Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
ATAS/1054/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/1054/2006 Généré par l'IA

Royalty Distribution Contract Interpretation Dispute

Numéro de cause ATAS/1054/2006
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A dispute arose concerning the distribution of royalties under an agreement where specified conditions triggered fixed payment percentages to the plaintiff, but the defendant allegedly underpaid based on a reinterpretation of the operative clause. The court reasoned that the language of the royalty distribution agreement was unambiguous, clearly establishing the conditions for the percentage payments, and found that the defendant's attempt to apply a condition not explicitly included in the contract, essentially rewriting the agreement through extrinsic evidence, was improper. Therefore, the court affirmed the judgment in favor of the plaintiff, requiring adherence to the plain meaning of the contract terms regarding the royalty calculation.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Royalty Distribution Contract Interpretation Dispute: The court reasoned that the language of the royalty distribution agreement was unambiguous, clearly establishing the conditions for the percentage payments, and found that the defendant's attempt to apply a condition not explicitly included in the contract, essentially rewriting the agreement through extrinsic evidence, was improper. Therefore, the court affirmed the judgment in favor of the plaintiff, requiring adherence to the plain meaning of the contract terms regarding the royalty calculation.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
interprétation du contrat notion de décision règlement du litige contrat de durée déterminée droit de suite moyen de paiement

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Généré par l'IA

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF

Cited in order 2 to declare the appeal inadmissible based on simplified procedure.

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in order 3 to allocate court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



               #$$%&#&''(  #)'(*#&''+

 

, -,    ,  

./0  $ " &$ 1/0  &''+ 



 !!!!!!!!!!"#$%" & ' (

(

))     * ++    "# ($% ,-."/(012"   

                 !"

   613726  

 2

78  !!!!!!!!!!"%7-92"#((% ,:;"<%%=#* =$( #*:(" (;( #/  74 $ 1555 $$ $>;  <?($(8(#$/(#;#@*1555"%%;# )84.*1.A868  %(( ;(" /  @ #*#( /= (  /="/ ++    +++ B ++    + B   +C+DEFD=;D:((G6/H+ I8

18  1. ;$< 1557"   %(% ;($ #* #( /= J  K  /@#*$$#(6@(L:$$M(%:D#?(# ="@%ED/D(#(=N:D8 *,/#(/#D(8/((*(#%($$O/L868O#( @@ ((8   ,% # /;  (; $ ( (% /H @@D/:(#;(:(#*//(#%/D%8P $Q$"(%($%## DQ6:NH;8*; *#%$(%8

48 +%((,(%;%;R((/%P(#,$/($(: #"*%(% !!!!!!!!!!"/%()&$%# ( ( $# D$($8  #" #  //( %(<  7 $ 1551" * #%( $$ /(D@ ( /,6/(=8  $%#   N  ,#$ :@ (;$( :<8   /%  /( O$<$O ( //% #*:  /  D: N  @ $# # %#/(( C I#+ N+8

08 *%  # %(% #% N   /  /  D: /#/ #  (R( #* ,$/($(: # %(#8  (( :@ #*#$ %(( $" D$ # (< /%=@ #  <(% /= C<# R( #   :D" <# ( # $( :D" # # /# :D" %: #(S# #(I8 *R$ ;  $(%  $(( =( (;  @  ((: /= %(( / (<(=   # (6/8  //(  %(% #%( $$ #==%$( # (# @ *  (( / # =D D,/( #  $( /6;  /8 *R$ #6$<  $  %;#  %:H $(( =(8 *%;( # *%/ :D %(( $D$%:H$((#*<#((;8

