Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/507/2006 • CJ GE ATA/507/2006 Généré par l'IA

Procedural Delay Not Jurisdictional Absent Prejudice

Numéro de cause ATA/507/2006
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The dispute centered on whether a procedural rule, mandating a brief delay before presenting evidence to challenge a prior ruling, was strictly applied, as one party presented rebuttal evidence immediately after the ruling without observing the required waiting period. The court reasoned that strict adherence to the procedural rule was not necessary because the opposing party suffered no prejudice from the immediate presentation of evidence, as they had full opportunity to address the evidence in their subsequent arguments, leading to the conclusion that the delay was not a jurisdictional prerequisite for admissibility.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 106 al. 1 LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Procedural Delay Not Jurisdictional Absent Prejudice: The court reasoned that strict adherence to the procedural rule was not necessary because the opposing party suffered no prejudice from the immediate presentation of evidence, as they had full opportunity to address the evidence in their subsequent arguments, leading to the conclusion that the delay was not a jurisdictional prerequisite for admissibility.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
retards de procédure incompétence ratione materiae violation des règles de procédure argumentation motivée objet du litige principe de la célérité

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 106 al. 1 LTF
The appeal is partially dismissed on procedural grounds.
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The appellant is ordered to pay the court fees.
Art. 68 al. 2 LTF
The respondent is not awarded costs because they did not submit a substantive response.
Généré par l'IA
C/23850/2015
Procedural Due Process Violation in Jurisdiction Ruling Due to Omitted Pleading
A/2347/2005
Procedural Rule Interpretation and Discovery Sanction Balancing
A/188/2007
Timeliness of Statutory Filing and Jurisdictional Requirements
A/3346/2008
Administrative Delay in Reimbursement Decision Not Denial of Justice
A/2063/2006
Non-Compliance with Procedural Deadlines and Mutual Violations

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 106 al. 1 LTF

The appeal is partially dismissed on procedural grounds.

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The appellant is ordered to pay the court fees.

Art. 68 al. 2 LTF

The respondent is not awarded costs because they did not submit a substantive response.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



        

       

  

    

 !"

#"$%&'





&'%"(((((( 



) * )) ++ )) ) *, + 

 



     !"# 

) 

234,1,1!((&*,,541,,*

!*  6  , 1,  ,7 1,,,8 4  3,  17,3,9,:, 42;6 <.8,57= 11,,,3,3;

 )!1,)00$

  ,  41,  , 4  / ,/1,/. 4/ 4 5,/ 14/    .  ,  11, 5>/?.?>>,>@

 !&417)00&

 /3,/,,4//41A1,/753, 1/,837,,45,//57,341, ,42/,5B14,C@

 D7)00D

  ,  41,  , 4  / ,/1,/. 4/ 4 5,/ 14/    6>EFG.  ,  11, 5>/?@

 !&7!(((

  ,,  41,  ,   7 5 3, 1/, 837. ,57,9,511/,@

 )#1,!(()

 44,57,9,511/,1,/*

3,//,4/3,49 8,2.C5,4,  33,.CC423,11/?* 542  /, C5, 3, 8, B 4,,. 5,// 3,  5,= (.& 9   9 4 1,    /C,3 3, // ,,*



"$%&'"!((& $"# 

%*  /,,$)H!((&.B/,7.6 ,/

,/1,/*5,,,3,,1/,/923:+</, >9/4/IB1448,5/34,I ,3/>,I1*/,,8,,4,425B4, .1,,I ,./,,B1,*

&*     !D 417 !((&  1, I 588,  4  $( ,3.

4/,/*  ,/,8/8,/4,C5,53,,4// ?.,53,3,11/*53,342 37. ,,9/B5,,1,3,///7,I,* 11,53,4 / I 59  4,  /4 C , , ,.  , 3, H 8,,4/,C,,4,,42 37*

#*  )(317!((&.5,//1,,7/4, 4,4/C5,3,/3,9//.3,.48B   ,.  4,, C, 3, /7,  42 37 5,,  )! H !((&*,C/,,9C,F8,9,, ,*

'*  5,14,4)D317!((&.

