Jurisdiction and Breach of Fiduciary Duty Appeal Dismissed
Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe case primarily addresses the jurisdiction and findings of a lower tribunal concerning various alleged breaches of duty and contractual obligations between the parties over several years, culminating in an award of damages. The court, after reviewing the evidence and prior rulings, determined that the lower body had the jurisdiction to hear the dispute, rejected arguments challenging the finding that a fiduciary duty existed and was breached, and affirmed the factual basis for the financial determinations, concluding that the findings were not plainly wrong, thus dismissing the appeals.
Regeste Legislator
Généré par l'IAArt. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Jurisdiction and Breach of Fiduciary Duty Appeal Dismissed: The court, after reviewing the evidence and prior rulings, determined that the lower body had the jurisdiction to hear the dispute, rejected arguments challenging the finding that a fiduciary duty existed and was breached, and affirmed the factual basis for the financial determinations, concluding that the findings were not plainly wrong, thus dismissing the appeals.
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IAUsed to declare the appeal inadmissible on procedural grounds.
Applied for the distribution of court costs.
Texte complet
#$%&%#'%%( #$%$)#'%%(
* * *
+, - " '. /0 '%%(
! "# $# % & $ '($))* ( $) "
$
++ , -- ! $ "( ) " ( ). /01 # $234!5355 56
!"
%3758%
1
59 : %# ; < , (=! ( 56 >? 5/24! ) $ $( $ !$ $ )'$ $ )'($@ "$ !$ ? $)# 3 A$ 5/// """B? # '$ # C - 9
39 53 ?"@ 3883! ' ( ?(! ) ) ) $ ? $( ) "B? ! D )'? 548 E 508 F $ $ *"$ ) ) 9
69 2)("@ 3883! !"() $ $$)' (!$$$() "@D ! D $ $D )(G $ $ H$ # $()$ ? $ $);53 ?"@ 38839
29 58" 3886! ! I"$ D! ) ## $"() ?$ *' "@ GG$( ?"@ 3883 ? $ " (? ) ) $ ; "# $$ ( )(D(( $ ?9 #$ $ # ($ $ ) "@ $D DI ) $J$ ) ( )(D(( $ ? (?; " "D) "# ) *' J $I DI)(@$$9 #$ $ # $ # # ? $ ? 9 '. ? $ # ) $ $"$ #( G *E# # 9
49 32" 3886! !#( $I D ! ) ## $ "() E)"))-K D $ )$(! %") # $) D )C - 9 ;?*L#$ $# ($!# ;#)28 ) $ ?J ) G ! ) ( )(D(( $ ? J$ M""$ "# $$ ) $ ) ($D ) "@ * $ $ H( (# ) ) "@ $D DN ?"@ 38839 $"$! '. # ) .) " ) " # $ .) " ? $(@ "@ ? $ ( E'GG $$E$$ )@ $# D(9 $)$!$ $"$ ) $ $ ."#$ "$ *$# $ $$ "$ ( ?(9' # $() $ ? $$ * "B? " # H$ $ $ $ )(G $ ?! * ) I$ ($$J$ M""$ (?( )$ ?J)G ?GG $ $# $ ) ) I D9$ ? )#$(!'$%E%) ( $$GG $ # $)I D # H$J D @!" E$"## $ O9
P9 56" 3886!' ( * )# $$ )' 9
09 5 > 3886! $$$() "@ $D DI) $ # $ ($ $"? 9
Q9 32 > $ 3886! ) ## $ "() # ' $$$$) "@ $D -5$2DI:) ;$"$)(G $ 2DI=! ( )(D(( $ ? "@ (?; !$( ) ($( J:2DI!
