Security Interest Priority and Prior Judgment Validity
Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe case involved a dispute over the validity of a prior judgment concerning the priority of security interests in various property; the court examined several prior state and federal decisions, noting discrepancies and interpreting legislative intent regarding security interest perfection, ultimately concluding that a specific statutory provision controlled the priority issue as intended by the legislature, thereby affirming the result reached in a particular prior decision while clarifying the reasoning applicable to the situation before it.
Regeste Legislator
Généré par l'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Security Interest Priority and Prior Judgment Validity: The case involved a dispute over the validity of a prior judgment concerning the priority of security interests in various property; the court examined several prior state and federal decisions, noting discrepancies and interpreting legislative intent regarding security interest perfection, ultimately concluding that a specific statutory provision controlled the priority issue as intended by the legislature, thereby affirming the result reached in a particular prior decision while clarifying the reasoning applicable to the situation before it.
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IACited in the final order regarding the allocation of procedural costs.
Texte complet
$%&'($&'') $%%*%$&'')
!!
! !
+, - # %( ., &'')
!" # $!%! & $'$& ' '' " (! )* &+
'
* * ! ' #$ '" +,-.!
! "#
)1/4)
/
05 ' 6 "# ! 7'! !$0448!( 6 ' 9 +:9 ")#; &' ! "# 5
15 ' #& <$ & =' & >? @ "& 1 &'#A 12205
B5 B2"$#A 122-! "$& $"#""= ' 7# & ;" 6 ' "= ' 7# >* C@5
.5 =&& " "#"! & " ' ' 7 ' " $#' " $&A (7$"$ " 9$ '''''( ' 7 5
-5 "$ "027$6 1223!* C D'$''"#"5
35 0- 7$6 1223! = '$ $ =' & $'$ 9 +' " * C & 7 # && ' E '' "$ 7 ' 6 (= & ' & ' " # ; & $& "$ 'E=' ' " 7'5
F5 "$ && ' "0 # 1223! * C 7 #$"$ " 75 7 ' # ( ( = $ " & ' " 9 " " =' '$ & ''("; !& & 6 A$$7 " ' ! "6 '& 6 (= # ' " # ; & $& "$ ' =' ' " =7'5 * & '! * C &&$ D & " (! & ( =' ' & ,' "$ $ ## & $& "$ '! 7' ( & ' '$ $ 6 ' A' "=' ' # $9E= ' 7# # ' 9 ! "$&"##' " 6 " 6 " &< " ( =7' ' " # $5 * C' #$(==&;!= $=6 '&&& '$& 6(= # ' " # ; & $& "$ ' =' ' " 7' ! "= & '! D' 7 ' 7 & " '=$' '&# "' #A "= 77 "' 7 '"7 "'!"=' & '! ' ' 7 '"= 9'6 '$'$" $E ' "#G " !(=# '&9 ""=7'5
