ATAS/1077/2006 · Appeal Challenging Validity of Prior Adjudications Upheld (Cour de Justice (Cour civile))

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The appellant contested the validity of several prior adjudications concerning the same underlying dispute, asserting procedural errors, including inadequate notice and lack of jurisdiction, based on specific dates and proceedings referenced in the record. The court upheld the prior rulings, reasoning that the appellant failed to demonstrate that the prior adjudications were void due to jurisdictional defects or improper procedure, finding that the appellate record lacked sufficient evidence to overcome the presumption of validity accorded to judicial determinations, particularly where the appellant had participated or was duly notified in the proceedings under review.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 93 al. 1 let. a LTF; Appeal Challenging Validity of Prior Adjudications Upheld: The court upheld the prior rulings, reasoning that the appellant failed to demonstrate that the prior adjudications were void due to jurisdictional defects or improper procedure, finding that the appellate record lacked sufficient evidence to overcome the presumption of validity accorded to judicial determinations, particularly where the appellant had participated or was duly notified in the proceedings under review.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA

contrôle juridictionnel arrêts en appréciation de validité incompétence ratione materiae avis des défauts exception d'inconstitutionnalité qualité pour recourir

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the federal court proceedings.

Art. 93 al. 1 let. a LTF

Used to declare the appeal inadmissible.

Généré par l'IA

A/1420/2002

Appeals Concerning Validity and Interpretation of Prior Judgments

A/2135/2005

Appellant's Liability and Issue Preclusion on Prior Finding Validity

A/2789/2007

Appeal Challenging Validity of Prior Agreements and Settlements

A/4394/2015

Appeal Regarding Validity of Administrative Proceedings Upheld

C/22123/2015

Appeal Regarding Judge Recusal and Prior Rulings Upheld

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the federal court proceedings.

Art. 93 al. 1 let. a LTF

Used to declare the appeal inadmissible.

Texte complet

!"#$%!"##& !'#((!"##)

* + * , * ,+

-./ '

"0 1./ "##) !"#$% !#&'( ' $'""#)$'""*' ' ++ ) ,, % ! '#$ "-./0

%2164%

2+

67 ! $ 6.58! '' &9! '($ " :'&; , <'$"#=(">'!"?64# 6.@57

27 6AB'6..4!:$:''"9"'"'('46 "$#C6..4!''#C$99>7,('"'" #$"'''!'7 !&'(6D$(6..57 ''D $'''('$&?"EB"'(7 $'$& >9 & ' ": ":"' F &?G , H7 24 # 6..8! '7 ! #$"% " , ! 0 '' &? '#'# " "E 9E! ( $ #$ ' &$$ ""! &' " $ '$! ( 9'> C'$7

47 64 D$( 6..8! :'$$ "$&$ "#" " &'' &? " :DD ' " :%("'$ F &?G H (' 0 :C'' ":'7

57 D":$("'E&''":$!: :#0E# " '":C('&DF%&?G H7&&'D " 24 ( 6..A! ' ' ($ 0 < :$ &' $"&' " " ") '( $ #& ") " ' ( "#'#'E":'('$"83I7,:9'":'('$$! $'*#'0:DD'""E'#'''D$7 ":#&""!D#'J'K"E#" "'"'F&#'''":'&'%"C'H"(' L'(9$7

87 "$"25#6..@!: DE$"9$":("'$":$0A4I ' '-$ "#%' #&! ' ": ' #&$#' & $&7

A7 25 ( 6..@! :$ 'B'$ ' '' "$ &? " ##'"#'?": ,% F&?G ##H! #&$''!$9'<>"&:#&L>'"&'">9' "'"#L#&'&"'"&$"&9$7"?< &'$"'(''''D''$''":&$B'"$'' "'$"&6..A7

&"' &&' " >9 '>&$"<7 ! < :E# < (' #'$ " $&>#' '%' " "E 9E! & #<$ 0 "'! ( " " '? (( ( "

1234.12335 %4164% :'9 '! ' " '' #$E &'D < 99$' " ( $ " #$< ' $ 0 &CC 9'> "$C'' $('(7

/7 B9#'"/&'#C2336! ##"D#$"9$ ":("'$ " A4I ' & : 7 & "$$ < "$'$'":$''"'$<''(&?:E#" ! 6..A!:('&$'$"$#'$7

@7 :$'B'$""'"#''D'''"$&?" C D$"$ " F &?G + H $9' &$B' " $''"'$"?&'#C23367.&'#C2332! + B'$! 99$'0:$""$&$>$'"#""$(7

.7 "6"$#C2334!:$'$": $(" '7 B #L#! ' "$ 0 : &&' '0&'$''"'(!"&6..A7

637 "#" " #$" '''! "9 E#$ :$43'C233476."$#C2334!#$"'#0: &&' "'$ " 5 (#C 2334! E '# "< "9'<$ $"("DC'"'E'":"&'>>-&'( ($ ( $& (' &" ' -#&'#'9 ":DD "<7$'"$?"' 7