#(  D/(("  /((  ;  /:$$ /D,(D%/(@ @(#8  $< ## ( %(% (%"   /( (  ((#((:<%(*<;(#*((;(%8 /:H ((<P(=@<P(=*%(%(%8



344.131552  643726   *%;(/%;#(/=*/;#D #  /$H % 6 T   (( < @ $ /(/% N # (;R # ((,:6"/((*((P#%%/<#*==(@@( #$(/#8

#%P"/((*(((;!!!!!!!!!!"/,D(8 //D/,D(D%/(@%(%((%"$%(%<#%/H#R %  O /( #*(% * / Q( (;% / $$  (; @@DF/((@;%#(#$H((/D@O( @ %(( =$% #  #8   # $ /,D(@"  $%#(;%@@%%$(#%/==$#*#%#( #*== $  R%(%  %%$( /,D(@ =#8  ( /%  #:(#(<#%/=$P##:%$,8$%#(#@% @  (%%#( =$R ( / %(( /(M( (" @*  (;(#/(D$(%N*%$:((N(( @;(/Q(#==$(:%@*%;%$(($(@;(%(% ;% # =K /(H #   @  P( *;( (%:% # =K ((/D@8(;%(#N*%;($(#/#(;$ / #*( %%$( /$((( # /  #:( #*%(( # ( /(6 ($(@8

+   !!!!!!!!!!"  #:( #*%(( #%/= $P # #:% $, *:# / #*/(% # (;  8  $%# *( #H  (;%  P(=( N  /( # */(% # (;8 *(   / @  ( /%%  / # (; N 25U #  $%( #B;  <?($( N $/( # 75 P 1551  /%( @ (( /(% /( Q( /#$(:$(%N755U8%$";#$/($(#R# /(("$%#(/%/(R(Q$$($<8

#%=(;"(%(%/%#:(;(J,$/($(:/(%=$ ; ;6#6$<: D@ #( # *%/ (  $$< /%:D"%/D%D@";(:"%((#%/=$P8

28  7 P( 1551"  8 !!!!!!!!!!"  (((% #  /( # ,#$ #R8

98 //(%(<79V(1551/$%##*#$(#+ " 8 !!!!!!!!!!"/%()& D:(D/%#@" ( @* <((:@*%(%(;%N,$/($(:/(%=$#*%8 /((/:(#*,$/($(:##==(#%: /( P@*N  %: %G  "  # %(( (G  *, ;(   %( R $%#$(G  $$ %(( $/<8   !!!!!!!!!!  =( $@ @" $:%  =( @* ( #  "  /(%#(;;(%(%=R%N25U"*%*;(P$/(;(%"



344.131552  603726   /(*%((/#*#;8!!!!!!!!!! @*;#/((/#*:D(#($#<" :% %(( <(G  ; ;"  % *;( %(% #(=%G R/(:@*;(%(%(;%/R/@,$/($(: # #== (  R(G  //D (D%/(@ *;( %(% ==8   #("  $%#   @  (( @ # *%  /;( / Q( #%% $$ %((  //( # (% (;*#(#1.;$<15578

.8  #% # 1A V( 1551"  +   $ = N  /  D: #  $%#R(;$(##$(%PH;==(47V(15518 + %=%( N *; #  $%# #*#$("   #%% @  (< #   ; ( $<" # *%/ ( # < :D *::(//<(%#$T*%((/( #(%;*#(8

A8  74 ;$< 1551" *%  #%/%  #$# # /(( /H # *==(#*6;#(%C6/H I8

-8  8 !!!!!!!!!!" # ( $%# # DQ6:"  #%  //( N *   #( # . $ 15548   /%  #:( # ;6#6 $<: D@" # ,#$ $(=$ #R /(( ( #*%(( R6#%/=$,8=R%*//(#((($#;$< 1557"@=%*%((#/((#(((N/(%((# (; # *(;(% # $>; # <?($(8   %:$( ($% @*  /;(R:#*%@*R((;(%8

758 12=%;1550"8 !!!!!!!!!!"#;$%#%: C6/H +I  /%%  $  / #* R/( /,D(@8  8!!!!!!!!!!" /%( )&  /,D( ( /,D(D%/"  %(% $#(%N((=8

778   )!!!!!!!!!!  #  //(  11 /($< 1550"   < #* (( @*   ; *%  /% #* (/H(" # (( /,D$%(@(###*%8

*R/(  #@% @ *% (( =%   /( # @" #*/H " (    #  /(% # (;8   /( # #$<";;($(#<:"@*(/%;% #/ (  ( *$/QD( # ;  /(  # $H /:%#/(#<P(#/#@NRL8

