Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/1022/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/1022/2005 Généré par l'IA

Settlement Agreement Voidability Due to Unilateral Mistake Regarding Claim Value

Numéro de cause ATAS/1022/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The dispute centered on a claim that a prior agreement to settle a matter was voidable due to an alleged unilateral mistake regarding the value of a contingent claim involved in the settlement. The court reasoned that to invalidate a contract based on unilateral mistake, the mistaken party must show that the mistake concerned a basic assumption on which the contract was made, the mistake materially affected the exchange, and either the other party knew or should have known of the mistake or its effect, or the other party was not entitled to the benefit of the bargain due to the mistake's nature; here, the party seeking to void the settlement failed to demonstrate that the opposing party knew or should have known of the unilateral mistake concerning the claim's value, precluding rescission.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Settlement Agreement Voidability Due to Unilateral Mistake Regarding Claim Value: The court reasoned that to invalidate a contract based on unilateral mistake, the mistaken party must show that the mistake concerned a basic assumption on which the contract was made, the mistake materially affected the exchange, and either the other party knew or should have known of the mistake or its effect, or the other party was not entitled to the benefit of the bargain due to the mistake's nature; here, the party seeking to void the settlement failed to demonstrate that the opposing party knew or should have known of the unilateral mistake concerning the claim's value, precluding rescission.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
contrat unilatéral règlement du litige répétition de l'enrichissement illégitime concours de responsabilités nullité du contrat garantie du vendeur

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Applied for the determination of court costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/228/2005
Settlement Enforcement Despite Alleged Unilateral Mistake
A/4157/2006
Enforceability of Agreement Affirmed Despite Claim of Unilateral Mistake
A/1423/1996
Settlement Agreement Validity and Consideration Dispute
A/760/2005
Enforceability of Settlement Agreement
A/3117/2005
Settlement Agreement Enforceability Based on Subsequent Conduct

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the determination of court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

               "#$%$"&%%' ("#%&&"&%%'

(

 () )()  )   

*+ '

 &, -.+ &%%'



 ! $

"#$ !



"%$

& '   '  !( *2$ )*+%$,!-"%./0!,110 '  



           !

  435  



) /(

,6 $ 78%  ,/ 2*($#$ 4110!  ,9: );$  $#;  -$#:$ #%-$""*#("$ !*,<7#,<5.!% "#$ !*41"=%,<.4!>#"%$#*,."(;$ ,<<16

46 '")#22$578%-$*#%*! $#;-$#:$#%"$"* -$%8-$"#%#*-$%%#""$%#$(%$-$% " #%#%%#"  -$*("? -$"2#"6   %$#    $#; *!2#>@#-$":A-$%86

96 78%#("$%(*2##%#24.($#41106

56 '"#2"$%#"$##-$ $#;*!$#-" -$:&"%#"#%#%%#"--*%#(@-$%%#"#;$-8 -$"(%   B$#) $ @ "%%  01@C0. 2$6 .1 % @ -$%%#"#;$-8-$"(%+"##@"%%0@0<<2$6 /1 A  %  @%$*  2"$  )" 78*  #("$6  %"%   -$%%#"@*:(A0.@50.2$6916

06 $"$$#$0"%";$4110! $#;*#2"$*DE*-"D!( "-# A  &"%#" #%#%%#" --*%#( !   >@# --$%#$ A @#%#%%#"-$*("?$%$2*$$$"-%;">* $"4C@44C2$6,0$-$*%%"#%#*-$%%#" "$%#  $6  *#  4C "%";$ 4110  *%* "$* D DE*-"D! -"$*%$#$$-$%8!2%*"%#@"%-2#%86

) (

,6 @$%6 40   "# 2**$ $  #;$ -8   -$*("? -$"2#"!(##!$(#(%%#(##%*,/*;$,<<9F&G! %$*(#8$,$7(#$4111!$:8-$"*$#("$6"$> "7"#%"%-H"$$-$%%#""$%#A-$%8$F$%6,44% ,49 " #(#E G!78##("$"-*%%@$%6/96 ,"#2**$$-$*("?-$"2#"407#,<C4FG!"#%A :( $#;%"$"#-#,$"=%4119!"#%! -$:>@22#$#*%*%$#F$%6,54 G!D*%$@"22#-$%8$ ;*$*-$%#%#"*%$#*-$78#("$.

