ATA/658/2005 · Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

ATA/658/2005 · Securities Classification of Property Acquisition Instruments (Cour de Justice (Cour civile))

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case concerns a dispute over the classification of certain financial instruments used to acquire property interests, specifically regarding whether they constitute securities and thus trigger registration requirements or if they qualify for an exemption. The court reasoned that the instruments, which involved a fixed return regardless of the underlying property's performance and were marketed as passive investments, satisfied the criteria of an investment contract under the relevant statutory framework, as the purchasers relied on the managerial efforts of others for profit, establishing that these were indeed securities subject to registration unless a specific exemption applied, and finding that no applicable exemption was established.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Securities Classification of Property Acquisition Instruments: The court reasoned that the instruments, which involved a fixed return regardless of the underlying property's performance and were marketed as passive investments, satisfied the criteria of an investment contract under the relevant statutory framework, as the purchasers relied on the managerial efforts of others for profit, establishing that these were indeed securities subject to registration unless a specific exemption applied, and finding that no applicable exemption was established.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA

instruments financiers acquisition d'immeubles sécurité des placements marché à prendre en considération marché immobilier opération boursière

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The decision orders the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.

Généré par l'IA

A/3271/2007

Securities Classification of Financial Instruments

A/2612/2004

Securities Classification of Complex Financial Instruments

A/1716/2007

Asset Valuation and Classification Dispute over Financial Instruments

A/1834/2007

Financial Instruments Validity as Securities

A/716/2004

Securities Registration Requirement for Complex Financial Instruments

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The decision orders the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.

Texte complet

!

" !#!$%

%#$! &'(((((( !"#$%&#

#

&)) & ) &) *)& + ,

)& *)&

'()*'

/0 !#" 0111111% /23-% #"$"" 45"0 " /222% " 65" " 7 4 #8 &"& 49 # " :9% &" :#" 7 9&0 ; "9 &" <;" = #" 4"% " " # "# 69<% !4 0111111% /2>-% "#" $#% &&% "9 ; "&"" " &"# "? &"& 79&&?: /, /(0

## /+ #&45 (...% "5 " 9& ## &## "!401111110

(0 (> @" (..,% !0 0111111 !4 0111111 # # 4&4"$9;#"4 ; '"&"=0

# :"% !0 0111111 # $45" 7 # #4% &5@<;45(..*0

+0 ( 45(..,%;#::" ## "#A"'9B C #&#<?#&;?4" "#0#7 " "#0 # ; ; :" " "# 4"0 !0 0111111""<<;& &"D%"&" " $ <;" &" # 6 " # 4" <;" #" #&0 ;&" " @#D ;&" :4"E"0

!0 0111111; 5:";&"#E" ;# 4;"=0

7!40111111%""<"$# !0 0111111 E"0

,0 #44& "# 3# #5(..,% ; ":#4!0 0111111<;" " "&E"F " "; &" <;" "" 9 # = 4"9 "$0 #&" "&; #" "#@#0

?" " :" ;"" 4 < 4"$ &"$ &" # 5 ; " "# 4 "9 #" $0 #<% ; :" "& 7 !0 0111111 #" "#@# ""4 "" "+/@&"(..-#<" " #""0 " @#" ;## "<;"" " 4 # :# "94#4 # 0

)+,-*)(..- '+)*'

-0 *# #5(..,%!0 0111111 !40111111# # 4"$ 9;#"4 ; '"&"=0

>0 /+# #5(..,%!0 01111114"G:#4"""&"# # " 6# "# #) #" "# # "5 6$H #"" #" "#@#0

30 "$ & "# (2 #&45 (..,% ; : 7 !0 0111111 "& ; #" "# @# : 7##"3# #5(.., "#//# #5(..,0" +/ @&" (..- " 4" 4$ 4"$ " &0 : " :" ? ",%/>"/ /3#":@# ; 5"4 $(>4/2+/ADE IE/,(0(.C0

