Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/850/2005 • CJ GE ATA/850/2005 Généré par l'IA

Property Rights and Easement Dispute

Numéro de cause ATA/850/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Frais judiciaires à la charge de l'autorité
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The court considered a dispute involving multiple overlapping claims related to property rights and easements, stemming from several conveyances and subsequent actions by the parties, including allegations of encroachment and interference with access and use of the granted interests. The court reasoned that the interpretation of the relevant deeds and surrounding circumstances dictated the scope and validity of the asserted rights; specifically, it examined whether the language of the grant created an express or implied easement for the claimed purpose, and whether the conduct of the parties evidenced an abandonment or waiver of those rights, ultimately determining the extent to which each party was entitled to relief based on the established property boundaries and established legal principles governing easements and servitudes.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Rights and Easement Dispute: The court reasoned that the interpretation of the relevant deeds and surrounding circumstances dictated the scope and validity of the asserted rights; specifically, it examined whether the language of the grant created an express or implied easement for the claimed purpose, and whether the conduct of the parties evidenced an abandonment or waiver of those rights, ultimately determining the extent to which each party was entitled to relief based on the established property boundaries and established legal principles governing easements and servitudes.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
servitude légale renonciation au droit droit à la propriété conflit de compétence civile fractionnement constatation de droits subjectifs

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The court ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
A/31/2004
Property Dispute Over Prescriptive Easement
A/288/2007
Easement Obstruction Dispute
A/2352/2006
Property Boundary Dispute and Deed Interpretation
A/1445/2002
Easement Validity Dispute Affirmed
A/3846/2006
Easement Validity and Enforceability Dispute

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

        



    

    

      ! """"""""""  !!"#$%&'"       "       # $$ $    % 





     ()*+(

$ 

./  !/ 0000000000   $ $   $1$   $   1 $ $ 23 ),,,/    4   $"$   "$  5 0000000000/5 6$ 7"$  3$2 282"29 00000000009:'/   $"$98  $ $$  $1$ $ /

)/   3   4 ),,;& !/ 0000000000  $  "'  3$2    $  "3  4 "$ $" 47"$   <(3 9 4$%

5 /00000000005 $  9     0000000000' " 1: "22 !/0000000000&"$% $3$/

;/   ),,=& !/ 0000000000  >> 9 2   <(3

5 00000000005 $ "'"!/0000000000/  $  "  $%  "  &  .- '$ ),,=& "  $     3$2 / !/ 0000000000  $"    1" $& !/ 0000000000 $  "  $ ?64 . 2 ),,- " 46$  $7'  4 9  %2 64$ " 1  3$  "2  !/0000000000/      2& !/ 0000000000  " $ 9 '$ %$:2    1 "  !/ 0000000000  >% 4$%& 6   '& $ '$ ),,=& 500000000005/ "  2"$& !/0000000000 '$  @A+,,/( 9 !/ 0000000000  4  $ 6$ '$  $1$ 1 $$$6!/00000000004 $2  '$ "$ $"   B$(:CD "'$E&" ?" &64$4%$$ (92 $"" "F9!/ 0000000000" '$64$11 $ "22" "2$ "$> ?"/

=/      "   "$ $"&  3$  .+ 2 ),,-& 6  D  '$    "     G" $  "   %2$  H6$& 6  "'$   4$% 500000000005  "  "$ $1"2 $6/  $   D  "  " " 9 4$ $"  !/ 0000000000    !/ 0000000000/     6 !/ 0000000000 '$   " 9 !/ 0000000000 "22 8 ("2& 6  2 $" 2  @A+,,/(  $  ' 9   11    6 47"$  $" 11 $'  1  $    !/ 0000000000& 6 4 $   31$ 4  "$ $"/ 4 $6$11 $ "223"$" "$ &6$2 $  "2 3$$ 91$$$&6$'$ 14 3$2 /4'$  "    '$/  '$  ">$  >% 4$% ' 4"  !/ 0000000000/

   9$&$'$ $%"  ' '!/0000000000 .-'$),,=&2$4'$ I4%  ' &"$  @AJ,4,,,/(&6

*)),,*),,- (;*+(

 . 2 ),,-/     &  >%2   3$ '$    11 /  4$ '&$ $  47"$  /"  $ '"$'$8 ("2/'$  "3$4"' "22'$&28264$'$ "3$ 4">%2 4$%/

   & $ '$    32  3   $"  "3:2    $"'23),,;?6491$?'$),,=/'$  @A+,,/(2"$ !/0000000000""2$64$"$ 9$($1$  <33/

-/  "$J'$),,-& 2 $ $  $"&$2   2 ? $&"$ $ B$(:C 2 E&$2 $ $9!/ 0000000000$$6K9!/00000000001$2  ""3' $"/

   $ ">2$'"$7"$ "2    11 $'2  1(   500000000005&4'"$'$8 ("29 !/0000000000&'"$ "3$% $"" 4$$ $" $7 &%$ "&2 $""2"$ $    47"$     "   4 3$2       '"$ 1$  1$% $2 & &>"$7 "$3"$"""9$7$1$9 6 $ %9$3"$"""$62"$>: 1$& '"$$1"2'$ $"4 $'$ 11 $'/

  "& 2 ">$ '"$$1"2'$ > 1""22&>%2 4$%$$61$ 4'"$ 7"$   1(   500000000005 "  "'  4 8 ("2 

8 31$4 "$ $"47"$  8  $ $ $1$  $ &'"$$$ ""2" 4 3$2    '"$ $1"2  '$   1$  4 $'$     11 $'  !/ 0000000000/

J/  $$2 $&!/00000000001"$7$ $"/'"  4  " $ "!/ 0000000000& "$$1"2 2 & )L'$),,-&6$($'$ $22$ 2  $9!/00000000004%   /"$$ $ 2 2 /

M/   $$"  ); 2$),,-&   2   $1$% 9 !/ 0000000000 2 @A;4-,,/($ $"4 $M=$."$   $"&3$ 3"$" K>3%2 .M23.L+MB@ (  ) ).E/  & $  ""  $"   '$$    $1$   $   !/ 0000000000 "    $7 2"$  $ $"  4 $M;@/

*)),,*),,- (=*+(

+/   9!/0000000000&$'"F$ $1$%282?"2 @A)4,,,/(282$4$ '"'7"$  '$  $%/

   "   "$ 6 !/ 0000000000 4  "     2 2$64$"$$ $$2 /

L/ / !/ 0000000000  $ ?  "  ); ?$ ),,- :  $3 2$$  $1 "     $"    $ 64$ '$  I  $$"  6 $")=2$),,-/"$$2 94 $"$$" 6& $" & $$&$" $1$ 1 $  $  $"" $" $64  $'$  47"$  %2  

5 00000000005/2$ 6 $""$ $2$ 92"$ 282$ 7 %1$7$ 2$$229$72"$/1$ 9" $ " 6  "2 (282 "'$  8  2$    &   "  :'  "$    " N 3 $   "2& 4 $   $$" $6   3 % $$2$   "$   '$   $$" 6$ '$"$ $$"" $"$ &4 $ 9$($  $$$'/

  " 4" $ 9? $2"  42/

 3/  2  "? "O""I $" 4$72"$&$4 $ "1"22$$22% &" $2 9  %&  "  "'$  "$'   $7 2"$ 47"$  $" 

5 00000000005 '  "' 7"$  & $ $   $1$   $ /    2"    42&   2  "$  9  "1$2 $"&  " 4%  "'$11$ 1$$: 64$ $ 4 6$ /  &   2   "'$  "" 64 2   " 9  $" $   $6    $%$   $ 2 '  $ $"$2$$/

.,/ /   $ "       $  "2 $" "  .= 23),,-/

        2   $$6 64$ 1$    "$ $"     "    '    "   $2   $7&  4 $ 2$:6$""$ 9$"$"/

 3/ &!/ 0000000000$64$'$  "94>N$  "  "'23 ),,; $ >"$ $ 9  $$6  "$ "P $  $    ?6423$ 9" $"9Q"' 6$4 $ '$ $/  '$  $  R $'  $ 2   $"  4   $1 6$   $   / ""$  $1$ 2$ 3$). 23),,- >  $& F>$ & 6$ '$  $'$ 4$   ;.2  - 2$ ),,=/D""2 &4   $ "'$ '"$$1% $'2 

*)),,*),,- (-*+(

 $   % $2  "  $'$  "1$"    7   $ /

../  D6"$& %9?%/



$  %

./   ?   2  $ '   ?$$ $" "2  &  "   '3B /-J "$K"%$ $"?$$$))"'23.L=.( ( ),-O /J;/.$ /"$"2$$  $'.)  23.L+-( ( -.,E/

)/   @  " 22  " 3  4 64   3$2  6$$ "2$"$  $3 "34"3$&  $$ 6$$  2"3$6&1$ ""$ $""7"$   B /)/.$ / @E/ 47"$  $" "  3$2  %$ @ "2$94"3  $"34 "$ $"47"$ &$'  2 /47"$  "$ 8  $ $ $1$ $ /    % "  3$2   1I" "   11 $'& 4 "$ $" 47"$   " $ 2$$3B /-/.$ /&.-/; )./ .@E/

   4:& 4  !/ 0000000000 6$    31$ 4   "$ $" 47"$    $ 47"$     1$ 2  43  66 >?"&'"$66?""$"'"2$& $ 4 2  2"$ 6  " $"  % $" "   11 $' 6$ %$:47"$   % $> 4"'   4 3$2  B *LM*),,-  . 2 ),,-E/     7$ $"!/ 0000000000$(2826$"'23),,;$" "3:2 6$4"$ 9 "'6/

;/  !/ 0000000000"  '"$'$8 ("29!/0000000000/ @A+,,/( 2 6 $($ $ '$  2$   ; > 6" $$   6 $ '$$  4 3$2    "  2$ 9 $"$ $"  "  $1$   $ /     4 3$2  2 $"$  "$3"$"5?$"5" ?4"%/!/0000000000'$ 11"2 " 6$1$%$ " 4 "2$  2"2 " N '7 $ "/

