ATA/337/2005 · Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

ATA/337/2005 · Judgment Affirmance: Arbitration Denial, Directed Verdict, and Corporate Veil Instruction Upheld (Cour de Justice (Cour civile))

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A litigant challenged a final judgment that denied relief, arguing that the trial court improperly denied a motion to compel arbitration, improperly denied a motion for a directed verdict, and issued erroneous jury instructions regarding the standard for piercing the corporate veil. The court affirmed the judgment, reasoning that the arbitration agreement was superseded by a later agreement, which did not mandate arbitration, and that the evidence presented at trial was sufficient to support the jury's verdict against the appellant on all claims, particularly because the jury was properly instructed on the elements required to pierce the corporate veil, which were adequately supported by the record.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Judgment Affirmance: Arbitration Denial, Directed Verdict, and Corporate Veil Instruction Upheld: The court affirmed the judgment, reasoning that the arbitration agreement was superseded by a later agreement, which did not mandate arbitration, and that the evidence presented at trial was sufficient to support the jury's verdict against the appellant on all claims, particularly because the jury was properly instructed on the elements required to pierce the corporate veil, which were adequately supported by the record.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA

arbitrage levée du voile social confirmation de compétence interprétation de l'arrêt décision communiquée verbalement nullité des ententes

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This article is cited in the dispositive section regarding the allocation of court costs.

Généré par l'IA

A/2075/2004

Contract Interpretation and Summary Judgment Affirmance

A/2003/2003

Contract Breach Rulings and Instructions Affirmation

A/2726/2006

Business Dispute Affirmation of Judgment

A/2833/2006

Contractual Dispute Affirmation

A/522/2005

Breach of Agreement Interpretation Affirmation

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This article is cited in the dispositive section regarding the allocation of court costs.

Texte complet

!"#$%%%%%%%%%% !"#$ %&'

'

& '' ' $'( )$'' &$ &

()*+(

'

01 2222222222034/ '5666 '7&896 : '6 6': 865 ;56 <%!'6 2222222222;6(7= !1 2222222222'' <>'96':? 6 ' '6 6'@66 6&,&6)..) 5 A 6% '6 6 ;6(7= B< C 5 '6 2222222222 B1 1;6(7=2222222222<1

)1 7&'6 @6 :? 6 '96'C 6 0 56)..)%!1 2222222222 '5D9 05)..-%

6'965 9' 6'C 60A6 5E51B' 696 &6 6 566 0. '&58 )..,% !1 2222222222 &6 ' 67 69 6' :> 6' FD @6 6 6'586 % :> 6'% & 558 ' @6 6 6 6 5 8''%@:&'7? 61 : 6 C&''5' 5 '96'1

-1 :6 &%'6 0G 58)..,%!1 222222222296 :'8A :'''5 6'' 66 6'86&:6 6' '556 6' 6A%'5' 5:5' #H+..1( 6 6 6' :66 6' 6 A666 96> C 1 !1 2222222222 &6 &'$% )) 'I )..,% 5? C 7 ''?D6@ 6 C 6'1

,1 B' :@E '6 5 C '6'% !1 2222222222 &6 ' &'6 &'$5?6 'A' ))'I )..,1 &6 ' > & ' 6 6 5? 866 : 9'5 ' &6 B!BJ 6 &6 D? @@ 5? & & ' C 6@ 61 '66 &'6 &'$ C 7 > 56 &6 5 6' @ 6' 6 A1

/1 )'&58)..,%B: C!1 22222222221&6 96 :'8A :'''5 6' %'5 96 @66 6 'D%6'6 C'6 6':D''866 &: 63 60 '' 66 0+' '8033G ;)0/K6(7='' <1B&6?6 6 6: '6 6' @:689666 :6 &6 E '6 1

G1 04'&58)..,%&' : ' 6 '96 E !1 22222222221:6 &6 'A' 86' '5'$1 5? D? ' & ' @6 :&6 '

*,-*)../ (-*+(

:&6 ':6@7(566196 : 6 ?&% '6&6 @6 &6 6'6551 6 &6?' 6 6 6'6'' 6'1

41 G 58 )..,% B '6 @ !1 2222222222 :'996 % % ' 7 ' '5' 5 ? 6 :D''866 ' D7: 6&6 &6?1B''L6 7 ' 6 : '6 6':??5 ' 89666 !1 22222222221