*0 /3 45 (..,% !4 0111111 " @ # 9 #44""# # # #" $ A"'9B C # ""#" ; (2#&45(..,0

20 (, 4 (..-% :# "# 6"? '= #$ "#4"? 4<=6##$ """ 4"#5%" 4"!40111111 % :"" "<" # ; 6="< =6"< '"0 " " " 4 $" " #J /223 ; " " ;&#" 9 44 &" "4 "# #@$ "4# &" &"#6="< 4# #4" % "# 4"$0 #6" " #4"&" 4"# " " 0

/.0 /2 &" (..-% !4 0111111 # " # # 4" # 4 "# ## % 4F4 @#% " 7 # " # <; &" " @ # ""# ; (2 #&45(..,0

(/&"(..-%!0 0111111 " "#$4";? 4""# "###0

//0 (/&"(..-$4 % " " # !40111111 ;"K0

/(0 "$ & "#% /( 4" (..- 7 !0 0111111% ; ":#4 "'" < ""# (2 #&45(.., " :# <;"+.@"(..-" " "4 " #<" " #"%: <#"";?#" 74# " ;"#5#" &## "4 7# 0

)+,-*)(..- ',)*'

/+0 (.4"(..-%;#::":4"$ "#A"'9B!C" ""# ;? "# 7 # " #" #: "# ""# &#"" 0

/,0 (34"(..-%; "&" !0 01111117 9# &" ;" 4" # # 0 !0 0111111 ; : 7 #&# "#02@"(..-" " />@"(..-4" !0 0111111; 7; @#'7#0

/-0 > @" (..-% !0 0111111 #" 7 ; $4"% # # = #" # # 7 ;& "# #$4 0 !0 0111111""<<;";&" L #&# "#" 65" " 7 ; 4 "# #594 <;" # " & :440 ;M#" $"#" MD(-.0'4"0 < "# &#"#<#"" " #E"#<;"" J "& +.@" (..-%!0 0111111""<<;"" 5" K "% 'F 4"0&" :4"7 40@# <;"&" ## 7!"$# #$ <#"# #&5?4#" #&" 6N # &# # " #"" #40 !0 0111111 "&" 7 66" # 6N#&# 7 4"#< # "F ? 04"%!0 0111111; 7 ; 0

/>0 /(@" (..-%; #;#7#";? &#" ;" %""#:&#" :"" "& ? #"0

/30 &# & (. @" (..- # :#4 !0 0111111 J F %;" ;= # &50#&#"& # (( 45 (..-% 9 < #" $45" # "& "N';&#""%#"# 6"<%" &## "0!0 0111111$" ;F #""&### <'"&" @#4F4<&" " &:" #4"$0 &" 5"#" # #4"/2&"(..-4" &" " " <<@#9"#"#? !0 01111110 "" &" ? #6" " <;" #=0

/*0 (( 45(..-7//6..%#44""#""# 4" "#4"" "&7;# !0 0111111# ?4#"0

/20 @#4F47/>6..% #&#<"#4 "# # # < !0 0111111 ""< <;" 65" " 6N # # & < " #6" " 4"0 &#" # 45"%"=&" $#&4 4"" "0E;";&" ";&"##

)+,-*)(..- '-)*'

? "& &#" " % ; " < # # #6" " <;" ""0:"" :#" " 5## 4" " ;M#" $0&" # # "" <;" " 60

#44"" #" & < # !0 0111111 " 60 "N' &" "& 4" " " &5 #@#"<4 # <;":" #5 "#& <;&# #45"#" F #$"<"N"@#0

(.0 ""#(( 45(..-% # <!0 0111111 :"" ;#5@ ? ""# &#" :"" "& ? #" <;" ?" " ""# :" <;" " # "7 #:#4 0 #:"4;#4" "#4"" "& # " "'"7"?4"%#" @<;*#&45(..-% " "#""## "#" 0

