Contract Enforceability and Unjust Enrichment in Construction Dispute
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe litigant sought to recover damages resulting from a failure to complete a construction project, alleging breach of contract and unjust enrichment against the contractor who abandoned the work and subsequently filed for bankruptcy. The court determined that the litigant's claims for breach of contract failed because the contract was not enforceable due to the contractor's status as a defunct entity at the time of signing, meaning there was no valid agreement to breach. However, the court allowed the claim for unjust enrichment to proceed, reasoning that allowing the contractor to retain the funds paid for unperformed work without providing any benefit would result in an inequitable gain, thus establishing a basis for recovery under that theory.
Regeste Legislator
OfficielAI(ASSURANCE); DEVOIR DE COLLABORER; TRAVAIL; TRAVAIL AU NOIR; ADMINISTRATION DES PREUVES; APPRÉCIATION DES PREUVES; ÉTAT DE SANTÉ; INVALIDITÉ(INFIRMITÉ); ÉTAT DE SANTÉ; MODIFICATION(EN GÉNÉRAL) ; RÉVISION(PRESTATION D'ASSURANCE) ; RÉVISION(DÉCISION) | LPGA.43.3; LPGA.61.let.c; LPGA.17; LPGA.53.1
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IACited in the dispositive to rule on the costs of the federal court proceedings.
Cited in the dispositive to determine the amount of compensation awarded to the respondent.
Texte complet
!"##"!$%%# &!"%"'!$%%(
&
&) )&) )
*+ ( $, -.+ $%%(
- ////////// !" #$#!%!$# ##% &'%# (
%#
00 )&) 1) 2)3 & % ! )*#+$%,-./-// /0
3-1/03
) 0&
/4 & #5555555555##% %$6!/),*%## 7!8 /)*/4
-4 9 %:# /)); !$! $#%% $#< =>> % =#3 7 %! ? 3$#<@ A 7 % " =:%% = #%4
04 # ! /; >!7# # % /9 /))) = # " =#! 7 %! /22B % %#+! #% % <# = 7 %! " $%# /#C7 #/))*4
,4 8%%-0C7 #-22/!%: $#& #5555555555 $%# %#DE% # $# % ##7 =#!7 % !%!7%# %#7 ##E% ##8#7%% /0% /. C7 # -22/4 %##6! # $#! # E% # =#! !$# #F= +%#7 %7%= F#>G%$#! #F= %#7 %$#$%=%#$# & # 55555555554% # %#7G& #5555555555> #!F= =6 %=%#7 # =%#$# 55555555554#F= $%#%#7#E% # /.C7 #=#!=+%#7 %%C#48 %G 7#F% F !% % $!$#& #5555555555=#! #%%%%!>#$$# = $%# F $ !7 %# $ 6#H " #!>G % " = %#7% = %#7# #%#7 %#E% #4# % 7 %$$!$ # F=#!>+ % G7 %#4
.4 %%$ .>!7# #-22/#!7!!F=#!7 %!%!#$# %! %=!% %#$:4% #$ ##& # 55555555557 %> #!# % !#%> %%F= 7 %!%!!# %$#& #55555555554
;4 8 #$$#% ! %#! # -. C -22/ # &5555555555 $! %! %#%! %# %%I#!I!%%%! # #%#%!%% #$ !:#/))9% I+$E6% 6% 4 %% % 7% % > # $ %! %#7 @ F #! %#$E !#!: 7# +$%% F +# $#!3J#J7 7 %#: ! F % %#% !%% G 3!$# > #!##% $+!7# % F #F! :6 #!##% # $+ : # >> % #%E# %#3 $$E+ # !%6!4 ! F %# F %% #6 F I% ! #! :% I F :6 $# %% % $$# % #>>#%$E+ F4I!%%G 3!$# >#% 7