    2$ 2& !/ 0000000000  $$6 '"$ "  "3:2 "'23),,;91$?'$),,="7$6"3$ "$  9'"$"2$4"D ' ""22.-'$

*)),,*),,- (J*+(

),,=/  2$ $    !/ 0000000000&       6 $($ 4 $ 2%11$2$ ;.2 -2$),,= 2 /&:-2$),,=&!/ 00000000003$'$8 ("29 !/0000000000 "  2 $"   $ $   9  2"2  " "  D     >%2  4$%    >%2   "2  47"$  / 1$&$  3$6 4 3$2 "2" $  42$/ "1$ " $  $1 $"7 $-&.)&),&)=& )-&)M&;)&;; =+@/

=/  ' 8 ("2&" 47"$ 7 $""  $M; M=@&9'"$4 &$"'$$  "  $1$   $  "    $7 9 '$% (6  2"$ B / M; @E6$ 8 2'2 @A.,,/(9 @AJ,4,,,/( "22'"$ 4 $M=@/

   2  @A ;4-,,/(    " "$  "1"2 9   $6   2 & 2$  1"$ "1$2   $3   B *LM*),,-   . 2),,-" 22 E/4$&" 4:%64$$  4$$ F/

-/   9$""$72"$'$$  $1$ $ &  "1"22$$22%  F 2 $62 "1$2  $3&22 "B *M.)*),,-)-" "3),,-E/

J/ /  &  "  "3?  64  $"   $"" $" $64428>%2 47"$ 5 /00000000005/

   "  " $  " 6  $3   "$  2     "2 (282  282 $   "  :'  "G    " N 3 $   "2&  $$" $6   3 % $$2$   "$ "'$"$ "'"$8 '/

 3/ D"  " $  11  B/ !& "$  2$$  $1& '"  / =).E& 4 "$      1 9 $6  "$ 5" 282 6&    " &2G $ $"" $"C$ "%9"2& 6$ 4  "$3 6 $ (282  '"$ /    >F" >:&  $$   "" $"$   4$6 "  9  $$" ": & 42$$  $"  $O'>&""2 "2( 282&64'$"$$1$ 282%2  $"64'"$  " 6& "   & $ R  1 $ $   "$3$$   "% $" $$'$B A*..J..;E5/

 / 4$  $ $"7 $3 & $ $" "9 $3  ""2$6& "  4 $ )M   " $  $" 1  .+ '$ .LLL B   1/ ( D .,.E&  "  "1"2 9  " $  $" 6 "

*)),,*),,- (M*+(

  641" 3%&? $1$ $ 8 3$    $$"" $"$ B /;J  1/E  $ $""$'  "    $$ 4%$   "    '$   ">  "F   $3  B /  & / !  & !/ @  & "$  " $  $"$'"/"$ 1"2 7/;-.E/

 / 2$   $ $" 1$%   2  "$&  $ 9 " % 4" 3$/  "2    "    2  "$  >3$$   9 3"" 47$   $ "1$" 9 4"3  $" 4  $1$   $    3   " %  3$ " 28> 6  " 4F    6$1$ $" $ 47    $'$  B"/ $ //;-)(;-;E/ " 4$ '7 "$@6  %$   '"  $"  ':2   1  47"$  $" " 11 $'4 3$2 6 '$" $"@& 1$ 641(  "$ 7"$ ">3$$ 91$   %% 4"  6$$ 3$6B$ ' $"!// #  & "$ 4  & !2"$     "$ .L+M& / J=LLE/

M/  $ $  2$$22%$72"$"$"'$$    $1$   $ & 4 $ M; @   $    2$: $"" $"$3 ""2$6" /   $"$'  47"$ "2 5 000000000052$!/ 0000000000 1$ 9 $& $ $ $1$ $ &6"1$%   2    $7 2"$   7"$   $     "  

5 00000000005 2   $$  " $ 9 $  ' "'   47"$  $"  3$2 /

+/ 1$&$$"$ 2 94" !/ 0000000000&   " 2   $$  "" $"$  2$ %2  $  4%$  $ 2 " 94 $2$$$4" $ "2   $1 $"  6($"  "22$/ B *M.)*),,-$ E/

L/  $ 4 $ M; @& $  "6     " $ $" "  $"" $"/  "  $$ ? /  2"2   @A.4,,,/(2$9>%" /4$$ $%&$$ "4$2$ "B /+M E/

 SSSSS 

*)),,*),,- (+*+(

 &$ %  $    

' () *+  ,

 '3  " $ ?   ); ?$ ),,-  !/ 0000000000 "   $$" 2 $ $  $");2$),,-O

) *+- ,

? O

2 9>%" 2"2  @A.4,,,/(O

$ 64$$ "4$2$ "O

"22$6    8  9 ! !" #$%& '"   "  $$ 6K  2 $ $  $"/

D$% C !2"'F&$ &!/F>:&!2@$&!/ >$&!2"& ?%/

"2 $32$$  $1C

%11$:(?$ ?/C  '$($ C     !/ ""$ /"'F  

"$"1"2 8  "22$67 $/

:'&  %11$:C           

*)),,*),,-