Affirmation of Judgment in Real Property Contract Dispute
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe court addressed disputes concerning obligations arising from prior agreements, specifically involving the conveyance of real property interests and subsequent contractual performance or non-performance across various years. The appellant argued that the lower court erred by not enforcing specific terms of the agreements, particularly regarding payment schedules, interest rates, and the proper allocation of rights or liabilities stemming from those earlier transactions, often citing prior rulings from different time periods as precedent or demonstrating consistent interpretations. The reviewing court ultimately affirmed the lower court's judgment, reasoning that the evidence presented adequately supported the findings on the parties' respective duties and the appropriate remedies applied, concluding that the original findings were not clearly erroneous or contrary to established law under the controlling contracts.
Regeste Legislator
OfficielLOI SUR LE CONTRAT D'ASSURANCE; ASSURANCE COMPLÉMENTAIRE; ASSURANCE COMPLÉMENTAIRE EN CAS D'HOSPITALISATION; AI(ASSURANCE); INFIRMITÉ CONGÉNITALE; ÉTABLISSEMENT HOSPITALIER; DIVISION PRIVÉE; INTERPRÉTATION(PROCÉDURE); RÈGLEMENT D'ASSURANCE; PRINCIPE DE LA CONFIANCE(INTERPRÉTATION DU CONTRAT) | LCA33
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IAThis is the main ground for the final order (Article 2 of the operative part).
This is part of the main ground for the final order.
Texte complet
"#$#%"&''( )"##'*"&''(
)
) +)! + !+
+,- # % .- &''( !"#$$$%&"'('# ) !#!- *+ "#,-.%$"!!"#$$%! !'/-0 1 2 %-$ "- 30 00 ' $$!+"" ) $$#% 3 4
!
+8&59+
/)
5( %8998 -% !,$5-;.$-899< ,-=! $+#!$$!30>$+,-=?$+#!$@,"--+ #!$ "A$B"$- ! "$ $$ C ,"- - "#,%#$- #A"$- D",$$=- " #"! !-$- ,-%."E ".-- !D",$$$" !$.$$" #$+,-$.% . $A- D"$F ! %A$#(
8( ,-%$$-#$%"B%$ "$-E,"-D$!$!-"$(!G! $ A$- $-.$" D$--B$ ,"- C $ %;"-% ) H%A$#D",$$-H!888<""A-899I!D#A-)!F$(
<( H%A$#D",$$-H.$"$$%B-$!D",$$$"!,- !$+#!$ C.$,-%A#$--"B%"#%!$+"$ -( ( $+$!%-#$%"##$?
- -$#D",$$$""#%!$#;$$%(
- "#$C$B(
- D",$$$" , -,,"- . ! ,-$" F #$"%)-(8:!"!$$"!-(
- $-.$","$"-!#!!#-#%!$ (
- ,-!-%"A$-%,"!C$"$--$)"%! %."$"!"-(
I( 0- -"##!$" ! $+#!$ '"$- "#$" '-$+ 'B! ,-! "!%,"%5<,#A-899I !#! ,-= ! JJ 00 >$+,-= @.$),-$D-B!#-#%!$(
-!%$$"!8%.-$-8997 ,%!#-"G!-$# !-E,"-D$!$!-"$ $-.$"!88""A-899I$$C"-K ,"+",%-"$- ! 5L "G 899I <9 "G 8997 % ,-%$% C !D",$$$" "G!$.$$""##-$-#A"-%(
