ATA/491/2005 · Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

ATA/491/2005 · Statutory Levy Validity and Procedural Safeguards Appeal (Cour de Justice (Cour civile))

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The court considered an appeal concerning the validity of a statutory levy and its application to certain property interests. The appellant contended that the imposition of the levy violated constitutional protections by failing to provide adequate notice or a proper hearing, arguing the assessment was arbitrary and exceeded statutory authority regarding the relevant property's valuation and classification. The court reasoned that the statute provided sufficient procedural safeguards, as the appellant had recourse to administrative review and judicial appeal, and the legislative delegation for the valuation method was not unconstitutionally vague, ultimately concluding that the levy was validly assessed and applied according to the prescribed legal framework.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

PRESTATION D'ASSISTANCE; ASSISTANCE PUBLIQUE; DOMICILE; OBLIGATION DE RENSEIGNER; REMBOURSEMENT | Le recourant est au bénéfice d'une autorisation de séjour en France et reçoit de l'aide sociale de ce pays. Cette situation n'était pas connue de l'hospice général qui lui a également versé des prestations d'assistance auxquelles il n'avait pas droit. Confirmation de la décision de l'hospice de fin de prestations d'assistance et de remboursement de celles indûment perçues. | LaLAsi.8 al.5; CST.12; LAP.1; LAP.7 al.1; LAS.4

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA

contrôle juridictionnel demande adressée à l'autorité prétention légale protection juridique arrêts en appréciation de validité recours contre décision de renvoi

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for ordering the costs of the appeal.

Généré par l'IA

A/1409/2001

Appeal Concerning Tax Statute Constitutionality and Application

A/4475/2006

Statutory Validity and Regulatory Authority Appeal

A/2641/2004

Statutory Validity Challenge Upheld Against Vagueness and Notice Claims

A/2315/2007

Appeals Regarding Statutory Interpretation and Application in Property, Contract, and Procedural Matters

A/3550/2006

Municipal Bond Validation and Tax Levy Challenges

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for ordering the costs of the appeal.

Texte complet

!"#$%&&&&&&&&& !"# " $%&

&

'()* ++

#'())#

*

)- !&"./////////0"#12!-.///////// (&3" 4$ ////////// )567$ &"8"" //////////$ & )555 !9 /////////$& " ://////////-

;"///////// "&//////////',,'-

!- .///////// 1 3 ; $ " 3 9"8$ & 99 ;" /////////./////////$//////////)55,$"% <1%*9',,=-

!-./////////$&& ;"/////////& &9"""//$ ///////// < 1%$ 9 9" < "&" "& : 3>&"80"#123>&"4-

!-./////////""?;" ///////// @;"" 39" $ %@=, 9@',,+-

'- !-./////////& &"93"A"$ "%9 )55,$ )55* )555- B 9"1 & C $ &""19 9 % &99""&"&9 "13"- 98&@;" /////////./////////-

=- !- .///////// @;"" 3" ;""1 3>&" #" ? 3"#0D# 4&&9"C&<1%)55,$" 9@ )55E < C" )555- " ) C%" ',,)$ " F&" " ;""1 & "#9G9 B ;"- A& & ;" ///////// & ";""19 3" ""& 8& " " 3 &" "&C&3>&"$" 9@',,7-

&""$&" 5;%")55,$'+ 9@)55E )E& &@ )555$!-./////////"8;&9"3>&"H ?3"; %&" 9 3" % "&3" @"?I-

7- &" )) &J ',,7$ 3&;;" & & "& 0 4 " 3>&" "99" 9 & " ;""1 ;% !-.///////// C?3< ""& & 8" "& C& K-

+- )=& &@',,7$3>&"""&$B &"&&@ &$ ;" "& 3" 9@&9 "& F"J9 !-.///////// B; $%;; =)&J ',,7-

()*+(',,+ #=())#

A&"89 3 $!-./////////%" &" "& C&K-3>&"& " ?3" %" %"&3&@"8 "& "8%<3 "*&"3" @"?)5 9@ )5E,0 #7,+4-

" ""&9 " 89 9<">8& " "& 3#9" &" &" < !- .///////// 3& &89 ""%"//$/////////?3" " "?" " % <>=)& &@',,7-

3>&" %" &" 38" < 3& !- .///////// & %&"&" "&9@&9 "&F"J9 $ & &9 "%" -

6- !-./////////& ',& &@',,7-

" )556$ " &;;" "@1 - "%" " 9 8" < "%""& 3&"&&8" "@1 &&8" >L" B "%" " 1%- 9 3" " $ " 3 " &" < %"$ " < %&" "9" 3#>L98- A& & "%" <1%-

