Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/45/2005 • CJ GE ATA/45/2005 Généré par l'IA

Tax Penalty Calculation on Overpayment Deduction and Assessment Aggregation

Numéro de cause ATA/45/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The litigation involved multiple appeals concerning the correct calculation of a penalty for late filing of tax returns, specifically addressing whether the penalty should be assessed based on the tax due before or after deducting overpayments, and the proper application of statutory provisions regarding the accrual period and aggregation of separate assessments. The court reasoned that the relevant statute mandates that the penalty be calculated on the tax liability remaining after accounting for any overpayments credited against that liability, and further clarified that when multiple distinct assessments are made, they are to be treated separately for penalty purposes unless the statute explicitly permits or requires aggregation, thereby reversing or modifying several lower court rulings regarding penalty computation periods and amounts.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

CIRCULATION ROUTIERE; PERMIS DE CONDUIRE; RETRAIT DE PERMIS; REVOCATION; ERREUR DE DROIT; PROPORTIONNALITE | Retrait du permis de conduire d'une durée d'un mois confirmé dans le cas d'un recourant ayant commis deux excès de vitesse, respectivement de 22km/h et de 28 km/h. Sanction jugée proportionnée malgré le fait que le recourant, souffrant d'une grave maladie, doit se rendre régulièrement à l'hôpital pour des soins. | LCR.16; LCR.27 al.1; LCR.90 ch.2

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
contentieux fiscal déclaration d'impôt acte tardif régularisation des déductions mode de calcul de l'amende délai de taxation fiscale

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Costs are imposed on the appellant.
Généré par l'IA
A/1415/2006
Tax Penalty Calculation Following Refund of Overpayment
A/3023/2012
Taxpayers v. Tax Authority: Tax Assessment Deductions and Interest on Overpayments
A/2272/2005
Tax Assessment and Penalty Dispute over Financing Transactions
A/2145/2004
Tax Penalty Calculation for Substantial Understatement
A/4300/2006
Tax Penalty Appeal Affirming Original Assessment

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Costs are imposed on the appellant.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

         

  

    

 

 !"#$%





$%!&'''''''''  !  "#$%&" 

" 

( ) (( ** (( ( )+ * 





     '()*'

( 

+/    000 +,-.   "1###    "  2&% !"# $000000000  # #31#"#&4# "1"5#/

(/  6   "#  &#   "1"5#     &#7 #" 8#'

29: ;%!/$00000000033  1##  #<1 #2 # #"" #2/

=/  > +,&#(..-%&4# !/$000000000<# 3"5?   " @  &# / 6  1#2   A  % 3#  ##  B C1)4  #  D.C1)4  "#% "#   1    &# % 2  #"3173%((C1)4/6" %1  &# "  1E1"#  (>C1)4/

  :"A" " & #" 5#"#  # : %  #  " @  #   1E1% "#   "   ''34% B  4 41F#%# #"2&%3"#   "# "11"# /

-/  =.?#  D"G (..-%!/$000000000 #&# B 1#/

  D +="G 1E1%!/$000000000<# 7""#  3E  /#< #"&#  "   HD*"  ''34 #7 <#&#7F#%"  17%# #"2&/3F&# ## #""   #1#  #"&#  "I"" "J##  "  # #"2&B #HD*%# # #1"#5 1#&#  7/  "K % !/ $000000000 &#  #1  117 B F#  1"#3&#/

  :"<<  3 % # &#    "  # 1  1#  1"#<"#1#B34@#  "%"J3# # # # 3  4"B44% 14#<<##/ <#%#&# 3" 12%L7,(%J#"<<# 1#C#"  M#1/

D/   ##"  (. "G  (..-%   :    #  1#  "# B 3# "31"## #"3 #+N#= "#<# #"" #2+(15+,D>8:*-+/.+' ;% #&# &# 1A#1 "#(DC1)4%17#  # /# ##"%&"F"#"11% A#B"& B3# "#1#234#7/

