ATAS/1110/2007 · Premises Liability for Defective Step (Cour de Justice (Cour civile))

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The claimant sought damages for injuries sustained from a fall on the defendant's property, alleging the fall was caused by a defective step and lack of proper maintenance. The court reasoned that the evidence, particularly photographic evidence and expert testimony, supported a finding that the step was indeed defective and presented an unreasonable hazard, and that the defendant had actual or constructive notice of this dangerous condition. Therefore, the court concluded that the defendant breached their duty of care to the plaintiff, leading to the injuries, and affirmed the verdict for the plaintiff.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Premises Liability for Defective Step: The court reasoned that the evidence, particularly photographic evidence and expert testimony, supported a finding that the step was indeed defective and presented an unreasonable hazard, and that the defendant had actual or constructive notice of this dangerous condition. Therefore, the court concluded that the defendant breached their duty of care to the plaintiff, leading to the injuries, and affirmed the verdict for the plaintiff.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA

devoir de diligence lésion corporelle par chute responsabilité pour cas fortuit action en dommages-intérêts pour séquestre négligence professionnelle de l'avocat responsabilité du locataire

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive order concerning the allocation of legal costs to the appellant.

Art. 68 al. 2 LTF

Cited in the dispositive order concerning the allocation of legal costs to the respondent.

Art. 64 LTF

Cited in the dispositive order concerning the allocation of legal aid to the appellant.

Généré par l'IA

A/2239/2006

Premises Liability Slip and Fall Notice Dispute

A/2243/2007

Appellant v. Property Owner (Premises Liability/Open and Obvious Hazard)

A/247/2003

Plaintiff v. Defendant: Premises Liability Notice Requirement

A/1172/2005

Premises Liability Negligence Appeal (Falling Object)

A/904/2005

Property Owner Negligence in Slip and Fall Case

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive order concerning the allocation of legal costs to the appellant.

Art. 68 al. 2 LTF

Cited in the dispositive order concerning the allocation of legal costs to the respondent.

Art. 64 LTF

Cited in the dispositive order concerning the allocation of legal aid to the appellant.

Texte complet

!"##$ #"##$

%& '& ( % &( (

()*+ , -.-+ "##$

!"# $

$

%% % & $"# !$'$()

0.*+)0

/

+1 # +2/2 3$ # - " .)), 45 ! $67!89"6:045;< 7!3'$!5 $$!$3!"$#!89"61

.1 !"!!3!"$# 3#"$#=37$$7# ! 4#$#> !+?#7@)7.)), 44$! $7A$#$###43"4A.(7.)), B!?"$! #$#1!C!$7??$?7$#$#+.7.)), 3#A$ #$# 7$" !3 !$1 ##!""$ 7$ $7# 4 '6 D $"'#?$1

@1 /C$.)), 7$#3#B"4#$! "$$$ $""$$$#!!"$$73$7$#!#4A#45 !!"4A1

(1 !# ! .( E$ .)), # B 3# !$ B 3!"$# C5 "$?=!$!F#4##!$4$ B7 !-".))(/".)), 37$C$?#=!$"!3$7$## !+$'@+!#"'.))G 45!"?$D1 5=34#$$44#!!$$!!H"""" $ =3 37=$ "$? ! '#$ 3# "4$ 4 !$!$+@$+( 4=3!"$#!89"6 47$I$71

G1 ! .@ 4$"' .)), 3# ?"# 44$ $ $$ !#1F4$7$7#="4'6D !+"B?4$"'.))G$=$"4"?$!01 7$$7#4#$#>% !?#7B7.)),1$ $$4#! 7$#$#7$"!367!$77$!7G 7.)), B$!=7$#$#I$!$7!+.7@)7 .)),1 $$7"!".)), 7$44=3#$$# $ = "4A #$$ ?$1 7$ #"# 4 7 C! !37 $ " .)),1 $$ !$ $7 B 4#! ! $$ 7$ ' #$# "41 344 ! 44$ 4!$ $""$ 3$$$$ !3"4A #$' 4 6 D = 7$ $7# =$# ! 7! ! + " .))G++$'.))G 44$!$7A$#$###43??! ?$1 % 3$$$$ !3"4A #$' 4 ?$ D 3#7$47$7$#4"4$! ?$!$$"I"#$# $$$$!3"4A"$$44$! $7!!#!#$"# !++$'.))GC=3@+C7.)),13# 4!$ #6"$ 3$$$$ ! 3"4A > % 4$$

*++,-*.))/ 0@*+)0 $"'!3??!?$ =7$$7#""7!+ ?#7+.7.)), 3"4AA$##44$!$7!$! +27.)),4.,7.)), =34!$$!$7$! $$ ! "$ !$# ! +2 7 .)), = #J$ = K$ B ?"$!$#$# 7$4#!!34!?!5+27.)),L1

,1 !#!.+?#7.))/ C$#344$!3# "$? ='!454!$ 4#!!$$#$$!++"$+- . C 7$ ! + " .))G +2 7 .)),1 ! "4 45 ! > % 7$ ??$ 4 ? +2 7 .)), "$ ""#!$ ! 3"4A ! "I" C1 6# A$ #$# !# 7'"$ 4#! !34$# ! $7 ! +. @) 7 .)), 47$ 7 !3??$ #7$ 4 ! !# ! 6# $ 4$ ! !1 !$ $7 B 4#! ! $$ 3#$$ 4 "4 3#37$4!$B3!"$#!89"61

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

-1 !#$"$ ! +) " .))/ 4$# ! $" ! !# =#1 3$"# 7# = 36"$ $# ! #4$ !