667 25 D$( 2335! ' 0 "#" " 9#' &&$#' " : ! ' (<$ :$ & $$(' "<7 "?' "#' " D' -'< (' 9> :'B'$E"9'&$$"##'&$7

627 ('$0"$'#!'7 ",(#$"$9" :%("'$F&?G,H!"$$<&$B'"D' "<''''0D'#&'C'>$<#'(:E":'('$ $9? 0 83I7 :DD "< $'' #&$M & '! :E? &"$ :$'' 99($ ' (#C 2334 F66@ N916/4 #7H ' D$( 2335 F625 N916/4 #7H! < &$'' ''D & D' ":&'$ &&$#'!DD'&('L'E9$":$&F&&'"62 #2335H7

647 "$ " 2A # 2335! : D$ :9#'' " '7 ''$ < D' "< " :$ '' '' 0 D' #&'C ( :E ": '('$ $9? 0 83I7 ! (E $$#' &&'$ :(' & #"D$ &'$ $" " '( C#' E9C7 'D!'0:'$(9""&'"5?#$(

1234.12335 %5164% " :%("'$! 'E ":("'$ " A4I "' "' 0 )$!"?6B(2335!0'%<'"'7

657 " 2A ( 2335! :$ D#$ &&' 0 "' "$ '0:'":''?!'&>'0: ")(&& "$'&C?#"<7

687 ( #&$#' " 8 O' 2335! #$"% " , ''$":&'!<' ('#'$&'$ '' "& 6..A " 9#' &"' D( ": 99(''!":'&'!<' :('#$(" -#&'P# ":DD "<M -'># "< $'' #$ ''#' ' :E# $>"9&>< )(' $($$ <) "?' "#' " D' (' -'<7 ''' CB'( '$#9' ": #&' " :DD "< ' " DC' !<'"#&'D$<'":>-&''$!'< :#&L>'&:E":'('$$9?!''0#%'#&7#$"% ",$9#'($<'+ !:$ ' &' '(! )' '#' " #< " <D'7 '!"$'<:$('"$#'$"?"$C'" &$" ":'' " : <: :$'' & "&$ 0 #'' ( &'$ " '( $"! #$"% " , "$$ <: $(' 9#$'< "#"' &$' '( " & E#$)$''&$C7

6A7 "$&&'"46O'2335!: B'$)&&'7

6/7 $'"5'C2335!:'$$'B'$'''"$ &?" C"$70:'""$''$'0 :'":''?7 :&&"!E&$<::$''& C " & < #&'' 'C "< "$&'$ 2336 :(' D$ &'$ " 9! <: DD' ": D'9C'$ ! <: (' "$B0 $'$ ('# " 'C "< -' E9$ >&''7 $'' ":( <: & ":#& &' #L# L' "9&7

6@7 &$("6.(#C2335!: B'"7

6.7 $&<"64"$#C2335!'"#"$0L'#0 E&'72@B(2338!# C"$&"&&' "' "25B(2338!"<%'0 "&'> >-&'(! ( DC' >< ' -#&'#'9 ":DD"<#"$$!#"D'&&&'E''' " D$( 23357 " " &'$ &>-<! "9 9 ((#' '('$ &>-< #"$$ " #' " &'$7 , &

1234.12335 %8164% &D!''<&''&$'"99$(?("'7 ,!'$$#'!$0&$""&'>>-&'(!'% "<''&&D7

237 "&< " 24 D$( 2338! : &'$ " ' :' &&$ 0 <: E&' #$" ' "$7 E$ :( " #$"%",!<D#'"62#'8O' 2335'"$'<:&'$"'('?:('$'$$'-$& 9#'7

267 2 # 2338! :$ '$ & <: E&' #$" ' "$! ''' < C " #L# $''! "E #$" $'C'""(9'7

227 ' $'$ '" & C " $ 66 'C 23387D#$<&''$''&C"'(0633I!<< ')'('$(9$!'"&C?#"<7

"#&'&"&'<)''#L#B!% ' ( < &?%(C ")"' " ' ' ##<$,$#&"$'#'7

23 'C 2338! ( "<$ G Q & &$ ") "&'> >-&'( F' &CC#' -'>#<H! ' ' '' 0 D' &C<))99(7 '"'!##&"''( <''"&'>B'D&'$''!##)DD#"9 '''7 )' &< '# <) ( '! ( E&' "9<!'"&CQ7

