Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/106/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/106/2007 Généré par l'IA

Corporate Organization and Transactions Appeals Affirmance

Numéro de cause ATAS/106/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The reviewing body addressed multiple appeals challenging various trial court rulings, primarily concerning the interpretation and application of statutory provisions related to corporate organization and subsequent transactions over several years. The court meticulously examined the evidentiary record and applied established legal principles to each point of contention, ultimately affirming the majority of the lower court's judgments regarding the validity of agreements, corporate structure changes, and resultant liabilities, while making specific adjustments or reversals in a few instances where the trial court's findings were deemed clearly erroneous or contrary to the controlling statutes.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Corporate Organization and Transactions Appeals Affirmance: The court meticulously examined the evidentiary record and applied established legal principles to each point of contention, ultimately affirming the majority of the lower court's judgments regarding the validity of agreements, corporate structure changes, and resultant liabilities, while making specific adjustments or reversals in a few instances where the trial court's findings were deemed clearly erroneous or contrary to the controlling statutes.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
instances de recours interprétation de l'arrêt responsabilité des organes examen des griefs formels cognition du pourvoi en cassation qualité pour recourir

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Imposed the costs of the federal appeal proceedings on the appellant.
Généré par l'IA
A/814/2007
Complex Corporate Transaction Appellate Review
A/205/2007
Affirmation of Lower Court Judgments Across Multiple Appeals
A/396/2005
Appellate Review of Procedural Rulings, Contract Interpretation, and Evidentiary Rulings
A/577/2007
Affirmation of Lower Tribunal Judgments and Remand of Limited Issues
C/10123/2022
Company Dissolution Affirmation on Appeal

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Imposed the costs of the federal appeal proceedings on the appellant.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



               !""#$!%&&' !(&'!%&&#



) *) +  )  + *

,-. /  "( 01 %&&# 



 !"###$!%&'(   !")*+ *"*+ ,$+#""##-$+.+*  **

"#* !"###$!%&/(  0  ! ")*+,$+#""##-$+.+*  **

"+*

11         !*"+ #+#$ 234(!   

          

   0&5/0  

 2*

%9  ( * &''&!     $)"$    )*++#" ")$+#*)"*++! 9

&9  %8 ",:* &''&! -;;# +"  )*" <=$ >#0)*?   @  *$##"*;-"+*"#)*++#"")$+#*!"+#;A $+#+#")?+9

69 *"*" *#:++$#*%&B#&''6!**+$+$ #+#+$;,* !+*,# +*=$$*>#0 )*? @"$C+;;+9

(9 &(B#+&''6! $)"$)*++#""+)"* ")+ 9

49     -  !    #  "#A$  &8 ,*# &''(  *))"*+ -D)*+#*+#;C-+#+#":##":##*-#+$*$9-  *A#  6',*#&''("+*+#;C-$++++2E)"+2$#*+ #+$*3+9

/9  & B#+ &''(! -   F   #;"*$ -    $?  -#+$*$!*,6'B#&''(9

79 * "#*  6' )+:* &''(! -    $ C -2"#*#    ! "#+    + " ;*?*  ! #  #" ,#+ $+$ )+$! + #    )*++#" ")$+#* $)"$  &( B#+ &''6 )*    $+#+ #+9 -    "##+$ $=+")#$*+#"#"9

