Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/1065/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1065/2007 Généré par l'IA

Contract Damages and Prejudgment Interest Calculation in Goods Non-Payment Dispute

Numéro de cause ATAS/1065/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The dispute centered on the proper calculation of damages and the application of prejudgment interest in a case involving a failure to pay for goods delivered under a contract, where the delivery dates and applicable interest rates were contested. The court reasoned that the controlling contract terms dictated the method for calculating the outstanding balance and that the initial statutory interest rate applied from the time payment was due, but later modified the award to reflect a different, contractually agreed-upon interest rate from the date of default until judgment, affirming the underlying liability for the unpaid amount while adjusting the monetary relief based on the governing terms of the commercial relationship.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contract Damages and Prejudgment Interest Calculation in Goods Non-Payment Dispute: The court reasoned that the controlling contract terms dictated the method for calculating the outstanding balance and that the initial statutory interest rate applied from the time payment was due, but later modified the award to reflect a different, contractually agreed-upon interest rate from the date of default until judgment, affirming the underlying liability for the unpaid amount while adjusting the monetary relief based on the governing terms of the commercial relationship.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
calcul du dommage paiement des intérêts contrat commercial notion de décision balance des paiements valeur litigieuse

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Costs were imposed on the appellant (complainant in the main proceedings).
Généré par l'IA
A/3010/2007
Contract Dispute: Prejudgment Interest Calculation Date
A/1603/2003
Damages Calculation: Prejudgment Interest and Penalty Assessments
A/1920/2006
Contractual Interpretation and Damages Calculation Dispute
A/1107/2004
Contractual Interest Rate vs. Statutory Default Rate in Damages Calculation
A/2547/2004
Interest Rate Calculation Dispute on Financial Instruments

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Costs were imposed on the appellant (complainant in the main proceedings).

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



           #$$%&#'(() *#$(+%#'(()

*

 * *     

,-. /  0 . '(() 



 !" # $ ! 

 ! !" 

%

&&' & ( & ) "3  ) * )+, &%-./01 

*    &    &  !%% !2% +2.$ #

         !   "

  74:  

 1*

5)  ;.!%  76 ;, 7889  55<! =!+  +  2!< %  2"  ,   !  "   5>:?%"5>9?!" % 9%+7888)

7) &  =33 0  2%3  ;.!% 2"%"  +  2!< % "%@ !   ,2%.2!%"  , 2",A23B2= (@ %!.)

/) ;.!%  ,% , "3%3>!7889%"%"%! (33  + "77!78892@"% 2%.)

?)  + "%" 2%! %%% 2",A 2%2"%%% "3 2% !!B !%%  ,   2% B %  !. % %  9%+7888%>!7889)

6)  ,%.% !" 2  +  " % 2! ("%+  3% ,%C

)&(.% , 2",A  ! C

&D&& *  B 2   7: , 7889 B  !  % 33" 2< ( 25E%788?%B(2%% +2.("%" %! 2     2) & 2%%  %  ;  ,("<,179(:5/3)

%% 7?!7889 &&( && &          & & &  & &    -  3!  + B  !  (% %!% 2 33" 2< ()2%% +2. ?6(:093)"%","5/;78861 *     &     &   1 $F=) %%  2" ".!% %% 78;%7889B ! "%"33" 2 5 ;, 7885 % B( 2%%  + 2.  "%" G   *      &&   5? 3", 7885 2  !%% 5/(>9>3)68)

 2  78 ;% 7889 $ #    ( &&  &     B B  !   "%" 33" 2<   *      &&   5 ;% 5>>>  /5 "!+ 7888 % B  2%% %!.("<,155(9563)/8)

    4556047889 /4:  

 *     &     &  !%%  !2%  +2.1$F= B  7/;%7889,G 2%% +2. ?6(:093)   % 77;7886 % (,%  !2%)  2%%  %  !   ;  , ("<,1?:(:7?3)66)

+)&(.% , 2",A  ! C

 %%  9 ! 7889  *         3!  +B ! "%"33" 5,!+788?/5E%788: % B(2%% +2."%"%3""  & 7? ! 788: 2  !%%  99(566 3) 78)  2%%  %  05(9073)06  "%" ," 2<      50 "!+ 788:)  2"  %B2%% %1 % !.("<,1/(>/:3)

 5?!7889   BB2%% %  !  1  %  !. .!%"  %"H% ;B( ;  ,% ?(90/3)68)&2%% %%%;  ,("<, 6>(>683):8)  2"%B ! %33"2< ( 25;,7889%B(2%% +2. 05(9073)06 "%" %3""   *         % 6>(565 3) 76 %"%","!2%2<   %77(:/53):8%,1(,% (!2% +2.2<     )

 %%  7/ ! 7889  *       &&         3!,G2%% + 2.  77(9>6 3) 78     5: , 7889)  %%  78 ;% % 502%!+ 7889 %% 3 % 2" ".!% B( !2%  + 2.  "%" ,%  !   !   5 ,!+ 5>>> %  ,!% 68(?793)08 *   '  *  &'& I    (& ) !2%"%" " 76%+7888%%3% (2%% +2. 65(:>:3)66 2<   *      *   &     )2%% %  ! ; !.A!2 %"H%;B(;  ,!%165(97:3)>8)

