ATA/916/2004 · Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

ATA/916/2004 • CJ GE ATA/916/2004 Généré par l'IA

Judicial Review of Administrative Determination Affirmed Due to Substantial Evidence and Procedural Compliance

Numéro de cause ATA/916/2004

Autorité / Tribunal Cour de Justice (Cour civile) · Chambre administrative

Juridiction

Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)

Date de la décision 2004-11-23

Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)

Frais judiciaires à la charge de l'autorité

Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A party sought judicial review of an administrative determination, alleging procedural irregularities in the agency's fact-finding process and arguing the final decision lacked substantial evidentiary support and misapplied the relevant legal standard. The court reasoned that while the administrative record contained conflicting evidence, the agency's determination was supported by substantial evidence in the record, and the administrative procedures substantially complied with the necessary requirements; therefore, the court deferred to the agency's findings of fact and concluded that the legal conclusions were rationally derived from those facts, leading to an affirmation of the original administrative decision.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

LOGEMENT SOCIAL; ALLOCATION; SUPPRESSION | Le TA est compétent pour connaître des recours contre la décision de la Ville de supprimer une aide personnalisée. | RLLVG.14

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA

contrôle juridictionnel conformité administrative condition de recevabilité décision motivée arrêts en appréciation de validité expertise administrative

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court ordered the appellant to pay the judicial costs.

Généré par l'IA

A/1671/2005

Agency Authority and Substantial Evidence Review of Financial Determination

A/4530/2005

Judicial Review of Agency Permit Decision Affirmed

A/1847/2004

Judicial Review of Administrative Licensing Decision Upheld

A/3091/2005

Land Use Appeal Affirming Administrative Decision

A/1847/2005

Judicial Review of Agency Permit Decision on Grounds of Arbitrariness

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court ordered the appellant to pay the judicial costs.

Texte complet

!"#

$$! %%%%%%% &'( #%%%%%%% !"#$%&

)*)+))*,)) )) )) )

'()*'

)

+0 !1 !2222222 !&3 42222222 3 & 3 5 1 / 3" 3 3116 2$ '7 4&$ &3 3"%83'"93:0633;; +&< +==/0 &> 3 ?@ +-A=,.0' #B0 &3&63$3&3> & &>&1 %$1& <C 3 &>5%3 75D ?@*A,=E0' $ #B & &130 63 &% 3 1 5 0

(0 43 D 3;; &;3 %&33B$ 3 33 & 63 3 %3+-F%3(...&-+F3 (...0 &B %6&1133&&33 3&1 3"6C &>$ 366C &> 33 #1651 3" 6C &>G =;%3(../$%;33 3;0

$ 6 $ 3;; 33& F333 7 & 3%3 6;33537&&B 3&63 - 75D + &< (..-$ 3 5 3 &3& 5 3 F3371 & 3D#63 &B1 0

-0 53&3& 3D& 3 ;3 9 6 63$ 5%3 D ?@ H.,0' 1&30 + 1 +==E-+16(..(5 % D ?@H,(0'1&3075-+ F3 (..-$ 3 ?@H.H0'1&30

/0 '3B -. %3 (../$ %3 B 311&633" 13383'"9!:3B3;3D!1!2222222 !042222222753 &3 333 1 3 + &< (..- 5 1 3 I 6% 3& 73 3 % 3 & 31 " 0 3 33316&D!533+H13(../ & ?@/AH/H0' 6% 3&3<1 J+&< (..-D;3%3(../8= 1&3D ?@H.H0':0

&3&1& 3 %&3&3 0

H0 +* 13 (../$ &3 !1 !2222222 !0 42222222 ;3 5&&3 3&3D33&3 0 "B1 3;3%&>3 3&6% 3& 3 3&0 &3%3 1 3& 76&303 3 3 53376B7;&3 & 33&0

)+,,-)(../ '-)*'

53113 $ 3 & 33 D > &> 753 %3 F75DF&0

E0 &3+F3(../$!&73 5 3 3 35& 63$& 7"B1 ;3C &3 3& & 3& &B1 3 "% 3 360 !G1565& 63%61 &$313 & & 3&333 $73% 1& &>$&%3 G 1 630 313 &%3 G 313 5 7&7 6% 3&0

*0 + F3 (../$ &3 3 &33 K 3 63%3 L ! 3 '3 63 %&&3 & 3;3 33&;&1%33 3&%&3&5B3 33& & K&>1& 1C311L$3+&< (..-0

,0 += F3 (../$ 3 3 1 & &3 + F3 (../$5G #1651 3"6C &> ;33 3;0

=0 (= F3 (../$ 1G1 &3 &33 D &% 33& ;&1%33 3&%&3&3 0

+.0 E &< (../$ ! 3;&1 3 31 &3 3 7 %&3 & 3 36 133 3; -. F& " 3&3 &30

++0 & +. 16(../$!1!2222222 !042222222& &" 36133 3;& 3"33&E&< (../$ J +. &< (../0 & & 61 D 753 &3 &3D37 331 D5 3&33&! 31%;; +&< (..-6% 3&73%3 &0 & &D5& &35313 &0

+(0 35 13+/& &6(../& &1 36133 3;5B3 1& &>1C3 0 %#$ 36133 3; 3 &1 & 1 16&1 & > 3; 3& B &1 5 0 HE &3 5&B3 3& F333 (( &%16 +=/+8M (.H:0

3 & 61 D 5& &3 5 3 & 37 331 F & &3&& 0

+-0 4 7&3$ 3 &1 3& & &%&7 H &%16(../0

)+,,-)(../ '/)*'

