ATA/733/2004 · Water Rights Dispute Based on Accretion Claims (Cour de Justice (Cour civile))

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case involves a dispute over the allocation of rights concerning the use of a waterway, where the litigant challenging the current distribution alleged that the historical division did not properly account for changes in the physical characteristics of the water flow, specifically arguing for an adjustment based on accretion. The court reasoned that the governing principle for dividing water rights in this scenario requires adherence to the established boundary or allocation method unless clear and substantial evidence demonstrates a permanent, non-negligible alteration to the waterway's course that meets the legal definition of avulsion or that the original grant was fundamentally flawed, finding that the presented evidence of incremental change did not overcome the long-standing prescriptive allocation.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

RESTAURANT; CAFE; AUTORISATION D'EXPLOITER; INFRACTION; PROPORTIONNALITE; CONDAMNATION | Refus d'autorisation d'exploiter un établissement public prononcé à l'encontre d'une personne ayant fait l'objet d'une condamnation à 2 mois d'emprisonnement avec sursis pendant 3 ans prononcée en 2002 pour abus de confiance au préjudice de son employeur, vol et avoir induit la justice en erreur. Décision confirmée dès lors que la recourante ne remplit pas la condition d'honorabilité prévue par la LRDBH. Rappel de jurisprudence. | LCBVM.10; RRDBH.7; LRDBH.5 al.1 litt.d

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA

utilisation de l'eau principe de l'accroissement redevance pour droits d'eau droit d'utilisation responsabilité pour dégâts d'eau servitude de conduite

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA

Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF

The court declared the appeal inadmissible based on this procedural rule.

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision was cited in the dispositive regarding the imposition of costs.

Généré par l'IA

A/1349/2004

Water Rights Allocation Dispute Based on Statutory Priority and Beneficial Use

A/2376/2004

Sovereign Boundary Fixation Over Prior Land Grants

C/13024/2014

Water Infiltration Cost Allocation Appeal

A/4401/2022

Claimant Challenge to Administrative Fee and Indemnity Over Submerged Barges

A/539/2007

Property Rights Dispute Over Subsurface Interests

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF

The court declared the appeal inadmissible based on this procedural rule.

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision was cited in the dispositive regarding the imposition of costs.

Texte complet

!

""#$$$$$$$$$$$

% %% % &%'(&%% %& %

!"#

%

&' ()*&+,#-./0/1/-2*'33333333334 (*4&++)/5/5/'

//( 4 % * &+++ (6* 7/- 6/ (/( 8/ 69: (6*; .// .<6/ 5( = ./0 > '3333333333?- /( = 33333333333 = 91- . 5.<6//%&*!'

/ // (( 1( ) 4 !$$!' 5 //@( .(1/=A)*!'

!' @B&&7/!$$%-//((6*.// .<6/5( =./0>C'33333333333?=33333333333 =91-66/((/((C'3333333333D='

7/=@B<//7///-@*// */ = < */ .*6/*- 1 / 6 / - 6(&$*/!$$!645/-161///7/ '

%' 5/ E / = */ 6(/( /1: / !% 71/ !$$!- 2* '33333333333 . 5( F 1//-161('/(4(* 7 90 1/- @/ 1/ (( //*( G' . *6( @@ H/ 5( @@ 6@ /0' 69@/-7(*G//6/( 7/. *-400@@05/5/5 = ' ,G$$ */- 6(1 6/ @. 1/ (( 1//* .0/'

I' I J !$$%- // 6/ /5*( (6* @. / */6(/(-./(( 61/64//5/ 41/*K' / /(*/6(1/(0/5'

A' !+ J !$$%- (6* /5*( 2* '3333333333 @.(6/6=//.G4//('

(//1/(=5/41/(6*-*/.( /=/1//'

"!!!$"!$$% %"#

,' /-6(//&#4!$$%-(6*(/( .// .<6/ .(4/* > '33333333333?- / 5( >C'3333333333?'

#' (//-2*'33333333336A1*4 !$$%((6*-@.*/ /4*///5'

<6/@( @. <6// 5( > '3333333333? 6/4&++)1*/' 5/.(!$$&-95/ .(/*/5(1*/-/4/@.1/(/(1/69 /618/.0/L'3333333333=E/;'. (//1/65 (6/' (///</9*5- @(!%*/!$$!'@.1////*1/ 60 1/ @. 0/ *9*' 6/ - 1/ 5*// (/ 1 * 1/ 6/ .<6// .(4/* > '33333333333? 1 */' D/ (// (/ 5/*(- */ / / /1/-66/(/.(4/*5/=*/ /0(=6/5/'

.(1(* !%71/!$$!- 1/6 (/(- G( @. (/ 6 (/ 61/ 55/ = 5 6E ' 1/ 0/ (/ 6 65- 6 < (@' (//.6/9*5-6*/7/ !$$I' 46 //( 6 @. / .// 6/1 .<6//5(>'33333333333?@.1/*(1*/'

)' (6* . 66( ' 5/ @/ 1/ / = */.(/64(/'*1/(4( .0*G/5(L'33333333333-*/1//*( 0/ 1/ 6( 6/ 6 ' 6(7/ .(/ (1( = @@ MN%OA$$' '

(6* . 5( 7/6 /4 (' (// @./ 1/ 6/ .1/ 6 6 4 .*6BG (5///1* .<6/ (4/* 64/' 5/ * .*6BG .<65/@/*6//@(1(664/6 (/ .1/ < = / ' 2E *6* /(6G4- 6/ 1/0 .< = 1 65/ 1/ 4/ ( (@'

"!!!$"!$$% I"#

% (

&' 7( *6 / 1 7/// *6(- 148'A, /O0//7///!!1*4&+I& !$AP',%'&/'/6(*///1&!6*4 &+)A A&$;'

!' /4 ( 91 @ 6 @ (// /( .// .<6/ .(4/* > '3333333333?'(=65./= <6/>C'33333333333?'