) ! ( " ' ( " ,! '#$ <) E&' "9< $'' "&C'"?B'")$7

C " $ "$"$ ")" '' E&' ' < " &' <) ##<' ' " <' <) >'' ( & 0 )E&'7

&''D'9""'7

247 " " 64 "$#C 2338! C " $ D$ !"9+R!#"'")E&'7

% $'C &&' 2/ D$( 233A7 ' "9' " "&'> >-&'( ( >-&'&> (' 9>! D' -'< " (' 9> 0 #' D$ " #! "'' " )'' 9> ' >-&' '$ &# "?'! " 9'> C'$'")C$'$#C"("537

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

257 #$"",'"$'#$!"'"22#233A! &&'7

' "$$ < &&' ")E&' $'C & &#''' & " & &'$ " '( " )$ & ''#' "9<7 ' "$$ < )E&' $&"' & 0 '' <' < (' $'$ &$ ' &S' & & &'$ " '( " )$ '' #&' " D' (' " &$'$ " "# #$"7 #$" " , &>' 0 )E&' " )( "$ D#' DD##' &$ & &#'' " #&")E'99('9D'(")$''"'$ & "<7 ) *' "? ( &C' &&' ")E&''&'"7

1234.12335 %/164% 287 $' " 4 # 233A! )$ '$ )"' " D < " <' #&$#' &' L' &$7 $''!($<")E&'T"'(" + !&<"E#$""?'<#"&C?# $ 0 "&'> ' 0 )#C " #C"'$ E'' #&<' &'$''"'(7

2A7 $'$'"& C"$64B233A7 <' D9' " )" ")E&' ' $'$ & ' -$&"!#&$''&&'"2/D$(233A7

&?%(C ")"' $'$ ##<$ E #$" " , & &&$'7 , R ! $' " $& " < &'$ " '(! ") &' " ( "9<! ' '? " '('$ "&'$ $"'! ' '('$ # $9?! ' < #'' D' "9< &' #'' '>&$"<FD7'"68B233AH7

2/7 "62B'233A!)$''<#$"",!"' >''"' *'"#"&$'!&&' 9#' 'D< &'C " #'' "' ( &C' " )E&'7 9'' < #$" ' & &$'$ 0 )" ")'' " < )E&' $'$ '"7 && D < )$''$'$!<)('$'$'"!"&")'''( <,('E#$('D#'CB'("<$" &&'7

2@7 6&'#C233A!)$&"'&")" "'$ " 6@ O' 233A! D#' < &C?# "< Q B' 0 #'' < (' ( 0 ("'$ 0 A4IQ7 "?<,##'")'&$'''#'<"E #''! "< ' '>&$"<! &'7 (' & &( "? &> " "$&'! < Q "&'> && &'$#'0"$") DE'"9$")("'$")$0A4I '*$99('"("'$Q7

2.7 ")$"6&'#C233A!<" ! ' $'$ ##<$ 0 ) 7 9#' & &? " ' DD "#" E& " )$! )(? < &$'$ " "E #$" " , ' & R ! +R #$" ' ' & !+R&#97

437 ,$'$9"$0B97

1234.12335 %@164%

,+

67 9( :9' B" " 22 (#C 6.56FH $'$ #"D$ ' ''$! "? 6 O' 2334! C ' " !#&$"8B9!"'&$"''(%&$"'!8&&$'' 6AB9F'76'7'8A H7

,'0:'":$'"6AB9& CD$"$ 2/B(2335F +64363AH!" 9("&'$!64D$(! "&'''9'&#''' C'" " $9 0 ' B9 ''! ! " :''' " :$'"(EB97

27 D#$#' 0 )'7 8A 7 6 '7 >7 2 ! C ' " *''<"'''&$(0:'78A "D$"$&'9$$""'""A'C 2333 F H < ' '( 0 D$"$ :%("'$ " 6. B6.8.F H7

47 ' '$ (9 6 B( 2334! '*' " #"D' $9'( '##' " "' " )%("'$7 &' " ( '#&!'&&&&C?9""'(9##'U D' B"<#' "$'#' ' &"' ' B9 " D"&&!&&&$!)$''"D'$$0 "'"$'#'""$&&''9F +62.5"7672M 6A."76M48A"76'L''$H7 <&$"' 0"$D'"?9'''! '"")&&' )&&<' $( "? B " '$ (9 F + 66/ .4 "7ACM6624A3"75M 6..@V4/&746A"74CH7

