Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/372/2007 • CJ GE ATA/372/2007 Généré par l'IA

Non-Signatory Liability Through Contractual Conduct

Numéro de cause ATA/372/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The court considered whether a party could be held liable for damages arising from a prior agreement where that party was not an original signatory, focusing on the transfer of obligations and whether the non-signatory adopted the prior agreement's terms through conduct. The court reasoned that while the non-signatory did not expressly assume the obligations, their conduct, specifically their continuing performance under the contract's essential terms and accepting benefits derived from it, demonstrated a clear intent to be bound by the original agreement, thus validating the claim against them.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Non-Signatory Liability Through Contractual Conduct: The court reasoned that while the non-signatory did not expressly assume the obligations, their conduct, specifically their continuing performance under the contract's essential terms and accepting benefits derived from it, demonstrated a clear intent to be bound by the original agreement, thus validating the claim against them.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
responsabilité non contractuelle obligation de conclure antécédents prohibition de concurrence compétence en matière de contrats conclus par les consommateurs dommages-intérêts contractuels

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive regarding the order on costs.
Généré par l'IA
C/26126/2001
Breach of Contract and Damages for Non-Performance
C/22050/2003
Contract Liability and Conduct Over Procedural Formalities in Amendments
A/33/2007
Personal Jurisdiction Over Non-Signatory to Contract
A/1687/2002
Contractual Liability and Breach of Agreement
A/4441/2006
Indemnity for Pre-existing Liabilities under Contractual Covenant

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive regarding the order on costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

       

  

      









 ! " !#  $      !"#$%&! &'(% 

% 

!  !  !   !  %   !  !



&#    !  !    '!!   $ !  ! 





     ")*++"

 

+/   (%&' %01& 2   (&'  &31 4 3( 5&"36(%&%% 7' %& &8+-99' :& -+   %00  3( " &&'  ; 23(  &00<% &:5= 1>742)<&'(0'+).?3(/

)/   %&  ? @&  )..?' 2%& &% 1(%&  :  % &5&"36 A 72  0 %  &%   B%%1&2&:%0 &%5&"36 0 7/

  A %& &' !0 B& &    B& &   (&  001 00     0   ?C &3  930  1  2&00< & / A 2(&  :&D &%  %E %   %&% 2 %(<& F0&)..?'&&& ;0%  &"4(&    G# ++2F99/" 4 G# ,92.F./"  ' B1 % %0&/  %& &&&;& ;2 0 (&   &30 :& /

  2 A 0&  0 & %& &%(&  &(  B '%00& &%%E0D&00 %&/

,/  ;H %&%  &% 0 2  +9@& )..?/

  %  ; (D&( (&  &6

− %( %0   &; 2 0 ' 00  2&1 &;I

− %(D (H 0   %&    %  0&;   &&I

− %(010 &&I

− %(D(H 0 % %&0&; <& J I

− %(D&& & %0 <&  J I

− %$1 &01 &%; '&0D'& I

−  0&& D & (&    0 ( ( &%  %0000  % 2&00<I

*+,,-*)..- ",*++"

   %  2;H      <&  ) %(0< )..=' %01  &B% %1B&/

9/   %&  +F @&  )..?'   0   &  0 &  (%&  & :&     %<( &% %01  %   &3 &@  (D &2 0 %&&; 210  &%%E/

=/  (%&2  0&&%%1 0  +=%K )..?/

   0%   1%<  (D 2  & D    &D &3  2 0  % 2(&  4 G# F)2L+)'?=/  (D  &   & 4D9.M0%  ';&2D&;&    &2 0 '%0 %0<<%&& &(/

  %  % &5:&)..=72 0  &  <%  2  &'&"&E %<<0 D &"0H0 (D :&B&0 /

   (D D  2% &   0&% &%  %:% ' 0& %& & 40 1%K @%&  &%@4&/:&D &% %(%E(&  %D&(0 :% &%2  &%D %E   ; &'  (D 2  & 2E   ;  4 D  &&"4/

?/  &&%9 0<)..?' 0 & &04(%& 2%  %'   &    @%'  ;H    %& &%  % &  &( D (D ::   2 0  0 &%/    ;0&  (D %0<& %%%&   0%& &%' :%0 &%   %( &%  0&% 2B<&  &%  )=@(&+LL?5 "=).7/

-/  (%&&&%00&&%%0 &3%  &% 5&"36  %00&&%7 2 % %   &&% &      +)% %< )..?' &  ;  &&% ; & (&    % &:&  +) 0<)..?/

