Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/1154/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1154/2007 Généré par l'IA

Financial Instruments Validity as Securities

Numéro de cause ATAS/1154/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Frais judiciaires à la charge de l'autorité
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case concerns a dispute over the validity of certain financial instruments issued under a statutory scheme, where the core issue was whether the instruments constituted securities or investment contracts under the relevant law. The court reasoned that the instruments satisfied the established criteria for an investment contract because they involved an investment of money in a common enterprise with the expectation of profits derived solely from the efforts of others, emphasizing the passive role of the purchasers in the scheme's success. Consequently, the court held that the instruments were indeed securities subject to the regulations, affirming the lower court's determination.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Financial Instruments Validity as Securities: The court reasoned that the instruments satisfied the established criteria for an investment contract because they involved an investment of money in a common enterprise with the expectation of profits derived solely from the efforts of others, emphasizing the passive role of the purchasers in the scheme's success. Consequently, the court held that the instruments were indeed securities subject to the regulations, affirming the lower court's determination.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
instruments financiers validité du contrat règlement financier réglementation des investissements droit de l'entreprise common law

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Applied to allocate court costs against the appellant.
Généré par l'IA
A/3271/2007
Securities Classification of Financial Instruments
A/1252/1999
Validity of Financial Instruments Dispute
A/836/2006
Validity of Financial Instruments Despite Legal Change and Jurisdictional Challenge
C/26116/2001
Financial Instrument Regulation Validity Appeal
A/16/2007
Contractual Interpretation and Financial Instrument Validity

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied to allocate court costs against the appellant.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



           "#$%&"'(() "##*&"'(()



  +, ++,  +  ,

-  '

! '% ./.  '(()



 !!!"##$ % %&

 &%

##   # ' !% !&!"  &(%!&)* + &,,-. 

                 !   !

   3,/43   + + 0 

5!3+%6% %&78&!%!&9:;& +%<!!&"+%"=+% !>?8@A! "!3%.0 B& ,4C

8  &%& 8+ ! &+ %!% &   "&"   &%  #  # ##  #5!3+%6# 7&% %&0%>!&,4 04 A"=%!% ,D "&& +%"!" ?  % %& 8 &%=!" + %  %=! &!!&%38+6E3?00>=!%,D04A"=%!%,D  !&+&0 !C

% %&"+ "0DA"=%!%,D8!!&"9:; +%6   ##    #   #   5!3+%6 8!&!"7C

+%"!! .0 B&,D8!&!"!A %"% %&?88=!& +% !&F!!&"9:;C

  % %&  A %" ++ !&!    "! ";F %++& = !% "&" %!"&= !% &!"@8%39:;+& G !C

+%"!! 0*=%!,D8!&!"%>&"  ++ !&! A &%  %%!%#%"&%!&8&&@8"  !5!3+%6# 7%"F!  9:;  04 +&(% ,4 F &% ? H+ %  +&%   +"%!    &!&!  & !! =%!%  % !& @ 8!!&" ! A& " &%% 8F!& 8 &!=!&" AA&!=  ! @  &!&! HC ? 8!&!"  &&!& ?% %&8=!&%"!&"&%=!"?%&0 !&+ =!&6 % >&!A!%8+"%!  G !8&!=!&"AA&!=C

    % %  2 ! ,2  % %&  &&  + !&  =  !"%&?!%+%<"&& !@ &!&!  !&! %&!=@ %" !!   &!&!    G  ! 3   !&!  "; %?! 3 & 6  % %+!C ?8  & @ 8&!    "!!  & @ 8 &% !  !!&"8%39:;+!0DA"=%!%,DC

%"+ )>!,28!&!"!& ! C

+%%%I&!!&0->!,2 %!(" &&"? %%I&  ,2 A"=%!% ,2 %     & 8"&&  A!& "&!&  & & + !& ((8+6&&&&% %=!&A!&8 (>&8+++%6  %!(A""%5!3+%6 7&+8!&>?8@% !&  &&+! &C

