Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/1060/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/1060/2005 Généré par l'IA

Royalty Contracts Supersession Dispute

Numéro de cause ATAS/1060/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The dispute centered on whether certain pre-1934 contracts, which had been the subject of prior litigation concerning the payment of royalties based on production, were superseded by a 1934 agreement concerning the division of production proceeds; the court reasoned that the 1934 agreement expressly referred to and incorporated the existing contractual framework, including the royalty provisions, and was intended to operate alongside, rather than entirely replace, the earlier agreements concerning how proceeds were to be shared and accounted for.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Royalty Contracts Supersession Dispute: The dispute centered on whether certain pre-1934 contracts, which had been the subject of prior litigation concerning the payment of royalties based on production, were superseded by a 1934 agreement concerning the division of production proceeds; the court reasoned that the 1934 agreement expressly referred to and incorporated the existing contractual framework, including the royalty provisions, and was intended to operate alongside, rather than entirely replace, the earlier agreements concerning how proceeds were to be shared and accounted for.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
bénéfice règlement du litige contrat-cadre droits et obligations précontractuels accord interentreprises provision pour risques et charges

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The decision imposes costs on the appellant, citing this article.
Généré par l'IA
A/2481/2005
Contract Interpretation and Royalty Dispute
A/3372/2005
Royalty Distribution Contract Interpretation Dispute
A/4379/2005
Contractual Royalty Calculation Dispute
A/1471/2006
Contractual Royalty Terms and Penalty Interest Enforcement
A/4024/2006
Royalty Payment Trigger Based on Aggregated Production

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The decision imposes costs on the appellant, citing this article.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

   

%&'((%'))* +%(),)%'))*

+

 + "+   "  "

"-  ( $ , .  '))*

  

  ! "

"

##     $ ! % &'"!  "'& " ( ) *+ , -.

          ! "  #$

5 1/6 5

 /+

27   $" " %- ( $88 " ( $'% 95  %-  :  2 ;" 133* "  (&5(  &"& ."   8. ( "" ("  03 ; 13367

17 """ < $&  $&"" % %&"& ,  "" .    %  23 ;. 1334 , = >! $88 &? ( %'" 95%- : ! % (& ( 2 ; 1334! %&  % ( (" , $('"& ( < ; %  ($@ ;"8&7

$  %  .& < $& ." (&;, 8" $@;" ( (& ( %! $)" % 88"&  >> % ($'% & ."  %"  >A'?!  $&"" % %&"& ,  & ($8'" B  ( 2= C" 133*!  $D! " )" "'%  ' ( '>& ( ". 9 : % %"& ( ". " .'@ " (&'@ 133*!

 ""8 %( ( "8" '&(7 $ %% %  < $& @&&8 (  "-' (&5( ($('"7

07 $&  8'& %%"  13 ; 1334! &?" < EF 8" >" ' <  B ' (" (G5. , 2* > %  (88&" "A "  ; H   >?& ($> 9= >:! ; '  8"

%(7  ; ( (G5.! ; '  %&"& , 2* > %&! '  '$ "(" (  .7 $  &(?&  %"" '" ($D <$  @ . ;( , ' >> ( ' ( (&'@E7

*7  (& ( 1I ;" 1334!  % &'"  ;"& $%%"7    88" (&& <  D%" 8 % $&  " ""  D .@! (-  <$  '@" ( " . %&  (" "

$> ( (G5.7    ""& <$ 8D"  (& (  % , < ;! "  ''' %&. %  @-' ( B  %  " '<'"! $ ." %"&  %% (  %%""&7

47 $&  ";"&   2* %"'@ 1334 " (" (&  %%"7

67   &% ( 1= %"'@ 1334!  % &'"    ;"

( 7

I7  %" " &"& "(  2 .'@ 1334 %  @ ( &7 $&  (&& <  ." % $"" ( 23 ;. 1334  ."

&"& ' %    ' %%  ($ %&&(" (G5.7   8'& <  (" " $>  ." &"& "'" (<&! '  &%&"& <$>@"& , J" .<& , 2* >!  &"" .  (G5. , ""

/0122/1334

5 0/6 5

>5,7  %& 8 . ""&  (& ( % ". ,   !  <  "8&   ( (&8" ( >> % ($'%7

=7  0 .'@ 1334! $  "'! '' .  ( $( ( '%" %!  " ( (" ( "" <$."  $& .    %7   &"! <$."  23 ;. 1334!  <" (G5.! " ." &"& 8D& , 2* > "  , 23 >7

"" "  &"& ''<& , $& % 8'" "    &"& ?(& , ;?7

  +

27   ?.  K?" ;( 9:  &"& '(8& "  ""&!