%' ' D ./ A /( & / /- (4/ 4/OG(40*&#(*4&+)#8M !!&;-.<6// 55/- 6 (( *6*- 0/ @ .(4/* /<6/(5*(*</6//6(/<6/6/ */96/(0-(/(//1/'

4' D O/ # 90* O<(/ M %& J &+)) 8M ! !&'$&;- (6* 69 = @B 6/ < 5/ O@@((6<//(*((=O/A/' 66// /6//- (6* 5/G/ 6/ <*/6//6(1=(/1O/5/4 1/*'

' D O/ &$ /( 6*/ ; / /0* / 6/ (/1 /5/ 4 1/ * !+ 6*4&+##8 2 N&!A;-/5/41/*5(= / / 7/// / */ /( = 6/ 6/1/1 /4(' O/( *6( 66(/ /4*- (0 < /- / / */ 6 01/( 61 6 B '6B*B**//O/5/ //'

' O69-((*(645/-1-6 1/ // 7/ ' */ // / 7/// O6/('O/((O4//6/5/4 1/*'

I' =(*//-/4(.66(//@//1/- ./(//*(5/40/0*@.@/6/'

A' 7/// ( . 6( = @@ 6/ // .G4//( @. 5/0 = ./ A /( & M' /6//(((/0(5Q=6*66(//(-5/ 0.(4/*@@(<6/'

"!!!$"!$$% A"#

' B,7/!$$$-/4(5/*(5.// .<6/=6@/1/ (( *(=6/.*6/* .(/*/-1/6/-6.< @/ .(/ (( 66 (4/* 64/ <6/( 6 ./((-@/*/=&++)8 "%##"!$$$,7/!$$$;'

4' - /4 ( 5/*( 5 .// .<6/=6@/.(/16G(166*.5/ 6/6(5/@./((1/1/./*(//'/4 /*(@5/6*/666/514=6/( //0*/95*=/(4/*64/8 "!+I"!$$$) */!$$&;'

' B- /4 *///5 /(( @ .<6/- *(6<@/=/=6/@*/ .*6/* 1 / 6 /@ - 6(/ 6 9 .G4//(/*6(6/8 "%,+"!$$&!+*/!$$&;'

' B(-7///((.6 E (( *( = < */ .*6/* 1 / 6 < 6 1/ 1 1(G/ *4/ @/ / 66/ 6' E 5/*(5.//.<6/-/4/*(@./E1// / *6 .(* *6- / 6(/( @ 6 @ ./(( 6 1 /5/- 1/ B /( = <6/(4/*64//(6/1*(4 .( !$$A- / < 69 */ 6( 8 "!#!"!$$I %$ *!$$I;'

,' 6(55/-/4@5/*(4 .( !$$! @ */ . (( */ !$$!' 7- / . ((66<6/.*/'5/@/ 7/5/(/01:/E45/6(7/ .*6E - 1 7 /* . 0/E//7/' *6*E6/@* 66 (/ / 1 65/ <(- / .<6/ . (4/* 64/' /* = .69 (1@( / 1 8 "!#!"!$$I 6(/(;-F/.(/0/./5/=96/*/E((/ 6///(6<-*6* /=./(/.5( -/*//-@ 6( / 6 B /( 6((' (1(* (- 6/@ */ * &$ */ !$$!' /- @ (6* ( &# 4 !$$%- / .(/ (( @ @@ /< G/ */ 6( */ (// @(' /4 // @ 6(/ 6 9 .G4//(@@//'

"!!!$"!$$% ,"#

#' (@@/6(9-/45/**//0/- @.//6=/1/(/1-/=*/- @. 5* 6//6 66//(' 66/ (6*- / ./(( (6 1 * .// .( !$$A- 6( = 1 <* *6 //- .B(@*6*((/(6G4'

2 5(- / B 7(' ./ //0- (** MNA$$' */=G0' RRRRR

&%( ' %

)*"+,!-

( 14 /7(A1*4!$$%62* '3333333333 (//(6*7/-6/(/(&#4!$$%P

"+,.-

7P

*=G0(** MNA$$' P

/@ 6( B = 2* '33333333333 // @O (6* 7/-6/(/('

/01".-

2' EG9- 6(/- 2' DG/- 2* M/- 2' G(/- 70- 2' - 70 66('

* /4 *///5:

055/9 7/: 6(/: '/ D/0/ N'EG9

"!!!$"!$$% #"#

6/5*B((/@(<6/' 91- 055/9:

"!!!$"!$$%

Water Rights Dispute Based on Accretion Claims

Synthèse Legislator

Regeste Legislator

Mots-clés

Dispositions légales citées

Décisions connexes

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Texte complet