&%" 1" "# &"93": C 3"9&"@"" & ;"?$ ?" & " " & " &9 "&<9& #"%" 9',,,9">9" "K$ &&% 39"&9""":-%" 8"& $" &%" " "& -%" &@ C& 9&" " &" ;F" E 9@ ',,,- 9 " %&" %" 3>&"-

6C%"',,7$8#;& "1%" & ?3"%" " " C& K "" ?3 ";" ;F" 3"99 " "& &%"&"3%>"-"&$ & %" 9"M%&> A"$ " ;9"- 3 " && < 3 @" K % ;9"$ 9" 989 3 " "$ "& & 99 &@19 - 9@" 3 : %&" &99" "& 39"" "&"$?"" & @"9 K&@9 "?-

A;9"&%" %" G "&$"1 B &"$ " &89 $ 3 ?3 C&" " &8 9 8"19 " &" &1%$""&3: <C&93"-

&" < " "&3;; ";""?3<3 "& ""&?-

()*+(',,+ #7())#

*- % " "& " $ 3>&" & 3;; "; < 9 "&$%;; =)&J ',,7-

E- ))&%9@',,7$3 &;"9 <3>&"?!-.///////// " " " 3 " C& K$ : &N " %" 99 >&" "- 3" %" 1 & "%" < "&" "& " &?" & :-3 " B?3" &>89 "& 3" K$?3 " 3 @"-

5- '7&%9@',,7$"3& "&;9""D #A%&" &;"9<3>&"?!-./////////%" "&89 ;9"" ')+-,* &$""?!<> 7E-E* &-

),- ""&'9@',,7$" &"39"" "& 3>&"8C 9 "&-!-./////////%" %"&"@" "&" "& &" 3" '6 C" )55E 0 " # A )7'-=)4 ? -%" ><3>&"?3"%" &@ ',,,9">9" " K$ &% >? "$ ?3" : %" &9"" ?3" : &>" & 99 & "& & & " & & &89 - 31&&$"%" &">&" "-&" "&$"3: %" " 3B9" " 3 " )' & " "& ; &; "& " )E %" )555 0 -# A ),)4 " %"& "?3" " @" ? 3" %" K &N " %" "& &"-

))- &" '' C%" ',,7$ &" !- .///////// ";&9 3>&"?&9 &>" !K ?3"3%" 3 " C&:-9" &<&%&"@;"" 3"3>&"C?3<&" ;"" ";C8-

)'- 3 >8 && : " C%" ',,+$ 3>&" &;"9 &" !- .///////// ? "& 3" &" G % < !- .///////// # % 3;; ";#& ?"#"9"&" "& "-

)=- =)C%"',,+$3>&"&" &&?"< 3& !-./////////- =)9@',,7$&99 & F " 3" 3%" < DKE+O*=E$*,-

)7- <&"C""")6;%"',,+$!-./////////& 9 "% 2

# %" @;""$9G9?B;"$3";""1A" K$ "& %" " $ & ?3" 3 " 88< "";&93>&"A"-

()*+(',,+ #+())#

# & %&" 9 3" A" 19 9" >9" "K0 )555 ',,,4-

# & %&" K$ &" "& & //$ & /////////<A//////////0D #A%&"4 &>"&89 & & "&-

# &%&"";&93>&"3G BA"-

# ;"$"&3G 8" K%)567&99 " )5+EA"$B"? ?&&9"9"8$"%&" P Q8?&&-

3&?"$ !- .///////// " < "& >9#&&$"B'';%"',,+-

)+- ',C%"',,+$&9 7;%"',,+$!-.///////// " C & 1 "@ 9"" "; & ""& 9 "&'9@',,7-

& " %&" %"& & &@"8 "& "8$ 9" " "%&?" "& ?" " " & 99 3 ")' - !G9 % " 9 A" K$ "#9G9 ;9" %"%" &9""99%" -

& 9" "3;; ";& <3 "& ""&?-

)6- ""& 7 9 ',,+$ 3>&" 9&";" &" "& 3" ;""1!-./////////- " "&3;; ";$3" %" & " < &> "& & "#9G9 B ;"- %" 89 @;"""9 "9" 9"<"&" "& 3&89 -

&& "@9"" ";$!-./////////B&" ? ;" ///////// %" ?" 1% < &" ',,7 & %"% K %&"" ?3" &>" 9 &" ;F" ! 7E & "" ?3 " &89 ')+ &- ;&" $ !-./////////3%" ";&93>&"9 - "$" " 9" 9B "&%& /////////3 $ 9& "&&<!-.///////// " 9 %?3" &>" K")9',,+3 -