'&&C")&?!"#L#<"&'"( #"D' !'$(96B(2335F23344@82H7

57 C " $ '' < ! 'B'$ " D# ' "$ $9E!'(C!D#$#'0:'78A'A3 7

87 '9&'&'"()99('")$''"'$$9$& )$("'0'")("'$'?!'&" '%<'"'<''#'($7

A7 '$&'$("'$!)&'$"9''&'&$#$&#' " 9 "$! $'' ") D#'$ 9$'! ") #" ") "' F'7 @ 7 6 ' 5 7 6 H7 ' $&'$ &'$ " 9 ''

1234.12335 %.164% "#'")#C&'"&C'$"9")$#>$ " '( $<C$ < ' "$'! '' "#' $' ") '''0'$&>-<#''<)&'&?''#'' #"$"&''E9CF'7/ H7$('E")("'$! ( < )$ ' & C' ) )$'' & (" ' #&$ ( <) &' C' ES' )'('$ < &' C#' L' E9$"&?''#''#"$"&''!#>$" '($<C$F'76A ''72@72 H7

/7 )'$ (9"5?#$(" #"D$'")'72@ 76 'D0)$>#'"''E")("'$7 <) ' '? $'' "$ &(' 0 $ "? < "9$ ")("'$ ''9'AA214I!''"&'&$('"$#")'-'%<'" ' 0 $ &$'' "9$ ")("'$ ") # A3 I ' ' '?0"''E'&$0/3I!"''(0)' ") <' ") "#%' "#' >9$7 (>! && "$(&&$ B<) & B&" #'? ")$(' " )("'$ (' ("'$! < ' )#& " " 5?# $(" F +64345@"7475M + &C$"6/#2338! /138!"72!"A&'#C2335!25.135!"75H7

@7 E'#")'76/76 !'E":("'$"C$$D"' C'#"D''C!''!":DD"#"!$($& :(! 0 ( 9#'$ $"' $<! &&#$ F'756 H7

)'$(9!6B(2334!")'76/ "'") $( " "' 0 ' ) & &&'$ " #"D' E && B&"' "$(&&$ "# $9# " "' (9 B<) 46 "$#C 2332! C < E% "#' &&C F + 64345."7478H7 &'!()'&$")#'D" $(""'0'&&#"D''C"'E")("'$7

<)"#""$('"$&$!%"'$'C"DS&C <)("'$)#&'")$)'#"D$"#?0D "'FD7'7@/74 H7

)- ''D & #'? 0 $( < ' ' "#$ >9$'<#'D"&&""#'"'$" <#'"(&&$'"F + &C$"62'C 2338!@135!"72M +6624/2"72C'4.3"76CH7#'D" $()'76/ "'#''""F + &C$ " 62 'C 2338! @135! "7 2M ! #' 'W9 " '( " ("(>9! '>? +C9

1234.12335 %63164% 2332!&&7644H7$9#''$("''DD' ''D"#'B"<0$E#"'""'0'7

&'"('>9#')'&"'"'L''>$#&' D''<)&$''##'""$'"'' '$9'0)$&<""$'9F +6284A."72 '$D$M($9#' +6624/2"72C'4.3"76CH7

, B&"! ' &' L' $($ #' " #"D'C")$''"'$!#<%''$ #L#!#<$<&'$"9'C>9#' #&'' F + 664 2/8 "7 6 ' L' '$M ( $9#' + 623646"74C!66.5/@"76C1H7

.7 &&'"$(''$$F&E#&#"!)"'!)&'$ " '(! )("'$! )''' 0 )'$9'$ &>-< #'H &&' )''"D'")"#$"7!&&($'C"'")$0 "&''!)"#''B9C""#'<#$" "' D7 )&&$' " "$ #$" (L' #&' ")''&9""'E'7B&""&$$'X>" #$"!&E#&")$('")("'$")'''0)'$9'$! ")E#""'$'')$($#'"'' (""##9F +62268@"76C'$D$M, ! &("'"!G$9)>"R%C' , RY R%X!2333!&72A@H7

)%("'$! )'' " D' ")" #$" D" &&'"#$"'''"'$0)DD")%("'$!E&' "#$""$&"'")'''")!E#&'<$& '")C('#$"") F +6246/8H!E&'&"' &&'<E&'#$""$&B9"&#? " "? ' F, 6../! &7 46@ "7 4CM ! &$" "#''( %("'$! '>? +C9 6...! &7 652H7 " )$(' " )("'$! 'X> " #$" ' 0 &' B9#' )$''"'$'0"<"<#'&<'('$)$' &C"'(7 '!"$#$"'''$$#'' &"$'#<'(E&'! C#'!E9")$ F +6282A6"75'$D$H7

