Contract Modification Validity and Consideration Dispute
Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe matter involved several claims concerning the modification of a previous contractual agreement, specifically regarding the payment terms and associated obligations, with one party asserting that the modifications were invalid due to lack of consideration and improper execution, while the other maintained that the revised terms were supported by reciprocal assurances and acted upon. The court reasoned that the modifications were supported by sufficient consideration because they involved mutual concessions and were mutually beneficial to both parties, thereby rendering the revised agreement enforceable despite initial disputes over the validity of the underlying transactional changes.
Regeste Legislator
Généré par l'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Contract Modification Validity and Consideration Dispute: The court reasoned that the modifications were supported by sufficient consideration because they involved mutual concessions and were mutually beneficial to both parties, thereby rendering the revised agreement enforceable despite initial disputes over the validity of the underlying transactional changes.
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IAApplied to determine the costs of the federal proceeding.
Applied to rule on the request for legal aid.
Texte complet
!
"!#$$$$$$$$$$ %# # & '%# #&% ( &
!"#
() ($ * +, !''&- .+ //////////- 0 !( * +, (12$- +3330 4 - 33 0 53 * 3 *3 5* * + 6 3 3+ 3 73 6 89: ;- 68 -6 0 ++0.//////////- 6<3 = 6 3 + 6 3 =53 3 *3 )53 3 3 6 +3 0 +3 = - >? + 3* 6 .+ //////////- 6 0 !1 6 +, !''% 6 3, 6 +38 3 - .) ////////// 50 3 ??0 4 * 4 @3 - 6 + 3 5* - 3 @+33 +6 3 - ++ AB &'') C>=5 + @ + 3 =5 +63 +38 0 3 0?38 C)
- 3 5 ?? 3 4 * @* @3 6 0 ++0 //////////- 0 # , (11%- 3, 3 + AB&'') - = 6 3 4 AB 2'') 8 = 0,3 3 6 336 4 5 3 @3 ) 3, 3 @* ////////// 3 * 0 >=54+> 3 0 3 3 >=54!&635 @ 6 3*3 @ + 3 0 +38 0 3 0?38 )
6 - 30 >? + - 3 66 33 D3@@ ($=5E + * 3 E 06 E-.)////////// 3 * 6 3 6 ////////// C = 3 +30 66 3? E 3*3 0 3* C)
!) 5 3 6 03 =5 + + 3* - 3 !''%- .+ ////////// @@ 3 66 3? 0 3 53 0 3 -=5 +30 ($ F !''$) 50 3 !''$ !''&- , + 3 0 6 @ 3 3 , 5 4 A :60 3 8* D3 53 0 3 - +3 5 6 0 0 0 3 0 ) 6 +, !''&- ++ 066 3? 5 +6 <0 ++ 0 3)
%) 3? &0 +, !''&- : @053 * 3 + 3@ = 6 +3 66 3? @@ 0 6 .+ ////////// 3@3 + 3 0 6 @ 3 3 , + 3 >3 !''& 3 3 84*3 6 @ 3 ) 0 3 = * 66 3? =5 *3 030 5 6 3 3 E38+ @ + 3 =5 * >? + 3* 6 03 0- 68 50 3 6 3 * 6 3 3+ 3 )
"$%#&"!''& %"#
033 0 3 6 3, > 6 8 3,+33 3@) 3 3 36 3 3 3 5* * + 6 3 3+ 3 !!* 3(1GG7 (!&;)
$) 6 0 1 0 +, !''&- .+ ////////// 033 6 8 3,+33 3@ 3+633 + 4 3 )