758/873884 %6758% " ) " 4 DI=! J $I DI)(@$$ $)' # $() $ ? $ $9 # $ ($ $ "@ $ #$ $ # $ # # ? $ ? 9
/9 2 #$"@ 3886! $$$( * '($$ ) $( ($ $ $( $$ $*'$ ? $(E48R)# $(D ($ $# @9
589 33? 3882! ## $) ()#$$ # G )'GG $ ) ' % ? ) $( : %# ;< ' = ;? *! ? '$$ $) ) ' (! )" # G $ $ ) *($*'$D @ $ $ E (I9 " ? ) # $( ) $ ? ) 48 R @ $ $ E )D ()' ? ) $()P3R! "#$$)')()$ D @)34R9
559 # ()' )6" 3882 $E' $ )')" % $)53 ?"@ 3886 65 )("@ 3886 # )' $ %* $ ) $ G )( )D ()' ? ) $()P3R9
539 )J)( )58 A$3882!' $ .(E' ()" % $) 5 ?"@ 388665)("@ 3886 *')" % $ "#("$ # > $ $ ); 5 >? 3882 $ %* $ ) $! *' $ % * $) $ "#("$ # > $9
569 54 ?"@ 3882! ( $E )# (? .) $ $ *' ($ $($ () $$ * #$ $ ? $*')" % $ * )D ( )' ? ) $( )" # ' ($ $ ) P3 R 9 $ ) PPR($ $## I) ( $(9
529 5Q ?"@ 3882! ' ( G $ ## $ J )( ) ' ) 58 A$ 3882 # ( $ *'E $ ) )( ) )? $ I I "# # @? E @ ? $J * ($ $ "# @ "#$$) ($$9
549 # ;%? @)' )53>? 3884! ;?*' ( G "? S)( )' A$3882$? G $ ## $ #$ ) * ? $ D(*' $ *"$) $E $)48R9
5P9 3Q >? 3884! ( $ E ' *! @>$ ?"$! #$ $ # D $ ) # # " *' @>$ ?"$ $ $ # ) ID"$# ## $J) D $ )( $32> $38869
509 58" 3884!' G "(' (*' (J" $ ) ? ' )) ? > ) *9
5Q9 54" 3884!' (( $E' *' ($ $E588R ? )9
758/873884 %2758% 5/9 50 " 3884! ' >$( ' ## $ ) ' ( ?$ * "() %$ $$ G " $*' '.? $#)ID"$)'($$)$( )# )( )' )58 A$38829
389 53 ? 3884! ' ( $ )( ## $ ) ' # ;) @$ ) ?$*' I $ $ $ ? "() * '? $ J" (! ? $ $ %"M" # ) $ ) D ? $( ) ! "() ! ($ $ ( "")'# )/89
359 58" 3884!' >$) ##$*'$ "$ )'# $()$ ? )48RG ) $ '## ( $ ) E*'($ $ ( ? "() )' 9' ## $ ($ $$ ) ?" '? $##M$ ? *(G$)# ?) $ G $ ))( ) 58 A$38829
339 P > 3884! @ ) ( $ ) ) "# $ # )# $ $)'*M$ )* ($( $)9
$)( (<L S $)48R! $G 92889%# " 9 ' $ ? () $4ITC - """B? $#)$32 IT (D"$ """B? 9 ?"@ 3883!>' ?( D ? ;D)548E508F ! '? # $( 54";$ !>' $) *"$ ) ) 9 # ! > ' ( )'? ) ) ) ) 9 "' ) $ * >'? ) )' # )/89' #$ ? ()# " "$ U>' )) 9 $"> (>"# ";#$>G # G E"D # "G * 3P$* $(D"$E' 9 ) '"# $# G 9) # ) # " "$ # ) "() "$ " "' ) ) ) D$ ?9' $"$#? $()$ ? ' "')(" ( )$ ) ## ( $ ) GG( $ E " (D )9 '$ " * > # $ ? E48R" G) $? ? $(!*>' # ) '$$ $))' 9 I $ M$ J" (# "() )' O9
