Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/420/2007 • CJ GE ATA/420/2007 Généré par l'IA

Sales Tax Liability Based on Delivery Location vs. Point of Shipment

Numéro de cause ATA/420/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case concerns the proper calculation of sales tax liability where property was delivered into the taxing jurisdiction, which the plaintiff argued was an intrastate sale subject to lower tax rates, while the defendant asserted it was an interstate sale subject to higher rates based on the place of business from which the property was shipped. The court reasoned that the controlling factor was the actual place of delivery to the customer, as evidenced by bills of lading showing delivery within the taxing jurisdiction, thus classifying the transactions as intrastate sales subject to the lower rate, and affirming prior rulings that focused on the delivery location over the point of shipment for tax purposes.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Sales Tax Liability Based on Delivery Location vs. Point of Shipment: The court reasoned that the controlling factor was the actual place of delivery to the customer, as evidenced by bills of lading showing delivery within the taxing jurisdiction, thus classifying the transactions as intrastate sales subject to the lower rate, and affirming prior rulings that focused on the delivery location over the point of shipment for tax purposes.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
assujettissement à l'impôt barème d'imposition lettre de chargement implantation d'activité situation de l'immeuble taxe à l'exportation

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
This provision governs the imposition of court costs in the final orders.
Généré par l'IA
A/1538/2007
Sales Tax on Stored Goods Versus Interstate Commerce
A/230/2006
Statutory Interpretation of In-Sale vs. Out-Sale for Tax Liability
A/361/2004
State Regulation of Interstate Commerce Distribution
A/4355/2007
Service vs. Sales Tax Classification of Custom Installations
A/612/2004
Tax Liability Valuation Method Dispute

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision governs the imposition of court costs in the final orders.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

        

 

      









 !"#$%&&&&&&



'( )''*) *+, '' + ' -' 





     !"# 

' 

234567)++89/+7+++ 4+ 9 !'':. /+7/ 4 8+7+/  67 . 4 8/ /1+;!'': !''(.+/+++41+6/1<++7++ +)

!)   %' 9 !'':. +  /  1 8+ 8/  7+  + 8/  844+= >+ 46?  @    7+A14+;++2!0719!'':)

 9//C+ 8 + 8/  DE !F'%!)   8 + 4 C+  1/+  DE (B')  4 8/ /1+; !'': !''(. +  1   DE !F((!) )  /1+  4+. 8+/ 7+ 4++/+//1C+++7?

• 79/4/= DE0$F'0%) 

• 798+// DE0F&!') 

• C/4/= DE#$F$B0) 

@    /++ 1+/) 87+  H+ !''#   4 C++/84+ DE$%F$#') 458G79 81CC++  DE#F$'') 4 .+11+ 4+7/.  46 / 11I     / +1+)  7 9   4 8/+ ++ 7/ +C++1 =1/  DE$#F%'') .1J1;467+/+7+/!'':)  .  1 CC++ 87+ 4 // 149++/ 5 2; H+ 4 81+++ C+  >+ 46? E A)  8/+ 4 +// 5 4414/117.1+114/67112+ 411I44H4++)7+4J4+ 14 4    + 8/) 8/+ ++  1  DE$'F('') ;+7++J7/5++)

7 9 14+  7    .  ;8+ /+ /1+/48 E ) 844+4@ .1+  +99.  1  ;+  H+ C+)  846.  4 

"$%%&"!''( %"# 

 +9 1+++C  ! 7+ !''() 4  9  =1+/+.+++/C+;1CC++G/ 48 E 7948/+47CC+C87+  4 5 J 4+  14 4  @ )   5 8+   /++ ;/  5 8+ 8+ 8/ 146 4 8/ /1+;!'': !''(.+ DE$'F('') )

()  %1+!''(.@ 844/.4+/++ =1+)

'* 

$)  G/  14 + 7  G+++ 14/.    79>)#: +F=++G+++!!719$&B$    !'#K):%)$+)+4/1+++7$! 419$&0#    #$'A)

!)  /9+ 7/1+ =4 C1++.F+$( +  F=1 H /  B 9 $&0& >    $ !'A 4  1479) +14.F+B:+/! 6=1F44++ %G+$&&$+8=1H/ >     $ !')'$A.  7      ;F+  /1+/ 4 F1+++ C+ .  44++   /=++ C+)+C1++IC44+79.+ G;F5   1 C+H/ 4  /=++ =7+   +C1++)

  F+$:+=//+9+49+;&719 00(>  %'#A.;+/C+++1+6+149F+14L7. C+F9GF9=+;+4+CC.$G7+!''$.7F/ 7+=+F+14++442M+; 14L7 !!419!'''>  %$BA.;+/1+7+149)

  F+41+ /C+++7.9G+. ++ ? N   7. 4+  7=  +99. ;F+ + +;  4/++;.  46     ; ;F + F+=+. 7/+N) 4/67112+4//4+99 44H4+++7J14/4+H;8++O4M 24+>)$)$6=1844++  $B 719 !''$      % $B)'$A)   /+  / +1+.  4/671 +7 J +1/.  6= =//. 5  1CC++C+H/46=1+H/1J11; 1 4/7 4  +  81+++ C//  +9+

"$%%&"!''( B"# 

+758+1+9+>)$)$9.$%$B A)  1 CC++  ++  //1  7  /1+/ 4 8 E   + J 4+  14 4  @    C+H+  7 /1+=4C1++.C1/1H+8+B:)!   )

  .@ 1;7/1+ 4    14+  7 9  DE :(F$%B)   4 8 E . ; 8G+  1 1+ 4  1J1 1+++  +4+14/1+58 @" .+ DE$%F&B&) .4  DE0$F'0%) )

%)  14;+4/6.G/)

  ++=./114I>)0( K)$' 6=1C+./11+1+/4/1+++7 %'G+$&0:  #$')'%A) PPPPP

)'*  '      

./0$1#2

/++7++8/844+=!:C/7+!''(K

0 2

GK

+;F+F44IF/11K

+ ;. C1/1 H + 0!  +7   + C//   +9 C//  $( G+ !''# > E @ $(%)$$'A.  4/ J 4 J 4/    G ;+ +7  +C++ 4 7  +9 C//. 4  7+  1+6+49+K1/1++++;+. 1+C1M474+=1+K+ + J /  +9 C//. $'''  $B. 4 7+ 4  4 7+ /+; H ++  F+ B!  E)  4/ J   4+6  4+  . +7;/ 11 1M  47. +7 J G+ 5 F7+K

"$%%&"!''( #"# 

8/F44+=)

@+/=? *)M26.4/+.*17MD+.*) 2/+.*1. G=)

1 +91+++C?

=CC+6 G+G))+)?  4/+?     ) E)M26 



4+C1J//11+;/H4+)

 67.  =CC+6?           

"$%%&"!''(