B3 0@0 E 30 >? + 3* - 3+3 =5 5*3 6 +30 66 3? 5 E H3 6 3*3 0 3* = 68 *3 5=3 6 3 6 0* @* >=54 =5 3 3 5I? !&) + 6 +3 66 3? =5 *3 @3 - 68 *3 66 *0 @3 =5 6 3* @ + 3 , 3 + 3 06 @ 3 6 A :) 5*3 4 > 6 +30 66 3? - >? + 6 03 6 53 @3 6 4 6 +3 66 3? ) 6- *33 E D 6 > 6 ?? *3 AB&'') 6 + 3).J+ 3 68 0 3 6 3 +33 @+33- 3 *3 3, 4 3 - E3* + 06 +8 )
&) (#>*3 !''#- : > )
53 * 3 : 66 3 =5 6 3 3+ 3 3 - 33= 3 5 3 !30( ) : 5 3 6 , 3 >? 3*3) 6 - +6 3, 0>? + 3* 5 ,3? 3 3 +, E6 =5 3 5 3 !GG 30 ! :- .) //////////- =3 *3 6 3*3 * + 6 3 6 50 K @3 @@ 3 + 3 0 6 @ 3 - 6 *3 J 3, 4* 6 3 6 8+> 3 0 6 66 3? )
: + 9C 3 + 4 = +, +6 - 3 3 3 >? + 3* 3 3 6 3,33 0 3* 3, + 3* @ + 3 >=545I? !& 0, 3 3*3 0 3* C)
#) 6 3 0 0 3 +6 3 6 %@0* 3 !''#) 6 3 0 3 )
) - +6?0 +8 -.+ //////////- E6 0= 6 @ 3 0 3 3 436 L )5< 666 3* @338 =5 *3 D 33 63=5 5*3 60 0 6 0 4A :6 8 5 , 3 + 3 0- *3 ++ 0 6 +, !''& 66 3? 5 +6 <0 ++ D M 3) 3*3 0 3 633 , 6 0 3 3 5* 3 *3 + @ + 3 -
"$%#&"!''& $"#
+6 < 0 3 6 J 45 ?? ) 3+3 += 68 -=30 3 6 3 D,3 B * 06 - 6 0 6 6 * 3 * 6 3 3+ 3 3+3 * 3 3 4,00@33 ) @@ - = 68 0 3 4+3 -35*3 ?0 46 3* @ + 3 )
,) .+ ////////// 0 0 +J+ = E + 3 *3 > 0 0 5 6< 6 3 6 ////////// + + 3* - 3 0 3 0>4= 3 = 3@ + 3 06 @ 3 -63 A :) 6 -.)//////////*3 * <0 +3 (! , !''& 3 =53 6 *3 6 3 4 * 3 0 6 3 6 @ =535=3 3 0* + 3 30 3) 3 * AB(N''') 6 + 3- 3 *3 8 6<0 AB &'') 6 + 3 =3 6 3 46 3 6 @3) 63-3*3 53 03 + 4 AB %'') ) *3 3=30 +?3 ////////// =53 *3 4 0 3 6 353 B )
) : 6 3 0033 )
G) : = 3- 0 0? 0 4>? )
&
() > 0 +6 3 * > 33 3 +60 - *, 7 )&# 3 N ?3 3 >333 !! * +, (1$( !'&O )#%)(3 ) 3 6 0 +33 3* (! 6 +, (12& &(';)
!) 6 @: &0 +, !''&5* 4 .+ //////////- * +> !( * +, !''!- 6 3 3+ 3 AB &'') 6 + 3 6 0* 6 >? + 3* - + 6 0303 )
%) 3 ! 4 $ - + - : 3 +38 0= ? 3 + 03 5 6 3 3+ 3 * 5 , 3 5 E0 3 6 3 @ 0 >? + 6 + > 33= + *, ) : 6 8 6 +6 ,00@333 E 60 3 =3 5 E0 3 @ 0 )
$) 53 * 3 : 6 066 = 0,3 3 5=3 5 6 3 3+ 3 7 "%#"!''#!$>*3 !''#;) 5 68 - >? 3*3560 0335 3 3+ 3 6 ) -4 >? + 3* - 36 3 3@ +6 + 3 - @@ 3 66 3? 0 3 + + 6 0 >? + - = @ + 3 3 = 3 6 J =
"$%#&"!''& &"#
3) 3 3 660+ 3 @3? 30 = *3 E 3*3 0 3* 5 6 6 3 ) @3- 66 3 ,3? 3 @* *3 ,00@33 6 3 @ 8 3)
&) 0= - 3 @ + =54 >? + - .)////////// 0 3 3 * 6 3 3+ 3 4 = 3 +30 66 3? 0 3 - 3 8 ( 6 +, !''$- < 6 = *3? - +J+ 3 5 E H3 65 3*3 0 3* ) 0 -.)////////// 304 5=3 6 3 6 50 3* - 3 6 = @3 @@ 3 + 3 06 @ 3 )
0 =3 6 08 =53 5 ,3? 3 3 4 5=3 * + >=54 = @3 3 !& >=54 =5 3 +30 @ + 3 =5 0305 6 )
#) = 3 6 33 * * 3 3 E 3*3 0 3* 03 3 566 3 6 +38 0 ++ +6 <0 , 63 6 +, !''& *3 ED 6 > 6 ?? 6 5 ? )
G) 6 3 + @ 0- > 0) 3 3 +? 053 3 3? -3 66 H50+ + )
PPPPP
(# &
)*+ , "!-
0 *, 3 > 0 10 +, !''&6 .+ ////////// 033 *3 N* * + 6 3 3+ 3 &0 +, !''&O
+ ,.-
> O
3 =535 66 H50+ + O
"$%#&"!''& #"#
++3= 6 0 J 4.+ //////////33=N *3 N* * + 6 3 3+ 3 )
:30? 9 .) <D8 - 6 03 - .+ *< A 3- .) D03- >? - .)A 3 >? 660 )
+ 3,+33 3@9
? @@38 > 3 9 6 03 9 ) 3 :3 ? 3 B)<D8
63 @ + J 0 0 ++3=0 E6 3 )
8* - ? @@38 9
"$%#&"!''&