  A:%'&  D& &%'4(%&; (D &2 & %0&4 /

F/  A   ).:(&)..-'%00&&%@ %/

    &   2    &D  <& 4 2   % &  ; 2 0  (&    % 0  :NB&/  21&&   (D 2  & &:: 0% %; & &0%  0%  

*+,,-*)..- "9*++"

%E/ &&' %  @&  &< 0&&  &:' &  (D  & %0&4 /: & :& % 00 42 *-=+*)..9 )F 0<)..9/

L/   (%&  &&  &< 0&&  &: 2 % %   &&%&  )(&)..-/

  & D& &%% %K  (D  % 00 2&0%  (D& /

  2(& :& ;;&(& 2H  & ;&0  :% ; (D&2 &  4%& %:%  %10 /

   %E E     % &  &  D H00  <' %&  G#LF-/" %   0   - &3  +,= 0)   ; &  B0/

  '& & 2 %E; &;%E0%E %   0   - &3 &    &00< % &  (  +L=+' %002 & 23'2(& 4 G#)2=F+/"'4 G#)2-../"% %&&30 ; &   4 G# =2.../" %  L30 & 5 &(  %E 4 3( "   & &;  %E  0& )..= " <%B    %0  8,F' % %< )..=7/  '  %E E    %  4 G# )2F=./" 5&7  0%&' &  %(&    &0&   %E   ; &/ & 0% &  ;2&21&& "40% &( &%'42D&% (D &' 0@% &%%E &;/

  A%  @&  &< 0&&  &:'  & &% &%<   & &%&(%&%0<D%@   @0& H  &    %&(  B%03  (&&&0      &% &%% &:1(%&5 *++.*+LLLL:(&+LLL7/

   %  <0  4  ; %&  %%  %      :%42 &%&&%;/

+./    %  +9 0& )..-'   0   %  @   %/

  &<& ;0' (D&   & %0&4 /

++/  +,@&)..-' &<0&&  &:%4 % /

*+,,-*)..- "=*++"

/ 2&00< % & +L)? ;&(%&+L9)/

     +LF."L.  :$ D &  2&00<    %( :H &&; %B1/

/ && 2 0  6

 /   B 2 '  &<  %     2 0%& %   < &;/  (%&D&; ;  &  &;  2 0  (&    10 '  %&  &;1&'& &  B1/

 </ %&& &2%::& & (H 0&;<&1 &/  && (&     &30  &   <  & 50' :%'<%&&7/

  2010  %(0  % %& &    <%"(& %0   &(0  ;  0%& 0' % "%   "  &"&/  &  &%  &   :  % '  0%&11%0  (& &;/

   &&&3 :&1&& & D% &/

 /  &010 2%&1&(&  %('50%&'1"

01'&   ED /

  :H  & %<(& 1 (&  %% (D &/

  2%::&' &<%  2%0 41>/ E &"1> " &  /

  <&'% 0 & /   (%&%&1;15(  (D7'%<<0  2%&1&' & :& @&/

   E &  &   /  &  2%&1& (&    0 & 0' E3B"&1 <&1%&'(<%  &  0%&"0&%& B1/  0&3 1' %   &  &% & & & <&;/

 /   J/" '  ( '  1  %    0  &  :/ & & 4+'=03 B /

*+,,-*)..- "?*++"

 /  ;   &  %   (& &:&  %  2 0 /  %&%'0B0<4%B'% 401  & (H &2(%&'& </

 :/ % 401':%(& 0%/ 1&  :&  &;  &  (&&<  %& ' 0& 4 2 '  &&& 0/

   B0&  %  &  %0 I  (&    %0 %  (D)..?/

 1/ A<%'  %& & %(/

 B/ 2 0 %0 & 1B '; B0<4%B' % L0)(&%'% 401%00&  %  %& '&&' & %::&'<&   J/" //<%%& 2(0/

   D B0< O  %  &  &      % / :%2%(& <&/

  2 0  & %%00-&3/

/   0 %  %0<&3' &0 ;  &  B0< 4 O    &&  %(&  H  %& %00  &3/  4(%&'&&;;B%(& H %0  %00&3/

 ! 

+/   @   0  & (   @&& &% %0  '  %   (<5 /=? %&2%1& &%@&&&))%(0<+L9+"  "  ) .=I  / ?, / + & /    %&   % 0&&  &(  +) 0<+LF=" " =+.7/

)/   %&   0%& &%' :%0 &%   %( &%  0&% 2B<&  &%  )= @(& +LL? 5  "  = ).7 (%&    & &% 4  :%0 &%    B10  2::  &%  0&% 2B<&  &% 5 / + /) / 7/

   %& &%  &&&% %  :%0 &%% %( &%   4 0%&:&  & &< &% & &  %  %  & 2 0&%2B<&  &%5 /L/+ ,/+ / ' /+/+ /<%& %  &% &  &%&(+9(&+LFF" "=.=7

*+,,-*)..- "-*++"

,/  A% 2 & , & +      )  ' %  ;&:&  :%0 &% (D;&% %%<@ %( &%'2 "4"&0&   '0H0 &' % % &20&%2B<&  &%'0&%  %:% D&  0%&:&& &< &%%10 '%(;2& 21& (D2  &/ &'%@ &4 '%   (D% :&  &:&2D%&  &%%&&20&% 2B<&  &%/ (D&%<2  &1&% %& %00 (D  :%0 &%' %    ;2& 21    0&% &%%:% D&  5 *=))*)..9F@&)..97/

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

9/ /  & & &%    (D 2  &    :%0 &% 5% %( &%7%& :& % 2<%%21  (D/

 </  '     (D 2   &&( %  0& 2@ &0  4   / % 0  ;  (D %  4  :&& &%2  &'&: %;%K  % %& &%</%& (&&&0 40& &B<&  %% '% 00 %21 %%0&;'D<%&% % &%'&: %(& ;  (D%%0&4 %& 4%14%&%&  B<&  /  %& BB 4 %0   % O  2    &  1%&  (D ( 1  :% &%  &; ;2& :%      3 <%<  %10  ;2 :% &%  E  (D D"0H0 5/A G     #/  P G '  @&    &< 0&&  &:   %  3(  0 &3 2  &  &00<'  #+LLF  / ,?=",??    H  & 7/ &&' 20  (D   <% &40%&:&;&  &(0 2&00</0H0'210  &%%E

*+,,-*)..- "F*++"

% &( 4  (D   (%& % ::  2 N  B10  2::  &% ;&  &:  %10  ;&  %%   D <%& %    % &% %Q (&    :%  & 5 H   &< : +/-+?*+LL.  +. % %< +LL+ %&/ )' <& & A +LL) / =-? I *,?=*)..+)L0&)..+I *)?+*)..+)9(&)..+ : & 7/

 /  &<0&&  &:% 00 @1; (D'&0&< %& 4  2  &' (&  2 %( &%' 3 % ;2& 2(&  4  0%& &&D2&00<'00  &0& 4 %( &%   B%  <%    5 *)+)*+LL-  F (& +LL-7/  (D 2  & &::   0 %   %K     %; &0%  %E';% D<%&%  % &%'%  @1%00( H %0&4 %& &%I%K   &   &(0   G# ,F2)+9/" %   0   ,'= &3

5 *)-F*)..?  +? 0& )..?7I  G#-L2,=L/" %   0   ?&3 0&5 *-=+*)..9)F 0<)..97I G#992.../"% 9&3 5 *?=L*)..9  )9 %K  )..97I G# 9L2F-9/" %  9 &3

5 *?+F*)..9=%K )..97I G#??2,9=/"%9&35 *F.)*)..+ 90<)..+7I G#9.2+L?/"%9&3' G#),R9))/"% ,&3  G#).2,??/"%9&35 *,?=*)..+)L0&)..+7I G#+.2?=./"%,&3' G#,+2F,.%)&3' G#,+2=,./"%  ) &3' G#L2.=./" %  , &3 5 *)?+*)..+  )9 (& )..+7/   3   5 *F-)*)..9  L %(0< )..97'  &<    %& ;  (D %  0%   %   G#,F2FFF'-. %0&   %10   %& &3   0&' %   %E (&    0@%  +,, M 3  (D' (&  H  %& %00 %0& 4   /  D  3 & '  %K   (D 2 &    &<2 N4&%0&&% (D4 / 2  %0<&&%%K  %&0 %E;& @1 0&  %%0&&%5 *,?=*)..+)L0&)..+I *)?+*)..+)9(& )..+7/

  (B' 2  (D(  4 2  &' % 20&0& & 4&D%" (2 2&00<5 A /+0<+LL)&A+LL,/=-?7/ (D 2  &;&2%   :: (1& '(%& % '%   &0  %0&  0H0 1&0 1 ;  :%0 &%'  & 3 &&:     %K     %;    3 <%<  %10 / && (D&  &%;&2(&     1&30   %    &3 ' 2 &D     ,M(&00<'2%  %0&1&02 %& &%  0 2 &    &< 21  B10   &(  %E  ;   & &%  2&00<  &  0%&:& 5 *,9*+LLF 