" ""&3;" 3&@C 39 "&-

)*- &)+9',,+$3>&"3 &&&-

()*+(',,+ #6())#

!- .///////// & " ?3" &>" ! " &89 K- & $ " %" & G & " 3 "& < A//////////$ " " 3 ";" ;F" 3"99 " "&&%"&"3%>" & 3 %" $ 9 " @;"" &"-A& "&&&$"%" F&"K-

3:%" "&? "&%&""3 ")' - " $ "&" "& 3 " < & 8 & &99 @ &" 0 (66(',,7 ', C%" ',,74- $ 8& ;9"""&" &" "&9""93B" &3 ")' $ !9 ///////// % DK )O,,,$+, 9&" & #9G9 ;"///////// !-./////////!$7E &$ "&89 ')+ &%"&$&" 3?"% ?? DK7,,-#-

)E- "& &9 "&&'69"',,+-

!- .///////// 9 "& & 9"" "% C?3<&" C8&-3>&"3: &&$ & ?3"&3;; "; >&$!-./////////& "" < %&" "&3" -!9///////// 3; ///////// 3 " &&&-

!- .///////// &;"9 ?3" >@" " //$ ///////// 3 9 9" < "&" "& 3>&" & &: " : "-

&" 9 //$& /////////<A/////////$?3"3%" C9" & ?" " %"- " " 3" &89 D # A%&"-%" 3 "&K?! 3" &89 - 3%" ";&9 &" ;F" ?3" %" ;" 93";""1<1%-

9 $ " 3 " @;" 9" >9" " K$ & ?3"&%" &>!$"@;""&"" &"- %>$ " &>" &C& 3& "& &89 - %" ;; "%9 %>""99 "K?3"%" > E,, &$" 3%" %C%"',,+<9"&+,, &-"&$"3%" %>"-

&%" %"$" " "" & " C&A"$& ?39&:388" -

)5- "@&&3& &? "& "%" <&

()*+(',,+ #*())#

"@9"" ";3 &$ C83" "&>8&"&;"9$))C" ',,+$? 3B "& &99""& &8 &" < : E %" ',,+ " " % &-

&"$ " C&" &" "&2

# !-//////////$ &"59"',,+$&;"9%&"% 3 9 & $ //$ >9" ///////// < A//////////$ ;%"',,)<;%"',,=-:" &: "" " "%;&" 3?" ; 3 "" >&- !- .///////// %" 9 9"%"" -;&"$"&>" 3 9 -

# !- !//////////$ &" )= 9" ',,+$ 89 &;"9%&"%3 9 //$/////////)7;%")5 %"',,+-:" &:">8-!-./////////%" &% "%"" ;">>&&"$9""3:%" C9"&9"-

# !- R//////////$ 89 &" )= 9" ',,+$ %" %>S!-./////////<1%9"<C" ',,'->>" %" K$& ?!-./////////"%" &&3 ""3 3 9 //$/////////$?3"%" ;" & ";""1-

',- &&"?");%"',,+$!-.///////// &>!K-

*'

)- C 9 " % C"" "& &9 $ & %@0 -+6 &"O&8" "&C"""''&%9@)57)# # ',+T -6=-)" -&"&9"" "%)' 9@)5E+# # +),4-

'- !- .///////// 9 "& & 9"" "% C?3<&" C8-

A& 3 " )7 " ) $ &? & & 9"" "% & "& 3 ? "& "%"$ & 9"" "% % &9 3 &" $ ;" 3&@C 3 & % " &" $ "& & 9"" "% $ > $ G && C?3< &" & ? "&-

31$!-./////////&;" & " ";3&?" &?" "-A "&;" % &"

()*+(',,+ #E())#

&& 3"<?3";" % &" 9"" "%- ""$??&" & &$"3:&";" 8 &"@"" &% 3 " )7 & 9"" "%-

=- 3&@C & 3G & "& 3" & !-.///////// B;" ///////// /////////$%;; =) &J ',,7 "" ? 3& ?" &89 ""%" " //$ /////////$9"<"&" "&3>&"=)& &@',,7-

7- - A&O ")' -$U?"&? " "& O 9 @%" < & " &" OG " " %&" 9&: ""@ & 9 B" &;&9 < "8" >9"U-

@- % O %"8 "&" "&$C" & " &"" &" < &" "& 9""9 OB" &99 &" & " "&&" ?"&@"8" & &99< " & &% @&"0%&" K)'))=6*&"-'@-=*)(=*' ;" 4-O ")' -&9" ""&" < &" "&9""9OB" & & &?"O 9 @%" < @&" ;& "& C ""@ < "& &" "% O 0 K )'' ' )5= &"- '( - )5ET ("&8"&! (!">D $&" & " "&"$ %&9'2&" ;&9 B$-6E+ 6E54- & " "&; 8 " & ;&"?""&" <&" "&9""9OB" T " " "" 8" #;$ & &99# O& 18 9 "1 " &" ?" & " 9""99 & O " )' -$ 9" ?" % $ > $ #<0 G "@;'-))+(',,))) 9@',,)4-