1/,,/1-22, 301/03 > % > !7<# #% $# # $ 6#! %# %%4 # # %#D! /9C -22/
*4 ### #/07:#-22/= !"=%#$# & # 5555555555 F#$ F=#!%#7 %$# %F6# =% 7 %! >>% %4
94 #!$;!:#-22/=%#$# 5555555555!#!F= =7 %$+!=#!%F= %$4
)4 ### #-/#-22-= !% #%#7G F="=#!F%+$=% 7 %!7 %!%!G#!$## # F#! % #$#K4
/24 -9#-22-= #K## ##%#$#%=#!7 % # %LC %#7 !M4
//4 /. C % -22- % # %#7G !6% #7+! ## # = % L& #5555555555=C %#7 !$# M4
/-4 ### ##!)C %-220= $#% ! 02C % -220"=#!$#F= G$ % #%$#! C% $#!#E% ##8#7%%C7 #-22/4 7> % %!>%:#% = $$# # %#%= 7 %!4
/04 -) C % -220 = 7+! " =#! $# $ $ $ ## #)C %F=#!=7 %$#!!$#<$%4
/,4 # ## # ) $%:# -220 =#! F! " = F= =7 % 7# ::% $ #K ## # #! # > % F ## # 7 % !%! %# :!4 % % !#% =7 # C %#7 !4
/.4 # ! /0 %:# -220 = $$# ! #% = 7 %! =#!"$%#> 7%%% > % ! 4 3#$%=: 6% # 6#$#% %#$!# %C7 # -22/"%:#-220 $!# #%F !% % !#!F=#! 7 % :% $#%% <# %4 $#%% 7# % N%# #% %!%! !$#!# %% > !"C%4= !6% #% #!=>>%$ >"!7%##4
/;4 ; 7:# -220 =#! =% $$! " %% ! % " % 4 #!:% % #% %% =>>% $ > =$$ % 4 F! =7 # $ #K ## # #! = 4 7 % !# % " =>> %D% F ## # !% % $#7 $# ## # $4
1/,,/1-22, 3,1/03 $7 % #$#E# =7 # 7 ! : 6% # 6#4 8=C% %"> %F= '%# %%#<>#K 4!% $#%G$ % !% %%#<$ :#%F= +7 % $#%%#> #7 ##6%>48=6 %> %F= =7 % $ G#! =% 7 %! #% 7 $ F= !% % :!!> = #% !% %$$ :># #$#7!6% 74
/*4 % -0 C7 # -22, % 67 $% ? A% > !"=#!! #% %% #%$#$!# /#C7 #-22/ 0/%:#-220 "F 3 =%$$!%, >!7# #-22,4#! #$$ % -#-22, $ $#!#CF="# %C6!$#= #F% $$# #%4
/94 -. # -22, =#! $!%! $$ % 4 =:# > #! F= =7 %$#K## ##!= %$#!!%% $ #%4 $7 % $ # F= 7 % #>! <# G: >## " : 6% # 6# :## " = %#% 4 # # : % % % # > % F= 7 % #!% G#!% 7 %!#E% ##8#7%%4%% %$+N%# ! > % F= + 7 % G#! % 7 %! =7 % $ $ N%# $#7!4 =!% %#$F$#$# 6#FF 4 > 7%$## ! !> % 7% #%#7G7 %N%# % !4
/)4 #! #$$ % 9C -22,= > #!! % 4 :#G## # F= 7 %7+!"=#!=7 %$!%! #% #! =7 % #K F #!$ %#< %4 > % F= '%# % >#K C% > %$$ 4# # ! %#$$#% $ ->!7# #-22/F= 7 %!%!7L#!E%# %#7 #M F ##$ % $ " !6% 4 > #!%: % =>>% $ > C% > % $ $% % # F $# =# $ #7###!F # %##$!7!4
-24 #%9C %-22,=#! %#C%!##%#%%! $#< # : % # % $#!:% " F #$#!%% %#$# +% O7#! # E% # % % ! NF #648#>=#!"=% ! %%F! : #% " # $ = G$#% 7 % " #!!7# $ %! %#7 4 %% % 7 # %#7 ! $E+ F% # E% # # 8#7%% N #% !!% # $7 % $#'%# %#:% " % !6#4 8 !6% !% % $ %% > #! $# '%# =7#6 F $# =%# #$ !% # F 7 % N%# %$# # :48=6 %$#:< %# :% ## # + 7 % = % # #6 :4
1/,,/1-22, 3.1/03 -/4 #!$-0P%-22,= #C%##4&N Q#% 7 $% # %$$#7=G$ F %$ $#F =#! =7 % $ ! #!$ $<% G ## # F !% % >%%$#74# #Q # :7# % FN% + # % !6% = % # & # 5555555555 NF%! =%#% %## #%##%4