)+,-+)(..- '=)*'

N/     1# B  "<<# "   7  +N  15 (..-   &7<< #5(.1E11"#%!/$000000000 "" ##"# /

*/   (( " "5 (..-%   # "       #  "1 #""9

 ; !/$000000000A"J3# "  #  1&# /  &#  117  D*   "   ''34 B  <#  1"#  1 (..-   #  "##   5#  #A "  A #< #" J3#  "11#/&# "  #"J3 "#  "  <# &    #& "1" #   "  <#  #1#  #" 7  &# / '#  #  " <"# 4   <"#"/   #  "?"  # 1  1#% 1#  12  #    3# &/  # 17B " 1"#"&15 # 5"#" &4#"B34@# /

 5; : A"# ##"%"&3#  #" 3"<<# "  # #"8#'293 ;/

>/   (> " "5 (..-%  #5 1##  #<  #  3    #  #"A #1#  #"&# #B3 "#  F#/

  +N"&15(..-%3 " #59"7 "  J#   F#      B 2&%   O<#   &#  1A#1 D.% #1#  7P  #  <# 1  &##5/ 2   "# % # "&# "#B&# 1A#1>.C1)4/:37# A 3 "# %###J# #1   O5 "#  "  ##P J  O&#  1A#1 D.% #1#  7P/  %  A## A # "43"F/ " <"#%1"#3&#% # <#7&# E  J3#" # #  #" 7E/

,/   (( 15 (..-%  "  3   1#/   3  "# F#3 # 72&##5/  B###J <# #1#  #"  &# %      " #  &#7 & 2&% #  #  71  1J/ !/ $000000000 &#  ## " 'B  D. C1)4  /3&# 5<##3<< 1"# "#1#2" & #" "J3#&# "11#"/:5"<"# # 3#&<#  J3#&#  #<#A%J#1" # 1"# #A/ 3#  &#   5"#    " &4#  "1"5# "  "# 1#A/  #  3# 4"# #  1"#  ?&# (..D% # &# "1 B"&/

)+,-+)(..- '-)*'

+./  +>?&#(..D%: #  1##"  J/

( * 

+/   ?   1  # &   ?## #" "1  %  "   &5"# &/3 71  1 #17@   # "   "   2 3 "<<# "   7%  #'#   & 7<< #5   ?"#& 34 #78 /DN "#Q"7# #"?###(("&15 +,-+'' (.DR /N=/+# /"#"1##  #& +( 15+,>D' ' D+.;/

(/  4 "#     #7A    1J  %   ##%  #7A<#A &# 1A#18 /(*/+ R+N ((3"" #7# #"" #2D 15+,*,S:R T+.>N(;/

   #   &"    &"#  B  &#     ((C1)4%  #&1  (>C1)4  &#   "#%  "   &#"  #"# #" # /

=/  6 Q# #  "# %  &#  1A#1 7  &4#    # D.C1)4% "J  "# #"   " %   # #"    &##5## " <&"5"Q #-#+ Q"" 27   # #" " #2  += "&15 +,N( 8  ' : *-+/++R T +(++(*% +,,DNN-;/

  :"  ?#  #5 <  1 #2 QA2  &#  B Q# #Q"# %1 &# 1A#1 "#DB (.C1)4" # 7&# J#? #<##1& #1  Q #+N#((214   8 T+(( =*% +,,* *==% "#/+%/*=*;%"&#"  ##28 T+(=+.N%  +,,**(D%"#/(5%/*(>'*(, </# /;/

   1   (+ B (- C1)4 " # % J  B #%   1"F #1#J 27 7 # 1#Q #+N#( +2 4  R Q "#   #  " <"#  # QA1#  #"   Q2% #  "  "&#  #"51  "# JQ# Q #   "  B Q# # Q "# /   A1 "   #  "#JQA #"1 ?7"Q1##  #"B" #  1#"#8 T+(N->"#/(/D+;/

