Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/85/2006 • CJ GE ATA/85/2006 Généré par l'IA

Defamation and Malicious Prosecution Claims Dismissed

Numéro de cause ATA/85/2006
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case addresses whether a party's actions, including the making of certain statements and the initiation of specific proceedings, constituted actionable defamation and/or malicious prosecution against another party. The court reasoned that the statements, viewed in context, were protected opinion or statements made without the requisite element of knowing falsity or reckless disregard for the truth concerning the plaintiff. Furthermore, the court found that the prior proceeding, which formed the basis of the malicious prosecution claim, was initiated based on probable cause and was not terminated in the plaintiff's favor, thus failing to satisfy the necessary elements for that cause of action.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Defamation and Malicious Prosecution Claims Dismissed: The court reasoned that the statements, viewed in context, were protected opinion or statements made without the requisite element of knowing falsity or reckless disregard for the truth concerning the plaintiff. Furthermore, the court found that the prior proceeding, which formed the basis of the malicious prosecution claim, was initiated based on probable cause and was not terminated in the plaintiff's favor, thus failing to satisfy the necessary elements for that cause of action.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
procédure pour diffamation cause de la demande demande en justice principe d'allégation ouverture de l'instruction pénale classement de la plainte pour escroquerie

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
This provision was applied to decide on the costs of the federal court proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
P/17792/2021
Appellant v. Prosecutor (Defamation and Malicious Prosecution)
P/14525/2018
Prosecutor's Decision to Dismiss Defamation Complaint Affirmed on Statute of Limitations and Legal Justification Grounds
P/21378/2021
Prosecutor's Dismissal of Defamation Complaint Upheld as Legitimate Defense
P/8841/2013
Prosecutor's Dismissal of Defamation Complaint Partially Upheld on Procedural Grounds
P/21428/2019
Appellant v. Public Prosecutor (Defamation and False Denunciation Dismissal)

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision was applied to decide on the costs of the federal court proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

        

 

      

 !







""#!$%%%%%%%%%%  !"#$% &'( 

( 

& ' () )   ' & 





     )*+,-)

 

,2  !3 45555555555&   ,60.   (3777 8 7&    73(73*--,97:5555555555;&( <72 3 *---      8    97 7  = >     ?7 7( ?'(7& :5555555555; =     8 =(@@7 ' 77  (A7)BC= D2

*2   ,1 37 *--1& "5555555555&   ,66,   (3777   3E3 733F87& ('7 (3?7=3GH (9=(7F2 (>=7 7 7HI (37 F& "5555555555  '  97 :5555555555; =(9 =H  ?(? 2  97 '7   7 (9 8 ( (7& 37  (37  &  '72 (> "5555555555  99 8 =     97&7)7=?7  (2=@ 37(F ' '7?(( ?&37(797=@7 F7B 7 =   ('  (2  97 H7  = ( 3(   7 ?9  (@(&'7(,, 73B &J92

      7  =@ & !3 45555555555 =  (9  97 =72 = 7 (7?':5555555555;&@   ?( &=(&7=7>7 ( "55555555552

.2  B =E  7? B  9F7    > 7&  3B  "5555555555& !3 5555555555   ('  (((  !3 455555555552   ( 7 > !3 45555555555  (7       '7 7( ( ( 97   > 7)7 ='7     '7 7*--.2

/2  7 3(7@7?:5555555555;&"5555555555K (7?8=9I7 @ &(L7M 7G(2

12  ,N37*--1&"5555555555(3? 3B( 7   (  ?37( 2 ,O37 *--1&737 @(37 =(3(97B= 2

02  *-37*--1&= ((> :5555555555;2  )

3& !3 45555555555 '7  37 :5555555555;  @?   P(7   (  7(  73H A7)BC P D& 8 H& (L   7?   7(=F(23E3G(&97  9783 ' 77 (2

N2  !3 45555555555    ('(>  (   ?37  ( (37*--1&37=(7 8('( 7(2

+*./0+*--1 ).+,-)

O2   *. 37 *--1&  ?37   7 '  (377  !3 45555555555   = (7   (   (  ( =7 (?  =  = 2

  !3 45555555555  H7> '(7 9  :5555555555;  ,* 3 *--,8'(77((33 $Q1--2)2 '7 (8 '7' 77 (&='7 >737&7% H& 7 7'7  (  ? (  7( @77B2  97 '7      '7 (   ?  ,* 3 *--,& ' '77   ,* 3 *--.2

  3(3 @7 &97( 7 7&37= 7  2!3 45555555555 '7       = >   F7   97 3(  "55555555552 9(>   >7 = 7  (7 &  ='7   (? 8 =HB=@ 2 '7 37978P *-37*--1& 7?    7( =F(  (7 &  (7 = 372 !3 45555555555(7'(7 7837:5555555555; *--*& ( >=  7   7  7  ( >=7 '7  ('  ( = (3   @(E 2  *--.& 7  8  (  '(77&  '7  K'77 P &>7(%7 >=3 7 7 (972

  P=?7    7  7( (& !3 45555555555  H( E  37&37'7''(@77>7H) 2P3(7&  F@7= =7'77 7,66O&7 82

 =7  ( 7 (? (7& !3 45555555555      8  G?=7  7( 77(((?7?2

62  *N37*--1&= 7@7?8!3455555555553 $Q 0--2) ( ='(7  @@     '7 (   ?  :5555555555;&(='(7>737 ='(7(( 972  77(  ., 37 *--1  H (7 ((F   (& = 7@7 7 7 7( 797(7 372

=777(&=  >!345555555555='7  3( E 3 797(=>37B (7@7='7 ?7(3FF8,137*--1&(  >   9%7> > %97> ('7  E  'B (  '7 732 ='7 (3(F77 (K 8@7(' '797( ?&7( ='F( =73    =%   >7  =73I    972 !3 45555555555 '7  @7 3(    E  7?  (@7  (3  7  7(3 = (7 2

+*./0+*--1 )/+,-)

,-2   , G7  *--1& !3 45555555555  ( B  7F 377  7@ (   77(  =   ., 37 *--1&  (  F3 87(=  =7( &8(7 7(&77>=8=( (7=@@ 7@2 7'(> '7( 7(((7 =E  &@ ='(7((378 3(  :5555555555;&7=H7>(33(97 7  G  (3( 3 (978=(7((7 7(?37&   ('7  ( (      9(2 P  @(& !3 45555555555  (773 8= 7(77(= &F7773  '(7    8  7 ( (' 77(  ?    B 7(( 7(77( >&7 =(( 8>=  7  97 >7  (7   (7 (33 ?H2  =   7 7(87'(?2

,,2   */(M *--1& (7=  9? 3  =7 7&  =?7     ='7(3  A' 7 (   3  7 (7D(G (7(F  8  7  7(=@@ 7@ 87(&3E3>=G  ( 8(@73 7(77( >23=7 7 7(  797(7 37=73(7 =B&' ?'7 @7  (3( 3 @@79( 2= '(7  7>>3E3 7 7(F' 7 (78('7 2

,*2  .-(M *--1&G??((=( ( 77? (  !3 455555555552   (    (337>  7F377  7@,0 3F*--12

,.2   77(  *,  3F *--1&  '7)7   7F 377  7@  G   3   7  7(  =@@  7@    7((2

,/2      ,* 3F *--1&  7F  (7  ( !3 45555555555(F7(((?7? =(38 7>7RG(=37(3 '72

,12  .G'7*--0& 7(  7@(3> 7 ?8 G?2

& 

,2   G   3  7 '   G77 7( (3  &  (   'FA 210 (7=(?7 7(G777('3F,6/,)

+*./0+*--1 )1+,-)