4  82 =1*  =  8,. , /, A/  , 5/   1,C   4, 4    11   ,4,*  6 . C I ,.  ,,C/ C5, 5/, 4 44/ I  1 43,,  ,,41,,I5,//.3,*

   4,  // ,81/ C  4/ , 4 

,7/,/,,43,,41,, ,*

D*   /,,  !& 317 !((&.  4/,  ,7 1,,,8.   1 43,,.  /  ,,  41, 

0*  )/17!((&.B/,/,,1,/.6  ,/41,,I,,*

)(*  !'=,!((#.6 1,,7/4,2 ,3;

   1!)1!((#4 9//4/4/348B,,I

"$%&'"!((& %"# 

5CA / 4  C C  4,, 1,   53, 11,  ,8,  C  8, // 4  4,9 53,  B, :,<*   4,, F 4// I

/1,3, 8,1/C5,// 3,.3,. 8, C, , /, 4>/. 4/,/  /,   11,  ,9/ FB/,1,* 8,.44/7,4 7,94,>,C,,8,C,,4

/,,548,57=@

53,4/,I1538,5B4,. C5,53,4//4,74/BB1C,@

      1,   !$ =, !((# 4  =9

/,, 1,   1 I  4,  )( = 514,1 3 , 4 , .  ,   4, /4/  0 317 !((&   C , 3, 4,/    ,,44,!'8/3,!((#* /,,548,57= *

))*  45,,4/. ,71,,,8.4

*

)!*  )D3,!((#.5,///4C/,*

)$*  6C,.588,//9/I=9*

) + 

)*  =/  14 , 3  =,,, 14/.    37:*&# ,J9,,=,,,!!317)0%)     ! (&@ * #$ * ) ,*    ,   4/ 1,,,3  )!417)0D&    &)(<*

!* * 6 5, )# ,/ )  7   , 8//   ,, ,2)!/17)0&D:6'%)*()  <.41,,,/ 4/,/1,/I4C,88581/4 ,4I,*

"$%&'"!((& &"# 

 7* 5, $(  5 /9 51,,  4   3/>,I,,,2!'7)0'#:6'%)*&)  <41 ,I,4/3,841,,C5,B,/,B CI54,I,5*59,5,/,/.C, 544,.1,11,,,33,I/,/ 8,*   =,8, , 914 C   ,  9 : ")&!"!((&)$1!((&<*=,4,.4,/  ,   ,, 4 A 1,   ,, 17,*  4 C,  ,  3/>, 17,    47,C , 3,  8/   8,*    ,.  ,  /,/    J, $( ,/ 41,   , A / : A  ,7 8// # *)))"!(((  !( 1 !(()@ "!D)"!(()  !% 3, !(()@/6>88>.,>E,G,>63K>>. 3*;, 1,, ,31>1.)00&.4*&%<*

  4,,. ,71,,,8,.34,2

33/>,C5,3,11?.  9 /     4,* 14   //  1,211,4/8,.//C,,/=I 3 B ,  41,  , 4  / ,/1,/.  6  ,4,5//188,43,/,B4, I,.4.,41,,I,4/3,8. ,57,9,1IB4,*

$*   /C.    =/*  /11  LM #((*   1,I>9C,17:*D' <*

 NNNNN

-  )+  )    

./01&" 2

/,,3,17,3,9,$)H!((&@

01&'32

=@

1I>9/11 LM#((* @

"$%&'"!((& #"# 

, C. 81/1 B , 0'  ,3   , 8// J9,, =,,,.4/A4A4/.43,,1,,,8.   = 2  ,8,,. 4 3  ,7 8//@  1/1,  ,,,C,.1,81F434,9 1,@,,A/,B14,1, ,7 8//. )(((  )%@  4/ A   4,2  4,  .,3C/111F43.,3A=,IJ3,@

17,3,9,IJ88,8//I*

6,/9; +*F>2.4/,.+1L,.=9*

1 ,71,,,8;

988,2 =,=;  4/,;     +* , M*F>2   

4,81A//11,C/B4,*

 23.  988,2;           

"$%&'"!((&