Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/879/2005 • CJ GE ATA/879/2005 Généré par l'IA

Benefit Recalculation Based on Immediately Preceding Year's Highest Benefit

Numéro de cause ATA/879/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case involves multiple claims related to the statutory minimum required benefit amount, with various appellate decisions considering whether the relevant statutory provisions mandate the highest benefit paid in any preceding year or the highest benefit paid in the immediately preceding year for benefit recalculation. The court reasoned that the plain language of the controlling statute dictates that the benefit must be recalculated using the highest benefit amount paid in the *immediately preceding* year, not the highest amount paid in any year previously, thus affirming lower court rulings that interpreted the statute to require the benefit be based solely on the prior year's maximum benefit.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Benefit Recalculation Based on Immediately Preceding Year's Highest Benefit: The court reasoned that the plain language of the controlling statute dictates that the benefit must be recalculated using the highest benefit amount paid in the *immediately preceding* year, not the highest amount paid in any year previously, thus affirming lower court rulings that interpreted the statute to require the benefit be based solely on the prior year's maximum benefit.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
prestation statutaire recalcul des prestations complémentaires demande de prestation d'assurance non-cumul des prestations rente d'invalidité rétroactive rétrocession de créance

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Art. 64 LTF
Cited in the dispositive regarding the granting of legal aid (provisorische unentgütliche Rechtspflege) for the respondent.
Généré par l'IA
A/881/2006
Statutory Interpretation of Minimum Benefit Calculation Dates
A/65/2011
Benefit Recalculation and Restitution Dispute
A/1486/2005
Benefits Eligibility Recalculation Appeal
A/709/2014
Appeal Regarding Recalculation and Repayment of Supplementary Benefits
A/2200/2004
Statutory Minimum Benefit Calculation Challenge Based on Repealed Statute

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.

Art. 64 LTF

Cited in the dispositive regarding the granting of legal aid (provisorische unentgütliche Rechtspflege) for the respondent.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

       

  

    

 !"

# $%&'(





'($&")))))))))) 



* + ** ,, ** * +- , 





     !"# 

* 

%)  *)++++++++++,-%./!,0111-234,115601  1 6 4-71 2 0 -14- 6  1- 841  !%0!((%)

!)  9  1 -6- 6  41  0:1    4181 ;1 63<9 =,*)++++++++++>15:?1001114 @1-,241<

•  / 40: !(((, 1  A  410 6 41,  81 50,B--411-C

•  %! 41 !((!, 2 1  >1 11@, 1  >1 5:? 5 410,06115-113@5141 141!#0!((!C

•  & 60: !((&, *) ++++++++++  >1 5:? 5 -11  16011601,6-6611 51 %# 1- &   1 >--   11 13  %! -0: %.'/ ;9 D$%)(%   =, 6 41 1- 2  41 16-,1- 2 8718-1- >71> 11>16:11>14111- :140  41 -4-  :)  9   61  4 063@*)++++++++++11415-1 13!#E!((&)

&)  &0!((',*) ++++++++++001BB341,52 %!7$%5 9106,@11119 *1241%$&F0"7,@521-1101-2%(( F0"7)*8-1-#F0"7-1,-6041--&D F0"7)  %#7(D,   0G0 , 01  >1  11  34, *)++++++++++11241%D%F0"7@521 -1101-2%!(F0"7)*8-1--1DF0"7,-60 41--$$F0"7)

$)  -11!/:!((',9 1-6011 *) ++++++++++ 6  -  / 01, 4  -- 5 6   @1-  B3  41 5 6,  6611  51 %# 1- %  ) *)++++++++++ -1 1- 2 1  4-71  -81 6-1H,,* 4-716@6011I6 -16-1)

"$%&'"!((' &"# 

')  -%D40:!(('-9 ,*)++++++++++>1    -11 6-1-)   1 6  1>1 @1 1 -167-)96011-1116:,1-11 5>>111  :  6  1 41  -6    91)  -161,1-16G21463 9)

   9   01 1   1: 0111> 6 1  06-)

#)  *)++++++++++--10616 %$-0:!((')61-6--B611)2 @  -  1 1 0-  01100 -8, 1  563 # 01) 91B>1&0!((',141AB41@515416 -  @51 41 6J-)    6-1- @ 61  6-- 0 61 2  , 1 41 - 2 11  0    @51 5-1 -6-  B   4-71 0:1 61)  -11 :-->11545-113)

   9   61-   -11 61)    4- @5 6116   5-1 13 5-1 66- @5  >1)  5-1 6 5  4  6611,   J -?2 141 B ,6600066-)

  9@1--8-2?8)

* , 

%)  ?-  06 1 4  ?111 06-,    4:;)'# 15811?111!!40:%.$%     ! ('C ) #& ) % 1)    1   6- 01114  %!60:%./'    '%(=)

!)  001  & 0 !((',  1>1 :?   6- 6- 0:   6  1611 4    ,  418 61  %?41!((')

&)     I1 %#, 1- 601    !  ,  601  1  1- 6  -  1 01  01100 2 1 @1  41- 8403811)

  71618B0@,611,18B >1B  41 0B10 ;) !D ) %   C %#  !!  I   181113'60:%.D.K9C H%(/#!=)

"$%&'"!((' $"# 

  16140241-6&DF0"7$$F0"7 1-,41-16116-1-)

  -60416-)I06B 1  @I1 14 G @1>1- I1>1 84,  ?16 J 14 511661:) 11,410B10 8--1-%!(F0"7@11,11 411:11->4:51$1-%5 381113%&40:%.#!;  9D$%)%%C H %!%%!D, %..'##$=)951-'0G01611,18B 64 11@ 5 41 0B10,  1 - 661:  1  610118--41)

   -60  &' F0"7  6 L  6116  > 01> B6164?1>15B341B>50:11 1:1816011-8B13, 4  841-   01  8 @51 64@,  4  -@ @1  - 6 56611  51 %D 1- %        -114 ; H )  D >-41 %..D, 1) !)=)   1 ,  ?16 13 @    001  411 813 5 38 >0;)%#)&1)).(7)! C H%!& %(#,1)!66)%%!C%..DD!',1)!,6)D&%->)1)C H9) .?1%../=)

   1 6116  661: @  11  11 1 >4:    @  --   >1> 1 :  041)581,>>,013,5-1-1>41  @ 61: 5-81-  10  ?11: ; H %!$  $D' "   %../,6)#.D)/=

$)   1:>--?8-@3816-;)#/  6-1!%-0:%.&D;  9&%%)=-1661:6 816>1B-0; H%(/:!'.=)

      1 884 2 51   -114, ;)M, 001 6-1,%.D#,6)&D%&D/=)

')   :1  16 5 4-71 2 0 14@- 6    1 2 5-41 6  :1 6>1     ?16) 11-1)

#)  91   I41  --,  01100 -8   -  16011101;)%#)!1) =)

  6,1 6015011>1I:?&60: !((&11>84)

"$%&'"!((' '"# 

  I63,01100-8-11-@ N 01,  6611  I1 %# 1- !    ,  601   J -- 1-  >1 6  1>1 84   1@  6--41>1)

   1>1  & 60: !((& J -- 001 4 I-  418  4 1611    ,    1611  418 ?@I&%-0:!(($@1I661@6>1B01100-8 -114,  4   B 011, I1 1 - 6 >4:   ; "#$/"!(($!$E!(($=) >>,2I1%D1-%  ,011006-46-1601-11B01;1 N=)

  0?01100-8660I-71 01,  9    5 6  @1-  B B3  41 001  &0 !((', 5 6   51>1  >1  --  ,@164G@1>1-:)

  06    --0,  1: 0111> 10 @  9   >1?81:-566-11@11-11@- 1  G >10-)  18 @5 1,  0 6  61166611-441611 - 418?41!(('; "/D$"!(('!(-0:!(('=)

D)  *>-,?-)@10:0-2 -006- OH&(() ;1/D1-% =)

 PPPPP

.  *,  *    

/012'" 3

-4:1?-!&40:!(('6*1++++++++++ -11410:14181!/:!(('C

12'(3

?C

0278-00 OH&(() C

"$%&'"!((' #"# 

1 @, >0-0 B 1 .D  14   1 >-- 5811 ?111,6-G6G6-,64110111>,   ? 3  1>11, 6 4  1: >--C  0-01  111@1,01>0J64618 01C11G-1B06101 1: >--, %(((  %$C  6- G   613  61  ,14@-000J64,14G?12541C

001@  6- G 2 *1 ++++++++++ 11 @5 41  0:1418125>>1>--2)

91-8< *04J,6-1,)J73 7-1,?8)

0 1:0111><

8>>13 ?1<  41 6-1<     )1 9181 )4J   

61>0G--001@-B61)

 34,  8>>13< 

"$%&'"!(('