Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/715/2005 • CJ GE ATA/715/2005 Généré par l'IA

Government Boundary Modification and Constitutional Challenge

Numéro de cause ATA/715/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case addresses a dispute concerning whether a governmental entity's actions regarding the modification of certain real property boundaries constituted an unconstitutional taking without just compensation or a violation of procedural due process. The court reasoned that the governmental action, which involved a necessary adjustment to existing rights to facilitate a public project, fell within the scope of the government's police power to regulate property use for public benefit, and since the modification did not deprive the owner of all economically beneficial use of the property nor significantly interfere with clearly established rights, it did not amount to a per se physical taking; furthermore, because the property owner was afforded several opportunities to participate in the administrative process, including hearings and submissions, the court found that sufficient procedural due process was afforded.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Government Boundary Modification and Constitutional Challenge: The court reasoned that the governmental action, which involved a necessary adjustment to existing rights to facilitate a public project, fell within the scope of the government's police power to regulate property use for public benefit, and since the modification did not deprive the owner of all economically beneficial use of the property nor significantly interfere with clearly established rights, it did not amount to a per se physical taking; furthermore, because the property owner was afforded several opportunities to participate in the administrative process, including hearings and submissions, the court found that sufficient procedural due process was afforded.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
limite de propriété foncière droit à la propriété violation de garanties procédurales modification de la servitude droit d'exproprier impropriation

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The court decided on the allocation of court costs.
Art. 64 LTF
The court decided on the granting of legal aid.
Généré par l'IA
A/898/2004
Property Owner v. Government Entity Regarding Procedural Validity of Property Designations
A/880/2005
Governmental Entity Liability for Unauthorized Land Taking and Just Compensation
C/4341/2018
Property Owner Elevation Works and Boundary Encroachment Appeal
A/2164/2006
Challenge to Statutory Provisions on Land Interests and Due Process
A/690/2006
Property Owner v. Governing Authority (Drainage Easement Scope)

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court decided on the allocation of court costs.

Art. 64 LTF

The court decided on the granting of legal aid.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

        

  

   

 







!"#  $$%  &''  !"!#$%$" 

" 

(     )(*   + )(,     -*   



.--. -   .-   /   .- . - 





     &'()&

 

./  !0   !"1 /2222222 "  ""1 1 1  3 " "4 .555226122"002227222(8$/

   %76'9.-:0'% 1 ;"#1"/    4"  "   "  222 7    " 2222   < 7"    =0/  41   1 60%  0  01" 7=41  1" > "".:3?,-0'%@  %A %1  :+0' $1"% $  ## < 7 #/ B  A  "    01" 7=41  1" "$"  1"'-0'$1"%0" 7#1/ 7#1 71##/6" .:+0'%"1  " ')+0' "C1$C/

  !0 /2222222+ 1  "61"% C "  1$1   71 ##1 /1.55,% 1 "1 7 #8$   $1"/ !/ /2222222% 1 1 7  161  6  1  7D%  6" 1"1" /

'/  "7" A66 :$1'+++%  "1 "  1" 0 90#0 %9@10  "#0  >1&8 E   0 ?  "   @7 1 " =$C $1    00  161  ""# 1"  4F 10  .:3% A  /     1C% !/ /2222222   $"1 " 1    1  D  G 7 "1 1"$4"002222 1 H <"@H  4" 6"08 0 /

:/   "1  .+ $1 '+++%   0   "610 < !/ /2222222 @7 161  71 1 %  H   461 7  "1 1"  " 1% 1 $1  " $ < 7 1 .   "1   "  1"    1  1"1$.3$1.5> &-+-?/1  I"1  1  10 1 " "  @H  611 1$   "1 1"  " 1 "  7"4I 1 1#1C/

3/   .+ 01 '+++%  "C /2222222 "  " 8   0  @H  "1 1"" 1611 1$D ""4I %" 00 %  "$  " =$C >?% 6  '. "$04 '++'%  1 1"  7 1 '3 4   "1 6  70#0   1 "1  '' I1 .5,5 > &B,++?/

-/  80 % 0 ""0"1 1""$ " 1   "1 1"%1"1C I"/

('*+,('++- &:()&

)/  B117"" 7 7 C11"% 14 011  16   01%  H   5 "$04 '++3 > (*,+('++3   (*,.('++3?/  14  @"I   1  "14 #  7 1 '3   /  "@% 7"  0"1 1" 7 1   6"/

,/  B     "   0 %  14 6 > J?    11"  "   $"D    14   " "$ 11"%7#1  117"0"1 1"/

  "0    6"0 1"  1%  "$  < =$C% 7 6-'0'%C1 *0'0C100.++0' "17 1 3' 1 :   4  7""  70#0   1 "1  '* I1 '+++> KB,++/.? '-L"  17#10 <7C 1 $"0C1  <1"1 1""1 1"7 13'1:   /  0 %  C 1 8 $1  H    " "4 1  "# 1"/