7( -"--$-!8M%.-$-8997 $+#!$$"-#%,-! C.--$,-$")$-!-"#,%#$- .,-$ D-B ,- #"$ C #"! ! - "#,%#$- D",$$=-!"$.$$C# %D% "#,%-!,-$" ! ' "! #$,! (
&5657&899: +<&59+ :( 8 #- 8997 $+#!$ -C$ ! -#A"-# ! --$.F-$!-$##A"$-C.$,E%)$-! ,-$"!-+#!$"A$B"$-(
L( H%A$#D",$$-H!-%!$-#F,-! "#, ! - ! $+#!$ !"-!- B-$ !D",$$$" -"$ -!58".#A-899I57%.-$-8997 "$"-
- - ,"-$",%-"$-!88""A-899I!7M8 -(79
- - ,"-D""-$-!88""A-899I!89:6-(97
- A" ",%-"$-N A"-"$- ,-$" #%!$"+D$C ,-$" B%%- ,%$ #%!$# #%-$ ! I966-(L9(
E $ ! ,-%$- C H%A$# D",$$-H %A$ -$$$" !$%-$% "- D",$$$" ,"- $- "#, ! $ C "G!$.$$""##%$)D-B! (
M( -"--$-!58;.$-899: ,-! -,-%%,--"$ " "."$"$$%!$+#!$-#A"-#! - -$.)D",$$$")$-.$"D$--B$( "--$--% -%,"(
6( 8:#$899: $"!%,"%,-=! -$A!%!#!.$ ,$#!"##!7M8-(79 ,$%-O)7P!=58".#A-899I !:5:M-(L7 ,$%-O)7P!=57%.-$-8997(
59( .$%)!%-#$- $+#!$ ,-"--$-!86"G899: -,,% C "-(88( !"!$$"B%%-!-"#,%#$-) -"A$B"$-!"$ -"#,=,-$",-%.,- ' ",-$D-B,--+$.$!$%( "- -(8: !- $ ! ,-$" F ! #"! ( !-$=- #$" $-#C,-$D-B,-%.,"-F!- "A$B"$-(- ,-%$%# ,-$",-$D-B,- "$! F ! - "A$B"$- ! "$( $ . ! "%C ,"$ "Q $+#!$ ,-!-$ ,-"= $$=- C -$. ) B$" !#$$-$. $+#!$ "D$+ C $- "$ -D% ,- ;$ H,"- ,,E- %D% - !%$$" "$! -$.)B#$"!,-$#C$$.-$F$-$"C-$ #% ) -%!$B- ,"- B-$- ,,$$" $"-# ! "!$$" !-H(
&5657&899: +I&59+ 55( "--$-%%-#$F,-!-%B-!%);B-(
!)
5( "$B."$-R"-B$$";!$$$->@%%#"!$$%$$% != 5-"G899< -$A"!-"$ "#,"%!7;B !" ,-%$! .$+,-%$! 7 ,,% 5: ;B - >-( 5 (-7: @(
0$)R$"!R%$"!5:;B- ,- -$A%!%- 8L;.$-899I> J5<959:@ -! "$B."$!",% 5<%.-$- !$,"$$"-$"$--B,-# -$A"!- "$ ! $%B- - ) -"$ ;B $$- ! R ! R%$"!".F;B-(
8( ""-#%# ) -( 7: ( 5 ( -$A " ! - "$ "/ $ $C ! "$" -$. F - "#,%#$- ) R-+#!$ "$ ,-%. ,- "$ %!%- - R-+#!$ ! 5M #- 566I > '@ ) R-+$! "A$B"$- ,-%. ,- "$ %!%- - R-+$! ! 89 #- 56M5 > @(
$$ C -"- ! - ! -.F ,-%,-"$- .""% ! %B$- .$ ) #%$"-- $$" ! -% C$ ! $$B . -- ,-$.% ,"- - ! ,-$" "#,%#$- ) R-+#!$ "A$B"$- " ) R-+$! "A$B"$- ,. !%"-#$ $$- -$A!->('%#"-$!-! "$8995+8998 ,(6M -$) R-(7:(5(B!,-";!"$M:<: !.R-(7:(5(@(
0" -$A!"$ !"--O!8:"G8997> '77&8997@ -$A " ! - "$ !%"-#$ $$ ! R#A ! "$F#$=-!R-"#,%#$-,-$.% !!"#$ !R-+#!$C!$!R-+$! C- "#,%#$- "$ "- ,- $ #!$ C ,- $$$" !-,-$.%"-$%"",-"$%!%-!-"$(
,-= !"-$ $ E $ !!#- C -+#!$ "#,%#$- " ,- -,,"- ) -+#!$ "$ + , ,-%$%# ) - "A$B"$- ! "$ + C !"$. ,-#- F -%!"#,%- )-CC"- ,-$"!- ! A > -+#!$ "#,%#$- "$ - "- !- $? '+2 $!-.FD"-!0"$%%$ !!-"$!- 566L ,(:L9@(E-"#,%#$-
