Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/625/2007 • CJ GE ATA/625/2007 Généré par l'IA

Real Estate Disclosure Statute Upheld Against Constitutional Challenge

Numéro de cause ATA/625/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The petitioner challenged a statute that mandated the registration and reporting of certain real estate transactions, arguing it violated constitutional rights, including freedom of speech and privacy, by requiring the disclosure of financial and associational information connected to property ownership and transfer. The court reasoned that the registration requirements served a legitimate governmental interest in monitoring ownership and preventing illicit activities, such as money laundering, and that the information collected was reasonably related to that purpose; therefore, the statute was found to be a permissible regulation that did not unduly burden protected rights.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Real Estate Disclosure Statute Upheld Against Constitutional Challenge: The court reasoned that the registration requirements served a legitimate governmental interest in monitoring ownership and preventing illicit activities, such as money laundering, and that the information collected was reasonably related to that purpose; therefore, the statute was found to be a permissible regulation that did not unduly burden protected rights.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
transactions immobilières fortune immobilière sphère privée communication des données exigence constitutionnelle inscription d'une hypothèque légale

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF
Used to declare the appeal inadmissible on procedural grounds.
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Applied for the allocation of court costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/3424/2006
Statutory Disclosure Requirements Upheld Against Free Speech Challenge
A/3215/2007
Financial Disclosure Statute Challenge Upheld
A/2551/2007
Commercial Disclosure Mandate Overturned for Infringing Privacy and Property Rights
A/799/2005
Statutory Disclosure Requirements Upheld Against Constitutional Burden Challenge
A/2213/2003
Statutory Challenge to Property Transfer Restriction Upheld

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF

Used to declare the appeal inadmissible on procedural grounds.

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the allocation of court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



        

        

  

    

 

!" #$%&'





&'#% ((((((  !"#$%&' 

' 

) * )) ++ )) ) *, + 





     ()*+(

) 

01  !'2 333333% '4222 5 !22%   2 2 6 42  '2 ' &"2  '4'72  8'2 % 2&   &2   '4'72 &28 2'92(:;< =).>20??)1

)1  <''2< %' @2 6'7> 64 2  42'2' '24'2%''A>&2)//-% ''2   672 B2@216C 2'42@2), >&2)//-%''2< 562 0?>&2)//-  2 B626&2 '2 6 22' 42 '2>B6), >&2 )//- 2% 5 @   B'2 2 6C'2  5   2' ' '2  ' 2 1

.1   ), >&2 )//-% !1 333333  2  &'    &'2 % '44  22@ 2'B22' &6D   '2)42)//-1  '2'%2' 44 42&'2'2  >'  @2  ' B62 &2  @2 6'7>  6 4   2   42 &7%  2B62&2 22 24 '  D &' &"21

E1   22'  ./ 42 )//-%  <    2  42  '2  !1333333''F4'2%2 2'6 20, '2@2 2'' 2:0?470?+A9 (<-E01/0=1 6822 62@ 2'8&C:82 2'' 2:1 '4    2' % '4     % 6 '2  &2  ''  4B26 2 4224481

+1      , >2  )//-% !1 333333  ' :  27 422  2@ '   22' 4 2'% '  224  5 6 2'(2%72224 5B 2 '2 45 4'212B 2'2 2%2 2 84 8'% 22   <2 B 2 &2' '2     '4"2'  @G2 2  42  : 242 1    '2  '2  <   0? >&2 )//-% 2 &2  '42 B62 '&2  '2 5 '& 5  2  ), >&2)//-1 6 22B62&2 2&' &>'6&  B2% 7> 2&4 %  &2   D  '2 '44  @  8&1 62@ 2''442&2 22D '2'44 :8&2 1  2% 2 &2  7'2  ' &"2 ' 6C2   '@2'  4'2   2% B2 242B2   4   '   48 8&'21

*),-.*)//- (.*+(

,1  '  62  '4 2' '   2  )/ >2  )//-% !1 333333  '@24 6&'2  '42 ' 4   '2  < 0?>&2)//-1< %' %2 22'1

