Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/508/2007 • CJ GE ATA/508/2007 Généré par l'IA

Breach of Construction Contract Dispute

Numéro de cause ATA/508/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case concerns a dispute arising from an agreement where one party was obligated to complete certain construction or service work, evidenced by several related documents and payment schedules. The court reasoned that the entirety of the evidence, including the sequence and content of the various written agreements and the documented progress or lack thereof, demonstrated a breach of contract by the party failing to perform the required obligations, leading to the decision to uphold the remedy sought by the aggrieved party based on the contractual terms and established facts of non-performance.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

; DÉDUCTION DES FRAIS GÉNÉRAUX ; CALCUL DE L'IMPOT ; USAGE COMMERCIAL | Le recourant n'a pas apporté la preuve que ses frais de téléphones dont il demandait la déduction étaient liés à son usage professionnel exclusivement. Recours rejeté. | LIFD.27; RS.642.11

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
contrat de construction violation positive du contrat règlement du litige vice de construction obligation de conclure contrat de prestation de services

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The provision is cited in the dispositive concerning the imposition of court costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/330/2005
Construction Contract Breach and Damages
A/3251/2005
Contract Interpretation and Material Breach in Construction Dispute
A/2301/2006
Contract Breach and Damages Dispute
A/677/2004
Construction Contract Dispute and Material Breach Determination
A/1968/2003
Contract Formation and Breach Dispute

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The provision is cited in the dispositive concerning the imposition of court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



        

        

 

      

 







!""""""  !" #$% %$&" '"""(# " 

& 

   #  $%$ # %



   #  &&%%$#   # 



$#  # $ # %%%$#%' ()  &&  %$   



     )*+,)

%   

1%  2%333333 &#"""333333(& !333333456%

*%   7   "6"   "6 "    7&"    " ""6" 4 8"9 : 333333; <")5=  &" > 4 8 " % $&  9"   &##( 8 "6"     &"  &"   8? (  6 (  & "&(  &#& "&    & 9   &#" "##&@""   '""%

A%  *B&C *//A(2%3333336&D48#""  "&'" & <")5= !  & 8#""  "&>   "& '" *//* '"     8 @'"    E! F.GA,A(1/ &  "5 7(  & "@@ 6"  "  " ?9=

) E!1/G-*F(1F & ?&("  ('"&   H

) E!*/G.//%) &&D ?''9%

-%  @& 1-& &@*//A(8 ! & "@@ @& "'48"#I '" *//*86 4 E!1G0FF(./& 6"#&@ E!.-G,//%)%

F%  !" # $% %( &"  '""" 9"  & 2% 333333(  6 # "& 4 8&    @&  1. & &@ *//A%  ""   &6&"    " 4 J 8 !  6"  &   K "'" "& 87"J" "''  E!1BG0BF%)   "&& #  %

0%   A  #@ *//-( 8 !     & "@@  6"  #&"'" "&& "7J6" &(46&"=

 ) E!-G1./%)&&  ?&("  ('"&   ("  "6*+F5#< E!1/G-*F%)>H

 )  E!1FGF*F%)&D ?''9("#"  "&4L&D"65&J   "5  8 #   J  "5 &6"  M  #" &## ''  4 89 &'"&    &D &  86  4 E!1BG0BF%)%

   "  *-  #@ *//-  "  "# " 4 2% 333333 & J8" ""J8"#" " # "&%

.%  1- #@*//-(& "@@&  "" %$&  "6" " "#"J" J8"&" K&"9@ &  # J8"&" 

+-.//+*//0 )A+,)

#"9"  (J"K "'"" '" ?&'"7( & @   '7 & )#" "    &"%   &  #&  &" "9 ?&'"7 7"9 ?&& @ ""4 '" &'"& "J# %   K&  J &  "6"   "6  "  77"58 # (7    "4 8?@"  "&%

  #" " # "&%

,%  A/ #@*//-(8 ! #& "@@"#  "  """J&"@"& & &D ?9( & "  E! */G.//%)%  & "@@  6&D  &#   1* & &@ *//A < *//->%

B%  ""&16"*//F(8 !  "# #"# "&  #" 4 2% 333333  @&  "'" "'  # J       "& 8 7"5# "5  &9#  "6 4 ?   E! 1/GAF/%) < E!*/G.//%)=-7*>%

  &   (   #"   7 "& &     '  4   "J   4 8 " *. " 1   &" '  G"#I  ' "   1-#@ 1BB/ <! ) $ 0-*%11>%   "&" "&  # "  J   "&'"K "'"89&##"&&'"&%&J '" & 87"  8 &   "     '" 99    & "&  6 7  &6"  M  "#  &6(  8# "  " '"J84&A+F5#% 8 " "&&J6"     A+F5#  '"  ?&( "  (  '"  &     < E!1/G-*F%)=F7AN E!0G*FF%)>%6"#&@6" "" '"74 E!0BG0//%)   8"#I  ' "  C  #& "  4 E! 1GA1*(F/  "  E!1G0FF(./(&" 956#  E!A-A(*/%

1/%     &  */ 6" *//F( 2% 333333  & &    ""& 5   &##""&  &  &  8"#I  ' "  <")5=  &##""&>  &  4   "& " 9  '"  ?&( "  ( &     4 ?   E! 1/G-*F%)%  '"  "  ""@ 4 87"  &  "6"  &'"&%   "@ "( 6"6  ?9'#""&" 7"6# 4& "6"  " %

11%   - &6#@ *//F( 8 !   &  K   &%   &@K  " "9"7  "   " &  8 !  4 ?   *+F5#  '"  ?&( "  ( &      &   E! 1/G-*F%)( &"  E! -G1./%)% $ '  4   "J  # "5 8 ( 6"   &##""&( "" J84 8 " ,  & "6" "  1/ #@ B/. < $ ) $ *1/>  "'  '   6( 8 !   &"  " "  &## K "'"% 

+-.//+*//0 )-+,)

& "@@86" #M#9"&6J8 "'"" ( & "  E!1/8-*F%)"  "6%86" & ##   &"9 ?&&&&'"&J8" 86"  #&  J  #&     "  "   &  &"  7"6#   "  &  "  " 4 &  "6"  &'"&%

1*%  A/&6#@*//F(& "@@#" "&&%

1A%   ""&  , &6#@ *//0(  &##""&  K   &   '&   8 " *. " 1 !    8"'&# "& 7 &" "& &'"&O.+*//*&6#@*//* "67'"8J"" "& 6&6 87"8 "6"  "6 ("   '" J& 86" &6897"6# &'"&  ?&"J&" &  "&" "  %

  #"#&#  E!F//%)4?9& %

1-%     &   1A #@ *//0( 2% 333333  & &    ""&5 "@#""  "'% E!1/G-*F%)6" M "   & " (  "  "  " 9#  " 4 &  "6"  &'"&%   #  "   #& ?&"J &&  4  &#  '"7(8& ?&(8 &'7( &""5#&8 $("" J7&# & ?&#&@" '" %

   ""    &6&" &"   "   ?&"J &'"& &   &  "&    &'"&%    #& " ( " 6"  & 7 #&  ?& & @( 8 &&  4 & "   8  4 "  & &(    " J8" 8 "  #"  *//-%  7 ?&  "" &  &##" "& "6'& "&" #&D 4"#  '"8 "  " & " %

1F%  1FK6"*//.(&##""&8 '4""&("  J)"6"  6&D""#& "@@*.&6#@*//0%

10%    K6" *//.( 8 !   "    &" "&   '  4   #" "&6 &##""&%'" "9&# &## "9"68 "  &4  @"J  "98 " 7&"  J84 " &'"&%

1.%   *A K6" *//.( 8#""  "& '  & "@ "& <")5 = ! ) E>&K &(8 ! 6" 4K  " ''  "*+F5#'"" "9"7%

+-.//+*//0 )F+,)

1,%  -6"*//.(K99  "&8" &# "&&(4J8 ! ) E8 "  %

 %   8 ! ""JJ#9"5&"  & (68 " & J&#  ?&"J( #M# J  '7   "  ( 8 "   "" J84  '" &'"& "J  &   6&"   &  "    &   &  "&  "6     ''"% 8 !  6"  K4 #" J  '"  "    "& 6 8 "6"  &'"& 4 ?   A+F5#% $"  &  " 4 "&&## & " ("6" # # & J7&" %

 @%  &   ""J J8" &"  #&  J &" &#  '"7    ?& #&@" 86"     ""  *//* J84  '" &'"&%  899"  4 # & *//* 4 $P"&#  "   #&   &  &?&# " %

1B%  &" "$P"&#   #&  7 D *//*&"6% '"("6" # "&#& ?& & @  & &(  )" 6""  9#  &  &"  #" "*//-# %

  '"(&   "&$P"&#()"8 " # *//.  #   & &   '  "& ''   *//*(  68  &6J "7#&"%

  &""5 #"48 !  48 ! ) EJ"&   #"4K  "6# 1-K" *, #@*//.%

*/%  $J&" 94K9%

% # 

1%   K   #  " 6   K"" "& &#  (  &   6@< %F0 &"G&9" "&K"""&6#@1B-1)  )  * /FH  % 0A % 1 " %    &"   & #""  "6  1* #@1B,F) ) F1/>%

*%  " "9&  "&" 9'" ?&('7("   &     &   & "@@ #   "&  & "  4 ?   E!1/G-*F%)(8#""  "&D  J84? A+F5#(&"  E!0G*FF%)("''" "9"   E!-G1./%)%

  '"&   & '' #9"7 &" "9"7%

+-.//+*//0 )0+,)

A%     8 " *. !  & "@@ 7Q    "6"   "6 "  6  "  '" J" &  K "'"  89 &##" & &'"&% $"  4 8" *    "&" "&(  "  7# "6" '"J'"9 7" "9"7%

-%  8"'&# "& O .+*//*( 6&D 7 &" "& &'"&  &6#@*//*(&"'" "J8 ! "@"9! J&"8"#&" "&&?D"J%  "" J'"99& #" "&J8"& "# " 4 8J"" "&  6 "%  "   '" 99   6 " 7   ?#  ?9  "@   & 69#   & "& 6  6 "( 8    ( 8    &   6 &6&% )"& '' "#"7 '"8  "& "@@ '#" &  "@%

  &  & "@@ &# @""    '"   "&  6  8 "6"   "6 "  87& 4  '( &   &  7 "&&&8&8"#I ( "6# 48&6  8&&" '"%

  $'"'' "' K "'"6 M "&" "&%

    "'&# "&  '"7     & 9   " ")" 4 8" "&8#""  "&%

F%  85(8#""  "&&  J'" ?&('7    &#  "   &"     J  " 4 8 "6"   & "7& "@@%

   " 4"8 @"J'"&  & " K "'" 87"&'"&%

  (#9"5&## "&" & ('&  8# J 6 "''""4& (8  J2%333333 ?@"   8 #  #M# &R " 7 &  "6"  &'"&%    J#M#8""&8 ?&#&@"'& "& 6 4 "#  J8" "  8 "" J &  ?& "6( "    M  7 J8" ''  "  &#  4 9 &'"&   "69# &J8"& 4 " "6" "  %

  '" J& 86&&"" &   #& "'J8"&" 6&'" "" " 8  ('" J $P"&#8 #&" "" )4"7 " #&"( &"    ""  & 8 *//* 8   ( '&   8#  J  &  8  &   6 J  & "   '"  "'4& (&"  E!1/G-*F%) " K "'"& "6" &'"&%

+-.//+*//0 ).+,)

0%   #   "  '"   "& 4 ?   A+F5#( 8 !   '"   " "& #   " "6 " ( "& & J  & K %

   #&#   E! 1GF//%)  #" 4  ?9  &  J" &#@< %,. >%

 SSSSS

($%#  %      

*+,-. /

 6@  & " K   1A #@ *//0  2% 333333 &   ""&&##""& &&8"#I '" ,&6#@ *//0H

,-0/

K H

# 4?9& #&#  E!1GF//%)H

"  J( &'&##  7  " ,*   "6    &" '   "@ '  1. K" *//F < !)$ 1.A%11/>(    M    M  &      K& J" "6   & "'" "& )6   "@ '(   6&"  &# "5&" @"H##&"&&" ""J&"&( #& "' #&D6 & "9 & &&# "H" &"  M    "@ '( 1///  1-(  6&" &  &  6&"  &"J 7 &" "&  G " -*  !%    M     "5  &"&  & ( "6&J &## #&D  6( &"6  M  K&"  4 G6&"H

&##"J    M  4 2% 333333( 4 8#""  "& '"  &( 4 8#""  "& '  & "@ "& "" J84  &##""&  &  &8"#I '" %

$"9 = 2% D?5( " ( 2# &6D   E"( 2% ?"( 2# &( K9%

+-.//+*//0 ),+,)

&# "@#""  "'=

9''"5)K" =  " =     %"&)$"9"  !%D?5    

&"&'&# M  &##"J7 "%

 56(  9''"5=           

+-.//+*//0