--4 -; C7 # -22. # : ! $#!! " $#% $# $#% 4
#%% ##% F!$7 #7 # F! >G F=$+#"& #5555555555 /0 C7 #-22/4!% %$!FF> #E% ## 7 %%$ =+ 7 % C %#7 !4 % % $#> 7!E > F %#7 %% # #%=7 %$#F!7%E% #//C7 # -22/4 > ##% F! F !%% % =!% % ! #! # <#! $$#:<$E+ F4>># %=#%E#4
-04 NC# # :!%$ #%! 4
%% & # 5555555555 '%# %#7G F! F =#!!% %7FF> #E% # =7 %C %#7 !$# 4 7 %#K$#7 #$+!=#! # =7 %$ %%!# =7 %$+4$H%#E% #7 %$ N%#%%%#> %4=+7 %FFF#%EF 7 %!%!>>%! $#& # 5555555555%R55555555554
& # R5555555555 $ %# $#! ! F %#7% % % " > %#7G% =7 %$%#7 !7##%47 %> %%%$% %$ %#7 $H%## 4 6!!# ## 7 % # E% # $# $ %# > F$H%#!% %$!4
& # 5555555555 #3!:! % F! F= % ##% $ $ # ! % F= =7 % $ %#7 ! 7 # E% #4 %$$H%# #E% #%%% %!6% & #5555555555F # %4 =7 %C 7=#!E: % %#7 #E% #%=7 %$!%!%! =#%#%#=#!% & #5555555555#E% #4
& # 5555555555 K > % 7 # # : F= =$ % ! % 47 %7> =#!#$ # #=+%#7 %$4 3N=!% %$%#<7%#E% #4$#$!%%$# %#7G $H%## % $ %# !% % & # R55555555554 & # 5555555555 $#! ! F= #%# % =#! >! 7# ; E# % $ ,. F= 6# % 3 $#% %%#7 #$# %4
1/,,/1-22, 3;1/03 & # S5555555555 ! F! 7 # !%! $#!% " $ # #$# # E% # =+7 %C 7##%F= % F%#<$4
& # 5555555555 $%# > #! # : % %% -0 C7 # -22/ % !#% " $ 4 #!>> # % 7 # 7 =#! %#7 # # E% # /0 % /. C7 # -22/4 3 > %#E: 6% 7 %% !%#7 4
& # 5555555555 #:# # F! # : ! F= 7 % !%! #K $# =#! # E% # % F =!% % F 7 % F! F= + 7 % " > #4 =7 % !6% 7 %# %#7 # = $ > % %%% " F= > % #<%%4 = $ ##F! F= >># % = E $4
-,4 9 # -22. $# % # !% # :H% % %# # : " $ # #% $#!# 7#% %# & # 5555555555 % " = F 7 % !%! > 6! $# 7 # $+!=#! #4
-.4 -2 7# -22. # : ! 7F! $#% $#% $#4 %% #! %;< E:#%% #!=%%% ##%## F#C%##$#!>%:#% % > G!! $#!%# #4
-;4 # ## # -* C -22. =#! > #! =7 # C %#7 ! $# & #5555555555 F= =7 %%C#>> #!4$# % % 4 $#! % !6% F= 7+ % $ F # !>% :#% $7 % N%# #$#E! $ F= =!% % #!6 <#% $#!%! 7% # : % 7 % ># % % %! F= E % %> #%#4
) &
/4 67 #=#6 % C #?A!%! > !% % %!< /#P%-220 # :%# $!.C6 % $#! % % 7 3$#! % . $$!% % /; C6 # ?#%4 / %4#%.; A4
8 %"=% =!% /;C6#$# # :>!!# -*C7 #-22,? R/02/2;A# 67 $%!/0>!7# # $ % %# % ##6%$#%%% # :%#
1/,,/1-22, 3*1/03 !6# # " %# C6 % % # =%%% =!% 7GC6#4
-4 >#!% " =#%4 .; 4 / %4 E4 - # : '% % F%%% $#!7"=#%4.; >!!##$#% 6!!# # % # ; %:# -222 ? 3$#<@ A #% 7 %% " >!!# # =#3 7 %! /) C /).) ? 3$#<@ A4
8$!%$#C6#=$<% !%: 4
04 %%#!7 6#/#C7 #-220%%#'! > % :# $ % $#% # I#3 7 %!4 !6 % 7 6#CFI0/!:#-22-#$%!%# % I$<4 >>% I$#< C# $# !6 % $$ : E6%#<6# %#%F !% %7 6###! % I!%% > % F % N%# $$#! ! C# F% F !F C# F? R/-*,;* 4//-;/;; 4,:A4
#7E F # $#!# % " !>% #<6 %# % # %# # 7 # % I$$ F #!#7 < C# %#!