(-  2 C" 1330!  @ " (  ! '%& ( 4 ;?! ("  %&(" "  .5%&("! 4 %%&" " 26 ;?  9"7 2 "7  " 46 :7

B" , K" ( K&" ( 26 ;? ! %  @ 8&(&  1I ;. 133* 9 # 203  236:!  (  ?.  (%"&!  20 8&.!  (%" "" ?" %'"""  @ " (   ( &?   , " ;? ""! ! ( K""" ( K&" ( .D ;? 7

17 8'&'" , $"7 46  7 2 "7  >7 = !  @ " (   L"  " < ( """ %&. , K"7 46 (   8&(& ( 6 "@ 1333   %" ?&& ( (" (   0 : < " ". ,   8&(&  K5 >A'? @?" " K('"&   (K.@"& ( 14 ; 2+=1 9 :7

B '%&" % ;? (  (K%- "  &"@7

07  ! ";"&  "'% "! " .@ 9" 46 " 63  :7

*7 D "' ( $"7 2I  ! K& < 8" . ( %"" (K ("! . K" ( K88 ( ". '%&""! "%( ""  <K %" @'" D? (  % &."  >A'?  K@&?7   '@!  %"! ( >> ( ".!  @  (> (  %8 <K DF" %&&(''"7  (" %. %%"  %. ( 88" <K  87

/0122/1334

5 */6 5

K& " " (K%" "" ". .@ <  " %%&7   K@?"! < K""& '%&""   ;"! ( %"% M 7 D ' ".  '>& ( ". %% , '&  %""(  %'"N @7 D "" ( ! D & (K8'" " D "" %&& .& , K7 4N 7 ( 8  ('" %'""" ( ;? K " %"  %'"    ". %%& " .@ # " ( "" < $&  $" % %&"& , $""  23 ;. 1334 , = >7

47 $"7 03   %&." <  (" , $('"& " %( < $& K@. %  %%" ( "A ( >A'?   "" ( K""& '%&""! "''" 8  ". .@!   %&" % ,  ' ( '>& ( ".  K"'%"  '"8 .@!   '%'"  '%J>! %  '%"'"!  (&'" (  '   &" (  @"7

 %  (&"' ($%-  ?."& (  8"! '%" " ( (" % ( $&7  '%"  $ ( %(  (&" ""  " %%   ($%-! "''"  '@ "  '%"'" "& ( $"&& 9B !   327+1 >88 1*I:7

 (& (  % < (" J" %%" ,  ?."& (  8" "

( 2 , 24 ;   ( 8" &?-! ( 26 , 03 ;   ( 8" ( ?."& ') " ( 02 , 63 ;   ( 8" ?. 9"7 03 7 0   " *4 7 1 "7 ! @!  ( $(  $5>A'? 5  :7

 B   &"@  @-' ( %  <  $&   %&" %  @ (  %&"  D .@ , $"" (  " ( "A  ,  ;& ($8'"! %  %'- 8  % ( (" , $('"& ( 4 , = ; " %&N $ $?" (  ( 8 ( + , 24 ;7

"8! <$ & '< %   "" ' <$ %. %  '%"'" ?&& <$ %(  @?" ( >A' " ( @&&8 ( %"" "-  &D!  $)  %  (  %( (  (" , $('"& % '%"'" (&<" 9 1333 %7 232:7

67  $%-!  8("   @-' "    ". , $('"& ( >A'?!  1330/ 1I1! D "' ( <  $& @ (  %&" ,  "" (  " ( "A " <$%- $ J" ( '%"!  ""(

/0122/1334

5 4/6 5

"" '%'" ($J" .<& % $D "  ;"8!  '%"'"

'&" ($J" "&! $  %(  (" ( $& %(" 4 ;7

I7 $&  D%<& . 8(  > " $J" (  (G5. , 2* >   ( = >7

!    %&"&!  $)  %  ( %(  (" , $('"& ( $& <  ( ,  "" (  " ( "A  ; ."  (G5.!  <$ -? ?&&  8" %. ( %""&7

 )    ( . < "! $&  $" % %&"& , $"" , $> .!  " ""8 .  'J' ;! "  ''&("'" &(?&  '" ($D! D%<"  8 <$ ." 8" "  >7  @ ( & "" , " &?( <  <" (G5.! " ."  88" &"& 8D& , 2* >7   ;"8 (-  ($ " '%"7

 " . %(" <  '%"'" $" % &%>@N % (& ( %  " &"& "8&7 D %&( " ( " %(" (."  @ ( &7  )   &<   % ($  %! ' ($ &(  (& , (D ;7

/0122/1334

5 6/6 5

 " +/  + "+   "  "

$

0.1   2  3   45 (,'  #6

  1 

27 &   .@7

$ 1

17 ('" %"'"   " &("  (& (  % , (D ;7

07 " <  %&( " ?""7

*7 8'  %" (  <K %." 8'  "  %&" J"

(  (& ( 03 ; (-  "8" % % ''(& (&  @ 8&(& ( ! B>OG>8< 6! 633*   !  " D'%7  (&  %" J" %?&7  '&' (" M : (< D"'" < (&  " (& @"   " % (  (& ""<&N @: D% % < '"8  "' %. ('( "" " (&N : %"  ?"   (  %&""7 B  '&'  "" %  " &&'" &'&&  "" : @: " : 5(!  @ 8&(& (   % % "  '"-    <K (. (& .@7  '&' (  '"   ') ( %.! < " ;"!  <  (& ""<& " K.%% ( <   &"& D%&(&  " 9"7 201! 236 " 23= :7

 ?88-  &(" M

5  P  Q   

 % 8' ( %&" J" " "8& D %" "  B&"" (K "" , K&' %  ?88 

/0122/1334