 $%#  #@% @ *R$ @ (  (( &$( #( N  N  ,$/($(: #%/; ((  / %:H  @  (( L ( N  #%/ (H %;H8  $%#  R/@% @ @*



344.131552  623726   R((##(#R(("(#N#%$((# N  $P( ( N  #$(( # /<H$8  /( # ; /,D/(D:@"*R/(($%@*%/%((@@:(% #  :% #%/;" ==( / ( #  # #* %(( #%/= $P # :;(% $,  %;H8  ==(" # *<;( @ ( # *, # =($( R(/= # *%"  ( ( @* *, ;(/;%(<$(#*/:$($"#*<"#<#$(;((@ *%/;(==(#(;(%#(:##==(%8

+*R/("*R$@*=(%N/((@#/((((# (H /; ( @ (# N ; $P  #==(%8 + " (( $/ ((( /$( #*R/@ *%;( ## #*//%( ( 6 $Q$($%#(((J#"/#%=("=(/((#%(% #  /(( @  (  Q( ((%8 *R/(  %:$( %;@%  /<(% @*N  = # *% 1551   #%<( # *% 1554" *% ( ==(;$( /%(%  ,$/($(: #%/; # :;(% $, %( ;(  #:( (  (< # *#/(( ; D$ R6#%/;%((#%/=#:;(%$P/$%/#8 ==(" N((/%#"*%%(%=(%N#;@*$#(( #$((; (H $/R /@  / # %(:   :=%  R/#((%;##%#* 8( #D"//(#*(($((6#%/6($/$1550 6(/$<%;(#,$/(M$#%/=8

$$(#*R/("*%/:(##R;R$<( ;" (,/@" $ ,(%$(<"  %/#( @ / R (:@ 8 /#("$/((###$=((*$/(# /("#D#/=(%:%(*<;(/#(/D  <(  @ *, # =($( R(/=" *R/(  (  $P( # /(" #(   ($% @*  ;( / #* /(D:/,D(@$($(#$(=((:$(#D$/ $%#8  ( %:#"  $%#  =( $@ @  *% #%(  $R"($$%#($(;,%#(("#(@/( $(@%((#(;(8

+ *R/("  *#@ @ *% /%(  (< :=(= #  /(% /%$<#    (P < =(% (( # /( # ; /"  @ /=8 +*  ;$<<$( /%(%  %(( #%/=#:;(%$,//(;#=(#($(/"6   %;% =;<$(  / (# #/ $ 1554 /   ( # D($(#*(($((6#%/8



344.131552  693726   /(#;/,D(@"*R/($$#%#*%;($(/(# ;(:($%#((($(//%""/<%$(@ (;#$((;6%$@8

(R=/(%#(;#*%"*R/(P:%@*/ /D,@"<P(;$("*%/(/$(%(@*R//,D@( $("==(@#*%:H,$/($(:#%/;"# (<=($(@(#8*R/(($%P(=%#=# *//%( /#/ #  /(% # (; %% /  " @   N  /((#  (; # 25U #H  75 P( 1551" / /#$( N 755U8 + " */(% # (; *( # #% @ # 1A;$<155747V(15518

718 #%#12;$<1550"* #%%@*%;(;%  /(% (( # (; #H  47 V( 1551 (  P(%  #$# # /((8

748   # 4 P; 1552" *%  =$% //( N (( #%  %:(==#/#(##@(#((((;(% /=8   /  ((% ; (;%  /(% # (; (( #H  47 V( 1551 ( *( %=%% N *; #  $%#"   !!!!!!!!!!8

708   <=  #%  72 P; 1552   !!!!!!!!!!"  8!!!!!!!!!!" /%( )&  /,D( ( /,D(D%/"  #@% ; K *% /  @ (( ( ; #:(@%  (< $(=$ #R"  %(( #%/= $, (  /(% =(8  $%#  P(% @  %%$(" $<% ;  ; #*(( ( # =$( =< (  :; #%(  ( ( # N #  ==(  =K #( $/< *<(% N  (D%/8

