ATAS/1062/2004 · Contract Validity and Enforceability Dispute (Cour de Justice (Cour civile))

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The dispute concerns the validity of agreements and related transactions where the court found that one party failed to establish the existence of a valid written contract, as the purported agreement lacked essential terms and was not properly executed, thereby precluding recovery on the contract claims. The court reasoned that although some consideration might have been exchanged, the absence of a definite, enforceable agreement meant the claimant could not sustain claims for breach of contract or specific performance, though it did not preclude other remedies related to the dealings between the parties.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Contract Validity and Enforceability Dispute: The court reasoned that although some consideration might have been exchanged, the absence of a definite, enforceable agreement meant the claimant could not sustain claims for breach of contract or specific performance, though it did not preclude other remedies related to the dealings between the parties.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA

validité du contrat règlement du litige contrat bilatéral imparfait partie au contrat contentieux contractuel droits et obligations contractuels

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision regulates the allocation of court costs, which is ordered in the dispositive.

Art. 68 al. 2 LTF

This provision is cited for the allocation of costs.

Généré par l'IA

A/1720/2004

Contract Validity and Enforceability Dispute

A/1491/2003

Contract Validity and Enforceability Dispute

A/1505/2005

Contract Validity and Enforceability Dispute

A/4301/2006

Contract Validity and Breach Dispute

A/247/2004

Contract Enforcement and Validity Dispute

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision regulates the allocation of court costs, which is ordered in the dispositive.

Art. 68 al. 2 LTF

This provision is cited for the allocation of costs.

Texte complet

#$% & '(

# ) #

!

*!

"#$% &&&&&&&&&& + * !, -*./'0- ! *+ 1 1 + #2 -+* 3! !4! + *

*+

' ( )&&&&&&&&&& + * ! ! 567 ; * 89 : '0- *+ 1 1 )*4!7 2 # -+* 3! !4! + *

!"

7 9/= 7

'

6" +! >>>>>>>>>> ?*710 !@ 6A5B *++! !10 31 C>>>>>>>>>> 0 6ADE"

6AAA ! ! ;* 3! 0 3- -* ;; ! 6 - 6AAB 3! + ;" EF5=B7 1 +" * G 1+4! 4! : H++ C>>>>>>>>>> ?*710 H++@ +1 1+! - 1!I 4! 1+! *1"

! 6= * 9<<5 H++ ;+ *+! * 4! + 0 6 - 9<<8 ;" 5FA897"

9" 1 ! 99 * 9<<5 *+! *+ + ! *1 ! 4! ;+ - 4! *7* - G ! + 4!- ! + 4! ! - - : 3-"

1+ ! 96 - 9<<8 H++ ,14! -+ J 1 ! 3 1 !*+ ! !, 3G + !, ! 1+! 9<<9 9<<5" ;*. -! ! 6 - 6AAB 1+ *+ 4!3 *+ 1+ + 1 - 1+! **! 0 6 - 9<<8 !*! G 3K +*+K 1+! 9<<9 9<<5"

*. *+1+* 3 !- 1"

5" ! = ! 9<<8 ! ! * *+*! : * 4!3 + 4! 3-+ 1-+K* ! 56 * 9<<5 30- ! ! :

;" =<5F86E <E : * 4! H++ + *+ : ! - ! ! ;" E<FD8EA< 1! 6 - 9<<8 +! 1!+ ! ;" 5FA897 - 1! * -* ! 1" ,14! 4!3 ! ;*. -! ! 6 - 6AAB 1+ *+ + -+ : 3L ;" =<DF9BD7 + ! 1+ ;" E<FBED7 1 " *+ -+ M! 3;+ + 4! H++ ! !, ! - 9<<5 ! 4! ! 3 1 1 H++" *+ 4! * ! 3 M! 3+ 3!+ !-*"

8" % ;; ! ! ;, ! ! 6D +J 9<<8 : H++ 1+! 1+ : " 1++ 1 *+! ! ;; ! 98 1 9<<8 : H++ 1! 1+ ! 6 +*+ 9<<8 + 1.+4! ! ;; -* H++"

E" 1+ 1+ ! !*. ! ! 6 +*+ 9<<8 H++ *+*! 1*1 : * 4! + * *-" ! ;+

/685</9<<8

7 5/= 7

*+*! ! +! ! !" % H++ ,14! !* 4! 0 H++ 1-+K* 1!! ;+ +;" % G 3! + 8N !4!3 9<<6 *+ 1" + !+ ;*0 H++ *7* *+ 1 ! 3 4! 3+ *+! : ;, 1+! 9<<9 9<<5 ! !, 3G ;! : *! 114! : 3-+ - ! %" 3 3!+ !-* 4! : H++ 1 ! 4! *+; 1+ 3! !, 3G <N 1+! -+ 1-+K* ! 3! G 1+! -+ *+! ! !

