Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/401/2005 • CJ GE ATA/401/2005 Généré par l'IA

Guarantor Discharge Due to Material Alteration of Underlying Obligation

Numéro de cause ATA/401/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case addressed a dispute concerning the validity of lien releases where the underlying contractual obligations, specifically related to a guaranty, were allegedly not fully satisfied or were subject to material alterations without the guarantor's consent. The court reasoned that a guarantor is generally discharged from liability when the primary contract is materially altered without their consent, which in this instance included the execution of subsequent modifications to the underlying security or debt structure. The court found that the actions taken discharged the guarantor's obligations, leading to a verdict supporting the defense against enforcement of the guaranty.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Guarantor Discharge Due to Material Alteration of Underlying Obligation: The court reasoned that a guarantor is generally discharged from liability when the primary contract is materially altered without their consent, which in this instance included the execution of subsequent modifications to the underlying security or debt structure. The court found that the actions taken discharged the guarantor's obligations, leading to a verdict supporting the defense against enforcement of the guaranty.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
garant dans le rapport obligationnel responsabilité contractuelle validité de la poursuite purge hypothécaire manquement du bailleur validité de la résiliation de bail

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Applied to allocate the procedural costs of the federal proceeding.
Art. 64 LTF
Applied to grant the request for legal aid.
Généré par l'IA
A/4407/2006
Guarantor Liability After Modification of Principal Debt
A/1000/2003
Guarantor Liability for Modified Underlying Obligations
C/3494/2023
Guarantor Liability vs. Lease Contract Amendments
A/1944/2003
Guarantor Liability Contingent on Condition Precedent Fulfillment
C/6942/2010
Lease Termination Upheld Despite Guarantor's Standing Issue

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied to allocate the procedural costs of the federal proceeding.

Art. 64 LTF

Applied to grant the request for legal aid.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

        

  

    



 ! "#$%





$%! &'()))))))))) 



* + ** ,, ** * +- , 





     !"# 

* 

'(  )*  +(,,,,,,,,,,- .  ,,,,,,,,,, '%#/-  0***. ,,,,,,,,,,-'!#1 *2(  **340* *4*!5 6*'%$'(

!(  7  * 4* 4  6*  08*    6*9* :* 4;<7 =>*38?-'.08!&&@-3*  40*  * 4  0*  * 3 2;  6*(   .4.  40*  '% ?6* !&&#  6* 2.  0 ?A3 '$ >.6**6(

5(   ' >.6* !&&#- B '1C@#- 3*..  .. D. B    E*A3***6*40*(

@(  6*.47 B4*86*-***A.-@>.6*!&&#- 6*.9A3*2.**B4*'%>.6* '%?6*!&&#(39**398-3*6 44>0B.**3*.(**.3*9 7 -*6*4.**>>**(.*>>CD09-6* >*FBC9CC*440(

#(   G.  ! 0 !&&#-  7   *.  40*   *  )(+(,,,,,,,,,, 4 *2 0*-  44**  * '1- '1-'/- !!- !5- !@- !1- !/- !%  *6   * >..   ** *;  '! .08 '%#$ :7 /@'(&'   = ;  '% >.6* !&&#- * B 3.C.  4..*(

1(  )(+(,,,,,,,,,,** *80***>3!%0 !&&#B.*.04*B( 4*  90* .*  **   8* 4  .9*98*440*>*A3*39**30.4*   4   3 *C*( -  *04 >*   04     .832.*30-003.*34;-.* 0G0 0* 96 A   **0  .**  3*.(

/(  4*..04*4!0*!&&#(

 ( )( +(,,,,,,,,,,  >*0.  (  3.* .0 04.  -  * 6* **   9 A  * 00* B * B 4*'%>.6*'%?6*(6*3*4**4**>* 6084*6.C*4A40*3.*4.*- >*6*>00.6.6.C*4;399(

"$$%"!&&# 5"# 

  744>*-*.*BCC3*6*.304E. 8(6*2.4>*4*8H*02I4*2 46*J6*-*B*0(

  24.A3*.**6.6*9>*- H9.F-A3*6**CF.4.**-94.*-( >*-***. >*A3* 6**6*843.9*4 .49  - A* .* *04  4   .9  48;0 >0**2(4*6*40*4*20*439 .*4.6;(

 8(  7   4*.   .**-  A3* 39** 3 **-*>*A*.**.4**20* 0**00( 3*. 6*  04  * 24. 4  6*.A.B3.0**00.9(

* , 

'(  ?.  04 * 6  ?*** 04.-    68:(#1 *K9**?***!!608'%@'    !&#L(15('*(*4.0***6'! 408'%$#    #'&=(

!(  ****>*96B :('1( '(> =(

  4;*>*96-40***.4*20* 0**00*-*A.4..-40*..*. >**3*>*0E096:('1(!8 =(

   34;-     4 6* *  6.C*  A3* .*  *( >*- * **   >* A3* 3 4 00*  *>*0*;**-0*A3*304.B4* A*6*>>*>-A7 *J04 .0B*(

    .9-  *8 0***>  A  7   3 4 ..  0**00 .9    *  *(  .A-  .** 6 G >*0.  A3* * 4*8  * 04  .9*-39*0C2*A* *>*46A3*.*.?B*(

5(  6A*4.;-?.(

"$$%"!&&# @"# 

   * 04   ** >**; 4.*  -  .00.*- IM'#&( -0*BC9:($/ =(

.  *,  *    

/01$& 2

. 68   *?.  5& 0 !&&# 4 )*  +(,,,,,,,,,,   .**  6*  08*    6*9*  ! 0 !&&# * *40**4*20*L

1$%2

?L

0BC9.00 IM'#&( L

* A- >0.0 2 * %/  *6   * >.. K9** ?***-4.G4G4.-46**0***>-   ? ;  *>**- 4 6  *8 >..L  0.0*  ***A*-0*>0E464*9 0*L**G.*204*0* *8 >..- '&&&  '@L  4. G   4*;  4*  -*6A.000E46-*6G?*BK6*L

00*A  4. G B )*  +(,,,,,,,,,, ** AK 6*  08*6*9*BK>>*>..B(

7*.9< )06E-4.*-))(EC;- C.*-?9(

0 *80***><

9>>*; ?*?(<  6* 4.*<     )( * (6E   

"$$%"!&&# #"# 

4*>0G..00*A.24*(

 ;6-  9>>*;<           

"$$%"!&&#