Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/856/2004 • CJ GE ATA/856/2004 Généré par l'IA

Property Owner Liability for Ice-Related Slip and Fall

Numéro de cause ATA/856/2004
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case concerned whether a property owner was liable for injuries sustained by a guest who slipped and fell on icy pavement due to melting and refreezing snow, despite the owner having taken measures to clear snow and ice. The court reasoned that a property owner generally has a duty to maintain their premises in a reasonably safe condition, and this duty includes taking reasonable steps to correct or warn of known hazardous conditions like ice accumulation from natural weather patterns; however, the court found that the evidence demonstrated the owner acted reasonably under the circumstances to address the snow and ice, and therefore, the owner was not liable for the resulting fall.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

DOMICILE ELU; NOTIFICATION; PROCEDURE | Mandataire professionnellement qualifié.Election de domicile.Notification irrégulière, le délai de réclamation n'a par conséquent pas pu commencer à courir. | LPA.46 al.2; LPA.47

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
responsabilité du bailleur lésion corporelle par chute régime de propriété administration des preuves garantie du vendeur circonstance atténuante

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The court ordered the appellant to pay the court costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/904/2005
Property Owner Negligence in Slip and Fall Case
A/2243/2007
Appellant v. Property Owner (Premises Liability/Open and Obvious Hazard)
C/27551/2010
Shopping Center Owner Liability for Slip and Fall
A/2239/2006
Premises Liability Slip and Fall Notice Dispute
A/1168/2007
Premises Liability for Defective Step

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court ordered the appellant to pay the court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

        

 

      

 !





   "  #$# " $ 





#"  " # " $$$#"$  $$% &' 



(&(()(  !! ""# # 





     $%&'$

$   

(#  ,# # # -#. !  ()/+. !010.  00! 230. 400 55 !!6!  7  50! 00   08$6 90$ 7: ## ##;#

  5000!< #$#=.0!050<>05 ?<#

%#  %)@40())'.01!!200!>0  7# 004$  0!0<0A*B8 50C.  #<74#

      5  64! > 0 >D100  24  ! #>!#

C#  !0 >05 ?55.()))2!!()))$ % E>0  5 0  %* @0 ())). 0  00E! E>0 !0 5000! < # @E>C(@0()))#20E>0!050<>05 ?< 0 ( @40 ())'. 0 060 E>0 40 !50 4F  !0 < >50002090$ 7: = ;#

    5. 0  50! >!   2 50   4 !0! ## ###

+#   (+ !51 ())). > =   8 !0! < >0!! <  500  =1()))!175>0C%  . F1 >00('@40%>!4< -=AG+('.'A#

  20.  0  (H !51 ())). > =   025!  011 E 0 <  4 85   0.  1 !0! !0 #  4 1  80 400 0 400 !05#

A#    !0 %. 4F!  C* I %. ,# # -# J @ 5000!=J> 50!0 ## ###

/#  %+1%.> = !50102002())). F1 %'451%.>!076 ## ##<74#

  175 0E!!05K5>05 ?I>!40< -=AG+'*./*#

   (* 451 %.   !10  1 %. F1  (A !51 %.   5  -= CG'%/#$#  5 !0 !65 !076 ## ###

&()(&%+ $C&'$

H#   0  C( @40 %(. " "# # < DL.   5 >8 5 10 ?5!.025!> = E>403()@40 %( ## ##818 !0!#

  5 0 !818000 8 00# ,# # -# !0  500  20E  7 E>0 0  . "  00  06 M 0 >!0  500N   18#

  " >060   5 206  0  4   50  0 ! E  200  > =  40 !! D!  060   0  %( 2!40 %(  0 40 !  8 00 < 50#"04050:M<N#

'#   055!(A@0%(.""# #4F!<> = :

 $ 0C(@40%(.!! !0O

 $ 0550> = /40%(.3%C50%(O

 $!0500DP""# #06!+2!40%( ,## -#.5000!<5! 10E!50E 6O

 $ 0 +50%(.3(+@0%(O

 $ 0<#

  ""# # 00> = 0!  !0#

)#   () @0 %(.  D2  40   0400    0  025! " "# # E>0 00    @E> C*  51 %(  5 > ()))%011#

  ! !00 ! 4080#

(*#   28  C( @0 %(. !  011 <  !!60  ## ##<5.4080025!>0!!E>! 0 400 !05# "0  5 40 !! 25!   50.  ! 40 0 K 550E!# "0 > =  0 40 !@< ! .040K0!!55490;#  !.0!K50!0  08 !5!4!#

((#  0!'5%%.8 !0! 005 <,##-#.   ## ##. !!60  5. (). 4   08 < 74 90;. > = !0!50080()))%#

&()(&%+ $+&'$

   !50  C( @40 %( >40  !! !!   !0

05 !02  C* @. 0  >0 C+)  #  !50 >!0   !!041 #

  5040> = 0006:M!!5!!   5   ! < 4 05 00       !600 640. 4 05 00  !! 22! 25!5 < >0250 '&)'. 8!   >05 00 050! <  10 0551000 <  DF0E5000! <>!6N#