' )( (<L' $ "#$)'? )"() $ $$!* # $ "#$ $ $ # $ ) ' (9 'J# $ - $ *"$ ) ()) $ )'? "() J $ ) $ !$ "$#G? @J (*'? )"() $ $$O9
)( (< L 9 $ $ $"$ IT " )# 2%4# ) "@D % $D !'$%E%) )) )@ )) $>"@9'D $)) D $ )) #$I !) $I !'$%E%) ) ' $I ) ) * $ ? $(@ J9 ' " %"M" ) ( 9- $$ $ $$@9 $ $"$# ) D( $)
758/873884 %4758% #I. $I( # $)$D *9'#? "$"( ('($$)$(9 $ ? $()@V$ "$"# H$ "# @# " #$ $9 ?I! $ ? $(# $)I D?) $)(#"$"# H$ "#$ @9 )' ) ? '## ( $ ) ) )' $ ? $( # @ (D; J ( E 48 R9 '> $ * 9 ' # )'$ G "$ *)"B? )@V$ "$! "# H$) GG *' # J $ $ ? $(9 !" $ ?$ $" )$# J $ ? $(# G 9 .D"# H$) GG O9
369 52 > 3884! % & ,$ $ $( # )(G ) $( M$) $$ * )( # "#($ 9
P> $!68 A$$3/#$"@ 3884! $(# D$ ))( # ( $(9
54 ?"@ 3884! & "#($( ?$*, ( ? $ G ),$ * "B? $ *, .D ($ $ )#$(! ),$$ * ($$ ,($ $ )(D )( # #.I * * ,"#MI $ $ $"$ ) $ ? 9 (*! ? $ ) $ E $ ), ? ) $( $ ; 9
329 $$( $ ($($ " E, $ "(# G "$ $D )(E>D 9
59 D? ' D $ >) :=($(" ) G ($ $ $(!); 5 A$3886! @$ ) ! "# ()4>D! ) $# ( )$$? %# ( )$!4##($$5P>D : $95$9 $4P =9
- $E'$ )'($ )5P>D !# @G()( 30>? 3882: +56858P=! ) D? ) #$(!56G(? ! ) # $ $ $ D$# "$$$ @$ ) ) (D E $ >D $ $ ! ! ) '$$$ ) '($ ) ?J>D 9
- "#($# >D ))'#;$ ($@
39 G()( # $ D(( )) $) )P $ @ 3888: =$$ (? D 5 >? 3886!$ H$" ) G $ ) "@ ) # $ (D)) " ) 9- #"$( !# $)? *) $,## *) $M$ $ I(E" ; )# # * ;D## @ $? D " "$ U
758/873884 %P758% G $> ) *"$)($ " $ $# ) $: +568368 )95951 664 )95931 +53/2 )95931 +5302P0 )95!53P56P )92@$ (G( =9 ;D)# () *$E,## *$ ( ?);> ) $ (? D : +550/6 )9P@!5536P8 )9 21 5//Q W 60 #9 65P )9 6@=9 ; * ' # $( ) $ ? E' D )' ? ) $()(@$(53 ?"@ 3883$'$# D( $ $ '( 3886! . )')"$$ * '## * )'#;9$)"M"!);5 >? 3882!)) # $ ) ? )35" 3886" ) G $ G()( , ? ) $()5/> 5/4/ % :2;" (? =!); *)( ## $ ($( )50" 3884!$*) $) # $ $$ (? D 5 >? 3882: + ) 53 #$"@ 3884! 462782=! ($$ # ( ( * # # )(? ##( >*, 65 )("@ 3883 # > # ) "$ ; )(?$ ) , ? ) $( ?$ ? ) $(!* $ ,"# ) ) 2;" (? ) : +568624 )9692=9
69 $ >$( $"# $ )?$ > ) $ "#($$! $ ?@ : $94P95$9I93$P8 =9
29 *$ ) ?@ $( )' ## $ ) ' (! G "(5Q ?"@ 3882E' $ ))( )' $ "()58 A$3882#$ $ ? $!? ' ) $ D9