85 "B6 1223!= $ ' D'$ ' ''"$ & A " #&9 "= " & '' D " ( * > @5 "# =6 =' '$& ' 9 "" 7 5*=9 '"=' ' " 7 ! 7 ' 6 ( =' ( $##' (= && (= 6 ' " ' " A$$7 " ' 7# ! & ( = & 6$ ' ' '$"& 6"6 #'77'$76 " 7 5" ( " H * ! 10 # 1223! ' " & #' 77'$ 76 "#; '"I ! "# !" #'(= & # "& " E=&& " ";(= 6 '5
/012./1223 )B/4) ''"'! & " '& 6"6 #' 6'J − 1=1047 52-. 6#A 122176 " # − 0=0117 --F7$6 122B76 " # − .-27 00 6#A 122B76 " # − .-432186 122.76 " # >#; @ − 1=2227 58 6#A 122.76 " # − 0227 18"$#A 122.76 " # − 1=8..7 50200# 122-76 " # − 1=2227 518D 122-76 " # − 0=2217 5B K'122-76 " # − 0227 53&'#A 122-76 " # − B=2227 51"$#A 122-76 " # − 0=1B27 5F7$6 122376 " #
7 ' # ( (= ! " 1221 E 122-! 6 ' 6 $ # '' # ## ' '"0-=14FB2& =' ' " 7 !( $( 6'E# ''# " B087 5F25 D '$ (= 6 ' $9#' # " = 9' E " # "' 9 122B >6 1=-227 5@ ' (= 6 ' )#,# && '$ "6 <9122.>6 .=2227 5@5L& ($& (&& ' " 6 #' 6 ' $'$ 77'$ 76 " I ! "# G " ! ( "# 9 ! E 9 ! #; ! "# !$D 6'+: ''" ; 6=7'! '&"' 6 ! ' (= ' #"5 =' E ( = $ 6 = 9'76 " 7 #"I 5 &'!9 $'' 6 "9 !#; = & = 9')#,#& ;"= "H * 5
' ' L& ($( ' #A "7 +"=6 "= 9' " H * $' ' '#& $ " 3 # 1223 & " & #' 77'$E"''$ !='(= =$' '" $EH * & ; ( * C 7 ' # ( ( " #' =$' ' & 6A & ( '#& $5
'7 & " '77 "6 '"'$"8"$#A 122->&10 @ " ' ' ( # ' " # $ E '<! (= 9 " " &' ')7 ! ( =7' M ' " 7 ; $'' (5 'L& ((#; ' 6 &! A (= 'E& 6 E =' ' "=7'5 '& & " 'N77 "6 '"'''"
/012./1223 )./4) 7# N "'$ " 14 # 1223! " ' ' ( "# $ 04F1!'I 5
45 " 3 6 1223! ' & " ' E =&& " 6A " "& ;7 ""$# ' (#; '$9#'" "# ' (= $'$ #" =$'$ &$! & ( " '= 9'EI 5
025 6 '$E& !* C!" $& "-# 1223!' #$ && ' "=''" $& "H * E (,'" '6'" "$' # 5
005 " 0. D 1223! ' & " ' & " $& " H * "'$"006 12235 <$9#'D ''''' "="# ! ##$ G!" ' '( ' 7 $ ##"1=-227 57$6 122B& #; 5$9#'& " ' '''' " H * 7 #' (= 6 $ 3 D 1223 # ''"0=2227 5E#; & =' ' " 7 !( & '# '' ' '"6 #'& =$1223E1=1B27 5
" #' " H * "'$ " 00 6 1223! & " ' & '! '(= 6 $J − 1=1042-. 6#A 1221E "# ! − 0=0117 5-BF7$6 122BE "# − .-27 500 6#A 122BE "# − 1=2227 58 6#A 122.E "# − .-47 5--11 6#A 122.E "# − 0227 518"$#A 122.E "# − 1=8..7 52B00# 122-E "# − 1=2227 518D 122-E "# − 0=0207 54BB K'122-E "# − 0227 53&'#A 122-E "# − B=2227 51"$#A 122- "#