728   # 1A =%; 1552" *%  $/%(%  //(  /#(  (((( %#:%  1 =%; 1552 /   !!!!!!!!!!8  # ,  =$% @  /(( /%((  / $#= *%(#(  / %"  %(( /,D@ (% ;  ((  $/(( ( @  #==%( (($( (/ *%(( #% /  %D8   P(% @  $ (D%/(@ *%(( /  %/% ( %((  /  D: :< /  % /%%8   %$ */ @ *R/( /,D(@ #  )!!!!!!!!!! <(  :; #%(  ( ( #  /((" ::;% %(;$( N *#( ( #%($( # *%;( # 8 + " *R/( ( #$(   /<%$(@#$((;%$@@"<@%"PN; @* M #8 #%( *%(( # (% /%/( # /((" 



344.131552  6.3726    ( /% #  /, #*:"  ;" (  # $%#%(,%%<%NH;"$%#%$*;@*%((/(H$( ///%#/;;(:(((($(+8

798 <=#(%#79P1552"8&!!!!!!!!!!"##%/($( # /,D( # &"  #@% @* /  D: /,D(@ ;( #%<(%0=%;1552"@*%((@#*%%(((%((;"  /$ /"  ,#$ #R $(=$ /(( ("  # /"%((#%/=$,@"$:%(($(#/(%"((%%(( DF  /(( O(H / $<< @( N  O8  $/  ;$%#%(%@=%/($"/((%(((P%:N#F6 ;8  ; #  $/ $%#$("  $%#  (%  / %:H # (($( 6 %;%% /  (R : # $%#$( (% ($(##$6"$:%#R/(#/(%8

7.8 //($%##%9P(1552N* "&!!!!!!!!!! =$%  #:( # (< #%/= %( $, ; ,$/(M$ $(@ ( # ,#$ #R $(=$ /(( $/@(  (H /(% # (; #/ 15518  $%#  #( ; ((%  (D,$ #%/;" # */(D" # *<" # *D%#" # (< # *((( ( #  (("  R%(% ( # /( # $/((8%$/(%;%8+"*/(%#(;(# @$( N   # ==( /D,@  $( (  N #  6%$@P(8

7A8  !!!!!!!!!!"#+"#;75V(15528 /HR$# #!!!!!!!!!!" !!!!!!!!!!(&!!!!!!!!!!"$( /(8

7-8 #%//(#10V(1552"* =$%#%#= # /(( # 12 ;$< 15508   ;% @   !!!!!!!!!! =( %=%N#=(#*(("#*("((#:@ H;(/#*6;#(%8/P:%@//(*%(( / /<( (  (#( #* / *R/( /,D(@ # !!!!!!!!!!8 +*:( #  #  !!!!!!!!!!" *   =( $@@**%((((%@#*//%(D(@($(@" ; # %$% # ; # /(( ( @* *//((  %%$( /<( (#( # $H ;( *R/( #  !!!!!!!!!!8 =" (   #  &!!!!!!!!!!" *   ( @  $/ $%#$(%((==((@*%=(#/((@%(( R:<#/(/%##$$:8

158 #19/($<1552"*%(P(%(((#%8 <("=(;@(H/%/P/#/#$((



344.131552  6A3726   @*(;(%/=*(/R:<#/((%8==$ @* ( # < ;(% $ @  %(( #%/="  # (  /(%=(/$(((/#*#/(=$(R(8 (@%(%%#:%(:%/ !!!!!!!!!!8

178 (:%/(<#%" !!!!!!!!!!#@%"/ #77(<1552"@*/%#(=$(P#@(RK((;(% /= #  <( #   $(H P#@" #$((; ( =8

118 ;(% N  /" * " #  %/ # 12 (< 1552"    P(#8

148   # 1. (< 1552"  (< # %  #@% N  !!!!!!!!!!@*//(N@*(N/%(*%#  $ T 6 ;( %(<  /(  < ( # =$8   /#(((%(((=(@*/(/Q(#%%$$ $#(/=$(@=%$(H#*8

108   # 1- ;$< 1552"  !!!!!!!!!!  #@% @" @ @*(";(%#*/8

  

