Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/117/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/117/2005 Généré par l'IA

Property Conveyance Validity Dispute

Numéro de cause ATAS/117/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A party challenged a lower court's decision concerning a complex series of agreements and conveyances related to property interests, focusing on whether certain prior sales were valid prerequisites for subsequent actions. The court reasoned that the lower court correctly interpreted the controlling agreements, finding that the contested prior sales were validly executed and thus satisfied the necessary conditions precedent for the later property actions, which ultimately supported the judgment in favor of the defending party concerning the validity of the property transfers and the enforcement of related obligations.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Conveyance Validity Dispute: The court reasoned that the lower court correctly interpreted the controlling agreements, finding that the contested prior sales were validly executed and thus satisfied the necessary conditions precedent for the later property actions, which ultimately supported the judgment in favor of the defending party concerning the validity of the property transfers and the enforcement of related obligations.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
transmission de la propriété arrêts en appréciation de validité contentieux contractuel valeur litigieuse exécution gage immobilier

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the appeal.
Généré par l'IA
A/664/2006
Land Conveyance Validity Dispute
A/2054/2006
Property Conveyance Validity Dispute
A/2919/2007
Property Transfer Validity Dispute
A/25/2005
Conveyance Validity and Timely Challenge in Property Dispute
A/2043/2006
Property Transfer Validity Dispute

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the appeal.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

               "#$%$"#&&' "$$%"#&&(

))

* )*   *) 

+,  - .  $' /0 #&&( 



1 2222222222 ! "#$ ! %  ! &'!(()#'#!(##

! 

33   4*)5  ( #!#' *+,-.

                 !

   40/+4  

 3

15  0 !$  1++, "5 6666666666 '  1+37 ( !##!'  !8# !#!# (& # (('( !!#(& 4#.#(#!'5   )&#! .##!### #'!#!!$'0,9!1++3 88: !$##!')(& ! ('#)!(#8! #'5

05  1; !$  0222    %6666666666  (  < !# =  (( (& .#   >#4 -? &  @ ! =  #!' ( ! .# ( & '(!#'8- =!<(A2B.# 5

75   ('## ( 03 C.#  0221 &DD# ! ( & 4#.#(#!' >#4  - & @  D' = & ' !! ( #! =  !  !#D )  (8 ' (&#.#(#!' '!#! ( 0A B '  D!# ( (! ( & ' (  !#.#!''8- (,2B5

35  0; D'. #  0221 & '    !  !! ('##  - (  ## ! (   E/   '8! )&# $##!  #.#(#!'!!5

A5 FC#0221&  C!(  5

;5  0F!$ 0221&  '=& ' $(#D'('   G 4#(!(02 1+F1> @ !(&#.#(#!'D('  (8 '(&#.#(#!'(31B5 !#!'(! .#(;2B( !# (!' >#!# #  !  ( #!# #/($!@  )#(#!# (D 50AGF+;54>#!# (&## (AF  0221 ( D 5 37G1;254 = 122 B@ )  '  8#  #.#(#!' ( D 537GAA254 >!!!'   &*   17 D'. #  0221@ $!##! =  (8 ' (&#.#(#!'(31B5

,5   C8! ( 11   0227  ## ! (   E/   (#    ! .*'  (#  = &    )&# D  '(  =  < !#'(#-!(& '! (.('##5

F5 < !#'!'DD!'  "  1;C.# 0223!= ##!'!!(! .#(& '### !#!'(! .#( ;2B(!#.#!'(!'5

 (#8!# . #D    #!' ( ! .# '!#! # ( ! $ !D  ( <  #!!  D  ( $8# : #) ( 8 !:  8: (& #8# !4! !#) ! 8 !:  ( #! D' 4 !# !( !#!#! !! -! !#(88: 1++3 . '# '# #!  ! !  ( #8!  #' !' #  ! *( (&'(#58 !: .#!! H'!! !(



/01,1/0223  47/+4   D!#(88:#(#!# !!$#! #! #! =  !:-!!(88:5&'(#! H#!D!#8$##!')# #DI#!  (!  ! .# ! '!#!  !#$ (&'.  ( DI D. $5#!(. :!8#)#!'(! .#'!#!(,2B  !!)!#!(#.#!# (#!#!!#)($!#  8'!)&# !(: 8 (5"8 ' (! #! '8- !(##'5