+- % 3 "E"+&"8%&"3" "& " )E9@)5E*0 "VK')+4$;"B "&$3& &" 9@&9 "&3" $9G9?&9 "&$& 8" -

6- - W1%$ %&" ?O" @"? "<%" "B&?"& ";;" &"&& &%9&: "& ";"@&"%" B &""@0 -) -' 4-

@- A& O " ) " = $ " @""" B "& &" ;$ & & &99 < &"-

()*+(',,+ #5())#

"" @""" C8 &;&9 < O " )' - ;- 0& 99 G "@ ; '-)56(',,' = 9@ ',,'$ &"- +-)4-

O" &" O "" & ? " 9&: O"9"" "&O""80K-XKK A$K&9 &" O" &"$)55+$-)7)4-

"@; ""9"$G & " O "&"$?&" ;&9 8 "O ")' -;-%"" &?"&%" $;F& $;; "%9 89 & 9&:"<&B" 0 G "@;'-)7*(',,' 7 9 ',,=$ &"- =-= " ;"T - X- D $ " 8 %& A&S">";" 8 " SY"8- .&99 $ "2 Z" >";; ;[ A&S">";$ 6(',,=$-E=#E7-4-

- 3 "*") %&" &@"8 "&"8&? & ?" &"" " & $ & " ; "&$;&"B&8"93" &"89 " " "& & ;""1$ "" ? &99"? & >89 <9&";" "&& @;"" -

OB" &%&" O" "& ? " &;1 O " * $ O" "9 &9 ""& " "&8" &" 9"" ";0 (=+(',,+'+C%"',,+ ;" 4-

*- B 9 O " 7 &" ; 9 "1 O" ) 9@)5E50 A#AE+)-)4$&@&"&&9""& &"0&9""O" 4 &&N"%O" "& O: @"- & & &9"" 0-)4- &9"" O?" "& O"% < &" >@" $ & 8$"%O &" "&"$<9&"?O"&" &%?C& &99 L & &&?O"O ? &%"&"0-'4-

B"8 " & &% < 3 " ' & ? 3" @"? 3 B & C& &-

E- "1 &" ? &? 3>&" " ""& ?$ !- .///////// " & @;" 3 9" >9" " ;F"- %" K && < "& ?3" 9" & < A//////////- &" %>" 9? !$ 8"19 "99 " K$ " &>" : & "& &"$ ? 3& "& &89 !- " 89

()*+(',,+ #),())#

@;"3 %" "9 @;""" &"-

@"3 ?!-./////////3&<3>&" " "& ?" " " K- 9 3 & $ %"& "&3 "* &" G 9"-

5- ?"1?3>&" " &" 9 ;"< & "&3" ?3"%" <!-.///////// <B;"-

3&?" &89 <1%9"<"&" "&3>&" G ?&;"9- ;; @"?!-.///////// ;9" & <$"?3"& &" <A/////////-

;"$ ""& ? 31 &9 "@ % " )' - '*>";;)&% "&',&%9@)5E5 "%B&" 3; $ ///////// &9" 3" ;""1 & < 91 %" 3>&" 3 $ " "& 3 ///////// 8""&79',,+$%;"" "%$3 -

),- "19 9;&$& G ?C -

))- " "8$"FO9&9 0 -E* T -), 189 ;"$9&9 "9" &9"" "% =,C" )5E6# +),-,=4- \\\\\

()*' *

,-.!$/0

%@ & " C ', C%" ',,+ !&" .///////// & ""&OD&"8'9@',,7T

-.!"0

C T

" ?O"O FO9&9 T

" ?$ &;&99 B " 5* "% &" ; O&8" "& C"""$ G G & $%&"&&" 9"" ";$ C& 1 & ";" "&$ % "@ ;T 99&" &&" ""?&"&$9& "; 9&:% & "8 & &&9 "T"&" G &"B9"9&"

()*+(',,+ #))())#

"@ ;$ ),,, )7T G "1 &"& & $"%&?&999&:%$&"% G C&" <O%&"T

&99"? G <!"# " $%& & ""?O< OD&"8-

A"8 2 !9&%:$" $!!-:>1$!9D"$!- >"$C8$ !-&$C8 -

&9 "@9"" ";2

8;;"1#C" C-2 %"#" 2 !- &&" -&%:

&"&;&9 G &99"?B "-

1%$ 8;;"12

()*+(',,+

Statutory Levy Validity and Procedural Safeguards Appeal

Synthèse Legislator

Regeste Legislator

Mots-clés

Dispositions légales citées

Décisions connexes

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Texte complet