Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/655/2004 • CJ GE ATA/655/2004 Généré par l'IA

Void Judgment Vacated Due to Defective Service of Process

Numéro de cause ATA/655/2004
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A party initiated a proceeding challenging the validity of several prior judgments concerning underlying real estate disputes, asserting that the court lacked proper jurisdiction to enter those judgments due to defective service of process, specifically arguing that the returned affidavits of service were facially invalid because they failed to specify the manner of service as required by relevant rules. The court reasoned that the face of the returned affidavits demonstrated a failure to comply with the jurisdictional prerequisite concerning service of process, and thus, the judgments entered based on such service were void; consequently, the court correctly vacated the prior judgments and ordered that the property at issue be listed for sale, affirming the determination that the original judgments were void due to the jurisdictional defect established by the record.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

CONSTRUCTION ET INSTALLATION; PERMIS DE CONSTRUIRE; DISTANCE A LA LIMITE; SURFACE; 5E ZONE | Les questions de la distance aux limites de propriétés et du rapport de surface ayantt été réglées par une autorisation de construire antérieure délivrée dans le cadre d'une projet de lotissement global et ayant acquis force de chose décidée, le Tribunal administratif n'est dès lors plus habilité à revoir ces questions. | LCI.59; LCI.67; LCI.69

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
notification d'actes biens immeubles incompétence ratione materiae restitution de la propriété jugement civil avis des défauts

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 106 al. 1 let. a LTF
Used to declare the appeal inadmissible because it relates to a non-appealable decision (final decision).
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Imposed costs for the federal court proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
C/29500/2018
Improper Service Renders Judgment Void
C/15408/2024
Landlord v. Tenant: Void Judgment Due to Improper Service
C/22752/2019
Improper Service of Summons in Opposition to Payment Order Proceedings
C/15687/2018
Appellant's Challenge to Default Judgment Due to Improper Service and Pending Related Action
A/4249/2020
Claimant Challenges Debt Enforcement Based on Void Judgments from Improper Service

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 106 al. 1 let. a LTF

Used to declare the appeal inadmissible because it relates to a non-appealable decision (final decision).

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Imposed costs for the federal court proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

         

        

 

   

 





!"# !!  !! "#$% &'() 

) 

#$$# $   #$  %   #$ # $

&

'     (')   * ('+     $)   

&

,-.&/!!  !*+ '() 



     *,-.*

 

/+  !)"+3+ " )" "4/5.26'05,/,'05,/0'05072  05/89:"79);;<"'"/69') <"' ""=>?/@/6 ,@/9'$;" " )'&)6)  ")+

,+  !+3+););  ' /117 /116' )A  > )" ") >=" >;A  ";B  > ) ";   ("C *=  (" D;'      > )   :  ,6E F1,59,2G+

0+   )(; )  " (+

7+   /11.' !+ 3+  )A  > )" ")  ) " F 17567.-/*,G "? ("D;4650./'650.,'6509/'6509, 65016"/* //'$;" " )) " " ))" "+

6+  ";B ):" >)AD >;"; "'"A"= ;)/@//$;" " )) :"; )( 4 65106'65108'6510.'65109'6512/'651.2'651./ 651.,+

8+  /111'65106'65108'6510. 65109'"/*.'$;" " )')  (@= =') !)" + ++

  D)'!+3+  )D))" "=   '" 1*//'$;" " )'>: ) 898;,+

.+  #)$"   D)   ""  )D   )  ")'  )(? )" "465106'65108'6510. 65109) ="> )" ")  ;)":"  )D  "" "  ": @  )  ")  "? (" D; F 17567.G+  )  "" )A '  /111' > )" ")  ) " =  (" D;(""F17>67.-0G+

9+  ) '+H "#+ +'C";;)A""B; !+3+'', (",22/')"" ;)":" ")")" ")" "':I  >";  ")  ? (" ("    )" ")  17>67.-/*, =" (" J ":"?1*//'$;" " )F=J 17>67.-7G+

   ? (" ) "CK ("  J  ":" @  ;B  "= '  "(; ;B ) ";" )" (465109  6>120+:$ )  " ,78;,+

1+  "")/6:(",22,A"3">(")::""F"* BL  3 G  ,2 :(" ,22,'   ;   >;C; ' 

-/01/-,220 *0-.*

>=";  )C; F"*BL G"(> )" ")=" +H "#+ +'"A  ) :)"> ;))"'@()" 1.5/8.+

/2+      ,6 ; ,22,' !+ +' )" "    4 65109 ";;" ;  ) "CK @   651.2'  ) B   );;"")  )); "B)  ")F"*BL);;"")G)  " "")) @) ")+

  > )" ")(")" " "); "B) :  "  ? ";"   )"  F + 61   81   )" C()"   )  ") "  ")"(/7("/199F M626GG+

//+    )  /2 D"  ,22,' + H " #+ +  )  D   )+

  #>C" ) :'A:""" )  )" @AN ")(> ""("")> C)A+

  )   "  ? ";"   )" ' > " 81    )("  J  "   @ >)   > " .2 " 0   ) "   ("A +

/,+   ")   );;"")/, ;A,22,+

  #)   ' > )" ")  = " C"     )   : =" ("    ::   > )" ")  A    :)+ #>C" " ?";" ')C ")D ":"" ;)O ">C"" >)D >;A') ) (" >"A:""+

/0+   :)"?" "))",9; ,220+

  >)"C"'";B ))" "  ")( )  "("")">: ) /05211;,+> )" ")1.5/8. ("" ?; > )" ")) "1,>9,2-7="(" ))AD   ;)":" ")    " ")  :  $   /5.26' 05,/,'05,/0'05072 05/8. ?C)A,6E ) ";B  " )C;  ))" >+