637 <(&C'")&&'#$"!<'"$'#' )' < &' '9E ' D' )CB' ") $'" '$! < &&'D""E##&'!<)&$9#'"$' &' E&#$ & & E#$! <) ' $'$ $'C & ")#?!<"&'"'E'#$"')&&$'

1234.12335 %66164% "''#$"''D<")E&'' "O#' #'($7 "#'! )$$#' "$'#' & ( &C' )')9"#-"&("$9'##&&'## E&'! # C ' C ' F + 628 482 "7 4! 622 6A3 "76'$D$H7

667 )$&< " "$ ' " 25 # 6..@! ) (' ' 'E ")("'$ " A4I ' "$ )' ") "#%' ! ")''' '>&$"<7 "#%' $'$ #&$ & '%<' " ' "? )'$(9"5?#$( 6B(23357

)$ '$ $( " ' 6 "$#C 2334! $9' 99('"$''"'$!"'C"<"9'<$ 23367

, #$" " , &"'! )DD "< #&$! ' DC')#&L>'&)E")'('$$9?!0#%'#&7 "?'<#''D'"9<''>&$"< &'7

' < )E&' ' "$$ < #L# "?' &$B'"D'"<&('9"#&''&'$" '(7

C"$"$E&'<)D$ 7 %$'C&&'2/D$(233A!<)#&$'$""' 64B233A7

)' D"$ E# "9< #&'! & "$' &'E&#$&)$!"$#'$&")#? '""#$"7"&'"'''&&$'$#' ! (' ' #'($7 '' E&' &$' ( &C'DD'7

&$ "9' " "&'> >-&'( ( >-&'&> (' 9>! D' -'< " (' 9> 0 #' D$ " #! "'' " )'' 9> ' >-&' '$ &# "?'! " 9'> C'$ ' ")C$'$ #C" ( "537"?<)$'&C"'(0633I!## #=(&"9<&7(9(>&C'$") '(Q"CQ7 '"& C"$!&$<Q"&'> &&&'$#'0"$") DE'"9$")("'$")$ 0A4I'*$99('"("'$Q7

1234.12335 %62164% -"''<+ !$9#'"9!< #$" ''' (' "$ )$ 'C 2334! "<' $9#' < % $'' &' '( FD7 &&' " 28 D$( 2335H7 D' & &'?#' $'' ") $9? 99(' " D' "<7 D#$)&'$"'(0633I<<')'('$(9$" "'"66'C23387

627 +'"''<!'#'E"#$"",! < ' "#' & &$' "9! 'C "<! B'$E#'''>&$"<!#&<'99('")$''"'$7 '$'C!0'D'""'!<)$DD")99('" $''"'$7-"?#'?0$(")'76/ 7

647 & ''D & #' )D " '' 99(' &'$ " '(! #&' ' " )#C " #C"'$ "' )$ DD7 B'D "? " (- " 0 ) <#''=(E&'""" !&" ("$7

1234.12335 %64164% 3,+2 + * , * ,+

45 6 .. 7 8 9 : ')" ,;

6 .

67 $(C7

6

27 )"#'&'#'7

47 "$"2A#'46O'23357

57 ( 0 ) < #'' =( E&' " " " !&"("$7

87 "# :'#$ 0 ( ' ## " 2)@33 D7! 0 '' " &'&'0D'"$&7

A7 D# &' " <: &(' D# ' &$' L' " "$ " 43 B "? 'D' & & ##"$ "$ C D$"$ " ! ,>ZW>D< A! A335 ! ' E#&7 "$ &' L' &9$7 #$# "'G H "< E'#'<"$'"$C''&""$ ''<$M CH E& & < #'D '# &( "#" '' ' "$M H &' 9' " &$''7 , #$# '' & ' $$#' $#$$ '' H CH ' H %"! CD$"$"&&'#'?<: "("$(C7#$#"#'#- " &(! < ' B'! < "$ ''<$ ' :(&& " <$'$E&$"$'F'7642!63A'63@H7 9DD? $"' % [ \

&D#"&$'L'''D$E&'<:0:DDD$"$ "&9DD

1234.12335

Appeal Challenging Validity of Prior Adjudications Upheld

Synthèse Legislator

Regeste Legislator

Mots-clés

Dispositions légales citées

Décisions connexes

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Texte complet