $B(#(  ##( " "B! (  8(("(!:#($"B"98:D(($B(#( ##(""#:I0@(@.>-J@!A( F  8(( " ( ( F 7B " 9 8: D((  ##( "   " #:  ($H( "  ##( " "B I - 4.C  .?1M -4.+>>>J@

L8/!A:"8#/("$(DD=$8D"<7 8(:(8#($8(("(#$8"(#:"  ((( " 8$BE@  "( 8(( (! "L 8(!  " #:!  6 "$#9 4++4! ( "L( 8(  .4 # .115! "( F <  A:#(""B("BD$(@

?@ %  :#( !  8(( " ( " "#" (!  ##( " "B! " .?*74*1 0@ >*@  (( ##!  B( " "$" 7B"B#$##("#:"..7*?.0@1*!< ($H(#8$A<7F7($0")A:$""B@

    3444.3.115 *36  

(D"7($H(889F((8(("((">NA<7?4"$#9 .11.! " ?!.* N  .11?! " .!.* N  .11> ( " .!* N "/ .11*@ B  ($H( A<7 ##( " "B! 7B " B  ##( " #: 7$/B  F ?67C1. 0@ 61@  $<(!  8(( " ( #$ 8"(#:7$(9(F4+67?>60@6*I.?*74*10@>*=?67C1.0@61J@

( F  "#"!  8(( " 9 8: ( " ?>75?? 0@ ?1  ##(""B!##"(B(""$"8(("(F "("#:!B($H(A<7"B!".746?0@51@ !B "B<8"(#:("?.7>*+0@61@

 $<(!  "#" "( F  D=$8  #(( " +C756? 0@ +1 I4+67?>60@6*@3@.J!(="(457..+0@C*I?.7>*+0@61@3@.J(8 ##"467?450@5*!## 9"$7B(##<$8 D"#"4?"$#9.115@ $((!88("D(((" 8$BE80""#""(0$F""#" ##"C.7>>>0@1*I+C756?0@+1=457..+0@C*J@

>@  B( " 7(@ > @ .9 -!  7$ ( "  ( ((( " 8$BE! 7((( " 9 8: B  8( " 8$BE F (( "/!0"#(8$BE@7$(("(0F7((( "98:($"B((("8$BEI(@J(F  B((("8$BE#"7((("98: ( 0#"8$BEI(@9J@

 7!  88( <  "#"  #0(#( (B F (( 9:(@ 88!E("<"#8("8(("9 8:8/"-"("98:"./#8"< 8%  (  -"( " 8$BE "  < ( " /B!  " "  ##B(F"#""B(H((0$$8-"(((( 88$(B @ 8"(! "  # O  0 " P( "  "D #8(  ( 8 !  " "K 8 (( "/ 0"(  8( 8 H("$(#$B8$@ !8"8(<! 9B(  -"( ((( 88$(B  F (0$  ((($ "  ## " C.7>>>0@1*F7((("8$BE""#"@

*@ 0#$#( F  A8"! "8  A "$(#( 8  8(: A<7##("(0("8(("(""#!A( "B$9$$0"((8(("(F"($H(#8( #(("=@ ($H(($(D###$:7(@4. "7"8$BE80B!BB((B"($ " 4C B 4+C> I .J    (D $:#(!  = ( 8$ I -89$?531."4CA(.11?J@

    3444.3.115 536  

5@ 8$"(88:((!B("7(@6?@.@ 8"(! "($#$($"$:/($!"0"A(8B(H("$I -4.C  ?.? "@ 4J@ :( B ($#$($  8(  8( < B  9:("9F7(("I -4.C?.>"@49J@

78/! 9"$B($"#"F"<#"  "((("8$BE80!D<$((00$"( #:!<(((:#((8(:"8((" (!8">B(5A.115@"!$($ ("(((0D$<"8B($@7E(A#$8"D A( " 9 " $ ( 7E(  9:$ "7(8" " #9"$#)<(8$($$B($!"#"7$((0#$ F  9:( " :!   A(0 "  "# F  $##( " A("471110@

    3444.3.115 636  

  (1  (+ +( +  +   



23454-- 6  744 4  8" $'%  9

4@ B(  -"( ((( 88$(B  F (0$! " #8( " 9 8:Q6*>@*>@.1.@.>>"@ !##"C.7>>>0@1*F  " 8 :  0B " #  ! Q % 6*>@5?@*1?@446!   <  ($H( #8(   " "$( "/.4#.115A<7##("(0(@

.@ 7E"#((<"9@

?@ "#@ F$##("A("471110@

>@ 0#  8( "  <L 8B( 0#  (  8$( H( "  "$ " ?1 A "/  (0( 8/ " 9 0$"$ I%);R)0<5!511>  J!8B"#(/""( 89!0#$#(D(@C."0$"$ 90$"$"46 A .11* I -JM  #$# "  "( "<  ! #(0 ( #E"8B(8(:("("#"(M"( H( "$  9 0$"$ 8 B 8(  8 B $(< D "( " 7(@ >.  -@  8$( H( (  8/  8 " (!B<$###E"8B!"B(H(A(F7B@  :00/  $"(S              &   % E    

80#"8$(H(((0$D8(<LFL000$"$ "8:00

    3444.3.115