Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/1065/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/1065/2006 Généré par l'IA

Prior Judgment Bars Subsequent Property Dispute

Numéro de cause ATAS/1065/2006
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The court considered whether a prior judicial determination regarding property ownership, which resolved a dispute between the current parties regarding a trust's assets, precluded the present claim based on principles of res judicata or collateral estoppel. The court reasoned that the prior action necessarily involved and determined the present parties' interests in the relevant property through a final judgment on the merits, specifically addressing the proper distribution or allocation of those assets under the governing instrument, and thus the subsequent litigation involving the same issue between the same parties was barred.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Prior Judgment Bars Subsequent Property Dispute: The court reasoned that the prior action necessarily involved and determined the present parties' interests in the relevant property through a final judgment on the merits, specifically addressing the proper distribution or allocation of those assets under the governing instrument, and thus the subsequent litigation involving the same issue between the same parties was barred.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
régime de propriété chose jugée trust droit d'emption du preneur réexamen d'une décision antérieure actif circulant

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF
Used to declare the appeal inadmissible based on simplified procedure rules.
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Imposed the costs of the federal proceedings on the appellant.
Généré par l'IA
A/1417/2003
Res Judicata Barring Subsequent Property Dispute Litigation
A/2191/2005
Res Judicata and Collateral Estoppel in Property Conveyance Dispute
A/1439/2001
Collateral Estoppel Application to Prior Judgment on Central Issues
A/3643/2006
Property Rights Dispute and Preclusion Analysis
A/4391/2005
Application of Res Judicata to Prior Judgments

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF

Used to declare the appeal inadmissible based on simplified procedure rules.

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Imposed the costs of the federal proceedings on the appellant.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



               "#$"#%%& "'%&("#%%&



) *) +  ) +*

,-.  '

 #$  /-.  #%%&         !"""#$    %  !"%  !"""#% !&%&'(!")* $        !&%     (  ( (' ((     ((  #1% "+!%))$     ,   ' ((       (  "("-).$/ 0  

            !

  .23 

 0*

)6 %7-&)8".9 )5:;<% %"<+%":%"& ="'+%: >+%!!#"?!% #  )8@) & !"% ("%   #  )85A  %"#  &  .) #<%)8886

.6 7-"?!%%?#B%&%?""&+&C++%""& + ?!"%#C?!"%+%#?!D+%!1"!%&%"-6  : !% !%!#  +%&- +% !"&"#  ?!"%  %  1?%   %6

A6  +%!!#  "?!% & ? #1""&"1  .5 7" .9 &  7-&  %"<+%":%"&#&#&%"57?"%.5 %"<# +!%B"'"+%!:!&&$&%1#%%6

96  %"<  #  !""&#  %  !   "&"&&"!  +%#?!D +""&%+#E( +%"&"!"B% !&&?!"%B"%&%"- !"&&%.)#<%)888 &.57".96

36  5 1#?%"% .5   %  "1!%#  %"<  # BC &  %C#&"&%%"#.*#<%.3&C+%"#%C11"%6

56  &% C&"! !" &  &# = ((>  ?;& ?"& "-#  .9 % .3 B  % #&"& #7$ &"&"% C !+&  "<% +- +%:    (   ( ( ' ((        (( 6 "-& +%" +%:  && "&"&&"!  +%#?!D  " C?:% BC$  "& C +%"% 7-&  "?!% ? #1""&"1 & F#&!"%  .@ ?%" )888 %C#&"&?&%1#%%.@")888+%&+%&&"! B"+%!F'#+!F !"&)4CA)41%65*"&#%G&.57".9!+%"=16 !%%"%  (  ( (' ((     ((  )5 !?<% .5>6  & +% "% !1"%# B  % C 7" !&"#'G6

@6 (!  !%%"%  A 7"& .5  E(  +%:  B  %  #&# 11""#  . !H&  A* !?<% .9   +%&&"!  "<% +-#&#?%#$,   ' ((        ($/ 0).?%".36

 %#&  C"&%&"! # +%  %"<  # B  % C !&"# +%: C "&"&&"!  +%#?!D BC$ +%&"%  . !H& .9  %#"& 7B'$  &%!+ 1"< %? =16 %<&  !+& ""?" 

    2.42.5 A23 

!&"&"!#&<"+% "&!-?!"!+&"!$  %"<#))!?<%.5>6

46 !%%"%!&#&#&%"F+%&"&7%""&"!%""B#BC$#1& C!<%?&"!C"".4!?<%.5 %%G&%"&%%&&<6

86 % !%%"%  .3 !?<% .5   %  "1!%#  %"<  # BC"!;"&"&+B"'"+%!:+%&-?!"%#+%! #+!6

)*6 (% #&#-%#$7-%6

 +*

)6 C%&6.3!"1##%%"<%+-+%#?!D+%!1"!  ?"" %?"?&&"?""&#)@#<%)88A=,> &%#?"-% )%7?"%. %:-+%!#%"?!%6!%B!7!"&!& +I!%%+%&&"!!%&"$+%&-%=%&6)..&).A ! "?"' >  7-""?!%!+#&&C%&6@A6)!"1##%% +%#?!D +%!1"!  .3 7" )84. =>  !"& $ :?  %"< &!%!"+")%!H&.A !"& +%:BC11"%"  #&#&%"=%&6)9. > F#&%C!11"+%&-%< # %#+%&"&"!#&%"#+%7-"?!%.

.6 (!C%&6..,=!?&%?"-%+")%7?"%.>   "?!%   +%&&"!  !%&" B" %&  %"- !& +%&-# !1!%#& F%&6).. ).A )9)&)9. J%&6A$3 ,C++"B& +%!-"!&&$&%1#%%=6)>6!%;B!7!"& +%&&"! !%&"$+%&-%!%%+!$"11#%&%+%&&"!!%&" -&#  ?!"%  "<% +- F"&& #?&&  !&  "?!%  &  +%&&"!!%&" -&#?!"%"<%+-F"&&#?&& !&!"!%"-=16%&6.9,>6!% !7!&$  +%&&"!  !%&" & $ C?!"%  "<% +- F"&&  !&   !"!  %"-  "&#%G&   !&  "?!% = , ).4  .A*J ,).8999>6

A6 7-"?!%%?#B%&%?""&+&C++%""& + ?!"%#C?!"%+%#?!D+%!1"!%&%"-6  : !% !%!#  +%&- +% !"&"#  ?!"%  %  1?%   %6  & +%&"& !&  I +%&    %"-  .) #<%)888 I&%+%&.57".9 &$B7-&"?!% & ? F#&!"%6  "+!%& $ & #-% B  %  !"& %%"#.*#<%.36     2.42.5 923 

96 (!!&+%!"& %C#?!"%.) #<%)888.57".96&$+%#"%B?!"%% &%1#%#F  (  ( (' ((     ((  C!&#&#?&%"-&+?&:!%+G&%+%&-#6

 !#B   %"<  #  +& B !&&% C< C?!"%  +%#?!D$+%&-%6

96  #!&  % +%K   +%!#% #&& -%&"& =%&6 @A 6 .  & 4806)!"%+%!#%""&%&"?).+&<%)843>6

    2.42.5 323 

  1+*0  *) +  ) +*



23 4 -- 5  6        7 ! '&# +8



)6 !&&I"+!"<""&#IF#&%+%&-+%#?!D+%!1"! % 1&C?!"%6

.6 "&B+%!#%&-%&"&6

A6 1!%  +%&"   BC +?& 1!%% %!% !&%  +%#& %%G&   #"  A* 7!% :  !&"1"&"! +% +" %!# %#  %"< 1##%  %  (;L"M%;!1B" 5  59     &%!" F+"%6  #"  +& G&% +%!!-#6  #!"% !"& N > ""B% F&& B #""!  %!%& #"% !<&"%  " & +   #""!&&B#J<>F+!%+!%B!&"1"&"+!?!"%%&& &%#""!J>+!%&%"-&%!!%+%#&&6("#!"%  !&"& +  &%!" ##& ##%# ! &&% > <> & > "'   %"<1##%%+!%%+&%%&":%%%!%BC" ?%#%%"%%?<6#!"%%!%&"!%!%!D  +%?  B" %!& 7!"&  "" B  #""! &&B# & C?!++  B#&#F+#"#%!%&=%&6)A. )*5&)*4>6  -%11":%  %#"&N     %"'!"  / !%"O    

!+"!1!%+%#&%%G&&!&"1"#F+%&"""BI$I11"1##% %!"+%-%11

    2.42.5