&5657&899: +7&59+ ) '""-C$F$$#%-$$##%!$-- -+#!$ "$ " -# !$ "-C$ E ."$" ) "#,%-"B!,-$"-%" ' "## ,-F#,!"-"$,-!B$>(! 566659:"$!(I I@( , ' "- !$$$" - - "$ -"#,%#$--#"!=!-+$!>3 C-#-C-$.!-"$,,$AF- "#,%#$- ! ". -%B$# ! ' ,( L<6@( !"#$ ! -+ $! A"$ ! ".-- "#,%#$- F$ - $!#$$" ,$%B- "##,"-,-#-F-%!O-D",$$%!$.$$" ,-$.%"#$+,-$.%&","-B-$-"#,$""#,=!,-! -."%$.)$!> --,-$.%-"$ 0$ D$-B."$-"#!!%-$%"$5669SL ,(5<M@(
<( !-"$)!,-$","--$##$$D",$$-$#,$CC -$# "$ %$-( $ ! %;"-- ! %A$# D",$$-$,)".-$-!-"$F,-$"> J557IM@( ,! , "% ! !,= C %;"- ) H%A$# D",$$-H$%%-!$!$,A,-%!%!(
I( $$B ,"- - ,-$ D-B ,- $+#!$ ! -$ $% ) D",$$$"!!888<""A-899I!$.$$"#$+,-$.% , ,-$$=-# ! -"$ - ! 58 ".#A- 899I 57 %.-$- 8997 %. " ) :L75 -( 87 , $%-O( $+#!$ "$!=- C,$-.$-!!,=,"-"#,%-,-$"! -"A$B"$-!"$!$.$$"#$+,-$.%C$---%$ -+$!(
7( - "#,%#$- " -%B% ,- "$ %!%- - "- !-> @(
#$=-!-"#,%#$- ,-$"$%,-"-!C ""!$#$!"$ $+#!$,".,-$$,%!$- $A-# !$,"$$" $- " -%B#$- ! A-D !-"#,%#$->--O! -$A!#$$-$ (!86"G8999 (!<".#A-566M(3(!6!%#A-566L@(
F-#!-(<< !$,"$$""-$-!,-%"$ R-- -%,"! ! " %.%# C$ ,-% -=- ! -$C "- "%C !C R- %% " ) #"$ C "- RF -$%.%#!R#$=-,-%$ "%C$."C(
$$ !$,"$$"C$$#$-$C-%.AC$F! --$%.%#!#$=-,-%$"%C$."C(0."$-$ "!$$" -#,$ ! "- !%-#$ !,-=
&5657&899: +:&59+ B%%-#!"%!BB"-F-#$$%(B$,! $-!#A% )"$",."-A)-%( .-$%#"$ C !F$" !"$ O- $-,-%% H--$$.#H > J 55M <I8 "$!(5N55:5M6"$!(8@(
0";-$,-! "!$$"B%%-F,-%#$%B-%)"- !"$. O- $-,-%% " #O# ,-$$, C - !$,"$$" "-> J55L:96@( $$ A!$!$"-$- -# $$% ,- ,-$ " % #,"E% ! - DA$ > J 55M <I8N55:<I7N59I 8M5@( "- $F!$-,-%-!#$=-$"% !$.- %%# ! "-N DC "- !"$ O- $-,-%% ) ,-$-!"-!"#A> J55L:96@(- "-C,-$ !"-!-"!"!$$"B%%-!-C$" ,-$ $%B- " ". ! !%$$$" ) !"- ) -# !%$$$"".$"C$$"$>J3 -2"##- !BT UA-!-$D-B+.--B 8995 S59: !-(<< @(
$+#!$"$!=-C,)"#,%-,-$".-%,- ,,$$"!-(88(8:!"!$$"B%%-!- "#,%#$-)-"A$B"$-!"$>$+,-= @(
:( ,= A%%$!-"#,%#$-#A"$- D",$$=-"#"! (
- "#,%#$- "-#% ! ,-$" -B-",% ,- #"!( #"! "- "#,%# #A"$- ,-$" ) %-B- !-B D",$$$" D"- ! " ! !"#$$ D#A- "## ! %A$# ,A$ ! " 0$( #"! "- D",$$$" !$.$$" #$+,-$.% . $A- D"$F ! %A$#"E=#!,-$#.-$A%"$"!VB !-% ) "$" ! "- #$ %." ,- $ "$" ! VB $>-(< @(
L( ,-$$,B%%-,,$A"-C!---"!$-",,%) .---,-",-,-$"-%B%)-(5I "C
@ $ ,$- -- " ,,% ) $-.$- ,"- #O# ,-$" 30 " ,-$" C ! ,-","-$" F$ - ,-$" -% ,- #" " ! ,-$" B-$ ,- #A!--
A@ $ 30 ,,% ) .- ,-$" $ , ! $- -%!$%!-!-"$;C)"--!#".% ,-30
&5657&899: +L&59+ @ $ ,-- !- " -% , -$" . $- -,"A C -$" ,"- ,-%;!$ ) 30 $ ,-! " !-"$ F ,-$" ! 30 ,"- "-% !"$ -#A"-- ,-$".%,-30(
$!,-$$,#,OD!="-C$$#%.-,-$"#O# $!---$-.$(
M( -(5: !-$!--$$"B%%-!".--!-( $$-,-!,D-B?
