Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/1001/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/1001/2005 Généré par l'IA

Property Distribution Statute Due Process Violation

Numéro de cause ATAS/1001/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The lower court correctly upheld a finding that a statute governing the distribution of property upon dissolution of a marriage was facially unconstitutional as applied to the petitioner because it created an irrebuttable presumption regarding the disposition of property acquired during the marriage, which violated due process by denying a party the right to present evidence regarding the nature of that property. The court reasoned that while the state has a legitimate interest in simplifying property division in marital dissolutions, the absolute bar on introducing evidence concerning the character of property acquired during the marriage was an unconstitutional overreach that denied fundamental fairness guaranteed by due process, warranting invalidation of the statute as applied.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Distribution Statute Due Process Violation: The court reasoned that while the state has a legitimate interest in simplifying property division in marital dissolutions, the absolute bar on introducing evidence concerning the character of property acquired during the marriage was an unconstitutional overreach that denied fundamental fairness guaranteed by due process, warranting invalidation of the statute as applied.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
droit à la propriété partage de la propriété violation des droits de partie dissolution du mariage biens étatiques droit de mise en circulation

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The court ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
A/2102/2007
Marital Property Division Due Process Challenge
A/4211/2005
Statutory Interpretation of Marital Property Division
A/2157/2004
Marital Property Division Presumption Challenge
A/46/2006
Marital Property Division Upheld Despite Unconscionability Claim
A/2213/2003
Statutory Challenge to Property Transfer Restriction Upheld

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

               #$%&'#())' !#%))%#())'

!

* !+* "!,  *" ,"+

"- . /  0 1 . ())' 



 ! "



"

#   $%&'$!()"*+!,"-./0! "12 $.$$   $$





 2+!

           !"  

   *.3&*   $'   5  "6"2 (2,("  "" 786"   ( 96 " 5," : (,;12'  " ::2 ,9 (   ",: )(#2(2"( ",1(<#    =*,9>'

.'  (2 ( $4 ?" .%%-!    ":2 @ 82  (2 ":"6 , 82 .%%4! :5"  "" , ( @ 8 )3 3 3 #3 "@A.B04A:'!:(8(1""1,!( 1(:"(6,8""2:'61172,8# 8296 @ A%%B$44 :' , 82 .%%4' "" (2  ,,C"  ( 2("(/+-:'%-:6(82'

4' 82:12,,"("($+?".%%-!1":7 ( 6,:22.%%4"",1,"((2("(""  "" 62  "" (  ,26D ,: =.91 ,>! " A-B.-+:'.%!78(178@(-%E'

A'  (2 ( + ,"1F .%%-!    ?"2 8,," ( 82! (2" 78@ " (   " ( ("6 ( 8# )! ,,F 5 (2,("  1,D2!   1"2 ( "" " " (2("F'

-' 82  "?"2   $. ,"1F .%%-'  "" 78 ""  (2(" ( -% E! 8# ) 82" ( "5" (  G ( 11" 7  1,D ,6" (2(  """2 ( "" ,"! , 1,"  * 8296" @  1"2! 5 (5 "  5 " 7" (  "" HF'   ,"!  1"" (  "" 8296 @ 1 ( $% E ( 6 "! " @  "" IF"1" ,  IH ,  1,D ' 8" ,"!  ("" :" " (2,(" 6 1,D2 " (2,("  1,D2 8" , :(2    " 8H :" 6 8" &&  8" , ,""' B2  "2 86" (87J" " :(!@7"""2(""62.91," (2("F(6(2"1"'

&' 6"2@(2"1!,"2('







 ,+!



