Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
ATAS/1070/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/1070/2006 Généré par l'IA

Statute of Limitations Interpretation in Obligation Dispute

Numéro de cause ATAS/1070/2006
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The appellant, appealing a judgment regarding an obligation, argued that the lower court erred in interpreting the controlling statute concerning limitations periods, contending that a shorter period should apply to the matter at hand than what the court used to calculate the claim's timeliness. The appellate court rejected this argument, reasoning that the plain language of the statute clearly dictates the longer limitations period applied by the trial court, as the appellant's claim falls squarely within the scope of that provision, thereby affirming the lower court's decision.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statute of Limitations Interpretation in Obligation Dispute: The appellate court rejected this argument, reasoning that the plain language of the statute clearly dictates the longer limitations period applied by the trial court, as the appellant's claim falls squarely within the scope of that provision, thereby affirming the lower court's decision.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
délai de prescription interprétation de l'arrêt objet du litige domaine de la loi du contrat droit des obligations inobservation du délai légal

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Généré par l'IA

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the final order to rule on the costs of the proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

           #$%&#'(()  #*(&(#'((%



+  ,+    +  

-./  $ " $( 0./  '((% 



   !"#     "$% & % #%!!"'#%!!(%)&   

%

   '       %"# !+,- $%./0  

                 !"

   5/16.5  

 1

67  #6,0. 8"% !#$#66$%"96,,/  $": !"! ! $%% $: ! '88 % ! '5 &!%# ;5$:  <   &=% ! "9>7  ?%%  & %+  $  ?> ! "% !  & $8 %  %7

/7 $:%>!'9&%$8='%!##!60&"9 64!#"96,,2 ' %"#=!%!!' &!%# '#%% $ #7 '#  !' $  %&%# $8  !% ! 6. @& 6,,. %  !"! ! $%%  #%# @%#$' $!#!63@6,,.7

27 '#  %&#  %% = 88 $ '%$ A  $  ""# !#9%!'#6,,0 B88!'>7

.7 6/@6,,0 '#!#$#&!"!!$%%$:! ' 7

07   $$% !%# ! 6/ @ 6,,3   7   $#% *C  "#! %   !=# = '# 88% !'D#" ! %% >= E ?"  "% % 8> !$  !#9% ! '# 6,,0   = &% %(#%%$%#!%&!$63@&6,,3!$8 ! "F7  $9:" !"%>= '#%% %: %%"% "## &  %%?#$7 '#88%$ !'?+$% %! ! "9 $$% %%  !'88% $?+= %7 '?+$% &% #%# %%# & :  "+ !' 9#%59=%7  "#!  #" '$ =' ##!% $8 !  %&%# 'E$% $  $%%E>:=!#?%D#"%!=#7

37   %  '#  %&#  %&%# B 644G !  ># &  ">#  $%!"9>7

-7 "$%!6,,, %&#%%=&!">!"" !  8 % !  958: @=' 0 " /446  !% B =   8%  8%!"+!#%%!%%7

H7 !2I%/446 ' #$%#%%7!=#= $ E"  ! " $8 $&% J% $  ?>   &% "!%#  9% $#% !  #!$%%  = "?"%  !!#$%!%%$ !!'#'&%$8'9@%!' & =J% = % $" !'E"   +% %&#  =%# ! "K&  8"% $#8=   #%%  " ! $!  %



123-1/440  5216.5   %&%##%%$!8"%$#9 B=%E%B=!"%  ='%%!!='#%%!%#!'#'#%%"## ='&% $ $!%&%#!$%#&"9 6,,H;&!! "" !!#%$$%%B""9!8"< ='%%!!&% #%# $  !#9% ! '# /444 % B  !"! ! >"% ! '  ='#'&%$!#%B%%=' &%!# !%!26"/444$$=&%&7: ' !"!#  ! '#      ! 9 & >  "!% B  #$!8='!#$%&!"!#7

