Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/536/2006 • CJ GE ATA/536/2006 Généré par l'IA

Agency Deference in Public Fund Management Review

Numéro de cause ATA/536/2006
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The appellate court reviewed a dispute concerning the scope of statutory authority related to the management of certain public funds or assets, specifically addressing whether a prior administrative decision regarding the allocation or disposition of those assets was subject to full judicial review or limited deference. The court reasoned that the governing statute clearly delegated discretionary decision-making power to the administrative agency within defined parameters, and absent a clear showing that the agency's action was arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with law, the court should defer to the agency's interpretation and factual findings, thereby affirming the agency's determination.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Agency Deference in Public Fund Management Review: The court reasoned that the governing statute clearly delegated discretionary decision-making power to the administrative agency within defined parameters, and absent a clear showing that the agency's action was arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with law, the court should defer to the agency's interpretation and factual findings, thereby affirming the agency's determination.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
pouvoir d'appréciation du juge pouvoirs publics pouvoir d'examen abus d'autorité patrimoine administratif pouvoir réglementaire

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Costs are imposed on the losing party.
Généré par l'IA
A/490/2004
Agency Deference in Statutory Interpretation Dispute
A/3756/2005
Statutory Interpretation and Agency Deference in Administrative Determinations
A/2592/2007
Statutory Interpretation of Mandatory Appropriations
C/4440/2020
Appeal Regarding Expert Examination of Discretionary Asset Management Mandate
A/2084/2003
Statutory Interpretation and Scope of Agency Authority Review

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Costs are imposed on the losing party.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



        

        

 

   



 !"#





#!"$$$$$$$ 



% & %% ''%% %&( ' 





     !"# 

% 

'(  )* +++++++, -  +++++ './0,  1***- 2 34(   **561**6*!71*!&&!(

!(  8  * 6* 6  4*  19*    4*:* ;* 63<8 =>*59?,!0619!&&#,5* 61*6*1*,*@@34*4'. 1%?*!&&#(

%(   *  '! 9 !&&#, )( +++++++  1- 2 64* -661*'$1*!&&$,A**61*6:6* 164( **,*63* *1*1 4*6>*B>>*4(

  '%9!&&#,8 6-65@-*1 '$1*!&&$(

  )(+++++++-6-61*8 ? 2(

7(  1C1?,2'.B7#,5*--**>*54 B@  **     34(   B  B1*  *  ,  4* A*  6--* 5 *119**- 2  *:** 1*( )(+++++++*4*2**>>*566-4***, -6*5>*:-:*A(

  :-6:1,)(+++++++**A-A5*4*-6  61*  * 63  8 ( >*,  * 6* >>  1*1(

#(  94*!&?*!&&$-8 ,)(+++++++  6*:1*,5:*26*A*6*A 1-6**>>(?*2*6B6* *54*9*-A5*-6-*(>*54* *'$1***:9,*46   6  >1 2  -**  5*-(   **- 5*: 

8 (

$(  C-7?*!&&$--@-*9,8  *-61**)(+++++++6A*D1*,66** 5*'$*>--***3'!-19'.#0 ;8 /7'(&'   =( 5*-- -* *- 2 *  4-B*  -:* 6-* E,   )   4-B* 6 A  61*  *5-*6-*6-*(

"!$%%"!&&$ %"# 

/(  )(+++++++** *91***>5'/?*!&&$ 2-*-1(6*:1* -*  **   9* 6>*  B>> *4  6*DD,  1 - 6  16F,    >* A5* 5:** 51-6*65*B*(4*1C1-4-4-B* *1*-27#G1"B3'/1*!&&$(

0(   6*  --   16* 6  7 619 !&&$(

 ( )( +++++++  >*1-  (  5-* -1 16-   -95@-*1,*6*A511*'$1* !&&$21**(31*,***4-B**1*-27#G1"B( 54* 6   --6*- A* * 4* -- 1*  8 ( 8  6 6>*,6*4*61**6*5-16931(

 9(  8   6*-   -**,  A5* 5:** 5 *  *(  5-* --  1**11 -:  *  4 *6** A* 6-4F* A  4 *  9** 2 *  * 1*-?26-(

% ' 

'(  ?-  16 * 4  ?*** 16-,    49;(#$ *H:**?***!!419'.7'    !&#I($%('(*6-1***4'! 619'.0#    #'&=(

!(  ****>*:42 ;('$( '(> =(

%(  63*>*:4,61***-6D 1*1**11*,*A-6--,61*--*- >**5*>*:42@6**5*>* 1F1 :4 ;( '$ ( !    =( >*, 5*- %   *6** 6-4* A  -  *  61*  * 5 *>* 4*-25*-',>,9*2-*(

   563,     6 4* *  4-B*  A5*-**,*A5*>*59?,!0619!&&#,5* 61**6@*>*:4*-1F,1

8 6-5@-*'$1*!&&$( >*,***>*A5* 5611**>*1*3**,1*A5*51-6*

"!$%%"!&&$ 7"# 

   2 6*  A  * 4* >>*>,   A  8  *J16-12*(

   *9 1***> 34 A      1: 566- **A**>--,8 4**16:4*- >( >*, 5*-  4* 6 6  -:*:  --1 2 -B:(>>-*9A5*56-*B, B3A4*-**4-B*9*-A5**:- A* 6 11   -6  '/ 1* !&&$(   *,  *9 1***>-*-12D1*(

7(  4A*6-3,6*11*(5* **:,-11 KE!&&( 1*2B:,A*9* 6*1:*(-11 KE!&&( -:1,1*2 B:8 ;(0/ =(

)  %'  %   

*+,- .

-49*?-'.?*!&&$6)*+++++++ -**4*19*4*:*7?*!&&$** 61**6A*D1*I

,-#.

516*1I

>*1-**8 A56*61** )(+++++++I

>*@-12D1*I

12B:-11 KE!&&( I

12B:8 -11 KE!&&( I

* A, >1-1 @ * ./  *4   * >-- H:** ?***,6-C6C6-,64**1***>,   ? 3  *>**, 6 4  *9 >--I  1-1*  ***A*,1*>1F646*: 1*I**C-*@16*1*

"!$%%"!&&$ #"# 

*9 >--, '&&&  '7I  6- C   6*3  6*  ,*4A-111F64,*4C?*2H4*I

11*A6-C2)*+++++++**AH4*19* 4*:*2H>>*>--2(

8*-:< )14F,6-*,))(FB3 B-*,?:(

1 *91***><

:>>*3 ?*<  4* 6-*<     (* 8*:* (4F  

6*>1C--11*A-@6*(

 34,  :>>*3<           

"!$%%"!&&$