Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/1072/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1072/2007 Généré par l'IA

Statutory Limitations Periods Prevail Over Conflicting Precedent

Numéro de cause ATAS/1072/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The court addressed multiple appeals concerning the application of statutory limitations periods to various claims, often involving prior rulings that established different starting dates or periods for accrual. The court reasoned that where the legislature has established a specific, clear limitation period for a type of claim, that statutory period controls, even if a different period was applied in earlier, factually similar cases or if the prior case law suggested a broader application. The court consistently upheld the precise statutory time frames relevant to each distinct cause of action, rejecting arguments for extending the period based on common law principles or precedent that conflicted with the enacted statute.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statutory Limitations Periods Prevail Over Conflicting Precedent: The court reasoned that where the legislature has established a specific, clear limitation period for a type of claim, that statutory period controls, even if a different period was applied in earlier, factually similar cases or if the prior case law suggested a broader application. The court consistently upheld the precise statutory time frames relevant to each distinct cause of action, rejecting arguments for extending the period based on common law principles or precedent that conflicted with the enacted statute.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
délais cause de la demande common law motifs légaux limitation du pouvoir d'examen revirement de jurisprudence

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive for ordering the losing party to pay the costs of the federal court proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
A/2095/2006
Statute of Limitations Application to Multiple Claims from Single Event
A/1434/2007
Statute of Limitations Accrual Date Dispute
A/100/2005
Statutory Interpretation and Appeals Rulings
A/1098/2006
Statutory Interpretation of Time Period Extensions
A/519/2004
Statutory Limitation Period Calculation Date Dispute

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for ordering the losing party to pay the costs of the federal court proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



           "#$%&"'(()  "#()'"'(()



* +,*    * +

-.  % ! '( /-.  '(() 



  !" # $!%&' & "&  !("&  )&*+  " , # 

&

   ,, # - !+./012 &!" %&1344 

               ! ! 

   +35:+  

 0+ 

1;  <" & 3%&!-399=&& (!% &!% '  ,'  ! & >, ? %  " !@!  / !;  A' &&A ("&& % !&"  & && 0& "&"   (&&& ( BB&& "&& %"" * (" '&C&D %& '<&+*&E% '&& "";  %!&   ! @ E<   "-&"  3 %&!-399=;

3;  '& D  &&  "&" <"  4 %&!- 3996 @ &! * (&""  "&" BB&" D ( !&& B & %  %"   8 F'13%&!-3996;

7; 17%&!-3996("(&"%G  ,, #H    >+%GI?&&"'!& ( !&" EJ!<;

8;  " 1=%&!-3996" &D( !&"!&B *("&% /! &&"&*(& !&B -"& (-<& &%'&C&%%*";

=; 13&-3996("B!"%%&D&& ""<&*( '&"&"<<"%(&& G'% "  /! &* '&K!D&&;F&"*("&&'*(('& %@" (&'&"BB&' &&&&&%" "&&"!&"D %& (&& G';

6;  "%%& 2!399:B!" " 1= %&!-3996;

:;    37 ' 399: ("  &F&"  & && "  "<&*( '&')& " &&  /!  3%&!-399=13%&!-3996;%<!& "FD "'%%" %%&&&-&*&&"&&<D (!%0"&'&%%%*&*('&KC& &"%!%0%B&'!* &&&%"  ("&& & D %&  (&&  G' *( '& % "*& BB&  %&& & *( !&   && ( - "< *  " '&B%*(<<D&'' !%0;

2; '&"D%(&!" "% 1=!399:F& ;

4; C& & 38!399: - "% %" ; BB&  3: B"' 399:  -  " '&    F<!&  



516785399:  +75:+   BB *%&!C!*& %%+D'"&" ( &' BB&B + > , 3925399:?; && BB '& "&" %&" '&  -B" "> .?;

19;   C& & 1:L&399:> .2 1625399:?; &C& "&"!!*"%B!&&& "18%&!-399: "&"!%&%B%& "'&-'&;

11; (  ""&"< "DF<;



 + 

1;  *&   !%"&  -  " &   '-&"  0& "FD"&"@!" (C& & 38!399:(&% " (0';

3; *& %% (&&& *%" '&"&"% + D '   %"  & *  "  "&" !  -""B ( && &!%C&BB&"D!%%&!%&!!%"  && +  "&" &E" %  .   &  1: L& 399:  & *( 0    % %" ;

7; '&%! %%*(" &D( !&" EJ!< (!%& &&'&!!&D%"  &&& -"">&;2;1&;   '&;17&18  ? (&+D+  *   !&  "   %"' D & BB& >&; 4 ; 7  ?  @" & /!!&'&"!D &&>&;17 ;1   ''< %1F&3997?;

 '  %"'  - * %&  '   (  B&B & (!%0 &  &'  F&   *  %! (<< &&!&D' F%  G*"&   & &' D  %"   && %"%% *(   "&" "!&'"&'> 3991%;332?;C&"&> .171 888? . %""&&F%  *&*(*& %"  && &  &D( !&" EJ!<"&& %%*("&@"&'&"!D&& &%"  "&!&;   C&  1: L& 399:  .  %"" * && F%  '& %C& !% *( '&& '"&"BB&'!&'"!!%!&*%'*('&- & - "&" %0" "&&    !%&&   * &  %'  (@BB&B (&'&""> . 1:L&399:%;&; ;3;3M . 171  888  ; 7 %; 884 & ;?;   F&" * (@ ( &'&"



516785399:  +85:+   "% & /!!"&&  &D%&&G% "& %"  &&& *'!& (BB&B ("&&%B"!&@<"!%!&&&- %%&%' && &'&" %"& *  '!& "" !!  %  !%0  B & % & % D    %"!%&  B& *( &'&" " !D&&'&"&"@"> . 1:L&399:%;&; ;3;7?;

&'&"!D&&B&& &&&'&" (" &" D (-&& ( ' ! D && % &  " ( %%&  &';  %% (@ BB&B ( &'&" " BB!!& &J-> . 1:L&399:%;&; ;3;8&"B;&"?;

8; @!"% .!!(%G&& (!%&!%  &  %& (&   &@&  ! &  B'  EJ! * (& % & @ %&&  (+EJ!< & * '& D  %!&&  &&  & @ %&& %  - ( &'&" ! D && ( " BB&  <   (&; 17 ;1 ;

 .   ! * (@ ( &'&" ! D &&   %<!! (%&   < %'& C& %   "& D &&  %"   && !C!  (  !    -+B "   ! D * & & %E"   % BB!!& &  EJ! D "&"<!E" &' &%&& B(@* &E> . 1:L&399:%;&; ;3;=&"B;&"?;

  %&  -  "   C&  3: B"' 399: > , 3925399:? '&  "" * !C!   " (&'&" BB&' ("&& % BB& %&   -<&> ?&'D !  (!%0 "&& %%-;  -  " '& &  B& * (" ("&& <<" D & %-  BK %!&  (&&& ( %!& & *(  &'& G    &&  !  (!%0+ %&% %& &'!-BB&% % !!" &!& & %  " !%G&  && &  EJ! ";"* - "'&F<"*((<&% ( &&  &' B&B  %&- (C& @"&" ! ( &&  &' % * (!%0 %   (<& '& " !!&"!& @ '  &';  "B&'  -  " '&&!"*"&" %&& &'("&&% "&!&*&D  B@&   %"   &&M  '& !"  && D  &!!& (!%0* &'F*(D("E"  " <"% "&F&B" && &';

C& 1:L&399: ."&"!&;



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

 & .&!"*(0'& ( !&&*&&%" % (&& '  %  EJ!<  %"&& %  &"&* ( && &'&*(& %  ! (!%0   %*( "&"  &' && & (-&  !% & %  !%& ( '  (&& & %G ( & !%0 >   G EE% &'*!-&?&*"!"& '"% &&!%%(&& G'@<B& (&' (%%&& - % D  %&&  (   *(D   '"  &%& (%&& &'!D&&> . 1:L&399: %;&; ;3;4?;

!C!!G .&!"*(%'&&%G&&& && &  ( &' * ( % &'" ! & (!%0 & 'F*(D("E"  " <" "&!&% "&F&B" && &'> . 1:L&399:%;&; ; 3;19?;

=; (%G "&F%   . !N%%)&* (" ( BB&'!& &'" &  "+  &B D  %"   &&*(% &!%B"D /!!%&% & %"' % (&; 17 ; 1  ;  !%& D & "<  *( &   K 



516785399:  +65:+   &* &&&"&" " & % &%"   &&> . 1:L&399:%;&; ;3;6?;

6; "*%&C&*F&";



516785399:  +:5:+  

  1 +0  +,*    * +

!

  2 -

1; &BD% %" ;

! 2

3; F&&;

7; &*%" &<&&;

8; B!  %&   *O %'& B!  &  %"& C&   "  79 F G  &B& %G  - B" " >,EP/EB*66998  ?%' !&G  & %-B!"!&@&;23 B" " -B" " 1: F 399= > .?M  !"!   &  *   !&B & !0 %'&%&<& & ! &M & C&  "  - B" " % ' %&  % ' "&* @  &  (&; 83  .;  %"& C& &  %G  %  &'*"!!!0 %' '&C&F&D(';  <BBG  %" &         .. Q,  Q



 % B!  %"& C& & &B" @ %&  *O ,"&& (&&D("!%<BB



516785399: