Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/342/2005 • CJ GE ATA/342/2005 Généré par l'IA

Contract Breach, Warranty, and Waiver Disputes

Numéro de cause ATA/342/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Frais judiciaires à la charge de l'autorité
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The dispute involved multiple counts regarding alleged breaches of contract or warranty, with the court considering several distinct sections of the governing agreement, particularly those concerning representations, waivers, and remedies across various exhibits. The court reasoned that the language in the relevant clauses, when interpreted in context, either clearly supported the claimed breach or failed to establish a basis for liability, leading to specific findings on each count, sometimes citing precedents on contractual interpretation, the scope of express warranties, and the validity of waivers or limitations on damages.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contract Breach, Warranty, and Waiver Disputes: The court reasoned that the language in the relevant clauses, when interpreted in context, either clearly supported the claimed breach or failed to establish a basis for liability, leading to specific findings on each count, sometimes citing precedents on contractual interpretation, the scope of express warranties, and the validity of waivers or limitations on damages.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
interprétation du contrat fondement de la responsabilité créance contestée garantie en raison des défauts de la chose compétence en matière de contrats conclus par les consommateurs manquement au devoir

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the final order regarding court costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/2347/2004
Contractual Disputes and Breach Analysis
A/3859/2007
Commercial Contract Dispute and Breach of Warranty Claims
A/574/2006
Breach of Contract and Contractual Interpretation Dispute
A/3014/2005
Contract Interpretation and Waiver Dispute
A/2331/2007
Contract Breach and Warranty Dispute Affirmation

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the final order regarding court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

        

  

    



 !"#$





#$ % &&&&&&&&&& 



' ( '' )) '' ' (* ) 





     !"# 

' 

()  *) ++++++++++, -  ++++++++++(#./,  0111-  +++++++++++(!(%2)113401141(51 (##%)

!)  51061517181 49:; <451=136>00111515:

  / -06 (##!,  401 3-95  1  -- 1- 4 201440?15-@1A

 $506(##$,5101---4017 -1-=1A

 !$B(##.,01201--41C 41558-01:&,D.7)"<A

 ((0(##D,4011--1-401,429 51!'E0"@5@1-A

 !/506(###,13551040401 1-1-=17130FA

 !(406!&&(,4011--1-4101,4 -405102101-'#E0"@,00171 30FC31-131-A

  ($ >51 !&&%,  ;   4-  1  401  *) ++++++++++ 4 12 01, 1 C  0G5 14441-  H151@-3535-@1) 1, 04031--51--12:151==00-C 041C30165--,411511H1-12 1 7 40415131) ;  H313-111-6-C417)

%)  #506!&&/,C&!@!&,31--1151 *1 7  11    3 41, H31  =1 36> 3 I  41)   1, 1 3 5-- H31 -1  - 315, 3F7F-5--230F(,.'7)"); 4011--11  @04)

/)  51-4; C41651,*) ++++++++++24-, !!506!&&/,H31514-1-61-=

"$%"!&&' %"# 

70,J13-1C41,14-145-@1)516 3H1-,135143111  1 C) , 5, (@%&,  01, 09  2 > = 0111- C 5F,35144-46) ==13=13@0 51 61 3 1 7) 1 H31 B H31 51 4 6, 1 51 04-5-@14401)11-=1 H-1-,H90,13514017 -1-=1)

  ;44=1,151551@==49  7 4-1  @I07,    H 1 51 -41-   1) ; 401, 1  451 4 51  1 1  =1 44 251124651C61)

  =1, *) ++++++++++  11H- 51 1   751-  31=1 H31 51 001)  3 4  4 @@- C 2  0-11---)

')   K-  ! -06 !&&/,  ;   1-  401  1  *) ++++++++++ C 1 -=111=, 01100 2 , 6 ,   =1($1-%6,(.,!!,!%,!/,%(1-!,'/'' 1=--1119(!-06(#'D8;./()&(  <) ,31-6-5-0C4-13 241  311 1511  0-1 -7 81 49: *< C34131--C15-@1C0)

$)  *) ++++++++++ 160111=4(&>51 !&&')   4-60 C  11  3== 41=   , 41140, C 31   -11 H-   4- 3 01401-=111=13-13-450-517 HCL01)311115-@1-44/' E0"@  4 H  401  1 3-1 4 -1 51 -70K5-)

   4, 1 3 4 -  =1 H1 1 -1 4@- 1  0 -1 41 4  ; )   41 3701 H31 51 -544- 5  1-  11   =1 H  401, 1  41420-1@==1311115H1 51377),1-16--=1040 ,50@-51,1111==113K4-5 041) =1,1-14KC0C3241-C15 1119)

.)   -11  !. >51 !&&',  4-1  16 0111=  >-  HK  0 4511, 1- H 1  1 -1

"$%"!&&' /"# 

-,  -H151 C 3011   5 H 3==1  1 >7-  =)  ==,   51  =-  1 4511007-1-1--4; )0K0 -11, 111  -- =1    1  5-@1 4 H4013-14-151-1101-C/'E0"@, 4-==1-C155)

D) )  160111=5H-411041 4.0!&&')344--,144 1134=12)

  5H-417,1=104K(D51 !&&')  3 4 -  =1 1  062 -- H1 1 -1 4@-, 01  24- H  1  =1, 1 3-1 5-   -  -1-,>0113141534401) K- 4  70 > 5 315   4E17  5 5 31006 1,15141H-,151H3-17) 70 51 =-   1  @L , 01 1 51 4 1 --4@51---44H31410-10 @H35141)11-=1H311651 26101,H1512=C@7,0915- 2G) 4,16517--04H3111 @01311F-1C-11; !$B(##. =14-,135143--1-C155)

 6)  ;   41-   -11 41, 04   062 --)3-7044-CH144 3064011135-@1C0)

#)  >7--7-11-344C4-11-4  1- 4-, 1 2 =1  !& 506 !&&!, J  ;  51 00   -6 C  41  7,  H1 351 0- C 4  1  401  1   4 12 01, 4 K-($>51!&&%)

   -  3  01  % 0 !&&%, H  7----46-6C417, 51197115131H313 0-C4112>3041051C0  MN'&&) )*) ++++++++++3444-C01,H1 5-=11152-1 04)

(&)  ;H1,--7-C>7)



"$%"!&&' '"# 

' ) 

() ) >-  04 1 5  >111 04-,    568)'$ 1O711>111!!506(#/(    !&'A)$%)(1)1 4-01115(! 406(#D'    '(&<)

 6)  ( >51 !&&',  5 1411      -  5178!&&!4)!.$.<) =1,141111 5,193441HH321=11119 00149-517,0-531 1 0 -71 4  1, = 241  -1-  349) 3         %( -06 !&&/ H1 3441H  8 "(."!&&'((>51!&&'<)

!) ) 111716O1(.1-!  ,H4011--=11150C)

 6) >14461-C-74-1H1-=111=401 146O2=1H1544- 0--1158 K 16=--(.51(##$1  (##($.D<);-11#>51(##&4 1O O6P, 11716H1,1504 1501,000051=1,07- 0 4-  01115 8Q R %& $/ 1) %<)   49 4 1,   (! 406 (#D/,  16  - 51 =10-  0  1 -=111=  401  1 C O-7 O  H1 51 001 1H 15  5  O4  517 H   H1 51 K 1-- 11 00 11716, 0K0 O1 O-1 4 1H   0-1 8  (#D'  /&& /&!   N (#D' 4) ('/A =) -70 ) ; M NNM ; , 1  ;@P1L1@ ;5 E@@,5) ,1 011150@0,4)(!/<)-00, 160111=01HO@==21F611H1 401  (##!  !&&&  F 001  5 1=1  !&&!, 51K1--00117168 "$#."!&&!(!506!&&!<A 1-1-0K04,40151--1-C 1H 41  (##(  !&&&, 2 =1 C 1 4-51=  1 =1 C 1 O01,4541=1001O041 6 4@16-,  12190 0  1, =1 1 C  1=1 4 1  - O-61--, F -6@-   1 C 1 -=111=

8 ".!."!&&!!$506!&&!<)((=-51!&&%,>111-  =10-  0  1 -=111=  401  1, 171=1- C O-7O@==21H151=1O6>1H01 4011O510(##%(##!,454  29  51)  19 1=1, 001  01  >1 !&&!,

"$%"!&&' $"# 

11C5295151--0010K0H  19 0  1 O01  401  1 O51 4 --2--8 "D$"!&&%((=-51!&&%<)!'0K001, 16 0111=  =10-  0  1 -=1115  401  1 C O-7 O  H1 O-1 5 1=17 1 510  20O1111;1O4HH4  0K0 H O1-- O-1 -70 01 C   O-1 19) O06  1=1 4@- C O1-- -1  29  518 "(&!"!&&%!'=-51!&&%<)

  !#51!&&%,16-1--H34F=1 36>H001115HH1=01,1C 241429514150C4144 0?1411,51-0-040141- 4-7H13441H1C1119)

   O49,    =1 36>  12 0 01115  01  12    19 4   1  401  12 01, 4-($>51!&&%)1,13514011 --5141=115C ,0044 0?1,017-1-=1,155,2951  -6 C  41  7) ;371   4- 4-,   015-435)