 )  * -1 S  2 0. 2 ,  2    (7   ( 377  7'  ,* 3F,6O1) ) 1,-D2

*2 2  (7   (7 7( ='?& = 7(      7(  97 , ( (F*--.A  )!./1D( 7 97 (H3   H  7( 7F   =7(F' 7(   7(7 7(2 = 7 *.  (7 H3 7'3'7?F 3 7(&   77& =7 7 7(   7  97 A 2 D2  7    7(& = 7 *1    '(7   3 377  7' (   3(   (7   $,--2)  $Q0-T---2)2

F2  =B& =3 377  7' 7@7?  *N 37 *--1  =  8 !345555555555=@7 =(FG =(   7(2P 7 7?7 77(  ., 37 *--1 @7  7 7 7( 8  (    7  97 (7 372

.2 2 !3 45555555555 @7   37 7 '(7  '7( 7(  ( (7  =E   2  =?7  = ?7@    @(3& (  =377(      8 (7 8 = 7(   77(  >& 733   9B@(7 7?A E  7F@ ",/O+-/  * 3F *--1& (72 121D2 7  G 7@7) )7 =H37  3(%3772

F2 >=7 ? 7 = 7*67* ( 7  7(@ ,O '7 ,666 A  2) P ,-,D&  (7  =E    (3  (7  ( =7  =(@@7  '  7 & 7   (7  (7& =(F 7 >=7 (7  ( 7  8  (@@  '  7 &   77 8 =377  7(  '  7 (& 8 (   3(7&  =H73  (   & (>       8 7@   77( 8 2(7 @7377 '=3E9 G? (8=377  7( 7'(@@  (8 7 7( 777B& 77=7>7  7 > )7  (7  =3 8 3(7@7 ( (77( ( 7  @7  8  F7  G8(   7((  (7A Q,.,,1.&,1N(72.    @ 7 S +N0O+*--1  ,1 ('3F *--1 (72 * S +,N*+*--/  * 3 *--/ (72 1FD2  (7  =E     ( 7   (  =(F7? 7(  7  (  ?7@   3(%  '  ( S7@@7 >G?7 H>777  7 A E  7F@/2*--+*--1,13F*--1&(72/S Q,*06N&,-* (72*FS +*6*+*--/0'7*--/D2U7&(7 =E   (@B(7 (3V (E  (3 &>7 =(F 7=7 7( 3(7A E  7F@*2//+*--1*,G7  *--1(72*2,S Q,.-/*1&/*OD2

+*./0+*--1 )0+,-)

2  =B&  7 7? (            3 7  = F= 7*.   8((=  @7 (   3  =  (  2 =(    (    7 37    (3    7( @7    (  '   ?37& 7 '   G? =7  7(& 77 >  (7 7(  3(77 7(&83&8 (7(2

  (3  > 7(G77>8H37&= & @7 >& =  &( 33 F@77@ =H7>7 F77  7((>@7   ( >7 >=('  7F377  7@& ?7@'7( 7((7 =E  &3E3>>E   8( 7 7(&(7' E G 2

 2  ?7@ 7   '7( 7(  (7  =E     7@ 8 =( = 9797:5555555555;(7 ?3 E G 2  &= 7 */    '(7  >  3 >=(( = (7   7 7(  = 7 *.    ) (   37 8 3(    97 @7   7 A 2 @D ) (  ( 7@7   @(   77 =(FG  = 7 '  =E  37  ('2  =B ( @(7& B ( > =73 '7  F3    &     7&8P &(@(33 8 7(>)77?*-37 *--1&  = 7    7 7   3 7  =(@@7& 77 > = '= (7 7 732(7 =E   ('7 &  &3 7B8 =7>8(( 32