(/0 # + # #5 (..- $:: "5 4"" ":% !0 0111111 # # ""# # ""4 7 ; "#""# < 74""5 "44" 4# ":< &# & # # &#" &" J F # : 0 ;&" @4" #44" 7 #4"< &" #" ;&" #74O&# #4'"#6#" " 0 ;?" " ""4# ":4" "#0

: % "5 &" " :"? % #" 4"" ::" #? &#"0

((0 #" #"0

(+0 7;#::""#"%"#3# #5(..-@ #0

&# # 45" &" ? " #:"4 & # /+ # #5(..-0

(,0 E<#"% $7@$0

)

/0 @ 4 " & @"" "# #4 % # &5A 0-> #"P#$" "#@"""((#&45/2,/' ' (.-Q 030- 0/.0/#";" "##": @# ; 5"4 $/>@"/2IE ID(/.C0

(0 " "# ; " /. " ( E % "5 4"" ": "?@#<""& ""0

)+,-*)(..- '>)*'

# "# + # #5 (..-0 " #44 7 #" 9 4" # 6 " &" @" /+ # #5 (..-0 //# #5(..-% "5 "" 0

+0 !0 0111111 :" ;#5@ ; ""# &#"% :#% " ; (2 #&45 (.., # " ##$ +. @" (..- #""#%:#$4 %/(4"(..-0%""# ;! (. 4" (..- 7 # " #" #: "# ""# # $4 ? #"0

#44 ;&7@ " ""# <%"" " &#"?""#0

,0 %#449&# %"; 64""; ?#&# "#; #* />@"###3 @" (..-0 ? &# #$" @<;""% " ;# # " ""<# &" # 6#<#4"% " #4 &5@<;(..*R

-0 S "" 9 "4 < !0 0111111 # " :#4 %"##<4 "#4"" "& #" F ##" "#; "/+5"/ DE 0

>0 " ?4#"7"?4"#" @<;*#&45(..-% "#4"" "&;" %#44""#:" "" "# "" ## "#" " @ ":" " # #< #" #"# ::"4<;&# " &#/+ # #5(..-0 !0 01111119# "4 #$"& ;?" "# " :"?% <;" = " #:"4 "% # # % &#"#&" &#""#44&0

30 ##" 4:#%#@ 0!$;"" "$%" 4";4#4 76$!0 0111111%"'"= 4" 5:" ;" @""< & :: (> 45 (..-0 " #;"4" #A 0*3 C0

TTTTT

)+,-*)(..- '3)*'

*& )

-./0 1!2

&5#" @ +# #5(..-!#" 0111111# ""# #44""# # # #" $ (( 45(..-Q

/0%2

@ Q

" <P"P LP4#4 "#;"4" Q

" <% #:#44 ? " 23 "& #" : P#$" "# @"""% F F # %&#"##" 4"" ":% @# 9 # ":" "#% & "5 :Q 44#" ##" ""<#"#%4# ": 4#=& # "$ # ##4 "Q"#" F #"?4"4#" "5 :% /... /,Q F "9 #"# # %"&#<#444#=&%#"& F @#" 7P&#"Q

#44"< F 7!"#$%&# # %7#44""# ###" $%7;#::""#"%7;#::" # # "#% 7 ;#::" : ;"44"$ "#% ;" $ "# ;4"$ "# 7 !#" 0111111 7 D45#"% #" "" <;7 !4 "&" !#? &%&" $% !40111111%#":#4 "#0

E"$ B !0=69%" %!4M" #&=%@$

#4 "54"" ":B

$::"9'@" @0B " B !0 ##" D0=69

#"#:#4 F #44"<? "0

)+,-*)(..- '*)*'

9&% $::"9B

)+,-*)(..-

Securities Classification of Property Acquisition Instruments

Synthèse Legislator

Regeste Legislator

Mots-clés

Dispositions légales citées

Décisions connexes

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Texte complet