78 :;B:(P#CI%(%$#=%(((%"#H 7V(1554" <(#"$/%#2P:" #(  /%#( (  ;6/%#(" 2 //%( ( 79 P:  C(8 7 (8(29 I8

+(NB(#B%(#79P:"/ <=%#% 1.P;1550C )745759I"# :;#/(%"74=%;"  #/(((:(/$((( <(#  # %:   N ( P: ((" " # B((( # B%(#;RP:8

18 =$%$( N *(8 29  8 7 (8  D8 1 "  < ( #   W(  ( @ # ((( /%; N B(8 29#   =%#%   /( :%% # #( #   # 9(<1555C I(;NB6;#(%#7-P7-2- C I8+$/%(/P:##B/H(%(<8

48    ( (%  ;:  7 P; 1554 (W(  $#=( # $< #/( %: #  #$ #  8 + 



344.131552  6-3726   /$(%"/(#;@#(*//@#(Q((D%N$H #//@H://<(;:$$(T =(P#@$(#%($((/#(C )745145#8787" 442#8781"71-0#8781"71.09.#87"719749#80<( %=%I8

 /%(    #( N # /(( #H  $ # ;$< 15518((#%@=(#%($((%%/(;((/H B(%;:# "#(N(#(Q(R$%:## * #( /  /%# P@* 47 #%$< 1551 (  =( #  ;%:$((%:/H((#(C )745002(%=%G =8  ) 745  41-I8 (="  $#=( %: ( #    ((("  H: :%%"  ; =$% #  " #  P/# (; R ( /#( ;( *(%  ;: #   G  * #%  $#=( # /( # ; #  (" # ( @  P/# #%;//% N  // /( Q( / ( //@% C )745402#84I8 (RH:#/%#"*//@("= #/(((("N(#H*(%;:#  C )747470#8484"77.-4#89<"771495#80G   7--A 4./8479#84<I8

$Q$"#/(#;#17$1554$#=(  C0H$%;I"(%;:7P;1550C15544A21I"( / //< C ) 71.  09. #8 7I8   $ T  ( %(% $#=%/;"#/(6/H(#(%#; (%7P;15508

="=%#%#79#%$<1552$#=(=%#%*6 ;#(% ( (%  ;:  7 P( 1559 C1559 1554I" //(( # $#=(@(($$(/%##(#;( < ( #  C(821" 2A ( 97 (8   I8 (="  /%(  *(/$;#("#$$(@##(#$((=  %(% =$% ;(  7 P( 1559 CD8 (8 # #/( (( (;N$#=(#79#%$<1552I8

08 (P(% #  =$ ( #% /%; /  "   ( ;< C=8(829( I8

28  (: /(   @( # ;   ((( N  (% #( ==  ( ( ;#( ( ;("   %D%(" #( N # /(( # *6;#(%8

98 I ( %/(% ;#(%" */(% # : ((  /( /%$% /$(#:#%"%((#*=$(%:%("#*$# #*#(C(8A87 (087 I8 (%/(%/(%#:



344.131552  6753726   (( #$( #*$<  #* /( # /<(% # : # *%   $D% # (; %@<% @ (  #%("  (( #$( %( #* ((( N  (% /D,@  $( ( @* /( /H  (($(($#%#/((R:<C(8. I8%; (R#*;#(%";@*%(/<(**%((/;#( $/% ;  @* /( <(  RK( *(;(% @ /( <$( Q( R:% #  /H  (($( (  $ # %#/(("$D%#(;%@<%C(879 ((81A81 I8

<I ;(#B(81A87 C#;(%7P;1550I" B%#(N((HB(;#N99134U$"N#$6 (B(;#N25U$"N@(#(B(;#N05U  $G #   /%<" B% /(" #B/H B(8 1A 8 7<  " /%(#N#$6(B(;#N05U$8H7P;1550" B%#(N((HB(;#N.5U$"N(6@( #(*(;#N95U$"N#$6(B(;#N25U $"N@(#(B(;#N05U$8