,7 !/0$%"9/446 ' #  7

647   ! 63 %9 /446   !  #$! =' &% +# B ! "9$!@!"!% &7

667  "$% ! // @& /44/  '#  #%# & $  7   $#%*C>7

6/7  !  #%9  $$% B '%% ! '   6- !#"9 /44/7   %='E">##!'#"#&!9#%#"$%%%  ?+$% %#  =   $ !=   %% $% 9 %9# ='#%%!#$8EE$#%@&/44/'#%%9"##  "#!"% % =' " /44/  '# &% #%# E"# $   7 =&%%"#='#%%$%B$!%&%##>:7 8"#='B& '##%%88%&"%$%B$!  %&%# $8 #>: " B 04G "% $ ""  $#%=!88%#%%%!%&%%&%# '#+% 88"#=''&%$$9%#!%&!""8"7

627  $$% !#  /4 " /442 $  7   $#% *C  >   77   8% #%% !' E" >= "  !#8% %&5"%  !' +!" >= !88 &5"9 % ! =% ""9 % !' E" ! ""9 8# "7  "#!   B ! "95%>  $$% & ! " !>= "9 %% ! "J" D "=# & !$%?  ? ! %  %%%"%#%%7

6.7 !/,&/442 '#!=#B' $9! ='"!8%'#%%%&!#%%&!$!#$L%! !"!  =  #%% ! %# %  $%# ! %& #%% %% &  %! B '>>&%  =' %% %@     =' '&%$!'%&%#$8 & '#%%$9##8!'  "! $% ! > %  9##8% $  $ ! $%% ! '5?L">M#%%!#8:"%$'%$9=7



123-1/440  5.16.5  

607 $$%!%#!/2$%"9/442  !$" "%5!5#   $#  !>% &% N "9> &!%  +!"%=!%9!'?!.50 $%! #%># % %? %8%%  "$%% #%% E5!#$8  9#%# "9! ; O .0<7   %"# =  !>%  $#% !$ !#"9 /446  &%!#$%#!%&!$%%%B%% $%# ! %& !  $8 ! &! B "$% ! 0 " /4467  "9!"%%!'# #"##N"$9%#!% $ ! &>% "%   "$9%# ! "? $ ! =% % ":%  'J%   #%% %: EE  >8  & ! $#! ! !#$" % ! !!#$7

637  /2 " /44.    *  ! & "#! #>  ;<  $##E"95!$7

6-7  !  #%# $%=#  !% ! 6, " /44. $  7   $#%*C"#!$?+=%##!% %7C $#% *C$+?%7

 % !  $$% = '?% %#5% "% B 6,,4  !% B =!:>"?%!'#'#&%!?% %  "   %?%  8 !%M  %%"% ! E " ! $?+%?#$&%#%#%# %=!!#!&% $%#='&%$!%$"$J?#'#!%&B644G ?%7  6,,/  '# % %"9# !' " & ?   #> $%M$?>'%"%#B$!"#!"%%$! %&  #%# $97 '#&%  #%# "=# $  $% ! ! "%$ "    ' $ % 'E% !'  ! %# & '!%7  6,,0  % $$  >  "%7   %  '#  %&#  %&%# B 644G !  ># &  ">#  $% ! "9>7  6,,,   ""# B %& !  "> !  8 % !  958: @=' 0 " /446  !% B =   8%  8% "+!=7 $    !%  $ $& %& PB  !  %J%  ! 88%!KP7%&!">!8%%$$"% B&!!$!%"% !%%&!#%""%7

 '#   ! "9 % # !  #> 2 B 6  !#%  9  $#!"% B !% % !% !  ""9 8# ?"%#7 '%%# !!% #&#B0647 '# !: $ "" #8% $  +"$%"%>7   $ ! "%% 8%     $& "? $ ! 60 "%   $& &  $%  = 0 "%   $& "% ='  #%> !'%$&$%!?>$#B0Q7 %= $$!"%%%#B!+$#7



123-1/440  5016.5     #%# !=# ='B '#$= ! 'E"  '# '#%% $  %%"% %!#$7 % #%# % B %% ! !>%  #$   $%# ! %&  %% = "> N ! ?> ?= ;$!+ !5"9   "9 #%%  ? ! "#!<   8% "+!= ?+$%%#%%# !9:%5!#$!% %9#%#"9!7 !>%$+?%='#%#$#7"#! %$##="%%8% 9@%& #%%$$"% %&"? %%=$%!?>7

'E"P#%9"%?$%P"#&!!"%%"!##B "$%% ! ? !5"9 %  !  "! "  ! ? &7  "#! '% $!% "  +!" "95&%#9 "%  #&!7  %  &? &#  >% %?#R% % ! $%%5>"=7*"% %%%#9%$= %%!'E"P#%9"%?$%P+%=!$%!'#  $#% B % #>! =  %"%% %  8 ! 9 &% #%# %=$%%$%!%%8%%>=&%$J% ##7

 E" !>= B !$% &% "  #&! ! %9 %%= % !#>##%8 ! %+$ %?= ! ? !5"97  %% #>"%  $% ! ! %+$ ? %%  %% &  8 !  & .507  "#! % %%# =  9&% %#5%%8%'#%%=$"!8#!!E !:#7E ##"%?"%>=& ?"9 %!&"%"!? '%"8%#!'%&7   $%?> & %  !' 8% "+!= 9##8% !' $?>$!%%!%="BP#%9"%?$%P !7

%$%"$%%B&E#%%$99"&"$ >##!'#7 %#>! %8%"=='#%%!88! =' $ #>: =%! ! 9#%9=% $ E$=  ?+$%%#%%?+!"8%=%&# ""%!'E" '%5B5!!#9%!'$:5"!7

"#!'%$"#&!!%9!#$8EE@%8%  $%# ! %& N  E   !? !' %9%# # B  $%# 8% B %% %#  '#  $#% $ ! "%% 8%!#%"%$$+?%=7

 "#!%@>#="%%8%%?#= 9#   %%% %"$%?>= % 9"#= &## %="%?!5"9%%$$"%



123-1/440  5316.5   $% ! ?> ! $ ! =D Q   %%   !9% $># ! $ ! =%5= "%   9 !'%  $%   > !#$"%B$!!$!E%"%%%&8E"% !%7E '+$!"%%!'!?"%>=!$6,,2 ! '%&%# ! "> %  $%# ! %& E>9  !  % %&%#  % ! 644G  %% "" ! %% %&%# %% "$% ! ": >%"$:%!"%%8%##7

6H7  !# ! 0 I% /44.  '   #  !% ! '# B ! $%%7 $: E" ! !    %%# = '# $#%% %  %%% >=  "% = '"$J?% !'E  $8 ! "F " =' &%$!%$%&$%%&%#!$%#B#%%!%# $"#!%%=&!!'%$8"% @='" /446  = '#%% ! & : =' '#%% #!$%# $8"% ! ": $$$#  = '#&% !  #%%! %#  $:  8% &% #%# 8&9 ! 8F % ='  9%% $ !'$%# ! %& ! '%&%#!&!5">%=$%#!%&!'# #%%! %:7' '%#8##B%#>!B'E"!%%='# $&% E  %&%# !$%# B  "%% %  #%% $ ! 8"%$%:7

6,7 6.$%"9/44. '#8"#$$%B%%!#7

/47 !#$$%!6-@&/440 ' 8"#!#! 8!$%%7$$#'9>%!'#!'%$!%%=' %!%!'E>!$%%#$$988%!'%%%B %# %   9%   #%% ! 'E$% 95!$ $%=# $  "#! !     = '#&% ! '8% &% #%# 8&9 % '%(%$%#!%&!'%&%#!&!5"> = ! %% % %&%# $%%  "%% 8%7 % B '9#%# !>%=#    #%# &# =' '#%% $ &!%   ! '5&!%#7

/67   ! 6- 8#& /440  '#  %@%#  % %% !#7 #9"%   !"! = % "  $  !9 E$% "#!  $?+= % $+?=  $$"% =  % !#  % %:  9!"%!"!"%$87#8:$$% !   ! - I% /442 % %" ?=% =' '% $ #%# $  "$%7%%$&E'%&%#!&!5">="$= ='  %& ! ": $>#  %%   !9%  & =' % B $%!?>$#B=DQ78%&=#%%'>>&%  #8: B % #>!  $$% "#! !  P#%9"% ?$%P ! 62 $%"9/44.7



123-1/440  5-16.5   //7 &%#B$ '  !#$!0&/440 @%! 7  9%   8% & = '  $% '#% !' E$% "#!=&J%%%&$9%7

/27   #$= ! 62 " /440  '#  8% & =  #%% ! %# '% !#>!# %%   $ $+?= = $?+=  ='  9 %""%  #>>&%%B$+!88$#$?#=&  " ! " /4407  $!% B '$$ !  ! ! %8% "#!E #"%! $+?% % $?%">7