%% 78;%7889*    &&       B B  2%%  %  99(566 3) 78  "%" %3""7?!788:2< *        )

 *     '  &  &  %!   %% /8;%7889B %%!2"!% /8E%7889  3!% ,%C  2%%  %   !   ;  !. ("<, 1 /(>/: 3)  2%%  + 2.  97(806 3) :8  "%"

    4556047889 ?4:  

%3""  /5 ! 7887 2<   *       &&      & %  "2%   ! )  %  2%% +2. 65(:>:3)66"%"G76%+7887 %% !H!%%%B(!%% 5(7??3)79%+78882,%  D  #)

 582%!+7889D  #   BB  ! "%"33" 792%!+5>>>7:,!+5>>>%  B  2  + 2.  "%" ") %% <  "%" J%"  7? %+ 7888 %  %3%  5(7?/ 3) 06 2<   *     ' &   )

:)  !% % "%" %! @ 2%  %  75 2%!+ 7889) ; %    B" B   3!%   ,  2",A12%.(",%16>(>063)062 ! 17?(>>53)66 2  !  % B(1 "3% (+,% (  5 %+ 7889  H%% %%+)

9) (+ (+;%  "3@""%". "1;.)

 *

5) (%)76 3" "+2. 2",A23 ,,,%%, %" 59 "!+5>>/K*L%",. 5;,7888<.2"   ,)B;%% 2 M 2%% %12%.K%)577%57/   ,- L ;.   ,!2"%% (%)9/)5 3" " 2",A 23  76 ; 5>07 KL % 1 <,  + %  25E%788/ %2<B(33  "%"%!K%)5?7 L@"% (332%.+  "  "2%% "%!"2;.  ,)

7) &(%)77*K,%,. 25;,7888L  ,  2%%  % B %  !. % 2%." 3!"!% @%)57757/5?5%5?7 N%)/16 *(22B% 2.!%%1%3"K)5L)=B;%2%%  %12%.2 1 33"%2%% %.!%"  ,  + 2. @%% ",%!%  !!%  , %  2%% %.!%" , +2.@%%",%!% !!%  !.K3)%)7?*L);% 1  2%%  % % 1 (,  + 2. @%%  !!%  

    4556047889 64:  

  !.  %"H%   !!%  , K * 570  7/8N *57>???L)

 M2<  ;.  2!< %  " % @ !      B%  2%. 2 !%"  2%%  % B 2 = (@ %!.% 9%+7888>!7889 %1B ;.!%  ,% ,@"%)

/) &  !% 2 %  2%% B 2 %  !. 2  ! ("<,16>(>063)06OK79(:5/P?:(:7?)66L-K55(956)/82%%  %!!% !.P%"H% ;B( ,LQ) %1  !   %  7?(>>5 3) 66 OK6>(>68):8 P 77(9>6)7>L - K5(7?/)06 P 65(97:)>8 P ?(90/)68L  %"H% A% ";1 "%" " 2  %%%  2",A "3 )

 "B  !  % 1  @-"2  !%%  7>(>>7 3) >6 K6>(>063)06C7L%- %1@-"2@!%% 57(?>63)08K7?(>>5 3)66C7LN "3%, !  %1@-"2!%% 59(?>9 3)56K7>(7>73)>6-57(?>63)08L)

?) 3!"!% 1  ;2  2  ; "%!% 2  2%. ;B(!!% %3% 2%% %  !;% ,"+""3 %%2%% %1 %"H%!2% !%% -) %"H%%"%@!!!".(%)57 ( 2",A23,,,%%, %"  50 , 5>0? K 7L    %@ ".!%  - % 2" K *57>766 )/L)

6)  "!!%   2G  2"  "%% .%% K%) 9/ ) 7  % 0>#)5 2"  !%%, 572%!+5>06L)



RRR



    4556047889 :4:  

  2*1  * *     

5) ,%  *     &     &    !%%  !2%  + 2. 1 $= 1 %3"  !2%     !!  59(?>9 3) 56 1     3,   !    B  %"H% !2%     "% <>!7889;B(!!% %3%)

7) MA !%%B +)

/) %B2" %.%%)

?) 3!  2%   BM 2,% 3!  %  2"% H%   "  /8 ; <  %3% 2<  + 3" " K&=ST=3B::88?  L2, !%<  % 2+3!"!%@%)07 3" " +3" " 59 ; 7886 K *LN  !"!   %  B   !%3 % !A 2,%2%.% % ! %N % H%  "  + 3" " 2 , 2%  2 , "%B @  %  (%) ?7  *)  2"% H% %  2<  2  %,B"!!!A 2, ,%H%;%1(,)  .33<  " %C         &A, # U   

23! 2"%H%%%3"@2%BM1M333" " 2.33

    4556047889