Contract Interpretation and Breach of Express Terms
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe case concerns a dispute over a contract's terms regarding the provision of a specific service or product, with parties disagreeing on whether the agreement mandated a particular performance standard or quantity, or if an associated warranty covered the alleged defect. The court reasoned that the unambiguous language of the contract clearly dictated the specific obligation or warranty at issue, finding that one party's failure to meet this explicit term constituted a breach or that the warranty did not extend to the specific failure claimed, thereby resolving the dispute in favor of the party relying on the plain meaning of the written agreement.
Regeste Legislator
OfficielCONSTRUCTION ET INSTALLATION; PERMIS DE DEMOLIR; AUTORISATION DE CONSTRUIRE; LOYER | Rejet d'un recours contre une décision de la CCRMC annulant des autorisations de démolition et de construction concernant trois bâtiments et annexes dont l'un est soumis à la LDTR. Les prix de vente des futurs appartements fixé dans l'autorisation sont fondés sur un loyer fictif de CHF 6'000,- la pièce par an, ce qui ne correspond pas aux besoins prépondérants de la population. Non admission d'un cas de "circonstance particulière" au sens de l'article 6 alinéa 3 LDTR, s'agissant de la taille des pièces. | LDTR.2 al.1
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IACited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the federal court proceedings.
Texte complet
!"
#$"%& '$($))*+ #$",&--&"$&./0 #$"$-'(0 , #$"%&$-'(0 !"!#$%$ &'(
(
* 0 0 11
1 / 21
0* 011 3 311
"+" *00* 0 *0 2 *0 * 0
4 54/ 6 547 0/
)*+,)+--. "/)0."
01 ($ $& $2 $ ($ $ 3 +.+& 4$5(667'&$4(8' #$61#$ &( $4$ ($9: $6 ;05+& 05/ 05.<& ($ = & $ ( $( %7 9: $6 >$ (6( $?""2$$>86$ % (69 44 @A29$ 1$7A29$ $(( 6 ($ ($ $&@ $ ('$($&@(( $'(%6 ( $ 1
+1 !$!$2B(? C$8 %( $( (($ $ 3+./&4$5&(667'&$0*&8 '$1 #$ & $4$9: $6 05,( ?""2 44 @ $'$ ( > 6$ D$76 % $$ > (69 ' @829$ 1A$669 6 ($%6 1
/1 !$ $ $% ( ($ $ $$'$ 3+..&4$5&(667'&$@8%8 '$ #$61#$ $4$9: $6 05*>$(6( ?""2'(@ $'$ 6$ % (6944 @ A29$ 19: $6 (($(6 A($ $1
.1 9 0EE-&($ $ $ '$ >$ ($ $($(6($9: $6 6 $669 $> % ?""2 $>1 0F69 0EE/& 6 'D 9$& ( (6 & '$ $' ($ $(6($ ( $&'$ 6 A6%6 & A>$6 (%6 ;$"7 G ( 6 <1(H ($8 ( 4($H6$ 6$I'1
F1 6 0, ('69 +--0& !$ "2$$ 2 "!$2 !( & 2$ 6 ($ $ (6 "> 3 +.+& ( >$ 6 J 8 ($ $(6($ (9: $6 $ 1
0, ('69 +--0 %6 & !!1 2 !( ( >$ 8 ($ $(( $$669829$ $(> % $> ' (66$ ?""2 ($ % K$% ("((+.+&+./ +..1
,1 '$$' ( $$G
".4'$+--+&$7''$4'(96 (H ' 8$ L $6($ D 9: $6 ( #$6 ;05.
)*+,)+--. ".)0."
05*< 9$$$6 $$ 8 '$;05,< 8$6 (H ( $( 4( $ > $1 8(($ @ 6($ $($669 >8 $'(' 6$ $ (' $(9: $D$ 8 $ 96 $J
" 0* '$ +--+ ("(66$$( M6(6 $>$ N (66$$(6(6 & $ '$4'(96 (H 1 '897' 2$ ($>6$ $( $6($ $ & (O(66$$( '$ > (9H ( 8$$'$ (66 6($ 6$7 9$ $( > $ D"$'1 L 8P( ( $ $ 66($ 2$ > $1 $& ( $(($( $(690E76 9 +-76$7($ %6 L (1
#$ @ '$$ $D 44 8 669 (66$$(&'$ $E( (9+--+19: $6 05+&05/ 05, $ 6 (' $( )(H $4$ 6$ $19: $6 05* 05.'2&8$$'$ (66 6($ 82$ 4(6 $( $ 49(%1 $6 $(& '(6 $ %9$ & $ $ $ L 9$ $> 2$ ($> >8$ ('$ '% @ 82 $ 9$19: $6 05* 05.& &('$ 4$8(9H 829$$ $( ( 6 '(6 8(H 9: $6 ('D( $%Q1 $$(66$$('$ ( ('$($' @6($ $(9: $6 829$ $(05, ( ((@6($ $(D9: $6 L G
" 0/ 4'$ +--/& '$ $ 9$ '$4'(9(($ $(( > $($ J
"*6+--/&$ 7' $ ('$4'(91 (H (($ R((%$ 8 6 ' (4( 8$669 7 +- 67 ' '$ 8 % +&F 67 & '($ +&.67 6 J
" +F 6 +--/& 6 8$ $ 8%$ 8'$(6 ;$"7G < '$ 4'(9 ( ' 86$ (4( ' >$ $ $ ( %( 2$> (6 ' 8(' 2 $J
"+*6$+--/&(66$$(82$ 66($4$ $( (H ( >A$ $ (6 $ $> $' G $ 6 % 9: $6 '$ 4 D $669 '($$ '$ $ (6 ($ $(J $ 6 6>$9$ 8 K$% '$ L ' 8 % %7 J 4$& 6 $D
)*+,)+--. "F)0."
'$ L 26($'( D J'6$($ $ 8( H@ (2$9J
" 0* H$ +--/& (66$$( 82$ '$ ($ $'6 (H 6($4$(0,H$+--/J
" +. H$ +--/& '$ ($ ( $( '$ 4'(96 (H @ ($ $( > $D ' $D 6 ( $ +5$7 ,E+6+$6$ D$76 %8$669 (H 8D7$(4$$&($ SB.8,--1"6+ 6$ % SB.8*--1"6+D$76 %1 ($ $('$ '$% $D@ 4$ 'D1
*1 *(T +--/& $'8 ($ $(6($;!F-F-O+< $$>8 ($ $(( $;E*FF+O+< $'(H 0,H$ +--/1 8 ($ $( $ (66 ($ $(& $D ' 6D$6D '$ H$$> ( 4$$ 8( $( 0- H$ +--/& ($ SB .8,--1" 6+ ( 6 6$ % SB .8*--1" 6+ ( D D$76 %1
51 8 ( 2$> ($ ( $( +.H$ +--/& $ ( > 8$669 (H (6$ ($ ("( (6( K$% = &?""2++-6+ $9@ $'$ (66$ $$ > > % $>& ($ (? 6 ( F* $7 ( 4 0F,- 6+1 $D $&/5F6+@ SBF8E*.1")6+& $ SB+8+--8---1" (T 'D SBF855.8---1"1 (T ( 8( $( R (6$ D 4$ 4$$$' $6' $ SBEA/F-8---1"1
E1 ($ $(6($ ( $*(T +--/( 9$ B$8'$(44$$;B <0/(T +--/1
0-1 5 69 +--/& $( $6($ $' ;$"7 G < >$ 6$@A$' $9: $6 05. 05*' A $* ($( $(6(6 & $ .H$0E*, ;!#".-F<1
$ $( $6($ $ (' (A$$ $( @A$' $&( $4(6($ $0F( (9+--/1
001 5 69+--/&$7'(( ($ $( ( $ 6($7(66$$( ((6 $7 ( $( ;$"7 G (66$$( (< ( @ $(1
)*+,)+--. ",)0."
0+1 0- 69 +--/& A ( ( ($ $( ( $ 6($7(66$$((( @ $(1
0/1 +* ( (9 +--/& 8($ $( U$' D D"$'U ( 68$ ' $(7(66$$((D( >8'$ ( @ ( ( 6$ >8 6$4 $ ( (($ $( @ 6($ $( 9: $6 $%$ = +, 6 +--/ 8 $ $( $%.--( ($6$$$7' ($1
0.1 (66$$((44 ( >$6$ ( ( 66 > 9: $6 05. A$ 6 (69 >$ $($ A R 76 244%& $ A 6 6$ %1
0F1 +/4'$+--.&(66$$(( ($ $( 6($ ( $7'($H($ (1
( ( $ 7' $ '9& $7 R >$ ( ($ > ($ $ 8 9: $6 9$ $9$( 27> D"$'& @ 8 +& #$6 ; ( +*+< $ @ (D$6$ (H ( 1 %$$ $$>$ '($$1
>$ ( ($ 8 $ 6$ $ $( 8 $ 0.F $/($( $( $ $($'0.'$0E55 ; "F-F<1
> $(>$ ($ '$8($ $(U$'D D"
$'U $ $(' 1
($ $('$ L 6 '$ 4$D$D ' 6 '$ ($ $(4 @$D ( $( 4$ $4 SB ,8---1" $7 1 $$( $ ( $ @ H$ $9 87& (R $ (%6 (' $ @$D SB,8---1"$71$ 4 $ (66$D(R4$ $4(R(( D9($( ( $( ( 4 (%6 D$ 1 (% $( ('$ L (1 8H( $ 4$ > (6 $ $ U( $(U%$ 0-H$ +--/ $D67 9 # ((%6 @( $'$ 4$D@ SB,F-1"(>8$ $ SBFF-1" ( $ %'($ $D ( $( (%6 8( (9+--/1
0,1 * '$ +--.& !!1 2& !( & 8 %( $ B(? ;$"7 G !12 (( < %$ (H($ 6 ($$6 ( (
)*+,)+--. "*)0."
$9 6$$ $4 ( $$( +/ 4'$ +--. (66$$((1
( $$6 @8 $($ $$( '($ ($ @ (66$$( ( 4$ > 8$ $( ($ (6 $($ 18%$$ ( 66 8(9 $ ( $%6 6 (68((6$(H '8('(H > D 9: $6 L $ 6$ 1 2 & $ ('$ (66 ( $ D 4$ 6$ 6 $ 1 #9$$$6 & $ ( @ > $9 6$$ $4 (( 68$ $($( %%$"19: $6 L $ ($6 8 '$& #$6 8' $$ > $ 9: $6 $ (% $7 7 8 $ ( $( (6$ @ ($ 6($ $(& 4(6 $( (' $(6$(829$ $(+FH'$0EE,; "F+-<18%$$ ($ 8$669 $$>6 @ $'$ &($ 9: $6 >$(6( $ >8(%6 ('$ $$D $ 268$ $( 1
$ > 9: $6 05. ( $ (69 6%& D"$ ('$ L ($(6629$ 97(>8$$($ '$8 %6$$66'($ 8 $ $9>8 ' (D829$ $(8$6696(R8$%$( $ $($ $(%$91 ( &$8 $ ( 6 $( $ $($ H( 44$ 1 829$ $( (69 8 $ 4$ >8 M( $( 46$$ 9: $6 N >$ (6( $ 7(>8(%6 1 $$&9: $6 05,('$ L H $ @ 6 (V 6$ D$76 % (69 $ 44 $'6 '( @ 829$ $(1 7 (& 8 $ ' $( > '$ ($>49 (%6 ($9: $6 ($8 $ &(8% &>.5+6+1
#8%$ (T ( $( H% ( ' (66$$( (& $ 4$ ' > 4$ 6($ $(& 8$ $( 2 $ '$ 2$(T ('( $(1
0*1 * 6$ +--.& $ 7' ($ (9' $(1 D ( & !$ 2 !( & '$ >$ ($ $( 6($ ( $++'$+--.&'(R 6$ $9: $6 L 1
051 00 6$ +--.& 4$ (9' $( $9 6$$ $41
)*+,)+--. "5)0."
(66$$((8'$ (6 4$ >8 ($ $( $ $%$'$$ $((%6 4 ( $ $6$>$ 'D 6($ $(1 $ >$ ($ (T % 8( $(& '$ >(T 67 9# $ $%$ ( > 8( ('$ $ 7' ( ?( '(6 & $67 ($9 ( ( $(1$44$ 2 $8 $ 6L6&(6 ( $ $2 @$ $(81 ('$ 4( $ $>(4$$(T 6$$9 8( $(
0E1 0* 69 +--.& ( ( $ > (' ($ $( $' 00 (T +--. '(R 6$ $ D 9: $6 L 8$ L $$!!2 !( &8( $( ' 9( ((T 1
8$ $( ( $ 9 9$ 8 'D (4(6(H $$ $1
+-1 ++ ( (9 +--.& 8($ $( U$' D"$'U ( (9' $(1 (W$ @ $'@((1
+01 ++( (9+--.&$7'$ ($( $ > D$76 ($ $( ( $ $' '$ 4 8 ( ($ $ 1 82$ 6 !!12 !( '$ (>$ $$ ( $9 6$$ $4 (> D$76 ($ $( $ 4(1 ('$ ($@8$ $((8 $$( D$76(1
++1 $$( 0, 4'$ +--F& (66$$( ( H ( >$ '$ ( !!1 B(? 8 %( $ D$76 (( 8 ($ $(( $$'@!!12 !( 1
+/1 +* '$+--F&6H%% @8$ $(& ( ( $ > D$76 ($ $( ( $ ' 4$$ $'($ (H >!!12 !( 8 $ $ $1( $(&$6$ $ (1
+.1 A A(A(9' $(&6%>$$ 1
+F1 #>($& %@H%1
)*+,)+--. "E)0."
0
01 H 6 $ ' H$$ $( (6 & ( '9; 1F, ($8(%$ $(H$$$++('690E.0" " +-FJ 1,/10$ 1($(6$$ $'0+ 690E5F" " F0-<1
+1 ('$ 6$$ 6$ $@(1
(66$$(($(' > $(>$ (%$ A($ $(M$'D D"'$'N 6$$7' 8 1
1 #A%$ A($ $( M$' D D"$'N& >$ ( @ ($ @($ ' $( (&6$2( 1
91 >$ (%$$7'&(66$$ $( A$669& ( A $ 0.F $ + 4( %6 >$ ($ $'($$(; 1,- <1
1 >$ ( ($ A H@ ( $9 44$$6$$( 6($ $(A$669J 4(A $,/!#; )+F/)0EE*++'$0EE*<1
/1 (66$$(($(' > $('($$D 9: $6 L ;05* 05.<('$ L ($(6669 94$$ ( $( $ 5E $' $ $% ( $(&7(>(H $4$$ ( 4W(DD$% 1
.1 A$> @ ( 9: $6 $ A ?( ( $( ' A $ 0E ($ 8$ $( ($ 4 86%6 $ ($.H$0E5*; "0/-< >$(6( (D>$&6%6 $ $9 $(&( 44 @A29$ $( ; 1 + 1 0 <1 ( H $& 6$( $$'$ (6( >A(%6 ; 1+1+ <1
(>A 6$( A29$ $( (6( 6($ D (%6 $ >$ ' L ( 46$ ( ( $44 &$4$ %7( >A$A%$ A6$($$'$ > $9J@A$'&6$(A29$ $(&$$ 4T "& (W 6% ( '($ 46$& 2 @
)*+,)+--. "0-)0."
AH $6 @ 1 ( 66 2= $$ ; 10/'$0E55�E551/F-<1
A $ + $ 0 ($7 6$( A29$ $( (66 9: $6 J'(R @ ( $(&($47@( $(2$ (4( $(1 (%$>> &>$A$7($ %'($( $( (($ (%6 &47A9( @( $(( $'(2$ M9: $6 N&($ 9( > $( ( ( M (%6 N& A ($ ' 4( $(1 $$& ( $(>$ 4W> ($ $ 6$4 &( $ 6$(A29$ $( (D6$(( $%Q& 6L6$(6( D(%6 ' $6 $'$$($ 6(6 ($ 17(> 6$( (6( D (%6 & (6$ @ @ $ F , ( 2%6 A44 $(; )E,,)+--.0.69+--.<1
A7& 9: $6 05. 05* $ @ A($%$ 6$( $$'$(6 $ 6 6$ % (691
$$'% > (69(%6 D$ 6 9: $6 1
> 2> 9: $6 (6( $ D 6 & ( $ $'6 E ,$71
($ $ ( >L 6($ $(& D 6 ( $ * $7 ( 9: $6 05. D 6 ( $ . $7 ( 9: $6 05*1 $7 $ & $ 44$6 >9: $6 05.(6( $ >A(%6 &(69 6%(' L ($(6629$ 9$('$A % A$9$$ 1
$ 7'& > @ & 7% > 9: $6 05. ( $ ($ (%6 ( $ 0- $7 9: $6 05*& D 6 ( $ *$71
(66$$( ( 2$44 ($ 1 6($&( ( &'&A%$ 9: $6 05.& >A 6 '$ 6%(69'6??$1 6 $ 2441 $ $9 $ A 6 0 %1
(> & (6 A9 A$ $7 6% (69& 9: $6 05. ($ L ($ (66 29$ $($$'$ A $$(6$@ 1
)*+,)+--. "00)0."
9: $6 05* ( $ @ 6L6 (> ( 6L6 ( $(>9: $6 05.1 $$(%6 9: $6 $'$($ $1
9: $6 05, $ @A($%$H@$669( (6( $(%6 1 $> 6 ( $ 0-$7 /269 (691 ($ $ '$ ( D (%6 / . $7 4(6$ $ $> H($ @ >L 6($ $(1 !% $'%& $ $( 9 > 9: $6 (6( A (%6 1
$$& 8 9: $6 ( 6($ $( >$ (6$ @ & $ ('$ AD6$ ($ $( A( ($ A ($ $( ( $ 6($( %$($ (6 4$ > 9: $6 ( (6$D($ $( 1
F1 1 & ( ' A( ($ A (% $(& 6($ ( ( $A9: $6 &(($(; 1F <1
91 ( (% $(& ( 66 (>A$ D$ $ L %& A "@"$ (> ( $( 6 $9 %6 $( 4 2 44 (%6 & ( (6 6$ $('(6 (66 A $ &(>A$ (2$ 9 (6 $9'($ $('$> $; 1,10$ 1 <1
( $(A$669(6( (? 6 ( $ F*$7$ A$669D&'($$> 6 ( $6 @$ L % >4$$@A $,$0 1 $A A$( 1
,1 @ 6$ $ (H 6$ ($ $( ( A $,$+ / 1
( (% $( $ (%6 ( $ ( & > @ % (R ( $D& D 9($ ( ( $(J $ $ (6 & ( $ $(& % (%6 D$ J$D'$ (%6 ( $ &%A$669& (69 $7 6 & $$ > 4 (%6 ('6 ; 1,1+ <1
4$D (66 ($ $( A ($ $( $D ' 6D$6D(%6 6( 6D$66(R; 10- <1
9($ ( ( $(& $ 4 (R $9 @ 6H($ ( $(& ($ (6$ SB +8.--1"
)*+,)+--. "0+)0."
SB/8++F1" $7 ; 1 , 1 / <1 4(2 D $(6 L $ $( $$7 H $4$ & ( 66 & $ 4 9 ( $' $7 $6( ; 1 , 1 / <1
*1 1 $9 6$$ $4 H@ ' > 6 ( $( $ 7 ' @ 8 $ E $ + 6 $ (6 $ L 1 %& $ $ 6 844 $ $( %(9 4$ 8'$ (69 26 $6 > %$ D6 '( '$ 1 8(> '$$( & ($ 8 '$ %6 $$ 89( $ 8 $ $( $(9 ($& ( $ '($ (69D (H H6$ L $ ($' 2(67 '$$$6 $( $(( $4%'($;!6($ ($0EEF1.F,F".F,,J )F..)0EEE0. 690EEE<1
($ $( '( 8 $ E ' L $ 8%$ 8 $ , >$ '($ %6 $ (6 $$ 7( ($6($ $()( $(1
91 8 4(6 $(& $9H%>(>A 6 ( D9($( ( $((% ( (R $ 6 6 D $ % (69& AD$% (R ( D 9($ ( ( $( $ 6$ ( A69 A 6 ('6 1 $$(R$($7('6 A $ 9 ; )+*.)0EE*+E'$0EE*<1
1 $9 ( 4($ 6$ A 4(6 $( A$669&6 $(('D(%6 (( % (R D 9($ ( ( $(& ( >A' $A DR(($ (R&>8 $ $( %(96 $ $' A ($ $(1 &6L6$ (R 4$D ( $ 6 D (( D 9($( ( $(; )00-)0EEEE4'$0EEE<1
1 $9 6$$ $4 6$ (66 (4(6 D D$% (R4$D@ SB/8F--1"$7A 6 > $7 A 4 0-- 6+ $( D % 269'='; )F..)0EEE0. 690EEE<1
87& $D ' ($ & ($ SB .8,--1" SB.8*--1"6+( 4((R4$ $4 SB,8---1"$71 6( $ 7%6 "D(( D9($ ( ( $(1
)*+,)+--. "0/)0."
H $4$ $D $ $7 >$ $ A $ $ @ 6(R ;+F 6+ $ 05&F 6+< 4$ > 6 ( $ ( 41
51 #A%$ $$7&$P > 6 (H
0 +76 %( 0/+6+ 00E6+(F$7 EE6+(
. $71 4 9 ' L ($ (66 $ M$6( N 8 $, $/ >A$ ( $ $( $$76 6 4(2 (R& A $, 1 44 &$4 0--6+(. $7 6 6 H>A@ SB/8F--1" 4(2 (R& (H$ $9&4(%6 (H ( (691 4 9 (%6 . $7 6L6 $ > 4 >$ 6 $ (6 8 $( $$71
$6%6 >8$D$ L 6$$( 4$ > 6 ( $ ( 41 6 >$ ($ L $(6 (8D686 4(6 $(((' $( ; 1 E < 8 $ 87 $>& 4$$ $(& ( (%6 ( $ 76($ $(( 41
AH( > 7$447H% $9 &D($"($ 1 87&$669A29$ $(& ( $ 8$$> > (R $ $ @ D (( D 9($( ( $(6 6 ( $D ' 4$D 4( (R 7 %6 $ D 9($ ( ( $(1(69(%6 $7' $669$$ 96 $6( 6$&$A 6($ >A (%6 (H (( ( $D D 9($ ( ( $(1
(>& 6L6 4$ $ $( %(9 > (2$ %$ &>$6 ( 66 $6$ 4$D $((R ($D 6 @ $('$6696 &(66 A4$ &A ($ $( >$'(L (4$6&$D ' 4$D( DD$% 1 8 7( $8D6$(4(6$ ($ $($ $%$(8% 1
(H 1
E1 A$$ $%&6(6 SB+8---1"6$@2% ( &$(H($ 6 ($$6 ; 15* <1 XXXXX
)*+,)+--. "0.)0."
* 0
8(&9" :
'9 ( $ H 5 '$ +--. !$ "2$$ 2&C$A %( $&!$2B(? "!$2!( ( $$( (66$$( ((6 $7( $(+/4'$+--.J
&9:
H J
6 2(8($ $(U$'D D"$'UJ
6 @ 2% ( & $ (H($ 6 ($$6 & 6(6 SB+8---1"J
(66$> L @!"!#$%$ &'( ( $$>8@ (66$$( ( ( 6 $7 ( $(& 6 86%6 & 8>$6 (%6 & @ $ 7'& @ 8($ $( U$'D D"$'U$$>8@ $( $6($$' 1
#$% G !6('R&$ &!1R27&!6S$&!1 2$&!6(& H%1
(6 $96$$ $4G
%44$7"H$ H1G '$"$ G !1 (($ 1('R
($(4(6 L (66$>D $1 7'& %44$7G
)*+,)+--.