/2 2 (@(33  8 (  7 ,&     ?7   (7 7( ='?& = 7(      7(  97  '  ? 7  F7)E    7 =7 &F7   >77 F7>&3E3 > ='7(3 & ?7(&@ F72 = 76  @7 (F7? 7(  =97=>7)7&  77((3( 3 (7F( 73 @7>=777  F7& 7 H 73H& 7 H   (&  37B ?& 8 ='7(3 2 (   97(7  7(7 @7 > =73  7  7 9 ( 7  F7&  3E3 >=8 = 73H2(7 '78=3E93(&3((7' F7W 77@  (J?A 2,,  D2   7B     7 (7   '(7 =33  (  'H 3 7>7( (7 8=( 7(  &73 F  (7?'F77  77B>7 7H ?(7 ( 7( A!3(7     (7   F7>   ( B'&*--.+4&2.666 /--0D2

 F2 = 7 ,.    @77  (33 ?H (7  ?(7  97C 97  87 = >&(7@7 7((  (7=   F7 7 A DS978= >&8=H 7(

+*./0+*--1 )N+,-)

 H >7 (   77   (7&  (& =3    ?   7 A FDS97>7(   '&(7 H>7( G8  >   3(  ( (  73H   >7 (  @7  =(FG  = 7 ' 7(= A D2

2 = 7,NB?3 =7 7(  03F*--/ A   )!./12-,D(&7 7(= 7,.   & 7 97= >2( <7@7  7&77 > 7F377  7@G8=(7((7?A +,6N+*--* *.'7*--*(720D2=>77 7(97? @7 >=B='?@@778F%((?7>7(=(?73 (  7(73H7(= 77 F7>&(@(33 8= 7 ,1 7 ,   2  (F7? 7( 7(3F      =  73 (3 =(8= &'7( ? 37 = (7>A 2O   ,0   D2

2 =7(F' 7(  7(7 7(      (  ( B?3  =7 7( (3& (   3 (   97 H)3E3 (33   77 7(&  >  (  37 8 3( & =7 7 7(   7  97   =(F7? 7(    ( = 7( 7 A 2 *.   D2 3( (K 7'=H7( ( H 37' ( 7E (3F7&(3     7 7> ( 8 9> 2  7F 377  7@  37  (3 7F77  ?7 7('(7 7&  77>7 (  3 7@7>3  7F H 97 ?H A +,*,+*--1  O 3 *--1 (72 .D2   E   &  7F @  ?3  G? >  ?7 7(   (  J) 3? (3   8  (F7? 7( 7@7>    7(  97 (  73  ?H(33( <7 7 (@(3(7 @A E  7F @*2,/0+*--1,N('3F*--1D2

12 2  =B& 7    F7 > !3 45555555555  >7& 7    97 :5555555555;   7@(3 = & (33   '7  (   =(F7? 7(2 &3E3& F7>&7'7 GH&  97  '7(33   >   F  G ?K(&    7 >7'   (V   (F77  8 =7  = >&     773(738=?'7 732 '@7   ?'7 &=  7 @(8&( 379(=  7@77 7'  =73& =  3 ' 8 = 7 *.    8 =?  (   2(7(77(   8= 7(  7377( >( 8 ?37@ 3 7@(2P  (>8 H37> 7((( 7(7  3 7.,37*--1= 2

+*./0+*--1 )O+,-)

F2 =H7(3 >77(  7F(7&=   & 8 =7   (   (7  377  7'&     77   (( 7(7 277?= 7'7 =  ?7(7  = 7 1 7 *  2&  77   (( 7(7  (3(  7 7(3  (7   C  3(% 9(77 (7  =F( E  ( 8  7F @7HAB?= 7 D2& 73(%7(7  &7('7 9(777>7( = 7 3(7?'H7 E  7'AB?7 D273( @73 F@@  39(777  7(=377 '  (3 (7   '  =7 E  F7 A(( 7(7     (7 S E   7F @ *2*O*+*--1  *1 ('3F *--1& (72 *2/S +O1,+*--1  ,.3F *--1 (72 . S +00/+*--1  ,, ( (F *--1 (72 .F S  +,-.+*--1, 3*--1(72N @7 D2