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

21 ' ! # !# "4$ 4 ! 4$ = 3$ $!$!.+".))/1 $$ $F4#=37$#$# 7$"!3!$G7.)), "=37$$#B$7C=3 +.74$#$$'$17$$#$#4$#!$7 ! ! B 3#4 $ B C"' C" $8 !"$# 1$$!"$ 6#43!"$$!#$# $ 7$#$#7A#44""!#$37$J.( 71?"$74!$#4"!37$" .)),!?$!#$#1.))/ 7$$7#=H!C "4 $"4 4 $ 3!"$# ! 89"6 #$$ $A#!4+@".))/1

*++,-*.))/ 0G*+)0 4#$$!44$F4#=$$!E ! $7 @+ " .)), ! ?$ ! #$#1 !"$$$ = $ 7$ J 6# .G 7 $ = $$ 7$ 4?4$C4$! $."1 $? ?"#"$F!$7 !% ?$$$!C6"$!#?$?$!#?$7! #!4#!!?$1 $"$?$$B?$ #$$!##4% """$C$?#1 3?? !?$7$!#CB?$7=33$!$N$!$= C=3 @+ " $ 4$ C 45 4# ! ?$1 #8#$ 3#47$7!$B3!"$#!37'$#: <4!H C??$7"$$7#!++.7.)), B!$= 4#4#5$"$#!3??!?$?=!H C4$I$"4$#!4#!!$$1

+)1 $4#4 '!# 3??!?$F4# 4!.+ C.))/ =36$!?$!> % 37$#$$ $C!3#$'"$ 4!$!3#3A$4#$# =#1 #$# 3A$ $? ?$ $ 7"''"$ 9$#4!#?$!3$?1

++1 4!$$4!#$#""=#F4$ !$!.G C.))/1% #$#6!#BC61

%

+1 ?"#"$ B O$1 G, 1 + $1 81 - ! 67 O6$ C! :< ' $ ! N$ $ = ! $$$ 4#7 B 3$ G, ! ?#!# 4$ 6## ! !$ ! ! , $' .))) : < = $ $7B?#!#3089"6'6$$3!"$# !37'$#!.GC+2-.:045; <1

%"4#$4C6!!345$#$'1

.1 $# 76 + C7 .))@ $ 44' 4#$ $61 $C$#!?"$!#4$ $7':$1G, ,)$,+ <1

@1 < O#!$BO!"$#!89"6$""$O"4$!$ $7 B 4#! ! $$ $ '## :$1 - 1 + $1 7$1+@$+( <1 = !"$!!#0!4#7 B $ ??$ :$1 2 1 @ < F# !$ !H " " $7$# "B$$"4$!$$7B4#!!$$:$1 +@ 1+ !776!4+C$.))@44' 345<1

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

< OF !O $7$# # 4!$ !H " " $ ! !$B4$$54#$!4#!!$$ $!= 7"$!O??$?O$4?#"$F6# "4"$'! 44$ 47 ! $$ $7$#1 7"$ !## "" 4 "4A?!4!$4 B 4#"4$!?$=O$7$# #"B$$#$#F#1

!< $7$# " B $$ ?$ $! $$ $7$# ! O# !$#BO'$$!O7"B$$4!$!#!O44$ ! $7 :& % R""$ H" '$7866$H S T 71 1-!$1+@ 41+/)<1 44OF??$?!O $7$##??""$$9': P++@@G.Q +2221+-41+)+ !1 .Q %% '$786 ; D S#!1T %8UH8!7U$68$ %H%88$ 1+,+41,(Q 089"6 ; $ ?#!# 7 ! " $ 4#! .5"#!1 1@1-1(1. 41+/2<1

(1 < $$$!7$4!!?$!?$!?$ ! 3"4A 44$ ! $7 47$ :?1 '$7$V6 " RW ! '$6' % 2, S.)))T 41 +G.< C=3B #$43!4$ #$$4##=$74$44 I$ # = "A$ 4$ ! !# ! 6# #6F $$ :I$! '!!$!8 !+/$'.))@ .))@1))++/ X @1+Q ?1 $1 @@/ <1 = $7 $ #4537$!?$$?"$!3$4 44$!