89 *A+*$##"&6#&''4!-  ++$**"#+;  C)*++#"")$+#*)"*)$*#"%*B#+&''6 6'B#&''(!"#+"++*$+*"+#;64-G'(;*9

G9  ( B#+ &''4! -    * A+* ", $##"  )*++#"! *+#;#+"++)*++#"")$+#*)"*3)$*#"!+ "*+*$+*"+#;)*++#"68-8'8;*9

%'9 7"H+&''4!** !=#+"+)"*")+ -2"#*#; !;"*$"))"#+#""+*$##"( B#+&''4##A"+*%8",:*&''&9

%%9 *$##"*"))"#+#"%4"H+&''/!"+#;#$)*"#**"$ "#-2"#*#!-  $*$#,:-"))"#+#"$)"$7"H+&''4



566785&''/  065/0   "+*  $##"  %8 ",:* &''&! + *B+$ -"))"#+#" $)"$  7 "H+ &''4"+*$##"(B#+&''49

%&9  %4)+:*&''/!+#*-2"#*# ;  *$  *#: +"  * "#! )* +$$")# C &%2(6!  *"*C-"+*$##"-  %4"H+&''/9

%69  %8 )+:* &''/!  =*;;  *#:  *I! " )# ;;*2# # " +#:*$)*"+!-"*#=#*"*DD)#*!$)"$)*-2"#*#9 -2"#*#"#+)*$:+C"*"*-;;+)#;)*$+*"* ++ A:"#!C)*"$*C-#+#"+$"#+!*;"!C*+ ++*C$+$##"*"))"#+#")*#)*-  !+C*)**   )*++#" *  :   ,* ++   )*+  ")*")*#$+$  ;  :##":##*##!"#+&-4/G;*9

%(9 6"+":*&''/!-  ##A$A"++*$+*"+#;$+#+*+! -+++  -)++#" "   *$)#+#"   #"    )*2$*#+#*$=D!C,"#*,+#?!A,#+ ;#+",)*""=+#"$#*$)#+#"6%$:* &''/9

%49   "#"  %7 "+":* &''/! -    ;#+ ,"#* A  $#  *"* $+#+ #,$ C $2$  %4 )+:* &''/! + A-C $;+  "#* )"+$%4)+:*)+*!*"*$+#+#,:9-  )*"#+  D+*#+  J *K  *J   "+! D +* A  $##"  $+$ #+*#:$D*"*++%/"H+&''/9*;"!-  " *B+*"*9

%/9   *A3+  *#:  $! -   #  "#A$  +  &",:* &''/ -++++#"  *$)+#"   $##" $+:# )*  "+! ";#*+ A -,"# *"$  $+$ #+*#:$  %/ "H+ &''/ C "#*  ! %'9;##+*#:+#"")"*++#=+* +#+#*+B"#+C+,"#9

%79 "+"+$+$"#A$D*"*++%6",:*&''/! +$#6'",:**$+$"*$)"*$+*#*9 *! $#")$+#*8B,#*&''7$+$"*$9

%89  && $:* &''/!  L ! *)*$+$ )*  ":*+ 1 L !*A#")))*"$* 566785&''/"))"+    + "#* 2##))   C -  9   ;#+ ,"#*A#"; #,#+"+++"+ %'6-%(6;*9('!*)*$++;+*-2$:*=++"#)*"#=$ C$;+)**$#F C*!"+#+#*+#"9



566785&''/  0(5/0   %G9  *"*+ -"+ ) $)"$  "#"   $# A# * ,#+ $+$ #)*+#9

&'9  %8 B,#* &''7!  *#:  $  "#A$ D )*+# ")#   *A3+-))$)"$)*L 9*!$+$ =*$CB=*9

 +*

%9 "#=,"#*M"*=#+#"B###*>@$+$"#;#$+#+#+$!? %*"H+&''6! *#:+"*"#!")"$4B=! "+)*$#++,#0)*$#+!4))$++%/B=*>*+9%+9 *+4/ @9

#+CM+#"M$+#"%/B=*!)* *#:;$$* &7B,#*&''(> 1%6'%'/@!* "#=,"#")+$!%6;$,*#*!  #)"#+#"+*#+"#**=+)*+++ *#:+"* "#  #$=*  * C +*"# B= +#+#*! !  M+++  M$+#"",DB=*9

&9 ";"*$+ C -*+9 4/ 9 % +9  29 6 ! *#: +"  *"#".+#+#A"+++#")*$,CM*+94/ "#;$$**)*+#=$$**"#+*"#/"+":* &'''> @A#"+*+#,C"#;$$**)*++#"")$+#* CM*0,##!*,#,++#,##+$%G*%G/4> @9".+ $=+"+++#")*$,C-*+9(6"#+"*)*++#" +" ")$+#* C -*0,## + *,#,+ + C -*0 #,##+$!&4"+":*%G/8> N;9*+94/9&+9@9