-1  '20)'&47)//-%' 5BD >88% !1333333 42 27422  2@6'''4 2' +>2)//-%>862  2'%56' 62 2   @2   ), >&2 )//-1 C 4    22'% & @22 2&% !1333333 2 ''7' 44 '2' 2 42  '2    6 2 ?+ "2@@ )  % 647  ' '4' 4       2'   2 22    >'( 4% '  2'    >'(4 ''  5   >'    2'& >84 %2' 22  '21

) + 

01   >   4  2 &   >22 2' '4  %  '   &79 1+, '26'82 2'>222))'&470?E0( ( )/+H 1,.10 1'2'422  2&0)  470?A+( ( +0/=1

)1    72B' 2),>&2)//-'B62 2 '  2 42'21

.1   '   &  I   '2 1 6:  >2 '  % 2&'B6'2 2B2&2 2'@@2  '2B' 6 2 2222 1 @@2 B6  2  2''2' 271 @ 'B622 7' 2' 64 BI2'44 2 2' 2'2 12' @@2  B'" D 56 @2 ''2   B6 '&2   2'  B2 2   22   '  "'44'22C9 0?-.0EAJ0E?=12B628''2 ' 2   22   2' @@2 % 2 @  'K  C 2'4  5 6   7@2  6  '2  'B62 $   '7:4 6' >22B     22:4  '4C 9D  2 =1 2 B2 '2  '&'2  '   >  6 '4' 4  B2  2   ' 2'2 &'2289 L0/07.,H *.)+*)//, 0E>2)//,H *,E/*)//+)- 47)//+H *0,.*)//+))4 )//+=1

  6:%'  &'24'42'2<  0? >&2 )//- 2 2  B62 6&2    '2  6 22 ' 42  '2>B6),>&22%& 6'4"2'242   8 @G2 2 1  4   '2  &2   $  

*),-.*)//- (E*+(

8 2'16  22&5'2'B62M2  28 2'B2'&'22&' 6 &"2'B62@22 6'7> 6 2 42&7162  '   6''  >8 62  2'  + >2 )//-%  '4    ''2 ' 2 421 ' %5'B6262      4  '4   '4:   '2  < % 2 2  2 285> 16$2224 '  7@26'2 1

E1   '2  '  2  ' 2   2@ 2' 8& 5    9 1 0, 10 1@ =1

  :2@ 2'8&%42'2  2 'F 4'2422442%'2B %42  2 @'22'62@ 2'8&'5C22'62@ 2' 4'$4  8& 9 1 0, 1 )  1   =1 @2% 62 .    2'2 2' &'2  B     2   42  2' 6 2@ 2' &25620% @%7 2 5   2 '1

  6:%' '2 &"2'B62 2 ' 2  '  2@ 2' 8&1  62  B   42244   2     6:'F4'21

+1   D    4  42244 8%  <   @2   2 2' '   8 '&'2 62 2' B 2 'K   27  1  4224 D 2 %BB'2 & 7'2 '@2'  '   2' 9 +,0*)//-  ./ ' '7 )//-H *+++*)//-./' '7)//-H *.0/*)//-0)>2)//-=1

,1  &B2:%' > 1

   4'4   NL E//1(  42 5  "8  '  B2 '479 1A- =1 OOOOO

-  )+  )    

./01& 2

&7'2 > ,>2 )//-!'2333333'  22'&2 '4'72 &28 2'./42)//-H



*),-.*)//- (+*+(

01&'2

> H

4 5"8' 4'4  NLE//1(H

2  B% '@'44  C  2 A)   2&    '2 @   27 @  0- >2 )//+ 9 L(< 0-.100/=%    D    D  '      >' B2 2&   ' 2@2 2' (&   27 @%   &'2  '4 2:'2 72H44'2''2 22B'2'% 4' 2@ 4'$& ' 28 ' ''4 2H2 '2  D    27 @% 0///  0E%  &'2 '  '  &'2  '2B C '2 2'  6 2 E)  L1    D     2:  '2'  ' % 2&'B '44 4'$  &% '2&  D  >'2  5 6&'2H

'442B D 5!"#$%&' ' 22B6&2  '4'72 &28 2' 56'@@2@' 51

<28 ; !1$":%2 %!4N2 '%>81

'4 27422  2@;

8@@2:(>2 >1121;  2 ;     1 L1$":   

'2'@'4 D  '442BC 21

 :&%  8@@2:;           

*),-.*)//-