Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/541/2007 • CJ GE ATA/541/2007 Généré par l'IA

Developer v. Property Owner: Wrongful Termination and Substantial Performance

Numéro de cause ATA/541/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A developer filed suit claiming breach of contract and unjust enrichment after a property owner terminated a construction agreement, alleging delays and poor performance, but the owner counterclaimed for breach of contract, asserting the developer failed to substantially complete the project and cure defects as required by the contract's notice and opportunity-to-cure provisions. The court found that the owner's termination was wrongful because the contract required specific written notice and a reasonable opportunity to cure before a termination for default, which the owner failed to provide, thus precluding recovery on its counterclaim; however, the developer also failed to prove substantial completion, warranting damages only for the work performed, minus any offsets for deficiencies.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

; IMPÔT FÉDÉRAL DIRECT ; DÉDUCTION DU REVENU(DROIT FISCAL) ; DÉDUCTION DES FRAIS D'ACQUISITION(DROIT FISCAL) ; ORDONNANCE ADMINISTRATIVE | Examen de la déductibilité des frais d'un véhicule Mercedes et d'une moto Ducati au titre de charges d'exploitation d'un commerce de maroquinerie. Le critère déterminant pour admettre la déduction des frais d'acquisition ou de prête-bail doit être l'usage commercial compte tenu de la nécessité de l'exploitation fructueuse d'une entreprise considérée. | LIFD.27

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
résiliation enrichissement illégitime défauts de construction demande reconventionnelle revendication de la propriété manquement du bailleur

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
This provision is cited in order 2. to regulate the costs of the federal procedure.
Art. 93 LTF
This provision is cited in order 3. to declare the appeal inadmissible.
Art. 74 al. 2 let. a LTF
This provision is cited in order 4. to declare the appeal inadmissible based on a simplified procedure.
Généré par l'IA
A/2526/2007
Wrongful Termination of Construction Contract and Damages
A/2134/2007
Software Development Breach and Unjust Enrichment Claim
A/2491/2006
Property Development Breach Regarding Construction Specifications
A/3945/2006
Owner v. Contractor: Breach of Construction Contract and Termination Validity
A/4019/2006
Contractual Breach and Performance Dispute over Commercial Property Construction

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision is cited in order 2. to regulate the costs of the federal procedure.

Art. 93 LTF

This provision is cited in order 3. to declare the appeal inadmissible.

Art. 74 al. 2 let. a LTF

This provision is cited in order 4. to declare the appeal inadmissible based on a simplified procedure.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



        

       

 

      

 







   !  "#" ! #







   !  $$##"!   ! 



"!  ! " ! ###"!#% &'  $$  #" 

 

 !! "#$%#& &'(%   



     0-0   

)*+,)-../ 0*)110

#   

1&  "("%"2222223%0 45%667(%%%! 4$&

-&   8 %  % %%$%'  ((  (9%%'  : ;0<0 <=%>?222222@&

*&  *16-..-'%66! !!%$ 8%$9%=!-..1%%9A& 6%*1!(6-..1! !<%( %6!!A% BCD1E.*,&*-:>=8 %%  BC,1-E///&++&

+&   -, A!$% -..*' =(%%% A%  3%0 45 = C 7  (! 8 ! 8 "222222  F%A% % '  8 AA!  %>3%0 45 ;06%7%AA!$!:%&

  %668!!-+F%-..*& ;06% % ((   $!:% (6%  (9 "0G' (4 " -/. ' %8> BC/+E*..&0'(%'(4"H.. && & "' = I%!  H.+(*' = %8 >  BC1JE+H.&0 %%9('(9K(:'(4+..C'=$  BC1*E...&0'9%$%!!$!( !  !!&

J&  *.F%-..*'= C 8!%66%=%( LA!! %-..13%0 45=C7'A%8=%( LM< BC*E.H,&0&

D&  #*F%-..+!(%%66'= C !%! (%%  8%  (%A 9 =%$%!  ?(:  :@  F%A%% ( =%%% % = $!:% (6%  I  "0 G-/. %(%&

/&  1,F%-..+'%66!%% !(% = C  4((%% =%( L A!! % 3%0 45  C7&  $!:% (6% > %( !% !%   $I>  % N  %66 :%  (:%& <(' (%! $%'(( ! L 6%9&  %66%% <9 = C   9 ;06%$!:%(6%(9"(  (9 % % !%  :> =8 %%'  !$ =  %$!-)J4(A%&