+5 !(0D'. # 0223(E"'#8'( "6666666666 -.)  ! $ !D  &  .  ( (#   &  ! )  #!' ( ! .#(#!J! !#'=,2B!!(!!#!('8'' !#.(8<5

125  12 # 0223 &   (  . ('## C!!  (( (  !!#!#(' !)#!'(! .#'!#!(,2B(!#.#!' (!'5

115 ,C#0223& 'D#!#!#=!!('## .!)&  .#!&' ! ((8 '(&#.#(#!'D#<' &   !)! !(##!!#)&#$##!('(!#(0AB(.#!J! DD!'  # .#.#(#!''.' &  5

105  07 !$  0223 &    !#! (# &#!# ! ! *' = & ') !( !(&#.#(#!'D(' (8 '(&#.#(#!'(31B(- 1 !$ 1++;5&! 'D' 'C8!( ##!(   E/ !=('##(&  5 K#&<#!#!D!  ( (# '!#  (##!  #!' ( ! .# ( & '  (8 ' (&#.#(#!' ( &   (.#! J!  D# '5   ! ( "  .#! (&#  '8!  #!' ( ! .# 8$ ( ;2 B (  !#.#!' (!'5

175  00 !$  0223 & '    = &!  ( !! ( #-  ('##  - ( #$ ! (   #  ! = &! #   & (&(#4 ! (-1 !$ 1++;5

&  &.#! = ! !   #  !  D!  (& (  (#D  !! '' ' (  C8! (  ## ! (   E/    !!  8 ( #! ## )& #. $# 5  '!#! '!! )  " #!#((#!##!'(! .#(;2B( !#.#!'(!'5

  #  &  (.#! DD!   ('(!# ( 0A B    . (&#.#(#!'   !#  ! (  L8 #! ;1  (  ##!!# D!# ! - # !! >!!#! < (< 8<  #. $#  ! ('!.(@(D#!)&#&.#!C#  ( !#.#!'



/01,1/0223  43/+4   (#0,9!1++3!D#(D#!)'!!D##!)&88 .   " !'(#! #!!5

135 10.$ 0223&  C!(  5

 )

15 #8.# & 8#!#C(### >@'!'(#D#'!#!#!'(- 1 9!0227 #$!( #'(AC8 (! '#(!!.#4 '#(!A'!!1;C8 > !51!5 !A; @5

E#!=&!#(&'!#(1;C8   #$D'('  0,C.# 0223> M17212;@ ( #8.#(!'17D'. #   (##!#! #!#  8! !!! #$!(  # ( #'8     = ! # C8 !#!#   ( &!!! ( &'!#(.<C8 5

E'! C8 ((&-!##'!$#5

05 ''(D !('##' # '!  ! .$ . !( !5A; 5

75 #D'('   !#8'' (( #!( #(;!$  0222> @ !! '  .#8  1  C.#  0227 ! H!  (#D#!# ($ (##!#'8((#( #5E  !' ##!(.# )( #!G#)(#!J! ! :'=#-  ( ##) -8#$!.#8 !K  D#! C #(#)! ('! #!  !  (#! > M 10,  3;, #(5 1 10;  17; #(5 3$ !  'D' @5  .:   )#     '( !=('D!( -8! #!# ! # .( #!G#)  ' .(-C (! '.#8 > M11,+7#(5;$110 7;2 #(5 3N  "  1++F O 7, 5 71; #(5 7$@5 G!  )#   '( (!1 C.# 0227#! (#! -!!(!(.! ! #$ ! '!!  !#-  (G  # ! '8#    . -8 (  '(  ! (   !    (##!# (  '( !((#DD' !#'#(#D#'  5

&-.'.!#'(#(& ''!'D#! < ! ( " 1;C.# 0223!('###!#8#'!' (07!$  02235 !! -8(D(( ##)(#D#!# !'= #D'('  G #.#(#!'(1+C#1+A+> @(#1 C.#  0227!#$5



/01,1/0223  4A/+4  

35 E & !5 3   &#.#(#!' > !5 F  @ ! '!  (& #D# #!' 8'#! (& (#  (& #(! >5 1@5 &#.#(#!' ! '!'  . (- )& !    !  !  8 .#!'    = . #  ( #! <  !!#! !#(' !#>50@5

 !5;=F  '.#!)?