+1 /A&6)../5656C'996' G5E5 5'6% !1 2222222222 ' ' 66' 6 1 (6 &6'6 '' % 96 : 6 7 ?&1 :6 56 66 'D'E 6?'9615 6&6'6 ?5 66 '' 6'6 % 6 ' &7 C : 96 'DC:6 1

6 '&66'%!1 2222222222'CE '6C' 6C > '96'1 '6' '5 6 % 6 5?5 C@:99 69'6 ' '$'1

31 04A&6)../%B@'>:6 6 ' 51

0.1 )0A&6)../%6 68566 69' @ @E 5 '&66'% 66 @ 6 6' :99 69 6 '8A 1

001 49&6)../%B'9'1' 6 &8J ' : 6'D8 & E 5ED :> '96':? 6 %'&6 E A 1

0)1 0/&6)../% 6' 6'5 6' '=

1 !1 2222222222 >' @:6 &6 6&6 6? 6 A66 ' 1 :&6 ' @ 6@ 5'6 '56& :E ??22222222225'656)..)1 '5 6'''&6 6 ? 6&%' 55 7 '5?1

B:?6 96 '@6&6 '5%6? 6 56 6 C '6? @:6 &6 '&'@ ' 6 ' 6% @6 &6 6 '96 @:&6 &6'%' 55 57 1 :&6 ' 9'6 '& 5?1 'A' 5'$ 2222222222% !1 2222222222 'D6 6 '&'6 ' 6 C >'96'''&'6M:& N1

*,-*)../ (,*+(

81 B% @ ' &6 '5 ' 66 6' 86& : 6 6' '556 6' ' 6A @:6 : 6 68 @696 96 % :'' '? 966 6&1B:?6 :69 6''556D' :>6 5E5 '96'% B '66 @:6 &6 '' 6 : '6 6'% '' : 6'% '55 6'% 6 & > 5@5 '556 :>6 '96'1

0-1 5E5A'% 6' 69'5@ 6 ?CA?1

' )

01 A 5 6 & A66 6' '5 % ' &8; 1/G '6O'?6 6'A666))'&5803,0( ( )./J 1G-106 1'6 '566 6&0) 5803+/( ( /0.<1

)1 'D66' @%' @6 '?61 68 566 69 56 @6 996 588% @ :5'$ :&6 ' ; *34)*).., 0, 58 )..,J *G+G*).., -0 'I )..,J *G0-*).., / 'I ).., *))3*)..,0G5)..,<1

-1 '' 66 0+' '8033G;)0/< 5'696 '& 6' ' &66' '' % - A6 )..- ;6( 7= '& 6'<1 '6 ' % 00 A6 )..,% '6 5'696 '6' '' )580333;'6'' ()0,<1 > '6 '6: CDC'& 6'1' 6 6'6 6' 6 '6% ' @ ' 566 6& A666 C : &6? '& 6' ' ?6 '&'6 1

6 6?% ' 96 @6 ' ' C '5 )) 'I )..,J6 ' 675 ?6'&6'6 6'1

,1 P O6 O6 '6 ' '96' O? 6 6& 0/ 5 03+/% '' ' 8 96> 7? '55 ?6 O 6&6 6 6 ? O &66 6 ' '6 6' ' ' ; 1 ) '' J! %0333%Q%13./0<1

/1 :6 6 3 6 0 '' &'$6 @ O '6 6' O?? ' O 6 ' @ 6 O? 6

*,-*)../ (/*+(

O&6 '5% 6> @E % ' 6'5 68&D7O 6&6 '96'&6?1

6'6 6'@6656 6 687C'96'O? 6 ' 6 6 6 6'C68 ''56@' '9'56 CO 6-G 6 ) ' 6 6' 9 0+ &6 0333 ;B 0.0< &6 AC 56 68; *G3/*)..0G'&58)..0<1

O>' 5' 69 '5? 'A OD6' C 567 &6''' %6&6 66@@ 6 &6'%O8 '96 &' '5 6 % >5% '58 69 6' A? 6'5 68 & D7 O 6&6 '96' &6? ;! % 033+% %1/034<1