,&  1JF%-..J'= C ! &$%!(% %A% ;06%=%!8$!:%"0G%

)*+,)-../ 0+)110

$% ; (%  %  :> %! < =%$%! %!   %66& = C   %  %! 9  $!:% %%>%8 !% %%! %(<% A%=%'$:'=(  !%  A% 9=  (    $ (8%(  BC*DE...&0 $!:%(6% BC/E-..&0 ('%  %8(I=>%= I%!1-J(*& A%' % $%  =;  %6 (%%%A  1 A!$% -..J   8%1HH/"&"2222223 )+H)-..J7&=$% !! ! $  %6 A!!' A  $%  %' (% =; !% %%96& =(%%% $% !(%> = %9 '  %9!(;((%4(%4=%( L=%( LA!! A!   !%%    ((%%     (%4=%( L&%(%$$!:%(6%'A%8! %%%( < BC-.E...&0 $% !! ! < %$( < BC*.E...&0' % < BC*DE...&0  A% < BC+JE...&0 < %  1 F$% -..*&  %9$%A%=6F=O/)-..---$(6 -..-% 9?A%%!<=%%% A%=$!:%  !%%9  A )  % !   9 =  %6(P((!% < =8%= A% !>(%!!(($$ @&

  #  $  (6   8Q  %$%! %$ %! 4$'% $%>(%'%$%   %% A%8(%6F%$&

  = C F&

H&   *1 6 -..J'  %66  ! %9!&  %%  = C  =!% 6>=;1A!$%-..J  %6 (%%%A&I$%%4=(A% ;06%= $!:%%%>%8'!$=  %$!-)J4(&

1.&   *. $(6 -..J' = C   !!  <  %9   /!(6'  %66' = C   =(%%% A!!  %6% 3%0 4 5 C 0 B7  !! %A(! 9   !% >! < F>&

11&   !%%  1* $(6 -..D'  C  (%    %66 =>%   !A%  A%  ;06%  $!:% "(%%:>=8 %%'!% =  %$!-)J4(A%&

1-&   *. F$% -../' = C      !%%   C& %(<9=$% %6(%%%A;1 A!$% -..J'   =%( L   (( 1HH/' =(%%%

)*+,)-../ 0J)110

A%!%(!( %9%A((%4  $ %(%  $!:% %!! (( < > A%&  $ A%8! =6 < BC-.E...&0' $% !! ! %$( < BC*.E...&0 % BC*DE...&0  A% BC+JE...&0 4  1 F$% -..*& %AA!!%% C!(%>% %& %4O1-  = C  (  8 %%  :A  $%   8%  %!  8 8&   1.  (6 1HH/ %%9 9=% $% !! !%!    BC*.E...&0 < BC*DE...&0  $ (8%( = $!:% A% 4 =! A% 1HH/   9  6% % !R   %% !  *. F% -..+   $ (8%(  BC*DE...&0< BC+JE...&0<1F$%-..*&

  = C <=%!%%! C&

1*&  -A!$%-../' %6(%%%A9% C!   %I(%!!%%9%!$% )D+J)-..J )-,+D)-..+%! =(%%%&

1+&  /A!$%-../' C! !%'! % (  !%%&

1J&  -,A!$%-../'= C 0 BA%$%9==% !  =6$%&

1D&  1+(-../'%66%A(!%69=%%% <!%% C'9%$%!!%A%!JF$%-../&

1/&   -. ( -../'  %  !! %A(! 9   !% >! < F>&#%>(A%  C' )D+J)-..J$% !!F>!-. (6-..D& < )-,+D)-..+'=$%F(% !! F>!'   I !! %!&        (%4 !%%'   =C -..-' 9 = C  =$% (%  !%  =(%(  $!:% (6%  (9 > 9=< :  BC*DE...&0& =(%%% =$%  !6% =8% = %9 %A((%4(%(6=$%(% (%%6  BC*DE...&0   $!:% (6%'    9=% $% =(    %66   %' %0%  9  (%( $% ; !   6 = $  BC++E1..&0&

1,&   !%%  , (% -../'  F> !!>! < =%%     %A(! = C  9= %% ( !(% !% !&  !%  11F%-../!%%( %< !  %4%< !(  %9  (%4  !%  A% =9%%% 

)*+,)-../ 0D)110

(I& $%!  %%%$%9%% ;%%6!<F&

1H&   , F% -../' = C   8 ! 9= =$% !6%  %%$ %(%$(8%(('(6%=%!  (   I   $!:%   ( 6%%   6% !% (>%&  9%   $ (8%( %   $!:% (6%&  %(  E C  !% A!   %%   9 A%?(>%9(@%!<!%%$8! !% !%6  $ 6' < =8 %  A%  $ %!<$% A% >!6&# %9'=%%%=$!:%!%%9A   % ! %  9 = $% %6( P (( !% < =8%   A% $%   $ =!% !%6&

     %%>%8'  %66 (%  %  %!%  A% =9%%% = (  H.. (* = $  BC1JE+H.&0(%A9=%=%%% ! ! L 6%9&

    %!% 9= (  1-J(* !% 6%   ! 8 ! (  $%&   (%A'  $% %(%!  $ A%  =>%< BC/E-..&0'9=%!%(($(I=(  1-J(*'  %AA!  %8 !   $   %%(!&

-.&   %11F%-../'= C 0 B=!(%!9% !%6%%!  A% F%A%!  => ((%  A%   %668Q%$%!%$=%-/C&  %66 (%  !%  A% %! < =%%%  8 $!:%' %  (6% = %8  >  BC/+E*..&0   (= %8 BC1JE+H.&0& ! ((('%$% =8(% % :  $!:% !% %%! <  A% ((%  A%  =% !%  ! <  > 3 ;  %6 A!!

- &-D-)-..D  D $(6 -..D7&  F%A%% ((%  !  ! %  8  % AA%% 9=% 8%     %! 6F%A   !    6 !(%9  = %&  %% !% %A% 9  !  % !! %   >%% %%' A% $   %%> 9%   % ((%&  =!%   !  =%=(%(6%9%   %!! 9%  $% 9=< =%%R    '  %!! >$% %M(( ! <:>!  %$!&

)*+,)-../ 0/)110

  #%  I   $!:% 9%   %66 $%  6  %A%  >M   %%'  !  %%>%  $% ; %!! ((  A% !%6 F%A%!  => ((%  A%&

    %6 AA  A!9 $I>  % ::%$$!:%IA %!:>%!< >$(%%!%&(6%>($('(  6S%<A%<(;($%$% $< % BC*.E...&0&

   %8  BC*DE...&0   = C   % <  !%!  (:! %89=%%>%%%%A% $ %%>6F%$9% %((% =:=$!:%&

     >% (%!'   (  (9 % "HHD' % =>%%=(4 '%(%!<=%%%  ;  (:%'% %%0& (=!% <(;( (=%%% ! %66' %! (6%9! L&>%%A% $  %%> 6F%$ 9% =%$%%  BC1JE+H.&0  =:   >%&    $%0 (  !%  A%  %> ! (' %$(1-J(*& A%'  %% >!!((%(%4A%'%%(6%<%9%A%% $%=8%=A%<!%<%(%A%=    $      !9  =!: 3$ A% J/)-..-,1D%&-&* &,1,7&

   = 4'  %%(! =$%   !  $   !%! ((%  %   8 $!:%  !>% %!!  =8%%$%! A%%! $%  !:&

  = C 0 B  < =%   !%%   ((%%  <  A%(%   !%%  !(%  =(%%% A%   * F% -..+  9 = C  $% A!    %!%  A%%!$!:%"<(%&

-1&     1* M -../'  %%(!  !! (%%  %%   A%  ('  !A! <  F%   %6 (%%%A

3 )+H)-..J1A!$%-..J7&

--&  -6-../' %!!%A(!9!%>!< F>&

)*+,)-../ 0,)110

# ! 

1&  F!  (  % $  F%%% ( !'    $63&JD %E>%%F%%%--$(61H+10  0  - .JR & D* & 1 &    %   ! (%%%$  1- (61H,J0 0 J1.7&

-&  9%%%>% %!% 89%%(!%%'A%!%9$!:% A%' = (6%  = (.  % %4 9=% $ ! <  !%   8 >%R  %% =  $%! %9=%!(!1,F%-..+!%% *F%(;(!&

*&   %%=%-/%A!!=%( LA!!% 1+ !(6 1HH. 3C 0 # D+-&117'  %66 8Q  %$%! %$ %!  $ !%  A% 9%  F%A%!  => ((% A%&

 & #F%  %6A!!'(%!% ! %$=%$%! A%%AA%9=%8% 8%!   A%  =6%  $&  A%  ! ( $ ; !%   9 !  %! < =8%  =%$%! A%%! % (%%< AA%'%< (I 9%  ! !   8 !  AA%$  %66 3 ;  %6 A!! - &-D-)-..D  D $(6 -..D' %&J&-D&*7&

  #%' %4% !%(%A%=8 %% !  %$!%;=>((%& %>=( ;:  %(  %%4=8 %%'>' %6!!A%%%'6:9%! 3T&K# &'!%%A%%0%( L%0+4(!& -...' &--+0--J7&

 6&   % < =(%%%'   %%$'  %%'  %%  $%'  %> %%'  $ ! =6%>%<:>%I6& F> A% % (       ( N    !   = 4  (  $% <  % !%   % %% !> %3 C1-1+/*%&-6 &+/,;%!7&

   = 4' =(%%%   ! ! 8 %% % A%8  $ %(%   !%  A% I % < => =

)*+,)-../ 0H)110

$!:% (6%&   !$ !>(  %$ !%%   ((%%A%(%=$(8%((%%6 >%&

  #6%% % ! ! = C '% I%%!9$% %% %%!%     %% %A(   %  A% F%A%!  => ((%  A%  (%4  %  (   A% %! < =9%%%=>=$!:%(6%&

+&   $%   !(% %  %%$   %6   = 4& =>%=8(%%$ =(%%%!%    %6 $ => ((%' (     !%!  =8 %%A= %%!!&#6%*1!(6 -..19=%$%!!!6% %%(!'6!!A%=!$%< BCD1E...&0 $%:>=8 %%< BC,..E...&0&((6% =:6%('<$!:%8=%(  & ((4$ $ %= C 0 B'%4!(% (!% A%=9%%% ;06%=$!:%%;=>9 $ A%AA%$(((Q!& #=>% =%  #%  %  (9%%'  :   $;('  A>'6S$!:%( !9&(%%%   A!!   %! 9= %8 =9%%%  BC*DE...&0 $!:%A((:!&=I %  (  9%  %9     $0%(% A%8!  =(%%%6%%0!%(%%6 %$&

J&  #=>%   ( %%!   ! (   %%(!' % =>%=>%=9%%%= !%<=8 %%A =(>%$;(5=! 9=(%%%%8 =  (( =%  %R    L <  !  =>!(' 9 9= %  (' 9  %%(!  % 4  !%'  AM0 9= %'  %  A% A%&  %A%%  !!  =(%%%   1* F% -..+  (%  9  9%   !%!  %%$ %   $!:% < 8 =%<;:! ! 4&

D&     = C   (%.  !A%  A%  ;06% = $!:% (6%  (9 "0G' (4 " -/. '  %8 >  BC/+E*..&0&  %(%! 8 A%   <  $ (8%(  BC*DE...&0&  A% %! <  ( %%>% 4$   $   %%(!R % = % <  !%  A% A%:A>%&

)*+,)-../ 01.)110

   %%(!  %  1* M -../  % A(  A%(%   !%% 9!&  (6   (! <  !(( = (  BC1=J..&0   %%  =% ,/ & 1  & UUUUU

&"#!  #      

/0(1) 2

! $6   %F!  *. F$% -../  =(%%% A% !%%((%%(%4=%( L 1*!(6-..DR

(1*2

=(R

$%%< $8%%!R

%9=!((<: BC1=J..&0(%<:>"( "%"222222R

% 9' A(!( 8 % ,-  %$   % A!!   %6 A!!  1/ F% -..J 3 C0# 1/*&11.7'  ! ;  ; !    F 9% %$  %A%% 0$  %6 A!!'   $%  (%4% 6%R(!(%%%%9%' (%A(I $ %>(%R% % ; !  %6 A!!' 1...  1+'  $%    $% !%9 8 %%  E% +-  C&  ! ;   %4  %  ' %$9! (( (I  $' %$ ; F% < E$%R

((%9  ! ; < =(%%% A% ' < E(%%% A!!%6%3%$%% %% E%( LA!!%'E%( L%% !' %%(6'!A&.-/&1)-J-*)$7'<((%% E%( LA!!%%%9E<" #$%#& &'(%! 8"222222&

#%!>5 "&I:4' !%'"($IB%'"& :!%'"(' F>&

)*+,)-../ 011)110

( %6(%%%A5

>AA%40F%5   !%5     &%0#%>% C&I:4  

 %A(;!!((%9!8 %&

 4$'  >AA%45           

)*+,)-../