   != & E"#  $%% B $ $  ! /6 8#&66"/440 %B$+8!%$$8#&/4407  % B  #$%?#$%? $%% B 'K !% % B  $+ 8 !%7

%7 $#%*C$+?%%$+?%?#$  %8='#88!'$9:"$+?=8"!%9E5 !#$8 !'%%# "+ !  ! ! "9 "! $?+= ;?+$%  !9:%  9#%#<  ='$:  %& %9%  %%"% $+?5$?">=   >>&% ! '#%% $+?= % $?+= % &$:#%$+!88$#$?#=!%!#9%! " ! " /440  = !$ % #&#"%   $%% %  $ %# $9:"!%# =''=:% $!" %$$$ %!"#! " %%% =""%%:$%9#  =' 8% ! ?"   #& $ 8 $ % >#  =  ?"!#$&%!#"!'%%##&:%%!88"%%9# %%"%7%B$%#%%%#&$%7

/.7   ! /0 &"9 /440  '#   $!%  $$% ! !%#!/6&"9/440!=%=$%%88%!' $#+$#$?#=!88!%!%'#&%#%#%"8&9  = !$  " !'& /440  '% $% ! 8#=%  ! &%>  ! #$?#$%%"$>#!!#%%%"$5$$>:  ! 8""%%!'?+$9%##>"%$>!&> % !$  !L%#>?7"#!%!>%!'?#"##9%%  =  #%# 8"# $   $%=#  62 %9 /4407  % B  $%# %% ! %& ! 644G %   $  !# !#%"#7  @% =  #&%+>$8'%$&>97





123-1/440  5H16.5  

 

67   >&  S>% @! ! // &"9 6,.6 ;<  #%# "!8# %  %%#  !:  6 I% /442   9 % !   "$#!0@> !%$#!%%&5$#!% 0$$#%% 63@>;%76%7%03 <7

%BS%!S#%!63@> $ 98#!# /-@&/44.; *624643< ! >&!$%# 628#&   !$%%%>%$"%%% 9%! !#>B2@>%%  !S%%%!S#% !&E@>7

/7 8"#"%BS%70376%7?7/  9!#(% %=!%%%$#&$S%703!8#!#$% >## ! !% !   ! 3 %9 /444 ; < = % %& B   8#!#  S5&!%# ! 6, @ 6,0, ; <7  "$#%$@>!!S$:%#%97

27    % %#  &>  6 @& /442  %(% ! "!8% #>%& %""% !  !% ! '5&!%#7  $% ! & %"$ %$$$$9:>!!%&>""%T  8% @!="% !#%"%  % $!% %  @> !  8!$$ $$$# '#%%!8%##B !%!#%"%!!#$$%%>; *6/,.!767/M 63,!76M203!76%J%%#<7

 $#%    !"! ! $%% !#$#  6,,07 U%% !#=8%!#%"%%##$%&%%$:S%# &>! !%B%!%J%E"#>!!'!% $  $#! @=' 26 !#"9 /44/ %  8% !  & #>"%%#>$:%%!%; *624..0%#8#M87 * 624  2/,<7 %8   "!8% #> % !    %%%   :> >##   & 8"# !    !  @$! %& E % $!% &% '%#  &> !   M  ' !#  "!8% ! $% ! & !  %  ! % =  @$! !#&$$# B  $$ $% J% $ % $$=# ; *6242.0!72<7 %E:>!$#! '$$=% 8 !$%%%% B%!:'%#&>!  ; *62626.!7272 66-,2!739 66/234!7.M   6,,HV2-$7263!729<7

"J" !$%!&!/6"/442"!8%  ;.:"#&< %#&>6@&/44.;/4422H0/< %



123-1/440  5,16.5   $ $$9 ; * 6/-  .3- !7 6<7   " T  % #%# "!8#$& !$%5$:%!%#!& %#6@&/44.7

8 8#!#!63!#"9/440"!8%8#!#'5 &!%# % %#  &>  6 @% /443 ;/443 /442<  $$%% ! "!8%=%%""%$#!!%!&% 9 % !  ;%70/  0H % 36 %7   <7 %8   $#%  '%$"&!% !""%=!!%!"%%8  #%# 8"# &%  6 @% /443 ;?7 %7 ! !$% %% %&B"!8%!63!#"9/440<7