! '!' ##!' ( ! .# !!  ! !!   !# ( &!#!( ( & '=# ( D#(#(&!#.#!'! .#)#! #$! J!  <#8' ( # # !!  ! '! (& !!#! =  !' :*#) !  *:#)5   (&##!' ( ! .# ( 8 ( ' &!#.#!' )# ! J!  <#8' ( # ! # .  (& !   D#  (&! (#(&!#.#!'> !5; @5

! '!'##!'(8#!!(##!#(&$(& !#( #$##!'(8#(& '  :'(! .#')##$ '((# (&!#.#!'#!!(##!# '!(&!!#!=!':*#)! *:#) ! )&  #!  -  ! #!! !    ( '(!!# <#8#$> !5, @5

! '!' #.#(#!' &##!' ( 8# !!   !# )# !  ''  !(8( '>51@5 '# !#.#!' !#. ! '!'#.#(&# '!!!!#!= !':*#)! *:#) )#  .)   $$!  ##!' ( 8# !!   !# >5 0@5   ' C  )# &< I#!  (&!#.#!'  !#. . (&J!  !!#!( !':*#)!*:#)!(!#!J! <#8' )&#< !! '!'#.#(#&!!#!J:(&#   ! .<:$#!>50@> !5F @5

A5 E & !5 0F 5 1   & '  ( #! =  ! !#-  &# ! #.#( = ;;0/7B  # =  (#4 ! &# ! #.#( = A2 B  #  =  ) ! ( ! &# ! #.#( = 32 B  #N (   '#$ & ' !(& -& !50F51$#  '!( (#4 !&#!#.#(=32B #5

 . (&#.#(#!'   C # ( (#! J!  '.' .! !!  D!# (  #!!#  D#  -! ( &#!' '5  &$ (& .DD!#.! '#'P#! )& ' - .(&!!#! =  !'&  #(&!#.#!'   !#.#!' (!' ! <#8#$4 .(&#.#(#!'!J! '.' $(!!#!#)  # *>D5 1++15770.5#(57@5C # ( #(-  )  !# J:!    =    ( &#.#( <#8! ) & '(#  !! ( #   !! ( !!#!#)5 !D# ( !('(!#(#.!J! DD!'(#- :'!#)#!#  ! ( &$ ( # ! (   !##  !  (  $! (



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

E&8#! ( . (&#.#( '.'   &   #(!    $ ( ( #!#(!(! .#> @& (   M  (' ')('! #!#(&! .( (!#(& ##) #!#($ !!(!(! .#.! !  #(' !#(& -!*(:(###)(# :! (# $!(# *(8 )#!D#! 'D' 5 '.! $C!# ( & '    :#< !     '!!#.#!' (   (    ! (#.! J!  .'   ## ( !   '(  (&#!#5 E#    &!     ( !#D#  =  <#8 (  '(    !   'D'   <  5  )  . (&#.#( ! ('! #' $(  '(!#(# '8 (*!-J ( &!#C!#D#'#(##$> M10+3,0@5

;5    J! $#' < M 10;  0FF  #$ D'('  (     '#'  C # (  !   (#!# ( G'.!# ( G#.#(#!' (  (#DD' ! $ : ( G  #5   !! D# '   !- #D (!#(G#.#(#!'((#DD' !$ :>D5 !51; (#D'('   !#8'' (( #!( #(;!$  0222  #$ !!D# # N .#  #(5 1@ ## )  DD! (  (#!#(G'.!#(G#.#(#!'5  .:# '= !#) #!!= (  ##(G# !=G'.!#DD!' G (    #< #('(! ( #! ! (! # (#   #! # !(G8)G#D#!( !5  !#D!'.#!  )(   -(!=('.!#(#. 8!(J5"# J#  !#- !! (  (   <  !< (G#.#(#!' D#<'    !      '.!# !' #'    ('## ! '  D   !  !  #! #8 '5