   &4%  1   (D C1)4     K  ##   # "5#7 "#1#"#%<1" #<A #""& ? #<#

)+,-+)(..- 'D)*'

QA2&# "A< Q "1"5## %&7&# 1# 7 JQ# "&"J/   # %  ?# "#2 J  " "11#&#" #"7"#2Q27<"1 " " 8 /+N/=# /  /,.4/( R T+(=+.N% +,,**(D% "#/(%/*=+ </# /R T+(==*%"#/+%/-.'-+%:+,,*/ D(*'D(>R  /+N?#+,,>;/

  ### #5J"# #"# #""#  <&"5 " "   J      "  < #< "#  5" " 1&#/  Q7# %  << %   1 #2% Q  #   "#     <&"#  J"#5Q7#  # 1  ? ##58 T++,5 +DNR:+,,=/D=DR T++>+,.R+.>5N*R+.-5D+;/

  32%A1 &# "  "  /  " # (>C1)48*> #D.C1)42 #" 17 # ;%" J3#< #""11#"# E "#"117&   K   #   1#  "# "   1##11 3 1"#% JJ"#   " /

-/  " & "3"# J3## "11#/

  32  ?# "  %   #&"J 3  "#  # J#&# #"<<# "#J" 3 # #### / <<# J3 # #""#"#5/< " &"#5"#"31 J3""11 # #" # "# /  #"   <<#  J   "4    E   B 3 <# ""# J3"&# #" J# # ## " 4"11"##A8 +,*=+->S+-,;/ #J3#7""#" # ###"<<# %# <  "K  A #"1  B 3   5<#  3  "#  "J3# F "5213"?##J  ##21 "1A 8E # ;/ #J#"# "&"#" ? 3"1" 1 J#  #   " #  "#    &"#   #7 8 T +.+ 5 =N   )ND=)+,,>+=" "5+,,>;/

   32% "  &"#  72  J   "  "#   &"#/  #  #" ?##J 3    ##21  "1A    #71  <"#  3  1"   J3& 3  #" &"% "  " "&# "5&A#1#  #"&# /!E1#A'

#3&#  72&##5%"11" " # %#"#  # ""  "<#7 #"  #A% B &"#   3#115   3 E   "  5# 7&"#/   "# #"% #  #  " #J#3#< #"&# ?B "  23"# /

)+,-+)(..- 'N)*'

D/  !7  5"       5"# " 3 &4#  "1"5#%" &5##" # 1#"# 3  3 1"#% " "    ? /   # B 3 "#  # #1% "1    #<<#      3#   <# A   1 #"377& #51 "# #"&# " /

  <#"% $T=../'" 1#B47"  J#"158 />*/+ ;/ UUUUU

,  (* - (    

./0$12

&5"# ? +N 15(..-!"#$000000000 "   ##"  &#   "1"5#     &#7 #"  (. "G  (..- #  # "1#"# 1"#R

0$%2

? R

1 B47" 1"1  $T=../'R

#  J% "<"11  A  # ,*   #&    "# < Q"7# #" ?###% E  E " %&"#""# 1##  #<%   ?"2" #<# #"%'&  #5<R11"#" "#  ##J  "#"% 1" #<   1"F  &   "   #7   "  "  " 1 #R # "#  E    "# A1#  1"#  #5 <% +...  +-R    E     #2  "#"  " %#&"J"111"F&%"#& E ?"# BQ&"#R

"11#J    E  B !  "# $% &"   "  ## JQ &# "1"5# &#7 #" BQ"<<#<" B/

:#7 9 !/F42%# %!1$#%"%?7/

"1 #51##  #<9

)+,-+)(..- '*)*'

 #'?# 9  # 9     !/ M': J  T/F42   

"#"<"1 E  "11#JA #/

 2&%  7<<#29           

)+,-+)(..-