015 $& "10D 1223!* C!& ;L#"' D' 7 ' 7! "# ( # '' 6 $ & ' ' 77 ' & (= ' ' ' 7' " # ; & $& "$ ' ' " A5 * C &"' 6$(6 "= 9'$' '' " $E#; 'E " ''='( "6 & ( =$' '&6 $E#; " =7'5* C"#"$!7 "= (= 9'6 <$'A "' $
/012./1223 )-/4) E=7'!( '" #&$#'"= 7 #' '' '' 6 "=$6' D' 7 ' 7 E =&& " L& ' 5 & $ $ ( " # O ' =6 ' "$& $ "#" "= ' 7# (=# ""$#A 122-='(=E #&' "# ""$#A 122B(=" '& ' ,' 6 '$+$'5
0B5 "02D '1223! '=' $7$ $E=77 "6 '"8"$#A 122- & & 6 7 ' ( =' A #; ( 9 " " 7 5 L& ($ (= "$ D" = $'$ " 9 & 9 " " 7 '("L7# '' ' #&#' "$ 7 '( "# 9 " ' &' ')7 5 77'!#; "=7' 77 "' A&<+ (( & #'''&"= & "=7'5 ='& '' (= ' #& A " "#" '''' 5 '='" &# "& " "=' " #'& ''' ( 7 '9 "$& #; 5
0.5 "04D '1223!* C=' && '$ED' =9 '" 7 & A'"=77 "6 '"8"$#A 122-& " '& '5
0-5 "12D '1223! '& " ' & "= ( " $#; '' "' A "" #'5 '(#; ' 7 6 A M= 9'& =' ' " &' ')7 " '9 " '(='''"7 '( # ##"1=-22 7 5 "& '" '5
! '7 '6 (" 'L ' 7# $ $ & '& "LE #&' "# #' OA$$7 " " ''(" ! = (' ; $##'! ' E&$ "E( "$& $"#"5' #" (= '$9 ' #(= $#& #'" ' 7# " (" ; $5
035 & " ' E =&& " '' '' $# " #; " ' ' 7 # ( I " " # = 9' ( $'$ 6 <$ & =' ' " 7 ' ( "=' & ' $9#' " $ ##"1=-227 5 5
0F5 " - ' A 1223! ' & " ' " #' $'A ' (= 6 $ ## " 0=23-7 5 14 &'#A 1223 E "# 5
/012./1223 )3/4)
!
05 96 P 9 ' D" >@$'$# " 7 $' ' '$!"; 0 K'122B! A' " > *@! #& $" (D9! " ' & $ "' ' 6 )& $ "'! ( &&$' ' : D9 > '5 0 '5 ' -3 @5 A '' ' (! '##' ''' ' 6 E ' 7# >75 '50'5 !-351'5@5
* 'EP' "P$' " :D9 & A7$"$ > C@1FD6 122. > C0B2 023@! " 96 " &'$! 0B7$6 ! " & ' ' ' 9' > '5 031 @ & #''' * " $9 ! E ' D9 ' ' ! " P''' " P$' " 6LD9 5
15 7 #$#'E= '5-351'5! * Q' ' (" ''' & $6 E P '5 B8 " ' " 0 # 0443 ' 7# > CR * - 02@5 * #&$' & D9 " "P&;'" $'A 5
B5 $& $"7 #'"$ #& $& !& $' ' 6A > '5B8 50 C@5
.5 P AD' " ' " "$' # ' &' ,' # A$$7 "P ' 7# & 7 !" # $& ;"9 ")#; &' ! 9$ 5
-5 @ P ' & 7' ' & '' # "$ "; # ( ' " "P7'D(PE7 " "( '' ' PS9 " 08 ! P ' " # $ * ! " 0- P P' & > '5 F 50 C@5
A@ P '5150" ' 96 ' 7# > C@ "$7 ' " & D'' E 5 7 ' '##' & ' & $ 6 "P #& < ' " P77 E "P ' 7# "P#& < "& "# " # $" ' 5
@& D'' E &'A$$7 "& '' 9 " "P "& 7' L P' '$& ' #P' ' "# ; & $& "$ ''" A> '5B50 C@5