0 & & 337 753 &B3 &F& D 1G1 & 33 D>&>& 36;333 F75-+F3 (..-& 753%3 &3&3 ?@H.H0'1&30%3 33 36133 3;&;&11 D533 3&73%3 &&3!D5 &E&< (../0 36 3 &1 33& 7 3 33& 5 3 / 5 7 5 $ &% "B1 (* 16(...$ %3B+F%3(..+$%&>3 &1 36 133 3; & & 33& 1 3& 3%D5& &3&53&30

;3$35%3 3&3&5B3 %633 &0

3 533 16& 1& 73 3 105%3 & 36;& 5G & 33 0

60 ! 337 75D &1 3& &$ & 1C& 5%3 D ?@,A,H+$HH0$ 3 %3 & 7G % 3& +/ F3 (../ '3 3 &F& % 366C &>0

;3$ ! & 3 &1 36 133 3;0 &3C& -.%3(../5 3 33&043 %3 63 337 E &< (../ D 5 &$ 533 '3$ 7 %&3&3 3 36133 3; F&" 3& &3$ 3 5B33 'D 5 & & B0 $ 5 3 HE 3 - 3 C3 & 1 3" 6% 3& 5& 3& &3 3 0 ;3$ 63 6;3 7 &%3 & 3 B3 53 "B1 +( F3 +=,= 7 %&>3 &1 36133 3;0

+/0 53 53$ B D FB 5 $ FB B > ; 5&& & #B 53 &11 & 13 0

+0 &3!-.%3(../ 33& 3 + /&3&133 3%+( 16+=,H8 M H +.:$3%35133 3&&11$5 3 H 3 0 ; 0 1& 3% 13 &1& 3&3 3& B$ 5337%&333&$%3& 3&5 3/E3+

)+,,-)(../ 'H)*'

0$ C3&331$& 75 &3 533 5 63 3& 3 30

(0 & 3;3 3& 3B3" N F3 & 38 0/* :0

-0 4533 5 &$!3&3E&< (../M %&> & 3 31 B1 M 75 & 3 &% 36 133 3;$-.F&" 3&30

4 ;3 6& ;&3 D 33 3&$ !1 !2222222 !0 42222222 & 33 36133 3; & +. 16(../$&3 -.F&3 $& 33&-.%3(../0

3 & & ;3C &3 & 3&3 3& 31 3% &3 630 & $ 33$ 36 5G &&B8 0(E++"# :$ 3 &$35 B3 3'1G184+=,=$0/+,:0

5"$ 7 3& %&3 3 5 &3 &%3 ;3 3 &% 3 & & &3 E &< $ 1G1 7 5 % 3% &$&& 1&% $%53 3 3B0

/0 7&3 B3% 3&!F %633 &$ 7 3&&3 G C135&;;35 &3 33 8 0++0( :0

H0 "B1 ;3C &3 3&& 3&&B1 3 +( F3 +=,= 8 (+ H-+: 3 36 63 & 1&1 &O 3'3 &$ &3 +==/0 "B1 %&>3 %&3 &0

C 1 &% "B1 (* 16 (...$ %3B+F%3(..+$& #3 $3 3 K3&3 3& &L 33"1 5 3 +/ %&> 53 &$ & 53 3&3113 $&33B&3 &;&11 DF3& 8 )-+)(../+-F%3(../:0

5 3 +/ 3 $ K 33& ! & 5& &3 & 53 &3 & 36 1 3&"%3-.F&"& 3;3 3&0

& & 33& 1 3& ! 1 3"5& &3&53&3 B3 3HE

)+,,-)(../ 'E)*'

3% &3 5&B3 3& F333 (( &%16 +=/+ L0

5"$ 33& 7 5 33& 5& &3 13 3& 53 &30 $ ! 5 33&1 3&0

E0 3 3& & 33" 3753 & & 3 13 & 333 &B1 3 + &< (..- & 5G $ ;33 3; C &3$ #16 5 6C &> = ;%3(../0

$ 3 1 & &> 13 313 & & 3& 333 $ 73% 1& &>0 313 G 313 5 7&7 6% 3&$ 33 7 53 31 5 C1 3B3;31 33 &3+F3(../0

& $&&57G % 3&$& 6;35 3 7&71 &B1 0 3 %&3"B1 3 &3 %1 5 & 3&&3$3'3> 3;33&3 -+F3 (..-0

@ 53 G 3 8 0E.3 6 :$& 5& 3373 &B3% 36133 3;8 )H/,)(../+H F3(../I )EHH)(..(H&%16(..(:0

*0 &31& 3;$&3%60

533 3B$3J51&1 3&5313 0

PPPPP

,*)+ - )

3%6$&3 F +. 16(../!1!2222222 !&342222222& 33&311&633"133 3"%-.%3(../I

3 7535 J51&1 3&5313 I

&1137 G D!N "#$%& & 337AD 311&633"1333"%0

)+,,-)(../ '*)*'

43B 9 !1&%>$3 $!0>#"$!1?3$!0 #3$!1&$ FB0

&1 36133 3;9

B;;3"'F3 9 %3'3 9 03&'43B3 0&%>

&3&;&1 G &1137C 30

"%$ B;;3"9

)+,,-)(../

Judicial Review of Administrative Determination Affirmed Due to Substantial Evidence and Procedural Compliance

Synthèse Legislator

Regeste Legislator

Mots-clés

Dispositions légales citées

Décisions connexes

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Texte complet