 +% %%I&  02  B& ,2    "  >;&  %!(  " %+! &C



/01.)/,2  3./43   8!   AA&  !"%" ?   &%& +" +% 8&& =  +%   9:;  +%"&!& +  %&"%!&!? 8  &%&  &%=! =& ? 3! !&;;"+%%=!&!!&%&?8!8J=!&+% 8+ J%C?+% "&!&!!&&&8 (&!%+ !&?%& && &&&  %""%&!  ? 8&& ! =%!&  F!;%  A %!&% 8 &%=!8++%&!&(!+@+%&&! 8! !?8@!%=%"   &%+%&! 8 +%&&!   &%=!   %& ? && +"%!  8&&&  + =!&I&%+%! !"%&! &!&%8&!=!&" !@ &!&! C

 +% %   0, +&(% ,2  %!(  "  % "  %+%!  8!&   !?" @  % %&  +!  8%%I&   & 8 !A %" ?8@ "A&  %%? 8!!  ,1 +&(%   %!& ;%" @ >;%C

% %&8+ "!&@&& % "!!+%&!  %&?"&";%"@>;%K

+ + +  

 %!(& +"&&&!6%5%&K4DK0&K9K17C

% %&%=(@A %5%&K4D&D* 7C

!&!;+ %&%% !&% %&@8!!&"9:;@ +&% 0DA"=%!%,DC

 8  %++%  %6; "; !=&L M%"  % !& @ M!!&"  9:; &&M!&+ ! +%&!&+ !5%&K1K0 &K 7K&%"+&"+ !!?!M&++%&!@%++ %&&%=! &?!9%9@F%%&!=!&"@+!&+5%&K0*K0 7K% !&@ M!!&"  9:; ++  ?   !&!  %&!= @  +"%!    &!&!  &%"!" ?M%"&!("%"5%&K1K0&K 7K F &%  8%&K 0. K 0   &%  =!;% 6  0% >!& ,. ! ?! !!&"!3%+%"=@&AA&5%&K-K.7F%"%& G  ! !&!=!&" !@ &!&! %+!& !&! %&!=@ +"%!  &!&! C

 %%!%# +%"= !&?!!&L H !& !A!&! 8%&K)08 % %8%39:; 5 7 !!&& F %"  +  4*  8;&&!    (% 8!!&"& @&F9:;"="6= !A %"



/01.)/,2  3)/43     9!& % &%&&%=!&+ %!%=+% A!  % !&K   =&!  +%"= !&  =%& 8 !% &  +!&   &!&!  !+ %&&?(""A!!!%A %!& &%3 +%&&!   &%=!  &&& % +& %"   + ! &+ %!% (=&! "K +%6 F & !=% "9;   %%!% =  & %!&" ;= ! = !=!& @+%% !%!=&K

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

 +% !%    %%I&  02  B& ,2 &%!&& 8   & & + !& ((8+6  !"%"?6 %?%&"!3% %&!A @  +"%!    &!&!   +%   9:; 8=!& AA&!=& &%=!"+ %%=!&!!&%?%&+"%! !A"%!%@ G !   %+!!& +   !&!  +%"= +% 8%&K 0. K 0   & ? + !+ %&!&A!&?+% !&%<!%&? &!&! !&"&" ";&"!&!%+&+"%! &%=!AA&!AC

A %& %!(%"A"%%@&%%I&& %?% %&3 ?!&%=!"+ %E%&0 !3+&>&!A!%8+"%!   G !8&!=!&"AA&!=&8 +% !&F!!&"8%3 9:;C

8!% % !&I&%%>&"K









/01.)/,2  34/43  

  1 0 ,  +, ++,  +  ,

!

  2.-

0K "%% %%=(K

! 2.

,K %>&&K

.K !&?+% "%&;%&!&K

)K A %  +%&!   ?M +=& A %% % %  &%  +%"& %%I&   "!  .* > % 6   &!A!&!  +%6  %!( A""% 5#9O!G%9 A?!DD)  7+%= !% %&!6%% !& +(! A %"&F%&K1, !A""%% %!(A""%02 >! ,4 5 7C  " !%  % %  !& !!?%   !   &!A &  J+%=&+ %&%!;&%% %&  &!%C! !& I&% %"  %!( A""% +% = ! + &  +% = ! "&% !? F  !&!   8%&K ),  K  +%"& %%I& &  +!6  + !   % %&!= ?"  J+%= !=&I&%> !&@8= !K  ;%AA!6%  +%"!&       $P Q   (#

  +!  A %  +%"& %%I& &  &!A!" F +%&! !! ?M #%"&%!& 8&&@8"  !+%;%AA



/01.)/,2