35 *P9 ' " ' " 9 " ' "P' '$ & '! < " $7$ E P '5 04 51 " ;9#' "PL$' " ' 7# " 02 ' A 1220> C@5 " & $ (P" 6',' ' +$
/012./1223 )F/4) " '7$"$ 5 ! 7$"$ " ' ' ' & 6$"08"$#A 048F >@ & $6 ' '5 81 50( ' ' & ' ' 7' ' $9 & " '"P ''" $ "+A '"7'5"$ $' 9; ' 6L ' ' & ''7' ' * (P ' $'$ " " P '' " $ " +A ' " P7' "P ''"" # " $ "+A '"& '"$7" 5
F5 '!" # $* !'D'' E C5 7') !& (P & A$$7 " ' ! (P #& P " " ' ' ' 6 & $& 5
85 P&;! P' " ' " 9$ ! &< " ( $ " =7'! ( P&& (5 &"'! '"# " & "P' '$& ' "9 ""=7'5 (= '! '"( '(' ;# " ' ' ' 6& $& !E6 "P' ' & $& "$ '" 7'!' #& 5
45 " # " '##'!& $" ' $9 & & & ( ' ! ( 7 ' & ' ' " " 6' ,' ''$ "= 77 & D95 & & =' & A 5 * & '$ ' ' '& "6 "& ' " A E= ' ' "=77 5
) #& "& ' = A 9' "& ' "=&& ' !"# O &' ,' A#' L 9$ "=! & 6 ##"$ & ' " ' 9 ' " 7 ' 6 ($! 7' " ( (' " "6 && ' $("=A"& 6> C01-04- "51' $7$ @5* D & "'" ' !=' '$"# ' ' 6 D9 " 6' "$ 7 ' ## & 6$ ( (= ' 6 " $ '$ >T ! " " U 6 & : +'! . $"5! 048.! &5 0B3R %!"6 V'9 +'&79!1$"5!&51F8+5-@5
D9 7 " "$ ! 7 " & ' ' " ! 7 ' ( ! 7' "=,' $'A " # ; $7'A! && ' ## & 6 #AA! =' E)" ( & $'' "9 $ " 6 #A & $& "$ '5 77 ' " & (= 7 ' & ,' "$ $ #' ## +<& '+; & A5 # ' $$#' " 7 ' $9$ 6 9A! D9 " '! $+$'! ' L ( & ' & & AA> C013B32 "5-A!01-04- "51' $7$ @5 =L ')') &! " ' " ! & & ( ="# ' ' D9"6 ''' !"" '!76 "= $> C 013B11 "5-@5
025 =&;! ' $'$ & " ' & $$& $ " H * 5 * P "; L( '$'$"K#''#& $'"'$! '( ' 6 $ " ## 77 ' E #; ' E I & 6 =' ' "
/012./1223 )8/4) 7 !( ='"= & ''$!E'""& $" !& = ' #$5 " ='&"' # ED' '(' "6 " #''L& ' " '=9 '"=6 "= 9'E#; ' EI 6,' '6 & A'77 '5
A " $ $'$ 6 & L& ' ' " 6 " #' 7 & 'EP&& "" ' "; (P $'$"$# ' $!6 "9 $"6 #A ( !(P P' ' & $& "$ '" 7 5 < "; "="#'' & ' ' " Q' E = $ " 'L ' 7# 5
005 'E"$' # "& (" '" 'E& '' 5
L' #"= '501 C!" 'L ' 7# $ $& ' & "LE #&' "# #' OA$$7 " " ' E& 6 " ' 7# !# &' "-& ;7 "# & ($' '"5
"$ " '' " & ' ( "L "P ' 7# $ $ &6',' $#$& P $""$ "& &' " ("; "$&W'""#"5
=&;! '"$& $"#"B2"$#A 122-!# #'( X "6 " " 'E& 6 " ' 7# 5 &' " & $'" E "L "= ' E #&' " '' "'! ' "; B2"$#A 122B>75 *013/23"36 1223@5
/012./1223 )4/4)
! 0 / ! !
#
1.2 ,, 3 4 5 6 %)& "7
2 ,
05 $ 6A5
# 2
15 ="#'5
B5 '( " 'E" ' 7# E #&' " B2"$#A 122B5
.5 "#P ' #$E6 ' ##"C 5822!))E' ' ""$&5 9 77 ; & $ "' CC T * T
& 7 #"& $' ,'' ' 7 $L& ' & 9 77
/012./1223