Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/1051/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1051/2007 Généré par l'IA

Construction Contract Breach and Damages Award

Numéro de cause ATAS/1051/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A party sought to recover damages for alleged breaches of contract arising from construction work that the other party asserted was defective or incomplete, leading to a dispute over the scope and quality of the contracted services and materials used. The court determined that the evidence supported a finding that the construction party failed to perform the work in a workmanlike manner and did not use the agreed-upon materials, thereby breaching the contract, and consequently affirmed the judgment awarding damages to the aggrieved party, while also addressing and rejecting certain claims regarding indemnity and set-offs raised by the construction party.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Construction Contract Breach and Damages Award: The court determined that the evidence supported a finding that the construction party failed to perform the work in a workmanlike manner and did not use the agreed-upon materials, thereby breaching the contract, and consequently affirmed the judgment awarding damages to the aggrieved party, while also addressing and rejecting certain claims regarding indemnity and set-offs raised by the construction party.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
contrat de construction dommages-intérêts contractuels vice de construction amende pour infraction aux règles de bâtir manquement au devoir prestations de construction

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Provision cited for the imposition of court costs on the appellant.
Généré par l'IA
A/330/2005
Construction Contract Breach and Damages
A/3546/2006
Contract Breach Damages for Construction Defects
A/677/2004
Construction Contract Dispute and Material Breach Determination
A/1926/2006
Construction Contract Breach and Damages Appeal
A/2026/2007
Construction Contract Enforceability and Damages Claim

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Provision cited for the imposition of court costs on the appellant.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



            !""!  "# ""!



$% &% ' $ %' '

'()*  +   ,-,*  ""! 



   !"#$%  &

 &   !"#$% 

'&

(() (  (  !6& * (     (+  ( *  (       ,-&( '.&/012-3

4  5.   - #$3

                

  #7%  

 .

"3 &9/'"&&#$$8%2:,& & ,;& 2& '  ;&!   -&    !   "<%% '  &!"<=8& !'"" "<<=3

#3 (: 66&<9/';&! '! & ,;& 2& '! '>;&' ?*;&'/';& ' !;&'' &'  & ' '' ;&!-@3

03 9/' -&'-!6  ' 6"A #$$8'!'! ?!  & ,'& "$9 #$$83

=3 B '&' !;& & ,!;& B!', &6 ' -'C

(B/ 'C

• & 6&! & ,!"#9 #$$A?*- '  ?' ' ! ;&2      ;&!-@  ;&  /'* '&' ;, ?'6'  &*  '&'  '2-D  E3

•  "" 9  #$$8     '''! ?  &   !' ' 66  ! ; "&9- &"<<1'?;&'' &' 0" #$$8!' ' %0*$=%6&38%3

(B/ '3C

•  "0 9  #$$8  &  6&!  & ,  ! ?*  - ' ' !;&24 '&':&. 3

•  % 9 ' #$$8  4 '&':&.   '''! ?  &   - '!'!66  !; "&9- &#$$#&; ;&2  F ' ?  ;&''    ,& ;/ ?  &   -&!' '"$*%886&30%3

• *>'& ';'  - &'''? . '&- ! ;'&!& /;& &'&!;&' '     '' ?* !;'  "<<= G #$$" ' ;&2  F2#$$"3

%3  #1 H' #$$8  & , '  &    6&!  & ?B ''  #"*#0= 6&3 #$ &- '  & ' &  ;&' ! ;&6&&&!-',&-' 3

    7#"#87#$$8 07%  

A3 &*';6 '*,&-' 3

83 (&? !'!/&!G9/&3

 $

"3 *&'3 #%     6!!& &   ,& ;/   ;&!-@ ;&6 -  &- -'' -  '!"8!,&"<<0D+E '&!- /&"&9- &#$$$&2/;&!& -&3&? 9 '';B&&;&'' &' G;&'/&D&'3"##' "#0  - . E9/  -&;!''*&'3803 " 6!!&&;&!-@;&6 #%9 "<1#DE 'G 2- & ,'& ; "&H'#$$0 ' ;&2?*66 & !'!'& D&'3"=# E>!'&*66 ;&'/& ,!&!;&' ' !'& !;&9/ -&.

#3 (*&'3## +D-'&- /&; "&9- &#$$$E  -&;&'' &' ? &'& /';&'/! 6&!'>&'3"##"#0"="'"=# I&'30G%+*;; ?' ;&/ ''G'&6!&&D3"E3&:?9 ';&''  &' G;&'/&&&;G 66!&'&;&'' &' /'!  - &   ,& ;/ > '' !-''  '   -& '  ;&''   &'  /'!  - &   ,& ;/ > '' !-''' & /D63&'3#=+E3& 9'G;&'' &' 'G*- & ,&;/> '' ' & / '!&J'' -&D + "#1#0$I +"#<===E3

03  B;2  9/  ;& 2& '  &!  ;&'/ ;&  ' !  - &;&!-@&3';&' ''B;&'  & /  ""   "<<= B'& ;&'  "A   #$$8 ' G ?  9/' -&'->!' &3

(  ' ;& '  ;&''  ?  ;'  & / ;& 3 '  "$*%88 6&3 0% D;&2   4 '&':&. E '  ?? ;&'%0*$=%6&38%D;&2  E  '!&J' @' !9G !'! ! ;&  ' ''   ;&!-@ !6&3      ' G  >.!;>  ''  #A*%## 6&3 <$ D%0*$=% 6&3 8%C #E '  .     '  ''  %*#11 6&3 8$ D"$*%88 6&3 0%C #E  &' ? B'    ?   ' G 3 ''#"*#0=6&3#$3

=3 6&!' G  9& ;& ;   9& !'& ' ;&  ;&'/ 9?* '  '&6&'   ;&''   &'     & 

    7#"#87#$$8 =7%  

9 '  -&! ,!!6   &  '' ;&''   & ' G  '!&J' ;' & &  ''  . 3  '!&J' ' !  '>    !/  *&'3 "#  *& &  ;&!-@ ;&6 

-   &- -' ' -  '!  "1 -&  "<1= D #E    '> &!/' &    .  ' ;!& & D +  ;, !  0A7$#  "1 9 ' #$$0E

%3 !'&;&K;&!&!''/&' 'D&'3803#' 1<53" &;&!&  '&' -"#;',&"<1%E3

    7#"#87#$$8 %7%  

 ' .  &% ' $ %' '



/-,0, )) 1  2,,  ,   3  + 4

"3 - '  ;&!-@;& /'* '&' ;, ?'  6'  &  *  '&'   '  2- G '&6!&&  ;'       #"*#0=6&3#$ G  4 '&':&.

6-&3  ? '!&J';' &  !&'2"A #$$89?*''&6&'3

#3 B@''?, 3

03  '?;&!&'/&' '3

=3 6&  ;&'    ?B ;-' 6&& && '&  ;&!' &&J'   !   0$ 9& 2  ' 6 '  ;&2  & , 6!!& D(:L M&:6? AA$$=  E;&- &&' 2&& ' ;, 6&!'>&'31# 6!!&& & ,6!!&"8 9  #$$% D +EI  ! &  &&  '  ?&    ' 6 ' @;&-';&'& /'&&&'' &I  ' J'& &!  & , 6!!& ;& -  ;'  ;& -  !'& ? >  '   *&'3 =#  +3  ;&!' &&J' '  ; 2  ;   &&' -?!@;&- -'J'&9 'G*- 3

 /&66 2&C  &! 'C   @(  !&     ; 6&;&!'&&J''' 6 !>;&'   ?BGB66 6!!& & ;&/&66

    7#"#87#$$8