Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/508/2005 • CJ GE ATA/508/2005 Généré par l'IA

Statutory Silence and Preserved Protections

Numéro de cause ATA/508/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The situation involved a dispute over whether an action, which was permissible under an earlier version of a legal standard, was still protected after the standard was amended, despite the amendment's failure to explicitly address the previously permissible action. The court reasoned that the omission in the revised standard did not automatically void the prior protection; instead, the court applied the principle that a regulatory change, absent clear indication of intent to retract prior protections, should be construed to preserve those protections unless the new language explicitly forecloses them, thus affirming the validity of the action under the former standard as incorporated into the current framework.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statutory Silence and Preserved Protections: The court reasoned that the omission in the revised standard did not automatically void the prior protection; instead, the court applied the principle that a regulatory change, absent clear indication of intent to retract prior protections, should be construed to preserve those protections unless the new language explicitly forecloses them, thus affirming the validity of the action under the former standard as incorporated into the current framework.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
protection juridique droit de préemption légal droit d'être entendu revirement de jurisprudence égalité dans la loi rétroactivité de la loi

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the federal proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
A/4233/2005
Statutory Repeal and Preservation of Vested Rights
A/2555/2006
Contractual Survival Post-Regulatory Amendment
A/2168/2006
Statutory and Regulatory Provisions Challenged on Due Process and Free Speech Grounds
A/521/2006
Statutory Interpretation Scope of Prior Rulings
A/257/2006
Restrictive Covenants Validity After Statutory Change

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the federal proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

        

 

   

 !

"# $ %!&'





&'$ ()* 





+  ,, ,  -,. /-,, +- , 





     !"# 

, 

$(  )*  (++++++++++  ** ,  -.*  /..  0*1 2*32  !# 4 $55&( -*  # 264 $55%1 * 0-*3*0*3-6**6(

!(  7  --  *86 2  !9 -64 !''& - )* (++++++++++182*2** -*2-1* *3*22--21$:;!''&1<,-8-6 3*   6  ,2-1 * <  ** 3  )* (++++++++++1 6-=2  3* 62*>  ,2-1  )((++++++++++1/..0*(72*)((++++++++++1 )( (++++++++++ ** *? *  ,3 * @  **  ,2-()((++++++++++3**1>*,3*-,/-* /..0*1>*,3**3*A>,-8>*( .** 3*66*0*.*< ./**82*2 -32/*)((++++++++++/1 < *(  0 32/* ,2* B2  *3 < ,2-( )((++++++++++2**3*3*62)((++++++++++1>* 3*--2,--(

  )((++++++++++,2*62-**?6*-08*.1 <,28-2.,>,3)((++++++++++(

9(  *--2**12-6A*1-* 2*2 C* -?D  2-6E  2 ,* < )( (++++++++++  -*  43*1 -* * *  *.*82  -*    -.*/..*2--*0A**>,6 6***3 FG&''( -3**3*822**(

&(  )((++++++++++** *46***.,$%A3* !''#(,3*-6>2<3***(,2*< ,*8*  ,**  **  8 -  8   ( 7 --3*.*,3*-22-*6---*(

#(   !$ .23* !''#1  2-6 , --2  ( )( (++++++++++1 - 6*.  626 . <  64** * - 6 <  821 ,3* -*3*1 -* 62   8 , -  3*  2*2  ,2-1 >* 3* --2  -*( )( (++++++++++ 3* 286 62  -2  .  ,( .*1  2-6  32 >   3*  22  >  *2*--*2(

"$%&"!''# 9"# 

H(  *-*-2-6>)((++++++++++.* ,4A*6*3D

 66***3 FG!''( *22*.*82!#3*!''!1 *,3*---2 ->,**.** *-2** - 4*I

 6 FG$''( *22*.*825A*!''!-3**21 >,*,2*-3*1332/*,*86* ,2*-/2I

  6  FG !''(  *  22 *.*82  $ A* !''9 - 6>63***1<*,4830 /..0*I

 6 FG!''( *22*.*82$'A*!''91<3-  - 3* --2  -> ,**.**   * -2* *  - 4*(

%(   -*  22   !9 6* !''#   , *  6-*-,>B(

  )((++++++++++0-2>,*=3**1< *,2-6-*(8,3*J021 -*2-2343*(,3*-*3*(

  )((++++++++++1>*226*10-2>,*** 332/*,-*>*,6-=*(0**3*?-? 3*.**-2-(>26*3*-***0-1 0* ,3* *3* A>,< ,2  ,2-(   3* - ->*  /..  0* 3* -2  * * ->* * ,3* K2L1 -* *3*32(   6* 3* .*2 <  *1  * /2**    < *316*2,3*.*3*6-8B)((++++++++++(

  )( (++++++++++  **>2 >,*  3=* - ->* * * *2 )((++++++++++*6-6* *,3*-22**>4,* ,3*-3*6.*23*-.**1*2> 2*0*3( 26*3**.*16*- .*0-?-,=( 4A*.**-.* *.(

,/ 

$(  A2  6- * 3  A*** 6-21    34 C( #H   *  M8** A***  !! 364 $5&$ 

"$%&"!''# &"# 

  !'#I(H9($*(*-26***3$! -64$5:#    #$'E(

!   3 *   0*  *6* C- -.*  -  6=  3* 64*E  !$ A3* !''# C0* N F $ 9'E  2  3*8  $# 6* !''#( 7 ,* H$  01  *-***!:<9$*3* 0*!H6$555 C 0*E--*40*.*66*3,23*8 *(

9( ( , 0*  - 4 ,  0*   -.*   0-**  0* .6 0 0*8   2*2    6*2 -4*>=2*66*(

 4( *!$!! 0*26?4*8*/.. 0-*1228 *, -3*.*0?8 6-64*8*/..C(!$(H 0*E(

   ,-?1  -2 26 >    3*2  3* 822**>,*-*3*64**-*> **221 -*  2 *-0  8*.  3  * >,3-2.,(

  383*2.22)((++++++++++1 * *.*82 -  2-61 *  -*    -.*  /.. *2- - *0 A   6 6***3 FG$''( -2.*62(

&(  3,***81266 FG9''( 6*</8 1>*64C(:% E(

-,/  ,   

012&(# 3

2 34*A2$5A3*!''#-)* (++++++++++ 2**2-6A*1-*2*2!$264!''&I

12&'3

AI

6</8266 FG9''( I

"$%&"!''# #"# 

66*>  -2 B < )*  (++++++++++ ** >M 2-6  A*1-*2*2(

7*28D )63=1-2*1))(=/?1 /2*1A8(

6 *46***.D

8..*? A*A(D  3* -2*D     )( * (3=   

-*.6B2266*>20-*(

 ?31  8..*?D           

"$%&"!''#