.7 #$#!8"%!#$#&$ $#%%&9 ;%734 <7

07  %> $%   =% ! &   %%% B  %# !% 88  % % &!% % &%    #?#%  !% B ! $%% ! '5&!%#7

37 < % #$%# &!%#  '$%# ! > %%  $% $#"# $"%!>!# #%%!'8"%#>#% !'"! !'!%;%7H76 %.76 <7%#$%#$%#!> %% !"% ! '"9  !' $% ! $9%# ! > ! '#   "?# ! %& #=9# = %  !#%   %% !"% #% !' %%% B  %# $?+=  "% % =' $% $:  %%"%%"!#!$%%E>9;%7- <7#& %E!'&!%# &='#%$9%''#%%$&!% "$# &  =' $% 9%  EF% '%&%# = $% 9"% J% E># !  $:  %%"% %  " ! #!$%% "?#!%&#=9#;%763 %%7/H7/ <7

9<&%!S%7/H76 ;!&%#6@&/44.<  S#!%B%%:S%&!B33/12G" B!"5 %S%&!B04G" B=%!%S%&!B.4G  "M !   $#9  S# $%  !S$: S%7 /H 7 69    $#%!B!"5%S%&!B.4G"7:6@&/44.  S#!%B%%:S%&!B-4G" B%5=% !%'%&!B34G" B!"5%S%&!B04G " B=%!%S%&!B.4G"7

< '9>% $ '# ! !"  !""> %  $$ >## ! !%!; *6/,.32 !7.7/ 6/2/22!72  66-/-H!7/9 .44%#8#%#<7@>$%$8! "$"%   %& = '#  8  '%" 5"J" $9 ! 8!$!#9%!$%#!%& $#&%=%



123-1/440  56416.5   % %%# !'8 B  $8%   !># !  &!%# ; * 643  H3 !7/$7H-<7

!<+!$#=@$! %!S&!%#  !!%! %%#"=%"#!M %#=#"=9@%&!S$%#8%=S "$%!S#&; *664/-0!7.M640/4-!7/<7

-7 %%%B%#$+?=$&% ""%%%$?+= %(  &!%#!'%7.76   ;&'%7H  <7 !: $ "" ! #= !' #%% $+?= "!8  ! $ "" ! 88% B $!  ?> $ '5&!%#   !"%!$%#!>='#$%"$J?8%$& ! 9 &%#M  " !  = % E>9 !% J% !#%"#  9@%&"% = $9 ; * 64/  630M  /446 $7 //. !7 /9 %  #8#M87 *6/-/,H!7.8<7

!"%%SE%!S$%#!>#$%%%B%# "%   S% ! $ !#8 = S# E  %&%# %& 88%M8%9$%L%!"!S+!S!"%%=S% E>! $!%$%= =S"%%B$8%$%# ! %&  W !% %%& W =S % E> % $$%9 $#%#; *6/-/,H!7.8 64/630M/446$7//. !7/9M/444$7602!7/M6,,3$726H!7/ $72/6!7 6 $7./.!76M 6,,/$76H/!7/%#8#%#<7

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



123-1/440  56616.5   %9$+?=$&=#$$"%$!%E%# %=$%%#"$%"%!%% %?= 8"  =  !88%# $+?= #  $"  $ S#">% ;!#"% % "%%< S% $   E5"J"  & !S&!%# ;?7 6460  <7  % % $&% %%8 %% ! 8% >>&% !S"$% &9   !&! % 8& S$$% ! %9 $+?>:7   =   8% $+?E  % %  L  "%: !'&!%#   *   $##  @$! %& E %%% B  %# $+?= ; * 6/-  /,.<N%"#=!%8%8>%$"9!%%%B %# $%9 !'%(  $%# ! >   ! S5 &!%#7

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

=&$9%!'$$%"#! =%!#%"% '% =  $% %>E % 8% '9@% !' #%! %#  =  $$%8!!E""$% ='$#>"%!#%  $% E$"# $  $ E"#  =' % #%# #%9  $ !'": =!$%!%E%"#!%'$$#% !%%"#!%%8=!'E$%% !I"% "%&#7  !"%  '##"% !#%"% $  & $9% '%'>!"+!$&!#>%""$$%"" E$%  " 9 % 9  % ; * 6/0  20/ !7 2  6//  634 !76%#8#<7