%" *+ 1 O + P : 8N 1+! 9<<9 59EN 1+! 9<<5 + 4! *+ 1 1 1-+K* ! 3 * 3!*! G 1+! * !, " - 9<<5 H++ ! 3;+ + !, ! !- 3! -* , 1 **! !

+ 3- 9<<5 !- 7 G * 3;+ + ! + ! 9<<5" ! 9<<5 + ; * + ++* ! ! 3 "

! ;+ H++ ;0 : 3!++ M! 3!+ !-* 1+! : 3 ;* *+ 1 3* +! G 1+! 9<<979<<5 *+;+ -* !

1-! 1 + 1!4!3 3+!* ! ; 3+ 3! 1-+K* ! + 4! G G + + -+ !1! !

! "

3 *- H++ *+0 4! ! * 3 1 *+ 1 + ! +; 4! 1+! + *+ ! + ;++ 1 * 3G 9<<9 9<<5 4! * *++ 3 1 **4! ! - 1 3* =5 % ! 3!+ !-* *+ 1 0" 11 +* !

! + 3!+ !-* + *+ * *. *+ 3!+ !-* + 1+*! 1-! 1 3* =8 %"

% ! 3 +!*. ;; 3 ! H++ + 4! 3!+ !-* 1++M ! ! ! +" O ! 4!+ 3! ! 3 * 1+! 3 ! 4! ! 114! 0 + 3 3! ! 1*! P"

++* ! B +*+ 9<<8 ! 1+ *. H++ ! ! ! ;, ! ! E +- 9<<8 1+! ! *- + *+" % *! - G ! :

! ! *"

D" *! ! E +- 9<<8 ! +* 1 4! ! 1++* ! *- 1+ H++

/685</9<<8

7 8/= 7

! +Q - 1!4! 1+ 1+! ! ;, 1 !" +! !1! ! 4! -+ 1 *+* 1+! 1 0 ;+ -* , : 3++* ! ! *+ 3!+ !-* ! + 9<<8" !4!3: * +! ! -+ 1+! *+ + -+ 3*+ - ! * !*! *+ 3K ! 1 *+ 4! ! 1! + + ; *+! ! 3* =8 %" 1+ +! 4!+ -+ 4!+ *+1+ : ! *+ ! ! + ;" +! K 1 11+ ! ! 1!4!3 3 * 3!*! G + 4! ! *+ *; ! 6 - 9<<8 + -! - ! G * !"

* *+! *+ ! *+ -! + 4! 1+! 9<<9 + 4! 1+! 9<<5 *+*!+ ! + 4!3! !, 6=EN ! + * 4! + **! : +!-!"

=" % ! * *! : H++ 1 1 ! B +- 9<<8 ;+ 1 4! *! : ! ! *"

=" H! ! + ! *+1 7**! 1 H++ !, ! - 9<<5 4! *+1 ! -* !-* ;++ !+ 1-+K* ! 9E 9<<8 : H++ 4! 1* O ! 3+ 4! -+! - + 1 + -* + 3! 1.+4! ! 6A +- 9<<9 3114! ! !, 3G ;! : *! 1-! 1 0 +;*+ + ! ; 4!3!*! G 3 * ! 3-+ - -+ ! 1+! 3,** 9<<9 +! -+! *+; + 4! +! 3-+ 1! 3+ *+ : 311*+ +*- ! 6 - 9<<9 ! +!- * 9E 5 -+ 0 P"

6" %3* =5 + ; ! 1-+K* 1+;+ - !-- - ?*710 %@ 1-+ * 4! !