7&66''' %: 6360 56 '&%'@=

M: '6 6' :?? ' : ' @ 6 :? 6 R'99 %' 7 ''5' 5 ' ? 6:D''866 ' D7: 6&6 &6?N1

B' :>' 5' 69 '5? 'A '6% '& >6?:D''866 %6 796? AC:6?6 6'?&'6 66 %&6 5 :>566'5' 5 :6 6 ''5 68&: 6&6 ' : '6 6' 6 @6% 5E5 6 6 ' :&6 '5 5 ; *34)*).., *G+G*)..,6 <1

G1 ' 6' O 6'5 68 & D7 O 6&6 &6? ' OD''866 96 ?675 O'8A OE 68 % 55 @ >D 6&5 ; *+3,*).., 0G '&58 )..,<1 8 % 68566 69 6 '5 %C ?%:65' 69 6' '556% D 6 6?6>% : 6 ' D7:6 E 'D1 7??%96 '55 &6'A 6969: '6 6' &6@6 :? 6 6& ' 6 : '6 6' AC 6&1 B 6' 667% '55 6&6 '96' 'D '58 % & 5 : 7?1 :$A6 68566 695' 6@:6 '5 6 6'& 96 'DC:6 1

41 : 6 0- 6 0 '' &'6 @ : '6 '6 6 : '6 6' 6& '@ >6? 6( ' 561 ' 9'6%C : 60-6-'' K' > 6 6@:6 '&&6'(: '6 566 6&

*,-*)../ (G*+(

?5 ''& 65 '6': '6 6':C6> 5'61 676'6 6'5 66 6'5@5 > 7? 96> '' '6 6 : '6 6'1 & : > 6' 66 :6 6 6' :> '96' 56 6 5E5 6 ' @ :566 &6 C 66% : (C(6 @:6 '6 5 :5 ; *G+G*).., 6 <1 6 6 6' ' : '6 6 65 ' @ 5 6 : '6 6' 6 '' :69 6' '556 D' &6% :& 65 ' 6' : '6 6' &% D % ' 6' 5@5 '556 &6% '&:6 > : 60- '' 1 : '6 566 6&@A66 6''& '' 6&5 6 : '6 6'% & 65 ' 6'9' 6'?&6 9 '556%6999' 96 &'66:? 6 6 ''&61

:996A?0,58)..,% 68&6 696? 6' : '6 6' :??5 6& ' ' 6>5'6%6&6 C:?6%@:6: 6 '& D'&6% :86 & 865 86%'9 5C:?:'6'6 5'1

:7 A? -0 'I )..,% :? 6 ' : 6 ?5 & 6 : '6 6' :??5 ' 6 6 89666 ' 6> 5'6% 6 &6 9 56 C 6 : D? ''?81

996% 68 566 69 6 C D? ' % 96 ' @ 6 '5 @:6 &6 '% '6 :&'665?C 7> ' 6A1

PD?%69 6'5 76'96 '@ 6 '5% :8 : '5 6' :> 6' &69'6:5'$' 1

? :58 6' % '' : 66' 6 : '6 6':>'96':? 6 6 ' 6 66'' 6'6 %@6?'& ' 6' 6@1

+1 68 566 69 '6 7 ' @: 6' : '6 6''>5'6 56>666 J6 5 ' 65 '1

*,-*)../ (4*+(

31 ' % @6 ?6 566 7 : &' @6 6 '6' &5 : 656 '% : & '%:5' #H/..1(1

5'5 '6 %E C #H0/.1(%56CD? ; 1+410 <1

$') ( '

*+,#"-

&8 ' 6 A G A&6 )../ !'6 2222222222 ' 66' 5 A 6%'6 6 G58)..,J

, -

:5 65 J

66'6 6?6J

> 5'6 : '6 6' :??5 6& C !'6 2222222222J

6 @:656 ' #H/..1('' J

5 CD?' 5'5 #H0/.1(J

'556@ E C ! " #$ % &' ' 66 @O 5 A 6%'6 6 1

B6? = !1$D7%6 %!5#6%!1 D6%!5'%A?% !1?%A?

*,-*)../ (+*+(

'5 68566 69=

?9967(A6 A1= 6 = !1 ''6 H1$D7

'6'9'5 E '556@> 61

7&% ?9967=

*,-*)../

Judgment Affirmance: Arbitration Denial, Directed Verdict, and Corporate Veil Instruction Upheld

Synthèse Legislator

Regeste Legislator

Mots-clés

Dispositions légales citées

Décisions connexes

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Texte complet