7 6#? R//*)0 4;://-0;2 4,T & /))9U0*$4 0/; 4 0:A4 I% $#F $#!# $% /# C7 # -220 %# % $#< %% % 7% %# : % $!%% % <# I# % #!6 $# 7 #<6 $#!# % % $# $ % $#!# % >>!#% $! > !$# 4
,4 =$<$#!%##!%!!$!>#%! $!$# %%<##7:7#%#%4.; 4
.4 # %%$#!#%#!6 $# $# $ F % # F > % $#% % 7% N%# %%!I>> $#I %#% C64& $# $I%$:4 8 $#%! % #%# % $# 7 # $#% :## " I %#% I>> #4 3 $#$#% #I: 6% $#% I$$#%# # Q $% N%# # :% G 6! I $#7 ! $# %# % 6%> % 7F!>%F # F%7 # $$#%#!FI:$#7?>4 R/-./). 4-% #!>!#T7 #!6%=#%4;/%4 A4
=#% ,0 4 0 =#! =%# #F!#% #>% <# G: >## " # : 6% # 6# :##"= %#% =##$%$##=!%% ## = %#% % ! # $ %## % <#4 % # 7 # #!
1/,,/1-22, 391/03 # !# % 7#% % !F C# F % # $#% %! #!>G 7:4I#%4,040 :% N%#FI#%4*0#<6%#=#3 7 %!/*C7 # /);/ ? A F !% % 7 6# CFI 0/ !:# -22- % =$$ F G : 6% $!#% ##%4 %% $ % $#!7 %$#% #F I#! $ % G 7: " # 6%?#%4*/4/ AI>> $%$##I!%% # $#< 7 # $#% ! # : 7 % !F !>%:#% ? R/-.,2* 4,T8-222$400- 4,A4
!E!% =# $## #C%# $#!%! $# $#% !#%F> %%%% ### %%$!%#!?>4 R//*-;, 40:%#!>!#A4 $###> I!%% # I## $% !6% #% ## ! I ##7: %!% % ? R/29-024 4 -T 7 # !6% U 8 #V%67#>E# # 8W 7# E#6 X --) $4 /29 4T ># & 8EV W# E >7# E#6#E%$4-.;TS#+ (%:#J %$# W $ EV W# E 8W 7# E#6#E%@ %# :## #YJ E% 66 # E%$#E6 6Z E# E#66# E%%E<(# E/)).$4 /*-4T>4 I#%4,040 A4& I##$%$##I!%% # #># I%## % <# 3 E G I I%# ! !$# %% I7% I %#% % !F $# I#! I!7% % # %!#! 3 F I % $ $ : I! # > % >> %! $ % $! 6#! I::#% I#!? R/29-0/4%)*/T& $4 %4$4-..T R $: !-,C -220*2212-A4
;4 # %>!!#> G$## $% # <#=$$#! #+ $#7$# $ :#$$#! % $#7=$$ F%% <# $#!# %#% 748$# $I %#% C6$$#! :#% $#7 N%# ! $# #<6 ># $#!% " $$#! % $<%%# 6#$#74<#C6 %G # <#:C% 7%+$#7FFI %$#7$ ! # %" $ % $#%%%$#%#C6%7:# # % % 6 G? R/-.0./A4
*4 8I#%4/* 7 6#$ /#C7 #-220?F I$ > ! % #!7 # % " #%T R 02 7# -22, ;-;120A %G I 7 %! :!!> # #% : % > % %: #% % I>> # #!7 ! $# I7 # " 7 # 6%! #! %!F #$$# !4 7%!6% $#I%#$#%% #:#!7#%I! %#!># #F I!%% > % !%# % > %:% $# %4 %
1/,,/1-22, 3)1/03 E6% $#%% #%$#$#" >#6#!I 7 %!% # % " #% $% % 7# #!7 I#%4 /* 4 #% $%N%##!7 !% > % :I!%%%! #F 3 %#%! N F!F# $ %!6 %: E6% $#%%? R/020,) 404. //0-*. 4/T7 #!6% R//-0*- 4-:%0)2 4/:A4 $ %7 # %E6%I%$# % %N%#%#E!$#% > %%FI $#!% %%! % #%% #%#!6%"I!$F! % 6 ? R/020./ 4 04.4-/-.0;) 4-%#!>!#T7 #!6% R//-0*- 4 -:%0)2 4/:A4
