Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/550/2005 • CJ GE ATA/550/2005 Généré par l'IA

Commercial Transaction Liability Affirmation

Numéro de cause ATA/550/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A party sought review of a judgment that found them liable for damages arising from a commercial transaction, alleging errors in the court's application of law and interpretation of evidence regarding contract formation and performance, particularly concerning alleged misrepresentations and breach of warranty. The reviewing court affirmed the judgment, reasoning that the lower court correctly applied the relevant statutory and common law principles to the established facts, finding sufficient evidence supported the findings of liability and that the appellant failed to demonstrate any clear error in the fact-finding or the legal conclusions reached regarding the breach of the agreement and resulting damages.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Commercial Transaction Liability Affirmation: The reviewing court affirmed the judgment, reasoning that the lower court correctly applied the relevant statutory and common law principles to the established facts, finding sufficient evidence supported the findings of liability and that the appellant failed to demonstrate any clear error in the fact-finding or the legal conclusions reached regarding the breach of the agreement and resulting damages.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
contrat commercial interprétation de l'arrêt erreur de fait responsabilité pour cas fortuit garantie d'une activité irréprochable common law

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the final order for awarding costs to the respondent (the private party).
Art. 68 al. 2 LTF
Cited in the final order regarding the distribution of costs, specifically concerning the allocation of costs for the state/appellant and the respondent.
Généré par l'IA
A/4510/2006
Affirmation of Liability in Business Transaction Dispute
A/354/2004
Commercial Transaction Liability Dispute Affirmation
A/1503/2002
Commercial Damages Affirmation
A/3210/2005
Commercial Transaction Damages Appeal Affirming Evidence Admission
A/2937/2007
Contract Breach and Misrepresentation Suit Affirmation

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the final order for awarding costs to the respondent (the private party).

Art. 68 al. 2 LTF

Cited in the final order regarding the distribution of costs, specifically concerning the allocation of costs for the state/appellant and the respondent.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

         

  

     

 







 !!  !"# $%&'() 

) 

"  "    "   #   " " 



$%    &  $  ' & "     & (    



   " !!  !&*'()



     #+,-#

 

23  )& $)4 &$3 3 5&#67) 89)& ':-')  ';.-<.'=&0/)>> )4'  &% % & &>&32:?& 2--2')(@   6()( &)  A& &)@  ) & % % & &>&3

+3  )&   )) ) &)$3 35&#67@& &>89 &(&   &% ;+0.2 +0.+'=&0+)>> )4' & 02#0.' )   3     +: ?&  2--<'   ) 6   >   @>4> '  @"&>     )4>  5&# 67 8>@ )& &)) &&  &) & % % &5-BC/1-83

.3  B=(&2---' &(@ )& &)) &>3

03  B>2---'$)4 &$3 3)5;/2/.86)>>&&)  ))> &6)  &)5&#67)>>&&)8)  @ )& &)) &3

B3      +B >& 2---'     =&  (&  )*( &)3  )   )(&    *& "  &&)  )%&   " "&)" & D &4)  &)3 )"'"& )4&(&  &D &3

/3  &&)++?&2---')>>&&))"& )4&  $)4 & $3 3 5 -BC/1-8   *  >) &= & A @(&)>     &(&  &A )&)9 &3

:3  $& A@ (&4B)E 2---)&4 &)%  +1>&2---5#2+18$)4 &$3 3)&& ')&+:) )* 2---'&)));/2/.'>) &=" &) @ &  &)  &  %  (&  =& @)*?  @  )& &) @9)& @ &2-@ )& &)) &3

<3   20 ?(& +111'  ))  ) &) $3 3  )&&  6   >   @& &'  @4&     @(&)>  5&#67  8 )& &)@9)& &  &) &% % & 5--#1..83 (&4&  & 011 )% % &3

-3   +=(&+111 & 9)*( &) &   )  ) )  @ )& &)  ) & 5;/2/.8'  )>>&&)    &&)  9 &  & A (  " &  

,+./0,+110 #.,-#

%   % & &    ))  ) &) $3 3  &&) =&9&   >&&)@9  >)  @(=&A($)4 &$3 3 ?"@ / > +111   &&"&  " @9>   &    ) &   @(  =&  & &)  @ & </   )&   )>&&  &(2+ >*2-<B5 # B2183

213   &&)  : > +111'  )>>&&)   @&  &)  );/2/. ()"&=&9&&)& '@         "D  @9)&  &) 5 --#1..8 )   ))  ) &)$3 3 ?)' )@ )?) &3

223   2+ >& +111' $)4 & $3 3  )*     @ )& &) @9)&  &  &)@&>& &)% 3& >9&>@&  &) @(& A2B1C111>.,3

2+3     '  +2  >* +111' ?   > @ )& &) @9)&   &  &)  &  %   % & )   ))  ) &)$3 3

   "D   =)&&   >  )*? &=  ? &=& &)  @&  &))? 4*)&& @&>& &)%  % &) &3 )&)& & 4> ==& &" @&  &)  $)4 & $3 3 @ &   9)&  A  & & 3  ' @&  &) )*?    "D   )(&   D  )& )>>   @&>)  )  A  *)&  *&  )  &)  @(&)>   @ &+1&+3

2.3   2+) )*+111'  )) ) &)$3 3&&)>>&&) @)5;//2.8) =@9)&  &)3

203   )&  2+ >* +111' $)4 & $3 3  > A )()&   >&)=)>  )) ) &)$3 3

  +<>+112')>>&&))A>$)4 &$3 3 ()F )&)&@  )) ) &)$3 3'   3

   ) )&  - (& +112' $)4 & $3 3  )&&   ?) &)  ;/2/. ;//2.3 ) &=)>)>>&&)"@ &&   "D @9 &3 == ' "D (&  =)>)"  @ &   )  (&4   "@&  &  A $)4 & $3 3'  "&   ) '>) "@ )& &)) &(&  )A ) 3 &  ) @  ))  ) &) $3 3 )   = @ )& &) @9)&   &  &)'  &  &)  &  (  3  =   ( & &(3

,+./0,+110 #0,-#

2B3  )& 2<?&+112' )? ) A )=&> &)=@ )& &)@9)& 3

2/3  )))+->&+112')>>&&)=?) &) ;/2/. ;//2.3

2:3  &&)2<=(&+11+')>>&&)>&))  =@9)&  &)  ))& )9> )& 3

  % )   )) ) &)$3 3=&&  & & )  &(')@ &.2)&=)  &)@(&)>  :) )*2-<.5 #<2031283@ )& &)@9)&  &)(&  ?   >) &=  &   &   &  &)  &  %     )3 ) =)&'      & .2   &(      +1 '  &* = (&  & " @)  &  &   @)*&4 &)  &=&  @ & .2     >&6 "  &( )&  >D% @&4   @9)&   &  &) @&>& &) "& )>*&  )  )*&& 3)& )()&&=& &) ) )(*)&) ) &  &)@&>& &)3 )"' (*)&@ & 9&4)&  &)&(36)' *)&@ &+1&2 & ) &)& =3

2<3   &&)  : =(& +11.' *&   G& @ (& ==&& 5G 8>D>?)' &(@ )& &)@9)& &  &)  &4)&% & &* % % &>4A  ))  ) &) $3 3  ()>  & >   )&  &  &=& A 2C111 ,3

2-3      / > +11.' $)4 & $3 3  &&  )>>&&) @ ) ) &&) 3

   )& &)  @ & +1 & +  @ &   >&   & @4&& & @(&) &)*)&@ &+1&2 3

+13  .1(&+11.'  ))  ) &)$3 3=& (&)*( &) 6   )>>&&)3  )  &   "&  ) 4&  $)4 & $3 3' "(& &"> @& D   ")  )& A @&(*&& )3'@4>  &)&&))&    & &"   &&)   )>>&&)  2< =(& +11+3 #& @ & (*'>)H& &&) &  =)3

+23  2< >*+11.')>>&&)  &)> &) )3 ) & )&)3

,+./0,+110 #B,-#

++3   &&)  2+ ) )* +110'  )>>&&)    ) &(*3   >) &= "  )  9)&  ) )    &&)  &   >) &= &  @ & +1 & +   &= A I *)&  *&   )  &)  @(&)> J3   > )H &  &  >&=  "@ @(& )* )  &)@(&)> '9K& '@&4  )  @& D 4'@ &)*&")%&*)&3

+.3   2<)(>*+110'$)4 &$3 3))  &&) 6 &*>&&  &=3

  4& &)% ' &&@ &+1&2'&  ) & ) ') A)& & D ) &4  )  &) >    )& )    )& &) &(  (&) &)   4& &)  > &6  % 3   &>&  " @ )& &) ) )F >K&   (& ))>&"3  )  "@ &  & >  )% >  )& &)3

+03   ) &   2/ >* +110'     &  "&  ) )&  $)4 & $3 33 #&' @(&   & A >)  "@  &  & >  )%&&)" "@(& & D ) &4)  &)A"@)& )>)&=&3

+B3   )) ) &)$3 3)? )'A)=&> &) &&)  "    (>  @ &>& '  >>)&  : ?(& +1103

  

23   ?  > &( ?&& &))>  ') A  4 (* 5 3 B/    )&  C)4& &) ?&&&  ++ )(>* 2-02## +1BL 3/.32& 3 83

    >)& A 9>&  " &)   "&  ) )&  @& 3

+3  $)@ &/1 * '"& ))& ) )"&  )%& > &&) & D )&4)  &) A"@)& )>)&=&3

  & "   &)  @ & /1   *   &==6 46>   @ & 21.      )& = @)4& &) ?&&&  2/ >* 2-0. 5 # 2:.32218' )  @& &) @&>) 4>  A  ?&& &)  )( @ &-<&.'& >&"@&)=6"&  ) )& 9 >D> )& &) 5 ,-2B,+110  +. )(>* +110L

,+./0,+110 #/,-#

,.B,+11+  2B ?(& +11+' )=&>  @D   &* =

2 30:,+11+2/(&+11+')&3.83

.3  9 >@ &21. '"& ))& & A "&)"  & &&) " & D &4)  &)A "@)& )>)&=&3

 3 ) )& ()&& D  &"A@>&&))'@ #A# & " ) >&&) )&  D  ) A >D%  )>>4    ))>&"' > & ) & 5 G 2+1  .< )&3 +* 3 0-L 2+2  2:2 )&3+*32:083 ) =)>@& D )&)@ &  (%&(*5 G2+1*0<)&3+3B2L22-*2:-)&323 2<.83

 *3  ' @& D  &()" # "& @   &>   & D  ?&&"> ) 4'>&"& D & D =& #)& D )  & 3 &>&"") )& D  )%)? & &4&9  >    & &   4 "  4&   >&&    @& D &()")&  )(' (@)*? )   &)' )   )& '& &4@D &)& &)5 G2+.22.)&3B3 22B83

03      '  )  @    & &   &&)   & (& )  ") 3

 3  ?&   6  & &( )"@& @4&  @>   "&  ))&)  " &)@ & )(@& 

5 G21-*2-<83= )  )& '& &4)& &)  )  @)*? & &43 6 )&   &) =) 4>  &)))>&"&A") )>&)  )    &> &  @D  )=)  A  )  =)  5 G +110'3B.:83

  @6') ) & " &.2 &(  'A >&6  "   )&  D  &  ' >   @ *&  )   )& 9&4?&)=)@& D &4)  &)3

   (94& &=>*>  )" 4& ())&>> &>& F 6>>%&*> &6  & >  @&>& &)% 5 G2+/+/& +111:.:)&3 .* 3 :0283   )>&  %  ) *&'   ) )&(   )&"&  &)  &)& &) &(A)  &) @(&)> 3 @)*&4 &)  &=&  )&   >D%  &( @&4 @9)& &  &)3 )"'4& &)= > &6  % ' A  >&6  "  4& &)  ) )&  D 

,+./0,+110 #:,-#

&    >   @ *& @9&  @ )   )&  9&4   ?&'>)H &.2 &(  &>&   &* )  > &6  & >    @&>& &)  %  ) *&&(3=& ')%& @%A)' & A @&( @ )( (   >%'  ) &    & D  ==& )=)4& &> &)A)&3 &)     >D>&&&*)'&  &) &4@D ) 45 G2+B:)&3.3-L G+111'3:./83

 *3 ') )("@ )& &)@9)&  M )   44( &) 4&*   )& &) ))>&"3   >)   &  &     &>& &)  )  &(&    @) )&  @ )& &)@9)& 3

  == '&>& &)&()"@* "@+112)"@  ))  ) &) $3 3 9K&  )  &(&   & &   "&N 3  ) ' @ )& &) @9)&     ) )F  =(& +11.' )&  9  6  *     &)  @ &(&  &()"3 =&' @ )& &) @9)&  > A  )) ) &)$3 3 &>9&>>2C111 ,% ' "& >&&>) ()>2B1C111>.,% ')& (&) :BC111 ,' "  )     )& A & 3  )"' @ )& &) @9)&  @   A @)&4&  @44( &)   &  &) ))>&") 3

 3  )  @& )   )( &) "@  )  2:?& 2--2(@  6(3

  ) =)&'   )( &)     D  ) &  &( @  &) &=) "& ))&3 == ' >)( &))  & @& >)))))&)=(3

  &&'  )  @     =K) &    ) ) ( L@  )%"  )     &) @ & D  &4  )  &) 6 ) "  &  &)@ & >  &> == @&)3

B3  = ()&&) )& & (&)"&  ()&&'9)&   )&A) )>>  )43

 3   "& )  ()&&'  ?&  &&" "  9 )   & D  )    =K) &    & )  @& D   && "&3  &)&  &)"@&F)>> =&     & D    & &   &&)   9  &3  ()&& ( )&&()" 64"&) )&  "&

,+./0,+110 #<,-#

) & >  &A) 4& D 5 G221*.-<)&3 2*3011L ,/BB,+11+B)(>*+11+83

 *3 "& ))& &&))")> )& &@ && > ()&&)  &))@&  &) & &4&5 G2+22:2)&3+*32:083!&& 6& @     >&   @& &)  @ & 2-.     &   & &)  @>*  &)   &  5 G 2--:  +0+83 ) =)&'"& ))&()&&)&4@ >&"& & )  &>   &* ) 4 3  )&(  ) D  @ &4(&  ()& &4@(&53O #GG ' "& ))& &4 &)@ &")&  >&&  &=7 &)'P+110'32::83

   @6'  9 )&  )  )&4 @ &  @(&) ::1> A () @)&   )    & )  6   &(  & 5=3   &  &(  & )& 4()&' QQQ3  4(3%83  (@)&4>  9'&M &==&&)& )>> ()&&3'  N) =&& &)*F   &> &) &( &3@9)&  &)))@&  &) &%  % &  ))  ) &)$3 3%4& A&  &)) )  &)( 43@   )% " "&)"  @ )& &)   @F   & D  &4  )  &)'  "& ))&  "()&&& &&3

/3   @&  & &4' )&  @  *)& @9>&  4&=  =) &()") 3

  >)>  RG2C1113#>&A%4) 5 3<:  83 SSSSS

% "         

&(*)& ? 2<)(>*+110$)4 &$3 3)  &&)   )>>&&)  )  )  > &6  )  &)  2+ ) )*+110L

> A%4) >)>  RG2C1113#L

&  "' )=)>>  9  & -:   &(    )& = C)4& &) ?&&&' D  D ) '()&))& >&&  &='    ?) 6  ) &=& &)'  (   &* =L  >>)& 

,+./0,+110 #-,-#

))& &&")&)'>) &= >)F( ) &4  ) ))> &L&)& D  )&9>&>)& &* =' 2111  20L    D     &6  )&)  ) '&()")>>>)F(')&( D ?)& AC()&L

)>>&" D A!"# $%&'() ) 'A  )>>&&)  )  )  > &6  )  &)'   >   @& &'  @4&     @(&)> ' A ! & *' ()  @  )) ) &)$3 3&&"@A@)==&=@(&)> '=)D   F43

$&4 7 !3 F%6' & ' !3 %&' !> )' ?4' !!3 ))   4'?4 3

)> &*>&&  &=7

4==&6#?& 7  & 7     3&)#$&4&  G3F%6  

)&)=)> D  )>>&"9 &3

 6('  4==&67     

,+./0,+110