123-1/440  56/16.5    $$   @>  '#% $  "%8 "$#%8 !  !' E$% "#!   8% @!   %R? ! 'E$% #%% $##"% ! "%%   $# B  !$% !  @%  ! S!"%%8!'#$%"#!E!'#%%!8%!#7 @$! $%%%!'#%!'E$%8% = 5 % ! %!%   =' E$% !# $  %9  8"   ! ": &%7  %  = !'%$#%#"%%%!$%$%B"%%#"% !%$%!!#!%!'E$% $%E   %$#%% !&>% !  !  ! $  @>    9   %% "$#"%   8" !' & E$% "#! ; *6/020/!7291%#8#<7

  @$! %  !%  S%%# !"%%&   @>  !% !#  8% "" $&# = =S % & !  #%# ;V  ! ! Y&$D?%  .:" #!%  6,H.  $7 623M )  !&X%>?%$8>  /:" #!%  $7 /-H ?7 0<7   !" !     @> 8!  !#  8 !$% % !      8% =  8% !SJ% #%9 ! ": #8%9  $$%""$&"99 S%5B5!=$#%%!>#! &"9$#$!#%788%!$=S8%$J%!## "%""?+$%?:$97"%##"%!8%#># &>9 @>!% #?#% %E=$%$ $99 ; * 6/3  234 !7 0 %7 9 6/0  6,0 !7 ?7 / %  #8#<7

8 @$!%% @>!$$# #>%#!!#%%=# :>>## !S$:S#%%!8%E%% ""% T  !# %>  #%# ! ; * 6/6  233 !7 69 %  J%%#<78%&$%#"% %=%"!8#%%%%  !&%""%8S9@%!S&!#!"%%&; *6/6 233!769%#8#<7

,7 '$: 8%!%%='$:&!#$#!"!!$%% % ">#"9> '#%&#$% !'9!! >#&  $!""%='$%&B$%"$!%$ # @='""%!8% "/4467%%%$#!  %!!"%%'E%!'&!%#7

'>%!$#!$%#B'8% V "/44/  @>#='##%%$%B$!%&%##>:5%=E# $&% 5 B $ %"$   =' 8"# == " $ %!    =  $## $  = '#%% !#$8 EE $$  @&/44/'#%%9"##7



123-1/440  56216.5   %      "#! %%%   @>#  !  $$% !%# ! /2 $%"9 /442  =  $%% #%% ! '$%# %% ! %& "" &!% !$"/4467&%%%8%!% $$# $ E !   % V   =  &% !'J% $$#7 %E%C %$$&E"J"  =  "#! %%%  $  $='B ' !' E$% 9!$$$8! !%%B&='"$%%#=%!  @$!   %  B  $%# ! %& ! 644G  "J" ! '%&%# ! &! "> %   ">#  %%% "97  %&%!" T%%&%# #>: $% "$%9&"%8%!'#7 '%$#=%B@% %%='""%!!#%> '%"##!%E$%%! %7

%E%8%! P#%9"%?$%P %$!% $  %   8% #%% ! & %%%  $%# B  !# %>  =  % ! J% E"# !  ! ! $#% %>7  $$%!B'# #?#% !!#$&!"!8% &>>&%!#%%!%#7

647 #>!E!#%=$#:!% %@%#7



123-1/440  56.16.5  

   1   ,+    +  

"

234 .. 5  6     7 8 *%' !9

  4 .

67 #&97

" 4

/7 @%%7

27 %=$#!%>%%7

.7 8"  $% !  =S $&% 8"  %  $#% J% !  !# ! 24 @ !:  %8% $ $ ""!# !#  9 8#!# !   ?XD?8= 3  344.      % E"$7  !#  $% J% $>#7  "#" !%N < != E%"%=!#%!#9%%$!!# %%=#M 9< E$ $ = "%8  %" $& !"! %% % !#M < $%  >%   !  $#%%7   "#"  %% $  % ##"% #"##  %% < 9< % < 5!   98#!#!$$%"%:=S !&!#&97"#"!"%"+ ! $&  = % @%   =  !# %%=# % S&$$ ! =#%#E$#!#%;%762/ 643%64H<7  >88:  $#!%          V  V



$8"!$#%J%%%8#E$%=SBS888#!# !$>88



123-1/440