6 O.4! *+ ! ! 4! *+R 0 * *+ *++ +11+ !+ 1-+K* 1+K! K +" % ! ! G ! 1+ 0 1+ + 3* E9 ! + *+! + 3* ED 6P"

9 O % *+ +- 1-+ ! 1+*! 1 1 1*1 ! S ! *+ ; 3+;;* P"

/685</9<<8

7 E/= 7

% *+ '0- ;+ * *+ 1* : 3* ED + ! 3++ !* 3 6 1-+K 4! ! *+R O *++ - : 1-+K* 1+;+ +11+ !+ 1-+K* 1+K! K + K *+ 1 * -+* 4!3!, 1+ 1+ ?* 556 : 556 ! *+ ++ S * E9 ED 6 * =5 + ; ! 1-+K* 1+;+ ! 9E ! 6AB9 S * 689 *+ *-@P"

+! *.4! *+ ! !+ 4! ,* !-* ! !+ 1-+K* K ! 0 ! + + ?* D6 6 %@ + *+ 1!- G 1+ - + + ; *+! ! 1 + ; ?* =8 %@"

%+ 3++ % + ; 11 4! 1 !,0 1 + +* 1+4! + !," + *+++ 1-+K* 1+;+ 3/ +* + *- * * 4! *+! + ; : 1-+ 3! 1 4! *+ 1* 0 % - G + ! 4! ; 1+!- : ! !+ !* ; -* 4!+ - ! + !* 4! 3! 1 + *+! *+ *+ * ! *+ ! ; !* *+ 0 3/ " % ! *+ - G *+ 1 1+! 3, +! +11+ !, !+ 1-+K* 1+K! K + ?*;" ! + ; HH 6 6A=D 1" 6=A76B<@"

+ + 3 -! ! * *+ 1 1+! +! * *++ *+ 3 1+! *++ - : + ; ! 3!* - !--" * * 1! G : -; ! **! +! " G 1!7 G : -; **! 3! %"

% *+*!+ ! ! - : 3+*+ 3! % 3! + ;" E<FD8EA< 1 ! 1* ;" 8=F5<87 4! ! + - +* 1; *+ 1* ! ! *"

&! ! 1! + + ; *+! *+ ! *+ 3!+ !-* 3 1 *+ 1 ! *+" 3+!* *1 ;! ! + !*! *+ ! 3* E 1+*! - ; 4! ! J 1! *+ : -+ ! * !4! 1 ! 1 ! !+ ! * -! *+* *+ 1+ +K + ?*;" # + ; -+ 1" 968 9AA@" 3+!* **! 3;+ + ! + - 9<<5 *+1+ 1 : * ;+ S 3! 1 3 1

/685</9<<8

7 D/= 7

4!3 +; ! !" &! ! *+! 3!+ !-* ! + 9<<8 : H++"

&! G ! *+ ! ! 4! * *. 1 *+ 1* ! ! 310*"

9" *+*!+ ! * *+ 1 0 *- : ;+ "

/685</9<<8

7 =/= 7

( " ' +

,,$,

-#$.#!$,/0 %1#% , #$,$% ,# 02,3 45

0.#6

6" * *+ 1 + "

9" * *- : ;+ "

5" #- ! 1+*!"

8" 4! 1+*! !"

E" ;+ 1 * 4!3 1!- ;+ *+! *+ 1 G ! 6< +! 0 +;*+ 1 1 *+ !

! ; !* *.TU.+;4! D D<<8 %# + , 1" % 1! G 1++" % + + @ 4! ,* 4! *+ *+! + ! 1* *+ 4!S @ ,1+ 1+! 4! +; 1+!-+ * ! *+S *@ 1+ ! +! * + 1" + *+ + ! +! @ @ *@ *7! ! ; !* 1+! 1 0 ! *+! 4!3 - * *-" % + *+! + *+ +K 1!- 4! + + 4! *+ 4! 3-+11 4! ,1 ! *+! ?" 659 6<D 6<B )@"

% ;; %

#

*+1 *+;+ ! 1 G +; !, 1 4!3: 3;;* ; !* +* 1 ;;

/685</9<<8

Contract Validity and Enforceability Dispute

Synthèse Legislator

Regeste Legislator

Mots-clés

Dispositions légales citées

Décisions connexes

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Texte complet