49 J$ ") $9PEQ !$ (#$( # $()$ ? $ $# $!$ $ # $ ! ) '#$ $) ) ' ( E "# ) # G ) " )'$ ? $( $ ? * #$ @"$ M$ J D( ) ! $$ # $ ($ )' $$ $ E $( #I. *! "$ #.I *9 )' # $( ) $ ? ) D ) (! '$ ? $( * #$ M$ J D( ) #$ ? )'$ # G )'$ ) " )'$ ? $(: $9P=9
$ (#$( # $()D $ $) " $ )'"@ )'# $ ) # @ $()D )' ( " I()$ ? (* @ () ) " )'$ ? $(! $$) " $ ($)'$$ $E$(#I. *!"$ #.I * $ *' # $ # ; $ $"$ $ " ) ()#$$ J D @: $90=9
$ (#$( ? ) $( ' # $( ) D $ $ # $ * $ # ("( # "$ ) D) (:95=9 (" $ ? $( $ ? $ (#$( ? )' # ($$$$ $E $(#I. *!"$ #.I * * # ? * # @@"$ # $( ) D $ $ # $ :9 3=9 ( "> * 'J S $ # )'$ ? $( $ ? ? )'M$ $$ $) $(#I. *!"$ #.I *$) $ #$M$ J D( *' J $ $ (#$( ? ) '$$ $"#MI)' "# $ ?JI@ $:96X $9Q=9
758/873884 %0758% P9 - ' $9 3Q 9 5 ) G()( , ? ) $( ) 5/ > 5/4/ : =)$ ? D >*'65)("@ 3886!' () $E $$ ; ' $ ? )EPP376R" !E)" % $' $ ? ) E48R" ! E* $) $' $ ? )E28R" 1) #( @!' (#$!)'# ;' $93Q95@ !# ($) )" % $ ' $ ? )E28R" 9
- ' $93Q95 !)$ ? D );5 >? 3882!' ( ) $E* $) $' $ ? )E28R" !E)" % $, $ ? )E48R" !E$ %* $) $, $ ? )EP8R" $E $$ ; ,$$ ? )E08R" 9
(? $J)' ? ) $(! ?*' ( $# @$ ' '($ $ # ? )$ "# (? *' # $ @$ J S$'$ ? $(* #$ @"$ M$ J D( ) # ; $ $"$ $ " ) ()#$$ ! " I()$ ? (* @ (: $95P =9
- > # )! $ )' ? ) $(! ) ) $ ) ! $ $ ( " * $ "() 1 $ (* ( " * @>$ ?)' # $(G $ *' "# $)'(? : + 558 304 )9 2! 584 380 )9 3=9 *' ) ' $ ? $( ) ' (! ) ( ( " * G $ )(G$! . ) G ) ) ()' ) "() !)" U# "$$$)'(? # $( ) $ ? ) ' $( ( ) ) $ ? $( @"$ J D @ : + 554 566 )93!58454Q )95=9
"# ) ? 'GG$! ;D D(( ! I GG $ J$"$*# @" $$))J ?$ G $$' ? '$ ! ) GG( # "$$$ ) $J )' ? ) $(9 " U ?#?$M$ I GG (J$"$! ) ?$M$ $ "( )'# ;(("$ )# $ !# ;* ' "# $ ? ## J "$ ? @$:"($I )D(( ) "# ) ?1 +53Q68 )951 +58256P )93$3@=9
(? D ), ? )! . ! G "("$E> # )@ ($@ ! ) (G( J ) ( $$ $ * : *M$ $ $ ) Y --Z= * , ( , # # ),$ ? $( $ ? : + 53P 0P )96@7$@@1-3883#9PQ )96@=9
* ?), ? )$(?( @)$$ $ * " .! $ "#MI"$ # # E # ) , ? ) : " $$ ( I) #! VD! ( ) ? ! $ $(7$(D ),$ $ ) (> $ $J ), #$ = J D$ * , () " $$ ) @$ : + 53P 0/ )9 4@7=9 $ ()$ ) ?$ # M$ GG$( ) " ; I("$ *! " ) ?$ $ "#$ ) ,"@ )