/7+  "")0D" ,220');;"");")  > )" ")1.5/8.+

  #")::"" C)A> "" "))("   '> )" ") ("  "((") ")" ") "(?" ?";" 

-/01/-,220 *7-.*

 )" +  :: '  )  ") ("  > )" ") =   )("    ) ) "C (  )  ")  !+ +    ) < :" >)AD >(" > "./ >("    )  >" ";+

/6+   ) 6)P ,220 ); ,2) )A,220'+H "#+ +  " D  ) )    "") B  "A ;""  ":  ) @) ")+

     ("  @ )  "  > )" ") = F 1.5/8.G  :I) " ' ) =>" >C""  > "; );;  @ > )" ")  17567.+)D  ":?"?("(" :: J ");; )   )   : ("        + #>C"   "  ?";" )" '= ")("  C> )" ")17567.  :)@D)+

/8+    )A( ")  /1 )(;A ,220'     ) @ >;"")  )   @  ):"; ")   ) "")  /6 :(" ,22,+

  #>C"   "  ? ";"   )" '  )D  = >" C"    )D  >;A )  )   ";B '  =" ; " )C ")";; ) "  ")("  ;)O ) A:""" ")=; )C ")+

/.+    )  ,7 )(;A ,220' !+ +  "    )") )D )+

/9+  +H "#+ +"=7;,227 ;)" ")+

/1+  !+ +)@"=+

,2+   ")    "A/2;",227+

  #)   ' " "    )"A  "   )" " "C"? F 1.5/8.G);;;);; ")"17567.+

,/+   ,,D",227' ):";=)D (" > )" ")) "=" :">)AD > )" ") ) ");; "@> )" ")) """ "17567.+ )  ""= =  )D   ? ("   ("   ;"  ) " "= @   ? (" (  ;J; )"      > )" ")) """ "+  ')D " "C"??("F 1.5/8.G' );; " @ "  =  (" F 17>67.-0G >;) "  ;)":" "))>C)" @AN ") @="

-/01/-,220 *6-.*

("  ;"> )" ")) """ "17567.=" (" ))AD "?(" ) +

,,+  #=)"' C@DC+

$ 

/+   D   ;  " (   D"" ") );  '  )   (AF +/71 Q68 )"5)C" ")D""",,)(;A /17/** ,26Q +80+/" +)");""  "(/,  ;A/196* * 6/2G+

,+ +  )  )$ @  );;"") >()"  > )" ")  1.5/8.  ;) ": =  "  ? ";"   )"  >("      +  ";= = ")("  C> )" ")A F17>67.G)  "?("'D)>$" :)'=  J ;"+

 A+    > " 81 " ,  '  "     )  ")    )    ";"   )"      "" J  ":" @ "? ;B + ) :)"' >C"   )  ") ":"  ) ) "C'   ;     )"  )  ")    ) @  ";"   ? )"  "( F + 81 + , " + A  G+     '  )" " ()"" (  )C @  ";"   "? ;B   ) =" )"  :" >)AD  >(" "" C" :)"F +./ G+

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

-/01/-,220 *8-.*

  ) ";  @  = ) "  !+ +' >)  "  "  > )" ") =";; > )" ") ")  )  ") "? ("   ="   @ D  "  J  =":" > R )" ")  AS+  =J  ";)":" "))D "" "$C "    :" +  :: ' "  ";B   "  :"  >)AD   =J  '   ) = ;"B("' ) ?"B'>  "=;   =  =  ;"B  "    4 /   .  $;" " )("   ; (+ ) ' "= >":" ")  ? "B (" =" :""  >)AD   > )" ")  1.5/8.  "  (  ;J; )"  =     > )" ") "" " F 17567.G+   ; )O     "   =J   ;)":" ")  > )" ") )   =  )(? )" " );;  "   )"  A F 17>67.-0G' " "  P  :"  ;J; (  =J   ;)":" "))) F1.5/8.G+

    '  )  ) "  @ ") =  = ")   "  ? ";" )(" J (> )" ")A= =>("  )"" + > )" ")  1.>/8. =" ;  >":" ")  ? ("  ;J; ;;  = > )" ")  A )"  B ) J  ):";   )" +

0+  ;J;"); )" J "=) :="  @D  " (");;"")+

   :: '    ":  )   : ("    ::  ) >;A  ";B      > )" ")  1,59,2' " "   :" )" ")"(+!J;") :>("    ' = "))" J ( "A       '   )" ")  ;         :) F1,59,2 17567.G+

7+   )   =" B =    ":   ? "  ? ";"  =>? )   : )    ::     > )" ")  "=") D)>$":)$)"+ ( ) J ;" > )@ ) =);;"")> )" ") " "C"+))= ;" "") ):";+

6+   ;);   T3 />622+*  ;" @  $C  !+ ++  ";" ))@) ="><)F +9.  G+

# $ *     

-/01/-,220 *.-.*

012/3&4

 (A  ) " D   6 )P  ,220   + H " #+ + )   ""));;"") )); "B)  ")0D"  ,220Q

2,4

>; Q

""));;"") )); "B)  ") 0D" ,220Q

 A" > )" ")  ) "  1.5/8. "(  ,2 :(" ,22,    ; >;C; '>=";  )C; @+H "#+ Q

; @$C!)" + +;);  T3/>622+*Q

);;"= J @!! "#$% &'() ) '@!* + '() 5" ";""=5@);;"") )); "B )  ")  ; 5;C; '5=";  )C; +

.56&, -4

!+<$B'" '!;)(<'!+#$"'!;T"'!+ $"'DC+

); "A ;""  ":L

C::"B*D" D+L  " L     !+ ))" 3+<$B  

)"):); J  );;"=? "+

 B('  C::"BL   

-/01/-,220