# # $ %!6 I#!I! # + !## F E6% $$# !E!% %% $#% # % G $#%% <FI$%I%%#"FI! #% %%! % #% W 6 $!# 4 7 N #FI % E6% !%# % #! %# !C" %##$% %: % FI $ % $#E % " # # ?#%4 99 #% 7 I#%4 /* A
94 8C# $##!$!% % $#%% $< P%%E! I 8%I#3 7 %!?#%4,*4/ 8%#%4,) A% : G % F $#! % " #!7% $# %# I ! %#% 7 ?>4 R /-- /09 4 -A4 $# $ I$%% $#%% 7>>%#!%#% >?G%A4I#3 7 %!'% #!6%% >>!#%#F > % $#%% I# $# F $% F% $! > F # % I#3 7 %!4 > % $#%% I# %#7 % $# $ 7 >>% G % $# >%# ?#%4 9. 4 - A > 7 % I: 6% # 6#?#%4 AT # # > % $#%% I#>>%#!%#% >?#%49.4-%99: 4-%4: A4
# 6 7 #!7 ! # $# %# %! C # I %#% % % $#!# " #!7 I ! %#! ># ># #F % !7#% > % 7G 7G + $#7$% : #"$$#! % C# F >>!#%? R/-* ,;) 4-%#!>!#T R $: !)>!7# #-22. -2012,A4
%%C# $#%#$# "=#%4.04/ F $F! % ! # $$ % >#% $! ># % " #!7 =#! =## !7# :!F% > % 7G $#%% %#7 7G + $#7 F $7 % N%# $# %$#7%4
1/,,/1-22, 3/21/03 )4 =$<$#! /0%:#-220=>> % !$$# !#% =#! # = !>% :#% $#% # $#!##!7 48=>> =#!=7 %$#% #!## #F 7 %!%!#!=+7 %$$#%!F#!$%#< #4
$% # 7#% F% 7 # $#!# % =#%4*0 $$ :"=!$F> %!%!#$%!=$< <#F= $$#%F#$#E3:#% $#!#7% = % !% C% > !4 >>%##%#!$"#% ## #% #Q F!F= =7 %C %#7 ! =7 %$# $ # "C%#4 #%%77 '%# >#K $#=#! # %$$#%"= % !7F#> >#%#7 #$$#%= $%#5555555555%%$#! %F% 4
%> N %%% F ##% F! " 7 # :#% % >%% $#!# F =% !#! 7% # : ! $ : %! %%# =!%% $#% $"= %#% %%#=G # %% =6#> :##%=:% #%%%#G$#%%#> "$#%% G$! 34
=$< ># % #% %%# F $ < # F= %#% !$# # :!!%#%"% >% # % F ##% %#7 ! " $ # #$# # E% # " # 8#7%%4#! : %!#$$#%%#DE% ##! 6!$#= $%# 5555555555 = >>% !%! % $# #% F #$$#% 7% N%# !#! 7!# F4 =#! !%! 7 " G #$# #NE% #=$%# C#%#7 %4$#% % E: %%#7 !$H%#%> %F= G!% %%#7 !%!> #! $# $+! E% # " 7 # & # 55555555554 # # %7=#! %# %#7 # =% !6%# #F ! " & # 5555555555 %#% F% %#7 " >>%#4 > % % F= % !%! #%! $# = $%# 5555555555 % !6% > % =:C%=#$$#%$ %=#% ### !!# %"=6# = $%#$#=#!4$> %%! " > 6!% #%#7G& #5555555555$# $# % # !% # 3O7# % /) C -22/ ! > #!###$# E:##% % 7%#7 )7# -22-4 $#$% #%#7G!#!# % F= =7 % $ %%! %% # = 7 % $ +4 % #6% # % N%# $# !# G # Q =#! #! %! %%!%%! $#$#37% E:##% % 7 %#7 ##> 6#% #4 > #F$#%!%#< #! %%"##G#!$%! G%#F% F %!%!