@ ,-$$,$"%B!-%F"G!%"!-"$N
A@ #!$ #"-#$" $$-#$%$!"-%CF$ .-%.$B-!-N
@ $! -. "- ! -$F ! AB-- " ! -"A ! "-!- ,A$ $-%,-".C$E,,-$,-!#$=-$. $$ C#!$$!%,-!-!$$"$"$"!$ !B--N
!@ -$ !$- DC "$ C - ".-- , F,-%# #$"%"##!"!$$"B%%-!-N
@ $$-$$"N
@ "$#%!$F,-"!$B%.!!-%.$B-",-=$ !"-N
B@ -"#$)30,!8I#"$,-=-%A$#(
, !%!$- C ! - $+#!$ $ , ! !$,"$$" C".--!--$F!,-$D-B! ,- (
6( -(88 -C"!,,-$$=-#$+#!$! !,=,-%."$ B$!,-$"!%$%!#"! #$ C$%B#,,$A#"!,--."$!-(86 C
@ -"#,=,-$"!-"A$B"$-!"$ ! ' !D",$$$" ,"- "$ "#$C $B !$.$$" #$+,-$.% " ,-$.% + " #"! D"$ ,- -% + ! %A$# ,A$ " ,-$.% !#$ ,- " ! ,$$$" D",$$=-
&5657&899: +M&59+ A@ -%!) #-$%!=5<=##"$!- >!%$! !%@
@ $-%".-,--$!"A$B"$-> @$-$C $! $ - "#,%#$- ,-! D-B !$%- -#"#-%,"-!$.$$"#$+,-$.%",-$.%$!G,- -$!(
-(8: !%-$C",-$"F!#"! ,- "B$!#"!>-(86 @"##$?
@ -$# !$- -$# D%$C " "%$ ) -$#D%$C -$#,ED$-$C #!$!)"" " ) !-"B DB# ! F -,$" B- !"-B " ! %;"- ! -%!,$" F ! -"A$B"$-
A@ -$!D",$$$"#$)D-B!"!!"#$$!-%,"- !-$"#%!$! '(
59( $+#!$ "$!=- $$ "--$" C $ ! -- - C --+$! "#%)#-"G!-$#%!$F! +#O#$A%-%!""A$B$"(0" $C-(8:( %- ! #"! H F ! - "A$B"$-H "$-# $-,-%$"(
,.$! -$A!%(
E$!-,,-C"-(<< !F$"!"$ O- - C $ F,-%# ,-%. ! #$=- ,-%$ " %C$."C( - ,= $+#!$$-,-=-(88 "--$"($$ ,F,-%#$!$C%C$+#!$$-.$C"#,%#! !--(
".$%B#!-.-C,!-#A"---$!$.$$" "## ,-! CC "- , ! -+#!$ "A$B"$- ! "$( - +$ .$ -# ) O- "#,%% ,- - "#,%#$- " #"! ( "#,-!-$ != "- , ,"- C -$" #O#-$"#,"--$O-"-C$B$! (
-$$A-!!F$B-!-%C$C$!,-$#,%.% $ C %D% D",$$$" !$.$$" #$+,-$.% "$ ,-$ D-B,--+#!$"#,%#$- $,.$#, A%%$$- $C #"$ C C$ ,E "G ! !$.$$" "##(
&5657&899: +6&59+ 55( $-"-!"$+$O-!#$(
&5657&899: +59&59+
+ 0!)/ ) +)! + !+
1. 2 -- 3 4 5 6 #(& !7
2 -
5( %-!#!-.A(
2
8( !#(
<( "!# $$#% ,$# ! -"$ - ! 58 ".#A- 899I 57 %.-$-8997,$%-O!=58;.$-899:(
I( "!# R$$#% ) .-- -"- "## ! M99 -( ) $- ! ,-$$,$")-$!%,(
7( "-# ,-$ C B$ ! "$ %!%- - "- !- ! 8.-$ 569M ! $#$ ! -$ I< :M ! "$ %!%- - "-B$$";!$$$-!5:!%#A-56I< ,-%--O,$-"A;! -"- -$A%!%-!-;"-!="$$$"(#%#"$-! -"--!-%-"$F#,$- -$A"!- 5M - ! '"+ 5895 =.( ,-% --O ,$= ,"$" ! -"- $."C%"###"E!,-. !"$.O-;"$)."$( B-$=- -%$!? '-$+"$ 4 "-$W
",$""-#!,-%--O"$$%F,-$$$CR)R$%!%- !-,-$.%,-B-
&5657&899: