Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/756/2005 • CJ GE ATA/756/2005 Généré par l'IA

Property Rights Dispute Over Alleged Contract Formation

Numéro de cause ATA/756/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case concerned a dispute over property rights related to an alleged agreement, which the appellant contended was established through communications that should have been interpreted as creating a binding contract despite subsequent ambiguities or lack of formal documentation. The court reasoned that the communications, viewed in context, failed to demonstrate the requisite mutual assent and definite terms necessary to form an enforceable contract, thus affirming the lower court's judgment against the appellant because the evidence did not sufficiently establish the existence of a completed agreement regarding the disputed property.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Rights Dispute Over Alleged Contract Formation: The court reasoned that the communications, viewed in context, failed to demonstrate the requisite mutual assent and definite terms necessary to form an enforceable contract, thus affirming the lower court's judgment against the appellant because the evidence did not sufficiently establish the existence of a completed agreement regarding the disputed property.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
droit à la propriété contentieux contractuel notion de décision contrat possessoire contestation civile droits et obligations contractuels

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Costs were imposed on the appellant (Art. 66 al. 1 LTF).
Généré par l'IA
A/4500/2006
Property Rights and Contractual Obligations Dispute
A/3818/2005
Contractual Dispute and Property Rights Determination
A/2632/2004
Contractual Disputes Over Property Interests and Termination Rights
A/1474/2001
Contract Enforcement and Property Interests Dispute
A/1968/2003
Contract Formation and Breach Dispute

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Costs were imposed on the appellant (Art. 66 al. 1 LTF).

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

         

 

   

 !"#  







$%%  !"# !$%&$ 

$ 

&$$& $   &$  '   &$ & $



(     )(*   + )(,     $*    





     #'())#

 

)/   $"  0$" 1/ / 2"#34 0$"5   $#$" " & 6    "    7*'% '-.8% '-,-% '97)   $00  "% "+'%:0":""; 1&</

   $" %6$" = >:?$;%$@$  $A '.;>:":BB< "/C>0$"D")889%  "  <0 >/

'/  $  )887% 0$"   "  0: " B"   0   $B$0"  &  6"<  0 "3  "  C>  =  &"  / 0$"""&"<>"  "$> $  "$ $ ""/

7/  B"0 "$D % 0$"$ %)80;)887%    $"  &"$/ >" "$%"   $& C E $  $0  $   $  " F" G $0"6&"$0  %F C>G3  "$$ %0" H>CI F" G$& J/

+/  0$"0 $"  ;61/ /2"#34 ;65%C" ;"% 0; )88+%  $0  " "  E" "B   J% C ""  >" <" $$D 2"#34" "B5/

    "  "   $0 %  < ,   9% :"BB 7/+% C E >0$"  "C $  "   $<  $00 "& 42K5$ =$" "$& "CJ2:"BB7/+/'5/

  $ %6 0:"BB7/9%<*4

  E 2K5 & F&" G I  $&  00      ""/ $ 0    "$ >$<  ; &$"" %  & $$  F " G <0  H $&" 00      H ""J/

   :0  ""% B )#)--,#8+      8 0; )88+ 2"#34:0""5% " <0 D$" " "B/ ""  >"  "$ $D %    C >" <"   ""   $0    & " "/ = :&B"<" ?0;$"& 4 E J/

./   '' 0; )88+% 0$"  $  CI    $" "$  $ " 3   0   &6 ;"    ><" L &

()*+,('--. #7())#

D$>:"   0  >0<0 %  >C"0     $<0  2"# 34   0 5/ #" $ "    "  "$  B $  >""/" "B" ? " D$" /

,/  '90)88.% 0 $H 0$"> $" "$B"" "& $ "B$87+-)2"#34> $" "$5/

  #"&$?" $ 00 %$$" .%$" "$"& 4

  E"  "$$ $B$06" "B 0; )88+% "" C>6 " "& $   $A< >:?$;M 2& "$ >"" 0$?>6 " "$5J/

9/  $ C  &6  "   $% 0$"  ;$ > $< >" /

  0$""B$0 0 "8D")889/ " "   $    0    C "$  &$" "  " "& "C  )88.  "  $D$ E> " J/ $3 0 %  ""  &$"%  &6>   0"%"0""  "$" $ 0$ "  $D$"/

*/    0  "  $  >BB"0 "&     '9 $&0; )88*/  BB %  ? 30 B"6 >6 " "$ H 0$  "  ;$0  "";6;$"" = /

  %$""" C4

  E""$0$<2K5>F " G"H> 0" >$ "$>$ $00 0;)8873 "$$" "$ $0I0/F " G  " "B  ;"N ;61/ /N0;)88+J/

8/   &6 $    BB  $  $O  >&"$ PQ 'R+--R---/#/ >"  "$ $ " & "& "$0&>  0$</

)-/  >   >&0   "$" "B B"6 >6 " "$   "B"   $ $ 0   6"<  0"  $B$0"  6"<"; $  $" "$> $" "$87+-)% 0 "  0$"%"  + D"  '--)%   $ 00  C E $   & 2 S 0$5 F&" G I  0$ $"   $&$" I   "$ "     $00J/

))/   '- 0; '--)% B"  "  H  "$  )9  0; '--) &  &" $% 0$"  "B$0   0  C> &"  B" 

()*+,('--. #+())#

&" H &"$ PQ 7*-R---/# > $0 " "$  &/  $ %  "  "$  $ =  H "  "  "BB       = /  BB %" " ;$ " /%<" 0> $0 "0 "  E0""0J/ $"$% 0$"0"  0  E;"&$$" 60""  "$J/

)'/      )7 D" '--'%   0   "   0 3  0$"%    C > $0 " "$  >$&   & " "; " &" I " % >""7- 0;'--'/

)7/   )* D" '--'% >" "   "  $0$ "$   " % :<  >"   >     & "$ >""  =   0$" H "%  $$  04

  E  "30" &$ = $"6 "0"$/ >  " C" "&$ "  > 3;$"&/2K50" B"" "&>$ ">6 " "$: "& : B$0 2? 30>6 " "$ $0 "CH0$&$&$"  $ <%""C"><H0$$;"5F$03 G""  " "$  &$  $& $ "" $   $  "$ $  <0 "0"$/J

)+/   )) D"  '--'% 0$"    "$  $"   0   )7D"'--'/"C""&" B"6> " " % 0$@&"  $ >;$$0 $D H>$BB" " $ >"0$  "$  ;    $0; "; "C" 2"#34 ;5% $&"B" "$/   %$  " >6"< 0 &$" > $0 " "$  & & $00% C E$&$CF" G  B"$0% "0$&"$"0 H PQ+--R---/#J/

)./  $ H 0$"')$ $;'--'% 0 >"B$0B"  C>" &"  EB""FG $" "$J%  0"3 H &$"  0I0 :0 >" & "$  $  = J/  $B"0"   $  >6"< > $0 " "$>$& &" "; "/$&"%7) D&"'--7% " B"6H 0$"$>6 /

),/   $" "$  ;   & H 0$"  )+ $&0; '--'/  $$  >"  "$  B $  >""   =  0$" H "% ;&" C4

 #  " "&  ;  "&"    0"3 "  "  "$& "$>"""  "$&$"&" I  $00H" $$M

 #  "  "$  0$< 3  $   :<0  $&" % 3<<%I :M

()*+,('--. #.())#

 # 0$ <0$  "C&6"  $>$< &$"%0$<&$" ;"> " "M

 # $   & $&"  I  0" H >" "    /  >?&" ; "" "; "$6 $00> >  =    <"$  "/   " " "$  "   " $  0" "$/

)9/  0$"  B"      0   $"$  ;  $"  ') $&0; '--'/ $  > $0 " "$  &% 0$" ""    0 %&$"$ ;%&$"H$&$" "$/ >" "  ""  " <0 $&E><"  "$0 &" "; "$J/

)*/  7-D"'--7% 0 %$ " $" 0$"') $&0; '--'%  $B"0  $" "$/ B"  EB""  >" & "$   $0" $  0"    ? 30 >6 " "$    $" ><"   " 0 J%  &6 &"  I  6  $B$00   $"')$ $;'--'/

)8/   '+ 0 '--+% $ > $ = BB     >" "$  $  B   " %   0   $   C  "  &6 0 >&"     "/   "     > $0 " "$  >$& & "C" "; "/

'-/   0 "B$0 0$"".0"'--+/ "0" '.D"'--+" " B"6$>6 "$ &6$BB/

')/   '+ 0" '--+%       0     0$"  $  "B"E"B"$" "$:J/  0 "$% $" "$ "&>$  $ B$"&$/

''/  0$"<"'D"'--+%0 H" "$$" $  "$ 0 C>""$B$0 ";$$"  H$$>6"<> $0 " "$>$& &/

'7/  ""$)8D" '--+% 0 $B"0H 0$"B"  C  &  " H "; > $  0$ " H  "  &$"&" I $00 "C0 /"" " B"67- $&0;'--+$ ;""  "$$B$0$" /

   ""$&" $0"$B$0" H> $" "$87+-)%  ")'8 "& $"$  "$ "  "$ "&)+&")82 L.-.5/

()*+,('--. #,())#

'+/   )' $O  '--+%  $;    "$  " "B 2B/ :/ + 5%B"  $;& "$H 0$"/$ 00 C4

 # E $ &$" " "; "$ $& $  B$ >""/2K5 "$"  "$"0% $  "0    :$""/   ""% $  " <  &$"  0" "$"0/

 # >""%"BB" >$&"00 &" "; "$ "%C" T $0 "C0 0"U& B$ "$4 $:$"6$  0" "$%"BB " $ $$ $& 0$/

 # >D0" C "$>0$ $" "$&" "; "$  B$ >""/ 0$0 $"B" "$  $  "$% &" > &$C%C$" &0T  >$&<$   $" /

 # $ >" " C" "B/1$ =   $" "$  & 2$& (B05   $    "C   &/  B$ "$ "C  ?0;$$$  $ )#)--,#8+/J

   "3%$" $ %  0" 0 /

'./   )8$O '--+% 0$"""$00""$ $$ 0 "3$  "$2"#34$00""$5>$""<$  ""$ 0 /

   ""$ $   B""  >$;D   "  "$$ "$    >&"  D0" $ " C"" " "0$/

',/   0 > $$$/$ 00 $"  ; B E'-7()J   " "  E,/7 ?0;$ $  ? "    $"J%B"" "BB ?0;$  ""$0"%$ $0E'+'8J%$" 4

#  4$000< "CM

#  4B0 H0"M

#  4&</

'9/  $00""$;$  0$" $ $"$""$ '-&"'--./

()*+,('--. #9())#

  ?0;$"C:0&$?" C$00& "  0< "C "<E J 0$"<"  3 "C" &/ ""%""$0"$B$0" H> $" "$$ """ " "  B$/  0 %  :"   <"B  &"$ "$  ""   $$ "$" /

'*/     $   '9 0" '--.% 0$"  $ 3  "; 0""  "B $  "  ""$/  $ % $ "   B"   % H $ "$/

  > $" "$  $ "  87+-) >""   >6"< > $0 ">$& &" "; "$%$ C"  "$ 6"   " $B$0H"  $" "$/ $ %0$$  " " "%   $$B$0""$$ "$" /

'8/  .$O '--.% 0 > $$$/

  >$0"$B$0"  " ;"#B$%$" .> $" "$  87+-) "  > $0 " "$  "C  >$&   &/  " "B ;6 &$?" 60  $:0""%     ?0;$4 E J H =   :  &/  % >$0"$B$0"  " $B$0""$$ "$" 

7-/    0  0$"%  "  $0 "$ $   ">  )'$ $;'--./

  0$""H $"$C><)'%0"3<+30V $ $% " B"  " E " "B  ;6  &$?"   > $0 " "$  &J/  $ %  ""$ " "<" &"    " 6"&0  H $ $ %     "  $" "    >   "H$/

   $$  :0  ""%   " $  "    "   "$  "&  ?0;$ E J/ 1$ 0$"%  "< ""C"  0 C$" "$&L$& $B0L&" I 0$ $"% $ C $   0 % " ><""    &  >6"< > $0 " "$&/

  0$"  <0  $ C> >&"  H  0$0  $"  H  $" "$ 0 /

   >"  >"% 0$" >  & "0 "  "  7) $ $; '--. $  $$   "3 $"     0 /   " $  <0  $    ";   C>  >$$"  %  : %HC$" $$6 "/

()*+,('--. #*())#

7)/  7)$ $;'--.% 0$">  0"C 6"3$"   0 %$ >0 $&/

7'/  1C$"% <HD</

$ 

)/    D   0  " &   D"" "$ $0  %  $   &;2 /., $"R$<" "$D"""''$&0;)8+)# # '-.M /,7/)" /$"$0""  "&)'  0;)8*.# # .)-5/

'/  $" $ %  C>  " """$  C%C" $$"2 /,- /; 5/

7/  ""$" "<"; ")'8 "&  />$;D  " "<$ $B$0" & 0 $" "$> $" "$'9 0)88. &6BB $ /

   > ")'8  %"0" "$" "$> " )7-%   0    $$% H ><  $  "$%  "  "$ $> :$%0"  % "$%0$"B" "$%"$ $0$" "$2 /5/

  1$ > " )7-  %  0 &  I  $$    0  $C >   > $  "$% > "  "$ $ >   :$ >   $B$0 6 " "$   $" "$ "&  " "$"$" "$<$<0 "/

  >3%"> $  C""$ C;$"  .> $" "$87+-)"&'90)88. 0 %C "$" C"  "$&" I $B$0" "B%""C>6 " "&$ $A<>:?$; ;" ;/

+/   ><"  $   0 " > $ >    6 $0  &$?" > $0 " "$>$& &" "; "$/

./  1><"   " "&  ;%  "     $"  H  $  C>  "$" "$   6   &$?"  >$;"< "$&$"> $0 " "$>$& &" "; "$/

    "$> >"$  %HD  " % "/

,/ / > " "B/

()*+,('--. #8())#

  1$   0 %  " "B%  "0  $ :0  ""% &$?"  "0  C  & &"  I   $0 "%  ?0;$E J" :0  &/

  $ "&$C%C H%C 6 " "B " "   C>"  &$?"  C  $ =  "C   $" "$   & 2$&  $ B05/  $ % >   " "B    $ :0 &"  $B"0$"   "$2B/ /'+5/

 ;/ $ 0"$ " "B :0"" ;" ;6% " $&"    B 6 3< <  R"   "$  $  /?"::% $ R;$% $00"  "$  " 2 / )*/ / ) 5/ $C #"    I   ;"% " B     $&"&$$ 0 ""    "$$   C   " "  #" $&"    &"  "$;0   $ $  3<   ;$ B$" 2""   $B"5/   "   "$B$0 R3 6  $ 6  "$% 0""R3"$ C"$ $$0<2 Q )'')+,$"/+%)'')-*$"/.%)'))'7$"/+;(%))8+.) $"/7%)),'''$"/'M Q !/)-$ $;)889++(8, M&$" "/  % " $;"< "$$" "%'30" "$%/'7.5/

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

()*+,('--. #)-())#

;"     ""$/  "   H C  " "B  $0$ "   >6"<> $0 ">$& &" "; "$/

9/  $0 0 "$$" .> $" "$$ "  '9 0 )88.  &$?  > $0 " "$  >$&   &  " "; "$%B$ $  C &6BB $ $  $B$06 0 $" "$"  $" "$/"$ %   0  > "   B$%   ;   " )'8   "&   % H $$ H  $  >"  "$ > ? 30 > $0 " "$  >$& &" "; "$ $= /

*/  ""%$>&3;"B$/""$ C$/

  >"" "<%0$0  PQ)R.--/#0"H:<  0 % C" $0; 2 (+'7('--.  )+ D" '--.5/  $  $;  <"%"0"  PQ'R---/#"$%H:< >  3&2 /*9 5/  XXXXX

& $      

-./0#! 1

&;$" D '90"'--. 0$"1/ /$ ""$ $00""$ $$0 "3$  "$'-&"'--.M

/01

>0 M

""$ CM

0 H:< 0 >0<0 %>C"0  $<0  0$0  PQ)R.--/#M

$"0" $ PQ'R---/#H 0$"1/ /%H:<>   3&M

$00"C I H!"# !$%&$ $ %"" C>H$00""$ $$0 "3$  "$  0  >0<0 %>C"0  $<0 /

()*+,('--. #))())#

1"< 4 !/ ?:3% " % !0 $&?   P"% !/ :"% !0 $% D</





$0 ";0""  "B4

<BB"3#D" 4  " 4     /"$#1"<"  Q/?:3  

$"$B$0 I  $00"C6 "/

 3&%  <BB"34           

()*+,('--.