")$+)"*B=*M)?+##$+:#9

69  ++*$,#=*%*B,#*&''6N#)"#+#"-))#A+D )*++#",*$)*+",*+2)#+*%!C"#A -E $*"=D)*$+>;9*+9%9% @9 +?"*))#: -)?!-=#+)*++#"")$+#*;$$*"##+$?%* B,#*&''69

 $##"*"))"#+#"+"+*A,"#-"))"#+#"-+ ) ",*+ "+ B++ C *"*!   $#  +*+ B"* #,+  "+#;#+#"$##"B++C*"*>;9*+94/+/' N*+9G"# *  )*++#" ;$$* ")$+#* C -* ,## + *,#,+ +C-*0#,##+$%("+":*%G/40 1+(6 @9



566785&''/  045/0    " *$*,  -*+9 % 9 6   "# ;$$*  &' $:* %%G/8 *  )*"$* ##+*+#, > @!  )*"$* ,+  +*#: +"  *+*$=$)**"#++">;9*+9/% @9

 ";"*$+ C -*+9 8G 9 %   "# *  )*"$* ##+*+#,  %& )+:*%G84> @!"*"*+*$&D)#* *#: +"  * "# "#+ )*  ++*! "#+ )*  $"#* #=$! ")"*++! "+*  " + )*$"  )*+#!  D)"$ #+  ;#+""+#;#,"A$!##A"#"9

 -)?!$##"#+#=#$+$"+#;#$+#**"*+)*)# *"$  %4 "H+ &''/ + #+*#:$  +#+#*  %/ "H+ &''/! " -++++#"*$)+#"+;##+*#:+#""+9$#6'B"* "$C"*#*%7"H+&''/+$2$#+,*#%4)+:*&''/9

 -+*"*$+$*$ *#:$!)*+$$")#!%4)+:* &''/! C &% 2 (69 -"*#=#  *"*  $+$ *I  =*;;  # %8 )+:* &''/!")#;;*2##"+#:*$)*"+9

 *#:  $ *)) A  $)O+ - *"*  )+ 3+* ;;+$ ,:+"E-+$$")#*9 ;;+!)"**#"$*#+$!#E #-D#=*A-+*"*"#+##=+*"*#=#"+*N -+*A#=+*;#=*A-)2"+"")#-+),:> 1%%&  %76 "#9 % +  B*#)* #+$N  ! "+#*   "# ;$$* -"*=#+#" B###*! * %GG'! ,"9 ! 9 %969%  *+9 6'N PQR5LS ! *T+=,*;2*  *T+=*2+);=  ! R*#2%GG6!9&/&!)9%4G@9*!)*$#$+!$"#**"*,"E$)* +$$")#*")"*+!)*$;##+#"!A-")##=+*"+*! A#+"+*#*DD#=$=>;9 1%&%&4&!"#9(@9

* "$A+! # E  #  "++* A  *"* $)"$ )* +$$")#  *#*B"*$#+#,:9

(9  ,   A# )*$?!  *A3+ -))   $)"$ )*  L !*"U+*,:!+":B+9





566785&''/  0/5/0  

  4+*2  *) +  )  + *

 

567-- 8  9   :; ('% + <

%9 $**"*#,:)"*+*#,+$9

&9 $*":B+*A3+-))$)"$)*L 9

69 #+A)*"$*+=*+#+9

(9 ;"*  )*+#   AM ),+ ;"** *"* "+*  )*$+ 3+   $#  6' B"* ?  "+#;#+#" )*?  *#: ;$$* >2T#V*2";A#/!/''(  @!)*,"#*"*+#?**"#+ ):#!";"*$+D*+98&"#;$$** *#:;$$*%7 B# &''4 > 1@N  $"#*  *"* "#+ ##A*  "#"! "+#; + "E)*,+)"*+*#=+**"*+""+#*N#"#+ 3+* *$  *#: ;$$* )* ,"# )"+ " )* ,"# $+*"#A D "#+#"  -*+9 (&  19  )*$+ 3+ +  )#?  )"#"  *"*+!#,"A$""E)*,!"#,+3+*B"#+C-,"#9  =*;;#?*  )*$#+         E,# L F #  

")#";"*)*$+3++"+#;#$D)*+###AMCM;;#;$$*  * "# + "#A$ C  # L ! )9  ":*+1 L )*=*;;



566785&''/