Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/41/2007 • CJ GE ATA/41/2007 Généré par l'IA

Insurance Valuation Dispute: Replacement Cost vs. Actual Cash Value

Numéro de cause ATA/41/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The dispute centered on an insurance claim following a casualty event where the insured sought coverage for replacement costs but the insurer offered only actual cash value, leading to litigation over the policy's valuation clause and interpretation of specific exclusions regarding certain property types. The court reasoned that the policy language unambiguously dictated a replacement cost valuation for the damaged structures, overriding the insurer's application of the actual cash value standard, and further determined that the exclusion cited by the insurer did not apply to the claimed items under the clear scope of the coverage provisions.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Insurance Valuation Dispute: Replacement Cost vs. Actual Cash Value: The court reasoned that the policy language unambiguously dictated a replacement cost valuation for the damaged structures, overriding the insurer's application of the actual cash value standard, and further determined that the exclusion cited by the insurer did not apply to the claimed items under the clear scope of the coverage provisions.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
assurance de la valeur à neuf valeur litigieuse chose assurée surassurance réserve d'assurance prime d'assurance-accidents

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the final order regarding the allocation of court costs for the appeal.
Généré par l'IA
C/22881/2003
Insurance Compensation Valuation Dispute Over Fixtures
A/274/2006
Insurance Coverage Dispute Over Physical Damage Interpretation
A/2490/2003
Insurance Coverage Dispute and Policy Interpretation
A/1477/2003
Insurance Policy Interpretation and Coverage Disputes
A/522/2002
Insurance Coverage Dispute and Interpretation of Policy Language

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the final order regarding the allocation of court costs for the appeal.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



        

        

 

      

     



 !  "



 !"#$$$$$$ #$$# % &' ( 



%&& % &    %& '&%  (  )     &%  '&%  





     )*+,)

 

1  %"2333333'$!333333-4.'$!!$5 !67"!   6 *//.'8! $#$"6 9 !1! :"$;  "<$ 1

*1    $ " *. 6  *//.' "="9>" $?(  @$"' !  66 "  "  6  9 !  =$ ! " ?6$ #  !9$$!!"*A6 *//.!9???$$ !$?"5$B) #C DE ?"  9  6  " !  6  9 !  !"    :" !  7" 66$ 6' ? "  :" ! 9@#  F  6"   1

A1   @#  $$ "!$ #" ?  " !"6 " !95  %123333331   !5":"  " !" ! , =" *//.' :"  #6 9$ <!:"!9$$$ <5$ !<$1!9"  " *A ="!! *//. :" !9 6<  " " <$  9  #  " %12333333 66     # &1  #!"' " F  "  !$ (!9 6<  "5$ '! "$# &?6$'! *#6<*//,':"%12333333$ 955$ 1

.1  %1 2333333  $$  6$' ! * ="!! *//.' F :"G =" 96#6' ("# "@ '#"? F! !?$$ ! "!"#$? "A<-HB7"#)74*1*E1 <" !#! !9   #!"  6$' ! . =" *//,' F " #  :"G 6 96#6  :"9F " @#"! ="   @ ' "=" #" ? F! 7"#1

H1  %1 2333333 ?  9@$"   # ! . = ( *//0' " (! F  "5$  $$$($#"!=":"1 (! "?I ; "!$'!9$$9$ # ("9"5$F! "9"#6' != (*//01

,1  0= (*//0'%12333333 $$J!$# ! #!!!5 '  D  (1 !  $$ 6 "@ "$ 5( ! =" 6;6'  ##!   !9   ! ! ?$$ ! "  ! 5"(6  !  $#"<!:"? K ! ?F! $ 6#" $5"! "*4<--4B7/1.*1A1.--E1

01   0 = ( *//0' F ,>H/' !9??  #!  $ !  6  $ 6 (  %1 2333333 #" " "$ 9" 61 9$$ ?  !9<=9"$?$$ !(7"'$?(@$"'  ! & (     $6  :"9!    "  F 

+*-.+*//0 )A+,)

?"!61$$6  ""= 6 9 ! (  "$$"#!"'!6 K $"69 "#" 6 5 (6 5!"(!"$5$#!!1

41   4 = ( *//0' !  66   !  "  #!  $ 5 B) #C !   E  " %1 23333331    6 " :"9!9$ # 5$ '6 !<$1!("! #  !! "5$ '6  # 5'8! ( "#6 ( !1!$  "9 9 !! "<$ 1

  ="6;6'!    ?6$! $!9??#!1 :"9"6"9@#"!=" ("@$" <!'!9$$?   !9<=9"$(7"'$?(@$"1!@  #6 #:"9!"  F?"!61 #!"' '   !  #$"'  $6  !9@ 9"   $="  # 51 ?' " ("   6  #$ !' %1 2333333 #$  " $"@:"#"! $"$!9#"<!1

-1  %12333333  ! <" ! 6 ?9"" (6  "  !9?? "#? ! *, = ( *//01 !  $ ; 5$   #$ ('!*-= (*//0'"$!$#9"  9$"   #(  " <$ 1 !  ("!  #  ; (&$   " # & 8 !     #1 ! ">      # 5' # & :" $  6#!" "!! ()F)($ 5:"! 7"' !:"!! #"(   ( !!1  6 (  !9  F #  $6 > #" <" $="1!95 5 F:"! 7" !:"  )>" >" !<$ 1

  !   #!"  # @$ " " :"' !   #!!  F !!5 ' %1 2333333 $  6" 9" <!!    !" #6 (& 5(=":"9 # 51

  %1 2333333  "" :"9! (  :"$ !  7" ! 0 = ( *//,'   :" !  $  ( " 6  6  *//. (  $$ @$"$   #"(  ; $#$$1  #!"'   6  $ #" !9<!5 F #  $  "!  < '   !  6" 8 ! (  $$  :" !  >!($:"1 ! (  !   >  # &   1  $ 6 ( #"(  !9<!5 F # ' 6  #  F !" 6# "  1

/1  A/= (*//0'!9??#!9##$  "":"9F!  6 "!9??"#?1! #"< $(!##$ ! 6?  !  $  !'  :" "@  !  $ " #  !   1

+*-.+*//0 ).+,)

 & 

1   ##! !9 !/! !9 ##! ! !?$$ !"! $="!9$ <!6$ 5",="-44B 7 )D*/E'!$!  ""$!   @="! ?  ! ="$ #$5 !69"$! @="#" "1  !9#'! $!5" "4= (*//.L!! $$  :"$#   $#$!*,= (! 6;6 $1 ="$  K" ! 6;6=" "  !$! 9?@$# !!$5! "  !1

  "  F !  :";  "  !9?? "#?' !!  $#"(" 9<='! ="$  " 6 "?1

*1 1 7! !M ! A< !$   !  7 '  " $  ( " M@#"!#6  $$?$'!M "$6#$#"' "@? M " !M@$"' 6  $ !  # $ !:"    ?   :"M!!   "  " ?"!6'  666#6=":"M ! 6F!":"M!!?"F <6#$ "@" "$B +4H0+*//H"H$6<*//HL +0,+*//H"H (!*//HE1

   !9#' ! "  ?  !9<= 9" $  ( # $  ?1    $!     '    66 F " ! "$  " "   $!!   !$  F 9$(   !9$ <!6 8 ! @$"    # :"  =" (  !    #$(" #"   6  !<$  !9@$"('!  6#!6$6$:"9!9 # !  7" :" #"    D  "  # 51  ! :"9!  # 9 ""   $="    # &'  ? K 9 5  ; $$ 66 " ?"  :" !  >!($:"1  ??' ! 5 56   "@  !  7" B  ( !  D  #$$    !  ?$$  "  ! & "6 9 # 5 ! ? F !  $ 6  #  "  $5"! " 0 (6< *//A ) 7 /1.*1A1A*-E !9<!5F$ 6"#" $5"!:" ! >!($:"F # &1

 <1 7!!M !A !7 ' ##! <!# (!M !A< !$   ! < 7 ' !  $ 6 (  $5 !6 #<! !:" !  #$6 $"6M "#"65 (6  5!"("!"$5$#!! :"'#"6?'!!? !M<= M" #"" #$ ! "  $$  6$1 !  !    !9#' #":" %12333333 $$ 6$F"#:"G696#6#" ? F! "#'#$# ! <" !#!!.="*//,1

+*-.+*//0 )H+,)

A1  "(":"#$'! $$F "!?"!6 %12333333"!6?$'6  $:" 1#!"'!!##)

$'! "$ & "6N"(#"#6!?"!6F<? $! 1

.1  % !?$'!" =$1

  %1 2333333 #!   " <$$?  !9   =":"' "" $6!"6 #K" ""6$ !!"$' "("!9""!5 B 140 E1

'% &         

*+, -.

$! ( <!!"=$!*,= (*//0# %"2333333 ! $! 66  !"#!$ 5"4= ( *//0L

, !.

!=L

:"M!M# #K"M$6!"6 !!"$96$L

 :"' ?6$6 "@ ! 4A !  >?? .  A  "(   !  ! ?$$ !"! <" !?$$ !"0="*//HB D)70A1/E'!#$ ;#" ;#$ !=":""( ? # )( ! <" !?$$ !' # ! ("""!"< L!6$6":" ! !"' 6?  6&  #"(  # !  5 " " "  "   6   L !  ; $ " <" ! ?$$ !' ///  "  .' #  ( # !"# ($!:" "@!M !.* D1#$ ; !##"" '(:"$666&#"('(; =F!M(L

66":"!#$ ;F% &' ( "" 'F! 66   !"#!$ 5'F!9??#!'F!9???$$ ! 65 F!9??  !! ##"! 1

7$5 C %1 &>'#$'%6(&%1 >$!'="51

+*-.+*//0 ),+,)

"6" <" ! 6 ?C

! 5??)="C  !#$C     1! ")75 D1 &>  

#?6 ; $$66":"$ "@# 1

 ('!  ! 5??C           

+*-.+*//0