/01,1/0223  4,/+4   !D# # .#! ( G' !  (G ! '.!#  )G       (( #!  '#!##!$> M11+3,1#(50$@   )G '!(G#! !#.G '> M110 1,A5#(50@5 !#D((#. 8('C= !' # !   C # ( # D! C!  (   (G#! !# <! J! ##!' !  D## ## )G '.!#  ( !! .#!  !:' (G#$C!#.#!'> M10;0FF@5G J! M11+3;F>3,3#(53@ #$D'(' (   #(' '#!$ '#!# (  8 ( G 4#.#(#!'  !#D )G G' !#!  8! ( G'.!#(G  4#(!) #! (#'(# .#!  !  #!' ( ! .# ! G!#.#!' <#8#$ ## )    #( . !!DD!'> " 022232;5320!  'D' N M (72C.# 02270A1/20@5

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

F5 &-& (#!(.( #)!#(' ')  ! '(#!  #!' ( ! .# '(#! = ;2 B5   &< !# ( " $!#!'8!=#!'(! .#(  !(;2B( !#.#!'(!'$!!D#!)&!#!!(&DD!#)&   &   #  #(' !# ! ) &<!# ( ! $ !D  ( < !  *(  (&' ( #5 !D# !! < !# 4  '!)( %6666666666(- )&'!'DD!'! # - 4#!(!#!'!' #=&#(&)(*!:- !#(#### 4#.  $!(C # ( '#!'5  !'8 ( " $# #!(& !'#(=&#(! (0,9!1++3!(&!  !! # !=&.#(  !DD!# (& #8# 4#(! ! )  $8# : #) !  88#



/01,1/0223  4F/+4   ( #!  .! = ! '8 ( &<#! (& 8 !:  ('$!! D' 4 !# !( !#!#! >< !# " 5;/,/17/1A@5&*(  #(&' ! (#(&< !#( " )  '.- J! -!!D#'5

+5 &     #  !  .  (&#.#(#!' ( D 537G1;254  (!! .# (&## (AF 5 #!&!$#(&<# # !! 'D' #)#  '#!' '(<<#8(C # ( (-   )  'D'   #  !!#!#)  !#)'    M  . #!# (  ('(!#  '#!' <# $!#! =  (8 ' (&#.#(#!' #(!#)(31B5

 DD!  #  !!#!#) ( 'D'  ! # ) .!  '!(   :DD!!(!#.#!'#! ''!#!#.(!  #.'0221 =.# 3G37,54D 5 #0222>&)J!# ! ! (#  0222!$ 1N#.()#D#!#3@#! ''.'0221= D 53GA3F54 &'.!#(# ! 0222!0221>R0AB!$1250$#'#? #'#),P02235+1@5 # $ !!( (#'!#! ! (& : #  ( ! .# ( ) ! :  #!  ( ' :$((#  #D' # =*(!  #0221>31,: N# '#),/02235+2!$+50@!!(#!J!  !'=3G,3154 )#(# (D 5A;&F+054#! !(! .#(;2B # (D 573G17A545

 J#& !('(!#<#(0AB #  &#.)  !$!#!=!!(D 50AG;2154) ' # #.#(#!'(D 537GAA254((8 '(&#.#(#!'(310B5

125 .()# '-(  (. J!  C!'5





/01,1/0223  4+/+4  

)  3  )*   *) 



671/1   8  911 1  4! $+# :

  /1 

15 '    .$5

 /1

05  C!!5

75 D    !# (  )& .! D     !    '!  J! (  ('# ( 72 C  (-  !#D#!#   # (' ( '  #$ D'('  (   E:S#T :D)# ; ;223     ! # <# 5  ('#  ! J!   8'5  '#  (#!? @ #(#)  <!!)('##  !('# $!# #!(('## !!)'N $@ <    ) !#D # !# .#  ((  !! !  ('##N @  !   #8!    (   '!!5 E#  '#   !#!   ! # ''! '' '  !!  @ $@ ! @ #4(  #$D'(' (  !  !#-    )&# (. ('  # .$5'# (  !#  * (  . )#  ! C#! ## )  ('## !!)' ! &. ( )'!'<'(#'  !> !517012;!12F@5  8 DD#- ?   '#(!?   *E ' #"   

#D ( '! J!!!#D#'< !###)&=&DD#D'('  ( # 8 DD



/01,1/0223