I *<:( / *% # #$  #$$: (  // :%% # #(#C )71-094 #8081"714144#84" 77.1.A#81<"055(%=%(%I8P:/(/=# $/$(   (; @ *%  =  *($ 6$Q$ /< # =#/#%<(#/(%#(;"/%;(@( (((%#*=N/=("#:%#;#(%C )759A9#8 1/8A.I8

#I,#/%@P/#"(#B;#(%" ##(#"((%$@($%#G (%@%$@<P(;#B/(%=(@B $/(#B%;C )7751.2#80G75215.#81I8

.8  $(H # (< $(=$ #R" ((( N  (% #(  $=(( @ 6 /( # #== 6  *R/@( / /  /(D:H  ( =<"  ( #== # $  $(( #  /(% # (;"  *  /( / #%# *R( #* /(% # (;#$/#:(/%"#H@6:/ *((% # # ( /  / %"    %;(    /( @* /( / #   (8  ;(6 %:$("  /% #* (< $(=$ #R" # /  /%$/(@((==(==(/;(Q($(%/==( #;(%<$(R:<C )74725I8

 )   ((=  @* R( # =( #%($% @" /  ((% (  (" #(  / /< # = ( ==( #



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

#<$Q$#:(#(<$(=$#R(#*<# =( #* $%# D$(:"  ;( #*R:   #* $%# /%(/,D(@**:(#/*/(%#(; @ (( ((( ( /(< #*(W" #H  @  =( /,D$(@ ("  */ #$("  = #%;   #%;//$(#(((((N(%8R/((#/((N =$/(#/(D$(:@(/,D@//W(#$ #*((#%@(/%(<#$H<P(;*%/%(%(( #R #* :;(% ( 6  %:# %:$( R (H #%($( /%(%6@$;#/(%#(;$D%#(; /( / # ((  $( /($( Q( R:< #  /( C;  & + " X :(D(: $(=$ +(Y:  J R -031552" /8155.8I8$(%;%T$%#D$(:(#*$<% $#(("/#<;($%#("@(H



344.131552  6713726   #%($(  ( / $/"  # $ / #* $H ==$$( ("/N/(%#(;C ) /%(%449350"#8 084I8

A8 *%;(#*/(%#(;//*((#=(#*#$%#8  *6;#(%" *(( # =( #*# $%#  =#   //(#$%#(((#(%N*==#*6;#(%"R/( #$%##%/#(#*(((#*"R$/(@%/ ( #*<;( $%# # *6;#(% C ) 714  7.2I"  R/(/#(//(@R/($%##%/ P:#/$H##H(C+7--."/847A#84<I8# *%;( # *;#(%"  (?D # $%# ( N /(  P:$(  *%((#(%(N#@#@$(/@(;(%*%( /<#(;8 ("#%$%#(((%%$(( /#%($@(;R/(" <$("R:#*% C )712197#80(%=%I8

@;/<(#*//($%#"@(#%($( *( @  /( (:R ( =( *<P( #* %(# (%" @  //(=##R$$/("@*/%:$(#%(  /( R/$% /  / R$%" @* ( %(% %(<  / #*$H"@#/(#(R($%#(*//%( #(($%#((=@#*R/(( #V$( $(;%8  #$(" *%%$( #%($( /  ; /<( *(*:#$,#/;#%:($$//($$ R/(" $ < ( <  ( C ) 712  421 #8 4" 711  795 #87(%=%I8

+*:( #  ; /<( # //( %(< /  $%# ((("  P:/((#(($/(#=(@"*R/%"$%#(((( :%%$("##("N/#/(//((# (#=@*(N#C )712424#84<3<<(I8

 //"  P:  *%( /  $(= $/%(= #  #* R/( $%#"  =( P#"  (?D # *R/( %(( /%%$( # $((   /% N  #/( #  P(  # B#$((=#*%/($%#R#*%((#=(#%8 +P/#"/(((#*%(#*R/(=( @ 6 ( # (#("  @* R/( #% /  (<  =$   # $H ;(8  (" @ #*(/%(%$(((#/(/(N$((%$( #(/(##%#(#*R/("/(R"" (/%(( #;:( #  #  # /  P: "  <"