1/,,/1-22, 3//1/03 $!$# # :4= % %#%! =$$# > #$ <# # %#7 >>%! $# =#! G3 % % =!7 F%=7 ## 74
# =%% %##% =$%$!%!$ :!%# # $%: %$"F%G=% 7 %!%$#F # %#7 ! #E% #%!7%%#=%#E% ##%F= % $ : =!7# =!%% !%% %! % $ %! 6 % ! #!$ %F= + > #6#!= 7 %!4%"#$$# " % !6# F =#%4 99 F =$$ F % " =!$F ##% =! #% %: =% F E6% #! %# %##$% %:4 %$$#%%=#!$## %3 N%# !#! F= %#7 !$%#!%" %G $% : 7 =%# = #% $<% ?>4 8%!$E $#!# %#% 7#3 7 %!R# :#6/)))$4//9A4
>#!%"C# $#$#! %!= % !# %P$## I!%% # ! $ I C6 % $% $#!# " FN%7%##! %!# 4
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
!%% I % ! # % P # # 6% ! G $$!% #G! %# %%=#!%%#"G$#% ! 4%#I %#% $#!%%>>%$ >> %! $ % $#% <#4 I%FI"!>%$#7 #"!%: #> %" % >% # % %% <# F 7% #> :#%
1/,,/1-22, 3/-1/03 I %!#! I % ! # % !%! E: %! " ## ! >% # # $%4
% # % $ $ G %%# > % I!%%%!I % !$#$#"C% > #$$# $#% $# %"#%4#7 "I>> % !#!7<! #4 :# % >> # > # %% ! ##%4 #! ?G$#%A7#%!%# # <$!# Q=#! !%! #$# %# %#7 # !%% %! #$% 7% $ %! %#7 7 %: E6% 6 > % >4
/24 $%%F $#!<##% ! %!% #7+!"= $# %#% $!% # !#% %7! 4
//4 &N ##%:% %6 7 % %#+# F% %!#! %"% %#!$7$#%%%%6 $#!#4 %% %!#> G!".22>#4
1/,,/1-22, 3/01/03 &0 &) )&) )
45-6-++ 7 8-- - 9: ";$ <
6-+
/4 !####7:4
6-
-4 =%4
04 ! = /0%:#-220%9C -22,4
,4 7 " = $# %#% $!% # !#%%7! 4
.4 I % !"$+###% %!.22>#4"% %#!$4
;4 ># $#% F= $7% >## ## %# $#!% ##N% ! 02 C# < % > % $# $ #! #! # : >!!# # 8EV W#E>F ; ;22, %# G$ #4 ! $% N%# $#6!4 ! # %@ A F# G%%F! ##%! #:% # %$! %%F!T :A G$# $# F % > % $7 # # %% %# ! T A $#%# 6%# #$#!%%4 8 ! # % % $ %# !!% !!#! %%# A :A % A 3 # :>!!##$##$%##% <####F= 7#!## ##7:4! ###% ##+ $#7 F #% C % F ! %%F! % =7$$ F!%!G$! !##%?#%4/0-/2;%/29A4 6#>> <# #! % [\ ( &+ & #!% #3C# %@ &# S &&
$ >#$#!%##N%%% > !G$#% F="=>> >!!# # $#6#>>
1/,,/1-22,