    3,.1.34110 935  



46 '"@$%644 &F"(%$(#8$-#,$7(#$4111G! #("$!-$%%#""$%#>#$%$#8"%-$%8* "2"$*%D$%6,44!,49!,5,%,54 I$%69A0&@--#>% -$"8#"%%A%$2*$$F6,G6"$)>"7"#%!-$%%#" "$%#A-$%8$"$$-"A#22*$%$-$%%#""$%#!8%*  ("#$  #;$ -8 D#%% *(%%  "%  #("$! %  -$%%#"  "$%#! 8%*  ("#$  #;$ -8 D#%% *(%%"%"#"$#8F26$%645&G6"$ !"7"%A-$%%#""$%#%A@("#$#;$-8D#%% "%"#"$#8#%*$J%"%#("$F & ,4C491I &,4<555G6

96  H-:!  78  -$#:$ #%  "$"*  -$%8 -$ "#%#*   -$%%#""$%#$6%-$%#%"%!H-$%! $#8!,."(;$,<<1%H%$-$%4.($#4110!%A> 78%#("$%(D*%"#$6

'"  #2"$%#" $## -$  $#;  *!  -$%%#" ># -%$#8-$$%0.@50.2$691"%@%$* 2"$)"78*78%#("$66 ##!$"#%A"DE *-""%%4C@444C2$6,0!$-$*%%"#%#*-$#$"%%6

56 "2"$*% A  7$#-$! -#  7"$ *%$#% -"$  -$%8 7>@ "%  %$2$%   -$%%#"  "$%# "   $!  "7"#% #("$* ;**2###$  %% -$%%#"  $"#% A  #%*$J% "-%"#$ $  "%%  E#6  #%*$J% "% *  %D ## *8 " @$%6 ,4  @"$" $  -$*("? -$"2#" (##! $(#(% % #(##%*  ,C ($# ,<C5 F 4G " "  %D $*8%#$! # #E# % -*$#$ F & " -;#*  9.314  ,C 7#% 4119G

06 *"%$-$K!-$"*$*%%8$%#%F$%6/964% C<L6,"#$-$"*$##%$%#(,4-%;$,<C0G6



MMM

    3,.1.34110 535  



  (/  () )()  )   



01-2-++ 3  4-- -  5! #$& 6

,6 (#%&"%#"#%#%%#"--*%#(A%$2*$$!"-%"#$  ! N 0916.4690,6,0<3111!  "  4C@44C 2$6,0 A  > %":(!"-%NL9414640611" 6

46 (#%&"%#"#%#%%#"--*%#(A($$!-"%%! #%*$J% "-%"#$    "#*$%! :  4. ($# 4110 7>@ "%%$2$%6

96 H?"%%>;"#6

56 #%>-$"*$%8$%#%6

06 2"$  -$%#   >@ -(% 2"$$ $"$ "%$  -$*% $$J%   *#  91 7"$ :  "%#2#%#" -$ -# $"* $*  $#; 2**$  $! ')O#P$)"2># .! .115   !  %$"# D-#$6  *#  -% J%$ -$""8*6  *"#$ "#% Q G ##>$ D%% > *##"  $"$% *#$ ";%#$  # % -   *##"%%>*I;GD-"$-"$>"%#2#%#-"("#$$%% %$*##"IG-"$%$#8%$""$-$*%%6'#*"#$  "%#% -  %$"# **% **$* " %%$ G ;G % G #E!  $#;2**$$-"$$-%$$%#:$$$"$>@# ($*$$#$$(;6*"#$$"$%#"$"$"?  -$(! ># $"% 7"#%! ## >  *##" %%>* % @("--  >*%*D-*#*$"$%F$%6,94!,1.%,1CG6 8$22#:$  $*#%Q         RS B ?       "-#"2"$-$*%$$J%%"%#2#*D-$%###>HAH22#2**$ $"#-$8$22

    3,.1.34110