    1 00  C 00  5 1=1,  -0-040141-C41)=1 36> 3  I 411=  019 3) 1  1 =1 41   =5,  415-   401 4 12 01 4 -6 C  41  7, 1  001  5 1=1, 1- C  3  5,013-49515-=-1), ;  351 51 H3   5 04011  97   11 19, 1 1 1-- 00   11716  H  401 1 1 1- C 1 -=111=)  1 -0  64111H1-C161 4-701)

  ;  >14 ->C 1-,  1  401  1 -=111= 4-CO-711716141O 4@71, 00 O10   0-1  0)   0  4-CO-72H1500-O1=1C -71119,4H0141=111-C --4F@1H411) 161, H3C>1H; 4-1-=111=401 1)

"$%"!&&' ."# 

%)  41144411-751-1H)11C O1-  4  0   -  1 4 >1=1- 4  1)

  104-13-45517 H01,31- 110-   =1 45  -5-1-, 04   61 4=1 -7-) 17=1>1=1-,59051-- 3-@4--01,411 19,--141201,01H1O01=0 4-4F-O==011)

/)  ;3713--1-31%/ 4-1  !( -06 (#%. 8  ; %(()&<  4-5  ,  16 0111= 95 H   >14  16 =--, 321 3  - 44 H  7 1  0 1001, 01  10416C-08 N(!!(1)%64)$A "('D"(##D  (. 0 (##DA ".(/"(##.  (D506 (##.A "$%$"(##$  !#6(##$A  M; ,;@P1L1@;=7L6@:SLE00 , T1@ (##., !90 -), @)'  ) %/<)  4,  16 =--  > 1-- H  =1  1  - O-61--   -4  10151019104451K1--00 001  -  -1-, 9  H  61 >11H 4-7- 4  -70111191040051,O1-71- 4-OK@018 N((D(#&1)!4)(#(A(($ %$/1)(4)%$$A((%6(/%1)%44)(/$ (/.A(&$(1)!4) /<)  4, 3  O 111 1  101    0  4163H11K-1-H8 N)4))($ =-51(##DA  M; ,4)1),@)(&)%/>141-<)

   349,  040 4- 4    1=1 4 2 4114  -1-  O-H1 5  6 51-, 9  HO1 1 B 51 HO 151 41 49   01 1 4 K 0- 5 3==11-54510-171,4204,  4  51 306)  7 451  4? 1001, 0110HO1-110416C-0)

  -H,14-51O1%/ 4 -@44C001115)

') ) O1 %$ 1- (  3 -7 O011  4   5-@1 C  11 19  !. 6 (#.$ 8   ; ./()'(< 14HO1-01115011O11C 4155-@10614H401  1 O 4 -1, HO O  4 O41 4 1  01  O1=101- 4@F1H  0, 4  O10 

"$%"!&&' D"# 

O =0  2101  H1   146 4 O 1) 14114011O-1-1-C5-@1 061 8 K  16 =-- $ )/"!&&/  !! 0 !&&/A ) ; M NNM ; ,1;@P1L1@;5E@@, :1 011150@0,(##',4)(/%<)

 6) 32114011CF45-@1 >1=1 H 31-- 00  1=1 C     1==- F4, -011141-C41)

  0035,0012951,01 131=1,001-3-61--   4  0?1)   1  1- H31 1  0  1,=11,5-@1511101-);  11 1==-   11716 C H1  401  1- 4 1 -71  5-@1 0, 4 H  1=1 001 37,002951)

$)  5H14-9,-1141190=10- 371411414011C14-51=,H 21-0110)

  *=-,>-)-00 MN%&&) 01C @7H1068D.)( <)

+  ') , '    

-./#%0

- 56   1>-  (& >51 !&&' 4 *1 ++++++++++ -11510615171!-06!&&/1 1401C1-=111=,01100517 H01,6A

/#$0

>A

0C@7-00 MN%&&) A

1 H, =0-0 2 1 #.  15   1 =-- O711 >111,4-K4K4-,45110111=, >91=11,45 16=--A0-01 1 11H  1, 01=  0F  45  4  17 

"$%"!&&' #"# 

    01A 1 1 K -  1 2041  01  16 =--, (&&&  (/A  4- K   419  41  ,15H-000F45,15K>1CO51A

001H  4- K C *1 ++++++++++ 11 HO 51  0615171CO==1=--C)

;1-7: *)F@9,4-1,*) @-1,*0,>7)

0 160111=:

7==19 >1>):  4-1:     *) 1 N)F@9   

41=0K--001H-241)

 95,  7==19:           

"$%"!&&'