(%#    ! !  A 40 %%. " "# # 60  ,# # -#.     !00  7   5500     507>05 ?<E> = 208 00E0     18 ()))  %. E  80 0 5  

05 ? F!<E>022! !00. !05 020!<E200!2!>0250'&)'>F@50 !!E0#

  20. >!0  500 40 K  !.  E0 !40  2000! < E  011 40 0 > .  50 < 0$0>605 0.> #

  ,##-#!080458!> = 40<>0CH+ #

(C#  !00('!51%C.5500 507 >05 ? 90$ 7 ,;  50    4F!   < > = #

   07 0 I 0! E  !50  C( @40 %(. 006!102002 ()))%+1% 1   %  (* 451 %. >!0  04 0E> !0 >05 0100!>!10! 0018#

  0200!00!50!00!607 0E>  0  >!0  500 ! <  0  > = # 25!5<>0+H .0 40! !@0  #

  > = 40 50700!2 !50#

(+#    ! !  622  C 2!40 %+. > =      !003 0)@40%+.>0 , ((2!40%+#

&()(&%+ $A&'$

   ,4020 00!>0+H O .  3  0!   !00 0050!   3 0I5 <   2.  40 !  !0  @0 25   8 0 !04005#

   !00 40 K !    4F! <  ,  E>2#

(A#   (% 5 %+. " "# #  !0!!  5 000  < 10  8 00   022! >05 ?  EE -= (*G#$ !  ,# # -#   80# "0  8 00 0 40 !! 20.05 ?0!@< F!# !.0!K50 40 K 50 <  D6  011  > 7# > =  0 >05 0>K>0 0!>8 0E80#

(/#  !D6>!0>  !>!!548#

(H#  "E0.!!6!<@6#

$ " 

(#  @!C2!40%+!005500   507 >05 ?  (' !51 %C. 3  ) @40 %+.  >500020419#A/ 0 G600@000%%451()+($$ %*AO#/C#(0# 0 !50004(% 51()'A$ $ A(*;#

%# # 4520!406(@40%(.  0002!!>D50005 ?0  55  (+ !51 ())* 9- J " /+%#(+;#   16!. < 0   .     0 00   0 6!!   010 10E  ) 451 (''H 9  J  C *A;#  0 00 5  0155E0>05 00  DF0E   !0 20 !0 < >! %(# > 0   !600 20 8 806   -   22 ! 4>22!0255>4! 0150002 @0   9 &%)&%+  (C @40 %+O &'CA&%+. &'C/&%+ &'CH&%+%/1%+;#

 1#  !006E0> ()))%50<     !0  ( @40 %( 90$ 7:  ;   E0 0 00!616!7#

&()(&%+ $/&'$

C#   ( @40 %%  !  406.  0  ! 20  + 1 %( 9=0 J  C (H; > 00 055!0   0 '/# >0AC=040 00<0 !50004 (% 51()'A9 J A(*;#

+#  05 8 !6!  > =    .  , >  !  0!   !00  !50  ' 5 %%#  4D. 0!!E> = 40<!!04!5025!C( @40%(E0200 > = <>>5 F,## -# 00  0200 0!607 0E>   0  >!0  500  7   50. !0  500   40 !! 025!(A@0%(#

A#  > =    0! 50004    >0 ( 0! %  A  #  !00020 000. 25!5 < >0 ( 0! (  #    00  >0 )   E0 !40   !0 > 0   50 205 E020! 0>60#

  .C(@40%(.""# #045,##-# (A @0 %(.  0!!  4F! < > =   0 5  >!050018<DL,##-#.0$0! 500 6#

    55. > =  > !6! E " "# #  0   50 205 E020!.    ! 0$ 9K  012!!,#%' 51%+(#+(/(&%+;# 40.< 507! 05E00!!8 !0!(A@0%( ".020!000!<,##-#<500!# >  !1060 !!>0+/0!%  9"())A #/*($/*%;4F 005 011.! '5%%.!00!50<>>5 F <74E040 <1060 20# 5020050!6076>0+H  50!!8 !0! 005 .E>  D E,##-#0E>0 0@5 0  701!#5 !<2005001#

   8 18   ()))  %. > =  >76   40 8 !0!  0 55!.  E>  20 @50. 0  E    >0 0! >!10    ! 0   00   85#

&()(&%+ $H&'$

/#  !E.!0!50> 55<0 !5025! 0C(@40%( ""# #>!! 5 0#

H#      1 6!  @000.  ,  40 E 4F   < > =   E $0     2   !50.E>>40 20 0E>>!01!<< E!50!004#

'#   > 0 0  01 50002 0 <  ,    !00E0051 500<> = 80!#

)#   052!.@!#" 0E01  !.  !55   K 0206! < > =  5K5 0 $0 51 5 75#  4D. >005!  0 <  050!  ! 2066!<>0.! !0!E>0F !0(%5%+E>EK 205 !60059#'H ;#

  00.  050!  !  -= %G#$ 0  ! <  D6> 74#

 QQQQQ

&#$" * $      

+,-.!/

! 41   0@!  C 2!40 %+  >5000 20  640   !00   5500     507>05 ?('!51%CO

-./

@O

40<>5000200!O

5 <  D6  >   74  050!  !  -= %G#$  24,##-#O

0EG0G  3G!55O

&()(&%+ $'&'$

550E  ! K < >5000 20 . <  5500 507>05 ?00EG<""# #.50,### -##

"0!6: ,#FD7. !0.,54F.-0.,# D!0.,5.@6#

5 0150002:

62207$@0@#:   !0:     ,# 0 =#FD7  

 025K!!550E!8 0#

 74.  62207:           

&()(&%+