*++,-*.))/ 0/*+)0 $7 47$ 44 7 $ !$ $ '6$ C=3B 3#8# ! !# ! #$ 3"4A #$$ ! !" :?1 @.( <1%$7$'##!3'6$!$74!$!#! 6# $#" #!3$#6$#!:I$! '! ! $ ! 8 ! +/ $' .))@ .))@1))++/ X @1+<1

'< "4$$ ! ! 4#! ! $$ C 4!$ = # 3 4 $7# " = !7$ I$ #"## C=3B 3#8# ! !# ! 6# : P ++2 (2, !1 @< $ ! !"!3"4A:$1@.( < $B!3"$C$?#:$1 @@/1+ <1

< ' ! ! $ ! 8 C6# =3 #7$##!$$7B4#!!$$ !" M ?$ 4! "4$ C C=3B ? ! !# ! 6# "I"4$#B37$!?$$4!$=3#37$4 $7#1$$?? 3"4A7$4##"$4! .G $' .)). 45 37$ ! ?$ $7 +/ $' .)). 6# 4$ ??$ @+ C7 .))@ :?1 I$ ! +/ $' .))@ .))@1))++/<1 % C!$ $ 4$ ! = 45 ?$ ! 3"4A 3# 47$ 4 '##? !3 "B$$ 47$4I$71

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

*++,-*.))/ 0-*+)0 '< A4!3'7="$#$#6?#4 ! 3"4A 4$# 4# ! C6"$ ! ?$1 44 B 4$!37$!?$ ?4$4!4!4$"$ !$!6$$!!4$$$"B3!"$$!?$ : %*P>* $$?$ !$1.@. X@(<1 $? 34$# ! ? !#$ ! 37$ ! ?$ $ !#4A !3??$ B 3#6! ! $ C=3B 4'$ :$1 .@. < 0 #$$ $7 ., " .)), :?1 F$$ ! 6$ ! "" ! 57< $ 45$?$!"$14 B44"I"=$?$ !"$3#$$ 4$$ 47' ?$!$$= 44$ ! $7 $ 47 0!B ! . " .)), ?$ !37 #$# ##7'"$1

,1 < 57#6"$ #?#$B!% =4 =34"4$""4#!!$$ $#=!$ ! 3# $ 4 C6"$ !#?$? 4 $ !#?$7!#!?$!#$#1

'< 8?? +G- ! ! % $7 B 3!"$# ! 89"6 :#$$ C7 .))/< # B $ #6! = C M 3# 3 4 $7# " 4 = 3"4A $$ $ ! 4A 4 ! "$C$?# "4$$""4#!!$$!$ B !"$# #$# B 3# 4 C6"$ !#?$? 4 $!#?$7!?$1

< 44N$ = 4# ! % 44$ "$ ""#!$ ! $7 4 C$ "$? :"$ C$?#<1 3F6 !3 C6"$ !#?$? !3$!#?$7!# 4'$!3#7$= =$#7??$""#!$4C$"$?$$!3#6 45!3089"6$5'?!6# 4'##?!3 4#!!$$46 "I"=!?$6#7??$ ""#!$4$I$?!#1

!< 345 $$? 3 $7 4 4# !3 "$ ""#!$ 4 C$ "$? " !3 "$ F4$"$ "$7# 4 ?"$!#$#:?1481@< '!#!54$!!#! 6# 3#A$!"$##4"! " $ 7 .)), ! ?$ ! #$#1 $ !3 $ ""?$ =$$"$=?$$B?$$"# B"$C$?#:!"4$4!.+".))/< #7$="$$7?$#!#""#!$"$$$ !$7!37'$#!3"4A:$1@@/ <1

*++,-*.))/ 02*+)0 /1 ? $!454!$=3##$#4$#!$7! +. @) 7 .)), $$$# "#!"$ 30!$ A$ 7 ! !"$# C5 4!$ $$ 4#! !#"4$ ! 4$$ ! +@?#7.))/1$$ 44$!3$1+@1.$1< $$4#! "4$ B$$?$ ""4#!!$$1

-1 '##?!!#$=4#5!$ ?$!$$=4#! !$$3#$!!+".))G.".)), $A$F# 4!$!H"$7$#"B$$!$1-1+$1< $+@ 1

21 $ !" $ !# 44$ # #$$ 7A# B3$$#$"#4F"!$!$$7!$ !3#B3!"$#!89"6 $7!#1

*++,-*.))/ 0+)*+)0

( / '& ( % &( (

0- *

+1 #7'1

0-

.1 3!"$1

@1 !#44$!$67!89"6! .+?#7.))/1

(1 7 B $ 67 ! 89"6 ! ! !#$1

G1 $=4#!$6$$1

,1 ?" 4$ ! =3 47$ ?" $ 4#$ I$ ! !# ! @) C !5 $?$ 45 ! ' ?#!# :%8UH8?=, ,))( < 47!"$5!!$ 4' ?"#"$F$1-.!?#!# '?#!#!+/ C .))G : P<Q "#" ! !$ != "$? $ "A!47$4$6$!$!"!$Q!$ I$ !# ' ?#!# 4 7 4$ 4 7 #$= F !$ ! O$1 (. P1 4#$ I$ $ 45 4 ! $ 7=#"""A!47 !7$I$C$BO71 6??5 4#!$ A% # #$0C$;

4 ?" ! 4#$ I$ $ $?# F 4$ =3 %#$$ !O$$BO#"46??

*++,-*.))/

Premises Liability for Defective Step

Synthèse Legislator

Regeste Legislator

Mots-clés

Dispositions légales citées

Décisions connexes

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Texte complet