344.131552  6743726    (( $/%$(   =$ #* ; R/( $%# C )712421#84<3(%=%I8

+//#<//%(#/;"@B//@< /%# #$((; @B /%# #  # #( #$((=" B#$((   P: //% <$(  /;"  Q( % / # H: =$"  /%#( N  //%( $/H( ( : # /;8 H"P:#(R$#$H<P(;($,# /;"@@B(/;"/#%##$(N#/( /$(((#/(P:$(;<#((:R8@//( $%#R ( (#("  P:  /( (D *==  #@   / @   =#   / $%# (  /   (8

-8 (((;/<(#//(#*R/(#)!!!!!!!!!! (%=HN*;#$%#6(((" !!!!!!!!!!8 */H"/ //%  #:% #*;#(% # (" *  *( ==(;$( =#% ($(   //( #  )!!!!!!!!!! #(  ($ @*  / ; /<( ( @* *,  #H  /  #* $((    " #*(( / @*  ( / =$% /  ( /H $%###8 %@",#*R$*($%%((=#%"   ; # #% $%# %  #" N #$((  /(% # (;%##755U#H47V(1551"((#(;(%D<(@ #(;(%#/(%8

758  @( # ;  *R/( #  )!!!!!!!!!! $/(  R: /%/P/#/W(/;/<((#(" $/((#(6(($(#%/;#(H$%#6@# $%#@(8 ((@(/(/#((;(*8 ==("(H;#(#(<$(=$/%(%#(@@* ( Q( %  ; # <;( <P(; # #==%( $%# ( # (H#%::%/P/## ) 8

/$"=(*R(#*$<#(%/,D(@#*(% (#*#%$/((#P/#"/@*R/(%== @ #* %:H ,$/($(: #%/;8 +  /(" *(((( #  !!!!!!!!!!"$%#(((/%("*(/#(N$(( $(;%#$/,D(@# 8

+/#H@(#/%%;(#*((H#($ /$(#*//%(H;#(#(<$(=$#R8

 *R$ # *R/( ( # //( #  "  /( ( / %(< *R(#*==(/D@8 ;D"$/((#P ?: # (" ($$(" = ( # (( @* * / %/% 



344.131552  6703726   #/((;(@*<(/#/(#*(%:(#((  $=(( #  ;" @ @* #   !!!!!!!!!!8  ( %:#"  )!!!!!!!!!!#*:%@%:H,$/($(:#%/;# *%*;(#(<=($(@(#8 (#;(:N*R(#*%((/,D@(%"N*%D # (($( $<(  (( =$ R H: # *(  %;( /<  / (D%/(@" /@  $%# ((( #@ /%%$(@(($(D%/(@(/%/%8

( R #%( # $%# ((( (   ( # /, #*: # (" = ( # (( @* ( #%% # /($(H#*6;#(%8

 ; # *$< #  %%$(" (  #%/( # (H D@ # # # *%"  #(  6 #* /( # ; P#@ 6  (H ;#( # (< $(=$ #R #(  ( (((8 (("   (/%(#N#/((#*6;#(%8

$=#%/%@(P(%8



344.131552  6723726  

   2  -,    ,  

"

345 // 6  7     8 9 )+& !:

  5 /

78 %;<8

" 5

18 P((8

48 (@/%#(:((8

08 =$  /( #  @B /;( =$  (  /%( Q( #  #% # 45 P #H  (=( / / $$#% #%  < =%#% # " +DEFD=@ 9" 9550   "  ( R$/8  #%  /( Q( /:%8  $%$ #(J I #@ R($(@#%(#%<((/##% ((@%G <I R/ / @ $(=  ($ /; #$# (( ( #%G I /(  :(   #  /%((8 +  $%$  (( /  ( %%$( %$%%  (( I <I ( I 6#"  <=%#%#//($(H@B #;#%;<8$%$#$($, # /;" @ ( P("  @  #% ((@% ( B;// # @%(%R/%#%(C(8741"759(75AI8  :==H  /%#(         )) + 

/=$#/%(Q(((=%R/(@BNB===%#% #/:==





344.131552