Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/606/2004 • CJ GE ATA/606/2004 Généré par l'IA

Taxpayer v. Commissioner: Substance Over Form Doctrine in Asset Transfers

Numéro de cause ATA/606/2004
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A litigant challenged the tax court's decision upholding a deficiency assessment, arguing the court erred in applying a "substance over form" doctrine to recharacterize certain complex asset transfers as a sale rather than a gift to avoid pre-payment penalties, which involved analyzing whether the transfers, though structured as installment sales for tax purposes, lacked an economic purpose beyond tax avoidance. The reviewing court affirmed the tax court's ruling, reasoning that the record supported the finding that the transactions lacked genuine commercial substance because the purported buyers had no means to pay the installment obligations, thus justifying the application of the substance over form doctrine to respect the original gift characterization for determining the appropriate basis for calculating the deficiency and associated penalties.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Taxpayer v. Commissioner: Substance Over Form Doctrine in Asset Transfers: The reviewing court affirmed the tax court's ruling, reasoning that the record supported the finding that the transactions lacked genuine commercial substance because the purported buyers had no means to pay the installment obligations, thus justifying the application of the substance over form doctrine to respect the original gift characterization for determining the appropriate basis for calculating the deficiency and associated penalties.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
transfert de patrimoine assiette de l'impôt impôt sur les donations paiements par acomptes cause de l'obligation procès fiscal

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The provision was cited in the final order concerning the allocation of court costs.
Art. 64 LTF
The provision was cited in the final order concerning the refusal of the request for legal aid.
Généré par l'IA
A/355/2005
Tax Assessment Upheld: Substance Over Form in Disguised Financing Transaction
A/2094/2006
Substance Over Form in Statutory Application to Transactional Document
A/2078/2006
Commercial Entity v. Taxing Authority on Collateral Estoppel in Asset Transfer Taxation
A/3712/2006
Tax Assessment Upheld on Related-Party Asset Sale Below Market Value
A/1524/2001
Tax Valuation Dispute Over Asset Value

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The provision was cited in the final order concerning the allocation of court costs.

Art. 64 LTF

The provision was cited in the final order concerning the refusal of the request for legal aid.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

         

         

 

   









 !"#$%$ 



&''()*))+'&  





     !"## 

) 

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

"#!"!$$% 8"## 

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

"#!"!$$% %"## 

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

"#!"!$$% 7"## 

=&

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

"#!"!$$% ?"## 

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

"#!"!$$% :"## 

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

  '9)2'9(1()0)  F&    4( 1(4 5 *((0'- *,( ,('  <(44 &%  ((,(;022(44(-(,( '2,  9; ' 2(,0 6 #B  !# 0(&  )0( ( P 24(  02 5 (2(( 2 ( 2  6(22'0(&  B& & D  (2((-  ( (2  ?$ 0( 2 2'2>@'2>@56()6(6(0( 2 '(&  '2 ) 6( 2'-  (  (,(' 5 4(  )2'    ( 0( 5  (1(   (, =- <'(6  2(6- +' 2  6(& *)2'  *(1(

"#!"!$$% F"## 

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

"#!"!$$% B"## 

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

"#!"!$$% #$"## 

2  2 2 +((- ( (  2((2   + 4(  ('69,(5922(6923369,('' 0(5(2(((&    *(61(4(,M'10='&  #%&  2(04'-='&'00 JL #*$$$& 0(5<16(0+&  SSSSS

 &)' , )   

-./#0"1 ' ,+   (='  7 =,( !$$% 2 .( .& /&   '((00((*)0,!'0+!$$8C

/1

=C 

05<1'00 JL#*$$$& C

00(62'M5.(.&/&((6*500((*)0 ,&

!23" 1

.0 ,;- 2'(- ..& D<(- <'(- =1- ..& 1  - =1 22'&

0 (+ 0(((4A

144(3 =(=&A  ,( 2'(A       .& ( &,; 

"#!"!$$% ##"## 

     

2(40M''00(6')2(&

 3,-  144(3A           

"#!"!$$%