*/   14011  16171  1"/

   "C /2222222 "  "1# @ 7"  0"1 1" 7 1   I 161#71 H 41 1"" 1"/

   0 1 "#0  1" 1/

5/  "   1  61 %  14 011  16  68 C 11"  " 61 /

 - 

./  1 1#" @7"0"1 1""$ <=$C/

'/   7H  J@"$ <=$C% 1<7#1   1@ < 1   "11% 7    "14  $   7 1 '' 1 '     /  %   0 "M 1  01    "1 1" 0 1$7 13'1:  4 %1 H  "1 $"1"# "1/

:/   0  ""%<7#"  1"%1  1" "7 ="01  % 1"%0"161 1"%1" "0"1 1"> /.'51 / ?/ 0$ H ""  0  "@ 7   7 "  1"% 7 1  1" " 7   =" 7   "6"0 C 1 1"     "1%  8#0  @7 $"1  "   "1 1" 1$  1 1"   1"1 1" # " #0 1 > / .:+  ?/ " H  $4%  "  01 

('*+,('++- &3()&

"6"01 % @1 "0"  1  10  1  1" 1 1#1% "1   "     "1 1" 1$ %  1 1"  11   "" 1"1      4" 6"1 > (--.('++-  .) "N  '++-    61 O J...4''."1/) I11 ?E

 / 7""1 H 11#"  4 > J.+,':?/

 4/  1  1"    "1$   $"1    "1  $   "1   $1#  0"0    1 1" > J .+3 4 :+3O  /  '-"N .55'?/

 / 1  "1 7H "17C 1"  $C1 1#1C> J.+,.'.P .5*:'55?/

 / 7 "1   "1   $"1  =; 7011  " K   "0%  16"0 1"%   "  "0" 0  K  C  1$%   "1 1"  @7 1  1   11   4" 6"1 >/ Q % 1  "1  011  16% 380 /% .55.% R -+5% /.+*O /':6$1.55:"610 J"41'.04 .55:O J..,'*,"1/'4 I11 ?/

    11%  1  1" 1 1#1  "1$   $"1   " 7 "1 76G"@11 " 1  1$7 "1 1" 1 "7 "1 1"<61 1"1 1" #> J.5*'/3-+O /':6$1.55:?/

3/ /  78%   @1   ""1 1   22 "C /2222222% @1 "  " <  "  1" 1 1#1% "   4   "0" 0 /

 4/  "  1""$ 7 C 0  01%01   1     3 " "4 .555 K   < @  "C /2222222 "  @1K :$1'+++% <@ 0 "   7C1 /

 /   0   1  "  "1  7""  0"1 1"  "$ % 1"0 14$;"6""1/

-/    %1"$1 7C0110 "0 14$71 H  41 11"" 1"1 /

 / B7#1   71 H  41      ;" #1"% 1 70"  016 0   1% 1$%  "C /2222222 < 01 1    ;"  "  1" @1 7D "    1 > H   14 6 . /*:(.55:'.04.55:%"1/'4O (3::('++-'.I1'++-O (:):('++-'301'++-?/

('*+,('++- &-()&

 4/  0"1 1" 7 "  1" "  "14 7   11  " 1  11   "" 1"1  > H   14 6 ./)',('++:'304'++:?/B17 "1   11"  " < ""  0"1 1"% 1 6  " 6"1 $ @7 8# #% "  1"1=";"<4F 1 ""6"0<766  1" ;"$1" 6"0 0 "1 670#0  1 "1  "1$  H  0"1 >/ S &JJ ( / T&   % 0#0   1 "1% "  1"   C"1 1"%  '++.% # 3')   1$ ?/ &0H0%0$1#  < 14 $1 7"$"1   @   0 0"1 111$ 710"1  @1  1  01C  1 H 1$" >6/E (-*-('++-:+"N '++-?/

 /  $   @1 8%  "  I    7"  0"1 1" "610/

)/  0"M17 10 1%"C/2222222""  " 8   0   @H    "1 1"  " 1  "$  < =$C @1 1 "0   "1 1" 0 1$  7 1 3' 1:  4 /

,/  71"%0"0  UJ-++/&01<=# "C/2222222@1"04 > /*, ?/

 VVVVV

 . -      

01$2% 3

 $4  " 1 I   '+ 04 '++'  !"1   !0 /2222222" 11" 0 90#0 %9@10   "#0 '."$04'++'O

$2!3

I O

"6107"0"1 1"O

0 <=#"C/22222220"0  UJ-++/&O

('*+,('++- &)()&

"001@    H  < ! " !#$% $"   " %   0   90#0 %  9@10     "#0 % 11 @7<  "0011" ""0 18"  1"/

B1# E !/ D=8% 1 % !0 "$D   U1% !/ =1% !0 "% I#/

"0 14011  16E

 1&I1 E  1 E     /W661 11 J/D=8  

"1"6"0 H  "001@C 1/

 8$%  #6618E           

('*+,('++-