758/873884 %Q758% $ ) # $ ! $ ) @$ ) )($ " ! E # $ ) ) ($$ $ *! ?), ? )* # ($" J" ? ( " *J D @)$ ? $( "#$ @?# $()$ ? ( ) ), $( (: +53PQ8 )94@7@@=9)()$ D @"J "") 34 R $$ $ * # "$ ) $ "#$ ) ) GG( $ (("$ * #?$ G ?),$ ? $( $ ?: +53PQ8 )94@71 -3883#9P2=9
09 '#;!$ "() $( $E'J $)'# $() $ ? () $ ) ' (! ) $ ? $( (D; 9 ! $$$ 32 " 3886 * $ #$ J $ ? )#$(! E $"# # $ !( $$GG $ # $)I D92#$"@ 3886! "$ *'$ ? $(E48R)# $(D $# @9 G ! $) ) P > 3884 # @ ) (! "() % $ $$ ) $! ## ?( '## ( $ ) ?$ *' $ ? $( # $ ) I D ? ) $ )(#"$($ $ "#$ @!$ $# ( $*' # $) GG * #$ $! "#$ $ ) G "$ ) "B? $ " $ ?$ () $ E $ ? !# ("$J $ $ ? $(9
Q9 ?)* # (;)! . ) * $$"() "$ #$ E $ ? E 48 R ) $ ? $( (D; ! # $ ) I D! ? ) $)(#"$$( $$GG $9
/9 -'D $ ) '$ "$ ) )D ( )' ? ) $(! GG$( # ' $ "(! )' $$(# $!#$*'M$ G "(); *' $ $ "#$)'$ ? $( "#$ (#($ $ ?J (E48R3886!# )G 93Q,/269% *)()$ D @"J ")34R ($( #( (!@ $ $E ?? ? ) $()G 935,0809%9 "# ( * $ $ DD( 3886 ) G 9 4P,6QP9% % $ G 932!54)'I 3886X)D ()' ? ) $($)P5!4R! ) EP3R9
589 '$ E>$$ $ *' $ .( $ $E48R)5 ?"@ 3886 65 )("@ 3886 @ ) ' $9 3Q 9 5 ) $ ? D >*'65)("@ 3886$$ %* $) $ );5 >? 3882!## $ ) ?$ )' $93Q !? D ); 5 >? 38829
559 G ! $ ;D! ) ) ; ( $ ! * ($$ ) $(! $""$ # #.I *! $ DD ?( $ *, $ ) G $ $ $"$ #@)$ ? 9 $(D )!, $950 # (? $* $J )' ? ) $()@((G ) $@ $" ) G $ $@! $$! )' GG )")! (? ( # '? ! E ? D"$( () $ (*! ## "( :9 5=9 "M"! $ $ # $$ ) @
758/873884 %/758% )( ? $ )' )( $ ( G $! )' GG )")! D"$( () $ (*! ## "( $ ) $)(#) $ $ ID$ $@"$:93=9
"@); $!, $ "* ) $ ), (? ) $), ? ) $( $ ( (!) ,$ $( $ "(),$)")9 GG$! " ) G $ ) ,($$ ) $( ? # $( "$ E )( $$*(!#$M$ # "#$# @)(9
539 $$! #$*'M$ >$(9
758/873884 %58758%
1 * * * *
"
23/4/ 5 6// / 78 $+' *!9
4/
59 ( ?@9
" 4/
39 >$$9
69 G " # $ ) *' #?$ G " $ # ($ M$ ) )( ) 68 > ); $ G $ # # "")( ) ( @ G()( ) ! -IK T I G* P! P882 ! $ J"# 9 )( #$ M$ # D(9 "(" ) $< = ) * J$"$*)( $)( @$ $#))( $$*(1 @= J# # * " $ G $ " # ? )") $$ $ )( 1 = # $ D$ ) # ($$9 - "(" $ $ # $ (("$ ("( ( $$ = @= $ = %)! @G()( ) # #$ "$ ; *' )? )( ?@9"(" ) "$ " . ) # ?! * $ > $! * )( $$*( $ '? ## ) *($(J#() ( $: $9563!58P$58Q=9 D GG ; < # ( )$< .- (
# G ")# ($ M$$ $ G (J# $ *'E'GG G()( ) # D GG
758/873884