*+,,-*)..- "L*++"

)-@(&+LLF7/0H0' (D2  &0% ' G#+.2.../"4 G#+)2.../" %   0   %& &3   0& 2E    D"0H0@ &:&10  &%%E  % %  %0&4 5 *+?)*)..,)=0)..,7/ (D2  & 2%K &%<5 G#)=2-+F/"%9&372% 4H %0&4  5 *=))*)..9F@&)..97/

   00 '  &< 0&&  &:  ;&:&  (D 2  & % &::   0  (D ::  %  0%    G#9)2,=F/"    0   9 &3 1&30       %& &5 *),*)..?)0&)..?7/0H0' &<0&&  &: @1; (D: &% 00 &  &%D&   ::  %  0%    G# +.2,+?'-.    &% % @;2% G#?-)'=.0%& % %E(& 4 G#L../"0%&(&  H  %& %00  (D 2  & % %0& 4  %& &%

5 *L?*)..-?0)..-7/

=/ /  % &%  <%& %    % &%    0&  :% &%  & 3  %E/  %E %    :&D   G# )29../"   G#,2)==/"  &3  /   :%B    H  D &%0  &&%  &&3@ &:& 5 /?/, 7/

 </  %10  %%  &&  % 1 %  % %E D <%& %    % &% %;2&  %(   :%B   %E 0 &% % %;  %10       1%&   0 ;31&2 &)= /E & 2 0  %;  D  %10  ( ' %&   1%&'   &:& 4 ) M   &00%<&&   0H0  1%& 5 / )= /)  7/ A% 2H   %& 2   %  &%  & '  %10 %Q(& &% D   &35H  %& 2  +F@(&)..?"=)./.,'&<3+@(&)..?7/

?/   23'  %  0    (%& % 4  (D  : &% 4 2& &  2 0  & +LF.  %   ' %&  & 2 (&1<& % &/

   (D:: '%& %&2(%& % %10 ' & %03 2 0 '%$1 (& &:& &%; '  0&%:%0& &  &% &; & &' 00   1    :S   &&'    <&    J/" / % &   0&: 0   (D 2  & &::  ' %00 ' & %&(  H  %& %00  (D  :%0 &%  & &%  2 &,&)  / <&0H0 &<%   ; (D &2% &%0 &'&%  % :%&::& % ;  %K     &0    %E  N   B10  E  %

*+,,-*)..- "+.*++"

%;  0%&:& &%  2::  &% ;&  &(  2 0  %/:& ;2&%& & 4 B0 ;%E&"0H02&&  &0& D0  &;; &2  &   2D0  %& % 21    /  0H0' 4      %'   0& &%  %0<  &3 ; %0   %10  2   0& '% ; &<& ; &%%( /

-/  %E(  (D & 2% G#+2?L)/"&3I&    0  G# 92F?F'=./  %10  % D <%& %    % &%    E%%1&/ (  (D'  %E  &  10  &:&  0%   (    ' % ;23  (D' &   0 &;& :&& %00%E&<40@%&  % &%/E%&%0 %10 & &1&D4 /

F/  %&&@ /

  2&& &1'0%0  G#+2.../"0&4B1 % ;&%0<5 /F- 7/

 TTTTT

#  !        

()*+,-.

 (<  % & @   ) (& )..-   (%&' %01& 2(&% &&%).:(&)..-%00&&% % %0 &3%  &%I

)*+/.

@ I

0 4B1% 0%0  G#+2.../"I

&  ;' %:%00  D  & F)   &(    %& :   &< :  +- @& )..= 5 #"A +-,/++.7'    H    H  %      @% ;& &(   % &:& &% "(   &< :'   (%&  %0 &3%& <&I00%&%%& &&;%&%' 0% &: 0%E( % &1 % %%0 &I& %&  H    &< :' +...  +9'  (%& %  %  (%&  %&; D %& &%  2 & 9)  #/    H     &3 

*+,,-*)..- "++*++"

%&%  % ' &(%; %00 0%E  (' %&(  H  @%&  4 2(%&I

%00&;    H  4 ! "#$%& ! &' (%    % ' 4  %00&&%  %  %  0 &3  %  &% && ;2  0  %  &%  B%%1&2&:%0 &%/

A&1 6 !0%(E'& '!/EB3'!0G&'!/ B&'!0%' @1/

%0 &<0&&  &:6

1::&3"@& @//&/6  (&"& 6     / /%(E  

%&%:%0 H  %00&;D &/

 3('  1::&36           

*+,,-*)..-