ATA/90/2005 · Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

ATA/90/2005 · Negligent Vehicle Collision Liability Affirmation (Cour de Justice (Cour civile))

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A litigant sought damages for injuries sustained when a vehicle, allegedly operated negligently, struck their automobile, resulting in physical harm and property damage; the court, after reviewing the evidence regarding the accident's causation and the extent of the injuries, determined that the evidence sufficiently established the defendant's breach of the duty of care, leading directly to the damages claimed by the plaintiff, and therefore affirmed liability.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Negligent Vehicle Collision Liability Affirmation: A litigant sought damages for injuries sustained when a vehicle, allegedly operated negligently, struck their automobile, resulting in physical harm and property damage; the court, after reviewing the evidence regarding the accident's causation and the extent of the injuries, determined that the evidence sufficiently established the defendant's breach of the duty of care, leading directly to the damages claimed by the plaintiff, and therefore affirmed liability.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA

violation par négligence du devoir causalité de l'accident action en indemnité délit de fuite lésion corporelle simple assurance RC des véhicules à moteur

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Imposed costs due to the dismissal of the appeal.

Généré par l'IA

A/3469/2007

Negligence Action Affirming Liability for Vehicular Collision

A/3076/2007

Negligence in Motor Vehicle Collision

A/2669/2007

Negligence Liability Affirmation in Multi-Party Accident

A/3747/2005

Negligence in Motor Vehicle Collision Upheld

A/1267/1999

Negligence and Liability in Traffic Collision

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Imposed costs due to the dismissal of the appeal.

Texte complet

!"#

$%%%%%%%%%%% !" #"$%&

&

& & '& &( )* +&

'()*'

&

/0 1 /2 3 /,,($ & 4" 5% && 6 4& !07777777777$"&8"& 9"8 4:"& " &" &; "& <; 4" 0 4: "& " " "& 4 " .2 <";; / " ( & " (/ 3= /,2> ? ' # 2//0@ &&&4" 3 4" ="3 &"0

""& "3A4: "B<" "9;" & CA 4" "& 3 9 "% %" &$ /> 3= /,,/$ 3"5 A "%$ 6 9 "& %&" " 4" &3&3 " $"&& 3 $A%3 " ="90 " 94" 3 4 " "&%"3"A 4 "0

CA4" "&%" "!077777777773 &%&" " "&3 3& &33DEA/F$4 A % 3"$ ; & 3&B 4 ;&< 4 " ":$ ; 6 1 3&B 4 6 &":$ " ;&G %"&33 &%A"3&=&"$& && %4 B=& ;0

(0 ""& + 3 (--/$ &" %" B<" "9 ?"'

5H #@ && % 6 4" 4" 3 " "& 4 ".2 <";;/ "( !0 7777777777"" <&" "6 ""9'0

20 $!07777777777B ;A" ""9& &%6 4&& " % 9 " 41 " 6 " & &3$ #$&&&%""&(/;%"(--($&;"3""& .3(--($&&" A "&!07777777777" 3 6 "& <3'&&0

.0 /F 3=(--($!07777777777$4" 3""&&"$ &"" %64"3:;"41 ;A"9$& B4&"A"$&B&"%&" 3 0 &" =A4 "&64""4"4%" " 33""&% ;" % 4 " &"" "&$ A "& 3"&'C""9 #& !077777777776:"$4" &<" & 6' "9C&3" 9 I" % 36" AJE9 <3K "%4 & A"90

)((+,)(--. '2)*'

33= # B &" 9 !0 7777777777 " && J"A"$ &%& $ %&" A"; ;&" " 4;; &A3 K 9 & 3": "38 4 ="" 3"& "& 4 ""9 4" $ # C "5 91 !0 7777777777 ""& > %" (--20

+0 % ; #&" 691 &%: " B<" "9 !0 7777777777 <& & &$ & &" &$ /. C" (--2$ &% 3 % 6 4" 4" 3 & # " 2/ C" (--2$ & &;"3 & ;4&&&%: "0

F0 * 3=(--2$A "&3"&'C""9 #& !0 7777777777$ 9 &% &=& $ "& & 9" "9!07777777777%" ="&C 4 "%" I" % 9 # 4 3 "5 % <&" " "&6""9'0