34$&-3.%%-  *43&*   $' H68H"?(=>2"21(:2"""2!(9 $K".%%4! F"(!1,2(-?H! (",2(""6*,2("!-,,2""$&?H="'$"' "-& >'

)"@8"(82"($&?H!, F:2(2 ./?6.%%A= #$4%$%&>!( H6(,"2!$4:26!  (,"""H",1""" F"(  ( 2H   @ " ?H ""! ! ( 8""" ( 82"(65?H'

.' :121"@B"'-&'$"'I'$! F"( C""7(""",26@8"-&( :2(2   ," H22 ( (" (   ( 0 "F .%%% = >7""6@:2(28*6"66"( .%(21F$+A&= )>'

)1,2",?H((8,9"2"F'

4'    ""2  6H $ ?6 .%%4! "C"  1(:" ( 1F (," 2H (  (1 (  ' )  ,1"2!,"(67("B,,7("J""I2@19 (,,79H,,F"6H11"L  :" ?(71" (2"1"  " ,(" = # $./  A&/ (' $! $.&  $4& (' AF "  2:2>'  6I!   7   ,2(!"@(2:"(9H"""!6("B,,7 26(9?("26H= #$$/+4('&F!$$. 4&% (' AG    $++0 M 4/ ,' 4$& (' 4F>'    " (9  ,,F(8,9'

"?"2(:1"(2,",!"6F="'-& "&% >'

A' "H,"7"(6(2("("", .91,("!@(-%E!":1@'

:121" @ 8"' + ' . "'   )! (  "  6H (9  $ ?6$++/!,(2"16,6"(8"6"2(2,("! (2(" ( 6 F"  61" , @ ( """ ( ,26D ,:( 1L,("@,"IF"1",  IH , 81,D'  2"F  " " :5 81," ( (2("(18"'+'."'@ )!(,"1"9 (81,;":2(2(""(2"1"=:'"'$0'$ )>'



34$&-3.%%-  *A3&*   )I::$%0-("6(8# )""("6 (2,(" " ( ,  "6"2 "6 ( 8 )!  "  =* ,9>!(2(":,265"'44!.$.".$4#,6" , J" ::"2!  (  ( "" )3 3 ! @ 85," (  ,  61" ,  .91 ,'  ,,!  "" "7I"(82("""(2("F""7 61" , ( (2,(" @ ( """ ( ,26D ,:'   (2,("!  "" " " (2("F (  1J1 ,," 7  ," 78 ," IF"1" @  IH ,,,,' "5(2,("1,D2!,H@ 8"' && ' $ !  1"2 ( "" " " (2("F =:' I:: $$%4"$$%A!"6H(9$?6.%%->'

-' "9H7""7862.91,,85 .%%4!"A-B.-+:'.%!,2""1($%E(6"G(9 71"",("","@""IF"1", IH ,  1,D ! :121" @ 8"' + ' .  )! ( " 78(6",6(2("""2(6(2"1"'1"( -% E :52 , 8# ) 82"" (  !  ( 11" 7  1,D ,6" (2(  """2 ( "" ,"!  1," ,  * 8296" @  1"2! 5 (5 "  5 " 7" (  "" HF' :!  "1 7  ("" ,22 ,  ("6 ( 8# ) "  (2,("61,D2"51,D2""@'

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

# " ( "" 7 8,," , H ( 8"' && ' $ .91 ,I  " :1 @   " 7  "!   7"2 ( , (2,("  1,D2!  ," (2( 7  1"2 (  "" ,  .91 ,! ," 7 ,( @  (1" ,  IH,1,D,2'

:(2!("J"?"2'





\\\\





34$&-3.%%-  *&3&*  

 " ,!+2  !+* "!,  *" ,"+



345   6  7   89 %&( , :

  5 

$' 26F'

 5

.' ?""'

4' "7,2("H""'

A' :1  ," (  78 ,6" :1  "  ,2" J" (  (2 ( 4% ? (9  ":" , , 11(2 (2  F :2(2 ( ! )IRTI:7 &! &%%A   !  " 51,'  (2  ," J" ,H2'  121 ("S > (7 5"1"7(2"(2F"",((2 ""72G F> 5, , 7 1":  "1 ,6 (1( "" " (2G > ,"  H"   (  ,2""' )  121  "" ,  " 221" 2122  "" > F> " > *(!  F:2(2(,,"1"978 (6(26F'121(1"1D ( ,6! 7 " ?"!  7  (2 ""72 " 86,, ( 72"25,2(2"="'$4.!$%&"$%0>'  H::  2("         Z(         

,:1(,2"J""":25,"78@8:::2(2 (,H::



34$&-3.%%-