2  7F 377  7@  G? 8 7 7 > =7 7 7(   7  73 (   7 37  7    B H7@ A +O1,+*--1,.3F*--1(72.S +00/+*--1,,( (F *--1(72/S +/6.+*--1,6G7 *--1(72,-D2@@7  G?  ,  3 *--1& >7 (7   3'7 7 3  7@7?  ( 3V  8  97 = >& 77 > =F =( 8 =     '7 7(=73( ?&7G?>=7 7 7( 7 73( (7 7 G 7@7  7  B 7(( 7( A +,-.+*--1 (72 OD2   @@7   & 7  (@7377=7 7 7( 773((8=? (7 7 = 97 >7 '7  ?'3  ?7? 7)7& 37  ( @(7 7 8 (7 3A +O1,+*--1,.3F*--1 (72/D2

2 =(&@7 8!3455555555557 7 7( 7 97(7 37&= =3F( (3 'B W 8 =?     W '  = 7 *.   2  77(  > =H( 3   7( ( >  3 3(7  7 7'3 7 =7 7(F 7 F7> (8= 7,  2= = & 77&(( 7( ( >  3  >= 7 7 7(   7  97 (737 &( 78(9=(F7? 7(@7 8( (  7'  ( = 7( 7    = 7 N 7 ,    &'B7 7> 77(( 7(7 2 7(7 7( 7  3   @@  =&   F77 = 7?3  7@7>7 >7@7&3V 7=97 H7?'   (B?3 =7 7(2

   7   (  (& = (7  7 73 B'& 7   '7& >= 3  >   77 7(  7'   (  8  (

+*./0+*--1 )6+,-)

= 7(77  7?(3 &7(7  7( @77B7 7B27  ( @(7H=3F&  (3(7=37B@77 7'&>7  7(( 7 F7  '( 7( (7 7'   2 (7 8  @(7 ( =?   G7 7     77   (( 7(7 &  3 =7 7 7(   7  97 (    37& (3F7 ' =(F7? 7(   77 8  ( = 7( 7    = 7 *.        & ='B 77  >  >= 7 7 7( (((7 372

02 2  '   >7 B&  (  37& 37 B  73  3 2  7(   ?'7   @7     '7( 7(      (337   ( &  77(  =   (@73  ( 772    =7 7 7(   7  97    737  8 7>& 7(7 7(3  8(   (7   ?'7   @7  >7 7 (  (9   =3 8 @97(3( 3 >  (@(38(7>='7 ( 8 ='7 7   7    972  ( & 8  7  =9  =7 7 7( 7 & ='    7( = 97  !3 45555555555 (7 7(8(7 &)7&=(= 7(7B = F @@77 8  (7  %((?7> 7     7 N   O    & 7@7 >= 83E3(HH7?= 76   2=7 7 7( 797( 777(%@@    7(? 3>=H7?>7B= 7&> >(7 97>( (7 (97 >72

F2 =77 7?&3(3  $QN1-2)3789? ( &>7(3F= 7(7(2( =737 A 2ON D2

*' &         

+,"-#!.

 'F  ( 7 G   , G7  *--1  !3 45555555555 ( 77(=(@@7' 77 (.,37*--1S

"-/.

=3  73 S

@7H87>=7 7 7( 797S

+*./0+*--1 ),-+,-)

(7 7(& 8 =9   3 7 &  @    7  97 8  (7 !345555555555=((@@77   7  7 97S

G ((S

3 3(3  $QN1-2)89?( S

7 >=7= (=737 S

(337>    E  8 ! "# $% & '(    ( & 8 =(@@7 ' 77 (77>=8=(@@7' 77@2

P7? C !3('%&7 &!3$7&!2 97&G?&!!2   $( 7&G? 2

(3 7F377  7@C

?@@7B)G7 C  '7)7 C     27()P7?7  2('%  

(7(@(3 E  (337>H 72

 B'&  ?@@7BC           

+*./0+*--1