3(--.$&"!07777777777" 3% 64"4" 3 0

(C"(--.$ # ";&39 I" " 3&"4""!07777777777:C&3" "% 4 &A33 " "& &" &;"& & 313 94 "" A4 " &6&" 0

>0 /-C"(--.$!07777777777 &&" A "& 3"&'C""9 #0 3 & =" 6 &"& /. C" (--. &3'3 "$ !0 7777777777 6 &"& J "& "A"$ 5 &C "; 3&3 &L90 3& "= 4" & "& " & 6 ; "&0A" 6'""33" 3 4A"%" 0&%" A";$ !0 7777777777 ; & & % "0 3= & 3 "=A99" "&9&" % K0

!0 7777777777 B "" ;" 94" %&" 6 <3'&&$3"6'$9A "&3"&'C""9 # 4 %"$ "3 9 !0 7777777777 4B " 1 $ ""3 " 94" %" %&""96 4<M" & 3"" 3HJ % 4%& "& ""9 9 !07777777777 & &A & " 3 B<" "9 6 "& <3'&&$ A "& && %& & 4" "" 3K0

)((+,)(--. '.)*'

*0 %" 6 3"& $&"!07777777777% /+ &N (--. 9 4" " 1 6 &;&3 &A33 < "9 9" " " 6 ""9 ' "" 946 " I" < 94" 4A"" 4 = " 6 & & A"90

,0 2 &%3= (--.$ !0 7777777777 & 5 "= 3"" "; & ""& " F 3= (--. # ; %34" 3 $""&G.& &=(--.0 "&" "; " 9 # &" 3" % 6 4"""&""3"0

& &$ !0 7777777777 &"" 6 " = 94 &%: "B<" "9&" && &;"63": " &5%$4: ""%3& 6/,,/0

$!07777777777" "9""& 99 #4 " &&%64"34" 3 94"4%" &"" $3"% "3'"0

;"$ " &"A &3=" " " &: & 9 # 3 " 4 94" =;""" 6 <3'&& 4 " 3 9 & " 6 3" " " "& " " 3 $AE6%64"" 3$41 " 6'0

/-0 %" 6 3"&$ #&3"5&"9 /+3=(--.94"4%" 4&=% "&6;&3 ;" 6 &" " 3" 3 4: " & &0

//0 &9$/+3=(--.$CAA" #=" %&&"&& 9 "&0

/(0 (/ 3= (--.$ &3'3 " & 9 #%" ; ";"634: "9""%" 3 &O " " &3& 4: $ 6 313 3" 4%& "&4 !077777777770 &"%HJ & ;&"$ 4A" 4 & &$ & %&B& &=C "& 6 94&%: "&" &&0&&& &&9 6%& ""&6 AK0

/20 &" &" " &3& " 4: " "" " "%$ " & "; 6 4 % /- C" (--.$ "5 & 9"&"!077777777779"&" >C%"(--+0

)((+,)(--. '+)*'

/.0 &" /2 C%" (--+$ CA A 9" 4& &0A3 " "&33"9&34 % : <& &0

/+0 & 3" "=3"" ";A;; &C "/,C%"(--+0

/F0 CAA&3": "&3 " &&3=6B$ "'"4 1 6;& "&&33: 0

"& ""94%&" "&6&& 0

3""&4: " &3": "0

&" & &<" $ &" /. ;%" (--+$ 9 " 3""& &" &3 & 9 4: &" "%" 6 "" "A3 5!3H

' 0!7777777777$" "JE9 K$

' <0 777777777 7777777777$ &= 9 <3" 4 I" $

' 07777777777$" &"6 <3'&&$

!0 7777777777 "= & % &;"& 6 &A0

#$ " ""9 4%&" 4&=% "& ""5 6 ;&30

/>0 #9&"$ A6CA0

&

/0 C 3 " % C"" "& &3 $ & %=? 0+F &"P&A" "&C"""((&%3=/,./' ' (-+Q 0F20/" 0&" &3"" "%/( 3=/,*+' ' +/-@0

(0 !A &"& "%$ & 4" 5% &&$ /2 3 /,,($ 4" 3 !0 7777777777 " "& 4 ".2<";;/"( #& 9&%"& " ;" $ " 3 &" 6 "& <3'&&$ ="3 B65%? )F.()(--((,& &=(--(@$

)((+,)(--. 'F)*'

&4B &C& ";" 6&="A "&&& "& " ="3 " " 0

20 # 4 &" &3 & 33 &3 ;"64" 3 && &""= "&64"? 0/- 0 =&"4" "& # 4 &";3 "5/.3/,>+R # ./-@0

"= "&64" 1 &&"64&"A"3 R&" 4&3"B<"9R"0

.0 "= 3"" "; 4"3& " 4A" 9 "& <"9 & 3" &9 4 &" " "3 &3&$ &33 45$ "" "& &3 9" ? )()(--/,C%"(--/ C"" @0

#$&3&":3"$& 9 B<" $4";"3"5 B<" "$43A" &"3A" &%&"C"""$: %& : %"&":$B<&&A&&;"& $ A" " && & A "&$ ; % 4" 3 9 9" !07777777777 4 3"$"&" "; ""& 9"91 4: ""%64"$&33 """C ";&30

+0 & &"" : " B<" "9$ ;; 6 C&3& 6/,,/ 33= #4& $ 3" & 4 " /- C" (--.$ 6 &"A 9 " 3 &"A 6 !077777777776"& <3'&&4 9 &3139 &;$4 &" " "33" " 3& 3 " 4" "" 0

F0 &" "&$"S "4&= " 4: : "3""3"A%&"%""& "4%& "&4 !0 7777777777 " "& % && %64"$ 94 9"0

>0 &9$ "= && : " 9" &;" " &&3=$ " 4B ;" %&" "&0

: 3""& 4: " ;" 4&=C "&" "; ""& &3" & &= "& : "0 &3 & "91 &33 "& /.;%"(--+$ 4: &% " " & &" & 3 "&&"$& 93"5 &""53" "= ;& "&A3 0

)((+,)(--. '>)*'

*0 9 "&;"4: "%C946&" CA;&0

TTTTT (& , &

-./01

%=&" C 2&%3=(--.!07777777777& ""& &"%"B<" "9F 3=(--.Q

!2.3.4"1

&&: "Q

&;" " &&3=$ "" U!V B<" "$ &3""" +2$ =&%U&1 $/--,BQ

" 93""&"% H

@ &" &" & )>>*,),/ & )((+,)(--.Q

=@ :3"!07777777777 "& <B"9 3 Q

@ ";&3 "& & &3& 3 $ & "&$ " "& &$ 0$ 5 & & "= & "A3 "Q

@ ="& & :9 "&"% H

/0 "&& 3 $!07777777777&3&3 '"A%3 " ="9W 4;;"3 "%$ '" " 4" &%"3"A4 "W

/=0 "&& 3 $!07777777777 ' '" 5 A: & "'313W 4;;"3 "%$ '" " 4" &%"&3"AW

(0 %64"34" 3 '%"A=W

20 & ;;"3 "% 6 9 "& $ 6 9 &" "&W

)((+,)(--. '*)*'

.0 ""$ 3&" '1 "%"54 " <A 3= &" % " "& &"W A$ & "& 4 "%" 6 & "& 3 B<" " "4<=" "&4" '9 W

@ ;" & AA "& )&& "& "Q

%& ;"4: "C946&" CA;&Q

" 9$ &;&33 : " ,> "% &" ; P&A" "& C"""$ 1 1 & $%&"&&" 3"" ";$ ":C&5& ";" "&$% "=;Q33&"& &" ""9 &"&$ 3& "; 3&B % & "A & &&3 "Q"&" 1 &":3"3&" "= ;$ /--- /. Q 1 "5 &"& & $"%&9&333&B%$&"% 1 C&" 6P%&"Q

&33"9 1 6 ! " #"$ %& & $ &" %"B<" "9""94 " &&3=0

#"A H !3 &%B$ " $ !0 B<5$ !3 V"$ !0 <"$ CA$ !0 &&$CA

&3 "=3"" ";H

A;;"5'C" C0H %"'" H !0 &&" 0&%B

&"&;&3 1 &33"9: "0 5%$ A;;"5H

)((+,)(--.

Negligent Vehicle Collision Liability Affirmation

Synthèse Legislator

Regeste Legislator

Mots-clés

Dispositions légales citées

Décisions connexes

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Texte complet